Footballer Comparison!

[30stone]

Basically it works like this.. Whos better..

Person 1: Ibrahimovic vs Torres

Person 2: Ibrahimovic
David Silva vs Valencia

Person 3: David Silva
Given vs Cech

Person 4: Cech
etc etc etc..

Get it..so

Arshavin vs Steven Hunt :)

[andyman]

I can't post in here, the BH need all my posts! :( the Den are trying to destroy us.

Ian Rush vs John Aldridge

[30stone]

You didnt answer the question!!!
Ian Rush.

Figo Vs Zidane

[Novo]

Figo

Ally Mccoist V Henrik Larsson

[30stone]

Hendrick Larson

Arteta Vs Novo

[Novo]

Novo

Keane v Viera

[30stone]

Viera!!

Ibrahimovic vs Eto'o

[30stone]

Bump:)

Ibrahimovic vs Eto'o

[Harry!]

I can't post in here, the BH need all my posts! :( the Den are trying to destroy us.



Quiet Andy post count obsessive.

[King Gizzard]

Ibrahimovic..just

Terry or Ferdinand

[Alf]

some terrible choices so far
figo better than zidane?
vierra better than keane?
novo better than arteta?
what you people been watching?

ferdinand

gerrard or lampard

[Locke.]

Gerrard.

Terry or Vidic?

[alc09]

Terry.

Crouch or Heskey?

[30stone]

Crouch.

Vermaelen or Gallas

[Alf]

gallas

ashley cole or patrice evra

[30stone]

Ashley cole.

Robbie Keane or John Carew

[Alf]

keane


xavi or essien

[30stone]

Xavi probably. But play completely different roles.

Lucas vs Anderson vs Denilson

[Novo]

Anderson!

Raul or Del piero

[30stone]

Anderson :nono:

Raul

Henry or V.Nistelrooy

[Alf]

henry

bullard or huddlestone

[30stone]

huddlestone

Lennon or valencia?

[Alf]

double a ron lennon


carragher or puyol

[30stone]

Puyol

Gourcuff vs Benzema

[Alf]

benzema (when he's intrested)


fabragas or kaka

[30stone]

Fabregas right now.

Ronaldo or Valencia..

[30stone]

Bump :)

[SammyWammy]

Ronaldo

Giggs or Pirlo

[Chels]

Giggs.

Chopra or Bothroyd ;)

[Novo]

None Both as **** as each other

Beattie or Fuller

[Alf]

beattie

drogba, or torres, or ibrahimovic, or eto'o, or berbatov

[King Gizzard]

drogba

terry or ferdinand

[Alf]

rio


zambrotta or dani alves

[30stone]

Dani Alves.

Aaron lennon or SWP?

[Alf]

Dani Alves.

Aaron lennon or SWP?

double A ron lennon


franck ribery or andres iniesta

[30stone]

Andres iniesta.

Ramos or Maicon?

[King Gizzard]

maicon


reina or buffon

[Alf]

buffon


tevez or arshavin

[30stone]

Arshavin.

Essien or Danielle De rossi (roma)

[Dolphin-and-Whale]

De Rossi ( just)

Totti or Del Piero

[Alf]

totti

beckham or ronaldinho

[King Gizzard]

beckham

ronaldinho had them 2-3 amazing seasons then he turned to shite whereas beckham has had many seasons at the top of his game


dessailly or maldini

[alc09]

Dessailly

Yaya Toure or Kole Toure

[King Gizzard]

Yaya by miles. Toure is shocking at the moment.

Milner or S. Ireland

[alc09]

Milner

Pato or Robinho

[haggis]

Robinho

Allan McGregor or Artur Boruc

[Alf]

mcgregor

jermaine beckford or michael chopra

[haggis]

chopra

Gordon BANKS or Peter SHILTON

[Alf]

peter shilton


pele or alfredo di stefano

[30stone]

Pele

Ashley cole or Gael Clichy

[haggis]

Gael Clichy .....but mrs cole is far better than both. i wonder how she scores. lmao


Johan CRUYFF or Gary LINEKER

[Alf]

lineker (probably not really, but he's fave ever player, so i'm picking him)


gary lineker or ian rush

[30stone]

Lineker

Thierry henry or Ruud Van Nistelrooy

[Alf]

henry

robbie keane or craig bellemy

[30stone]

Keane

Bellamy is a tit

Jack wilshire or jack rodwell.

[Alf]

no contest, jackie rodwell easilly, he's something special


jermain defoe or michael owen

[30stone]

Says the everton fan lol.

Michael owen back in the day but defoe right now.

Berbatov or Tevez?

[Beastie]

Wayne Rooney comparison to Mr Potato!

[King Gizzard]

Says the everton fan lol.

Michael owen back in the day but defoe right now.

Berbatov or Tevez?



its a tough one to call, berbatov is amazing when he wants to be, but lazy alot of the time, a bit of the same with tevez really.

but i ll go for tevez, just


foster, james, hart, green, robinson, or kirkland?

[atieah2009]

Joe Hart

Ronaldo (Brazilian one) at his peak vs Zidane

[30stone]

Well Zidane at his peak was amazing so ill go for him.

Fabregas Lampard or Gerrard?

[Alf]

fabregas


saha or anelka

[30stone]

Atm.

Saha

Diaby or Song

[Alf]

diaby (if he wants to be)


think i've said this 1 before

fabregas or kaka

[30stone]

Fabregas.

Wilshire or Ramsey?

[Alf]

haven't seen enough of wilshire so i pick ramsey but being english i hope wilshire fullfills his potential


owen hargreaves or gareth barry?

[30stone]

Owen hargreaves if he can stay 100% fit.. as hes quality, but normally barry.

Andre Pierre gignac or Yohan Gourcuff

[30stone]

Yohann Gourcuff vs Yoan Gouffran

[King Gizzard]

gourcuff is the next zidane so deffinetly gourcuff


miler or arteta (for non-everton fans)

[30stone]

Ohhh.

Milner based on current form since Arteta is injured, it would be far closer if Arteta was fit.

And i agree Gourcuff is amazing, gignac is good to.


Sagna or Bosingwa

[30stone]

:)

[King Gizzard]

Sagna

bosingwawent ****e then got injured


Ben Marshall or Ruud Van Nistelrooy

[30stone]

Ben Marshall

Great youngster, shoulda stayed at stoke..


Torres or Villa?

[setanta]

I'll go for Villa cuz he's injury free compared to Torres.

Evra or Clichy?

[30stone]

Yeah villa is better more prolific scorer to..


And evra.. (just)

Clichy is great but sometimes has a mere..

Makes more mistakes than evra.

[30stone]

The big one..

Messi or Ronaldo?

[setanta]

Clichy has lost the plot a bit. Don't know what's happened to him.

[setanta]

The purist in me will go for Messi. He looks effortless when he's on the move.

[30stone]

Clichy is just coming back to form?


And Messi is amazing so is ronaldo.

But Ronaldo is like a main striker now..

Messi plays on the wing with ibrahimovic in the centre one of the best strikers in the world and messi is still second top scorer in la liga (behind villa)

[setanta]

Clichy is just coming back to form?


And Messi is amazing so is ronaldo.

But Ronaldo is like a main striker now..

Messi plays on the wing with ibrahimovic in the centre one of the best strikers in the world and messi is still second top scorer in la liga (behind villa)

I'm just basing it soley on the kind of football that I like to watch, that's all. Ronaldo is more effective at the moment but Messi moves the way we'd all like to move. He's poetry in motion at times. It just looks so natural.

[30stone]

I'm just basing it soley and the kind of football that I like to watch, that's all. Ronaldo is more effective at the moment but Messi moves the way we'd all like to move. He's poetry in motion at times. It just looks so natural.



Untrue.

In the league ronaldo has played 15 games got 13 goals and 0 assists..

Messi has played 21 league games scored 17 and made 9 assists.

Messi seems to contribute..

[setanta]

Untrue.

In the league ronaldo has played 15 games got 13 goals and 0 assists..

Messi has played 21 league games scored 17 and made 9 assists.

Messi seems to contribute..

Wow, I haven't been paying attention to the Spanish league. So yeah, I was right in picking Messi. Just love the way he moves. Still though, I'd pick Rooney over the two of them, as mad as that may sound.

[30stone]

Id pick messi..

At international level id pick david villa over anyone..

[30stone]

Iniesta or Xavi ?

[setanta]

Id pick messi..

At international level id pick david villa over anyone..

Messi is a natural footballer to me and I'd pick him ahead of someone like Ronaldo, even though I think Ronaldo has proven himself to a certain extent. Still has to do it at international level though.

Haven't seen enough of Villa but been impressed. Oh, last time I was going to Italy his team were in the airport in Spain! You should have seen how people greeted him. He's loved so much over there.

[setanta]

Iniesta or Xavi ?

Too difficult. Fabregas. lol.

[30stone]

Yeah villa is amazing!

and i dont know either both amazing.. but yeah fabregas current form is better than both..

1 goal 2 assists for fabregas today..

[30stone]

Can i ask how Fabregas has not won player of the month this season?

Defoe
Torres
Van Persie
bullard
Tevez
Rooney.

Really bullard has performed better than fabregas throught november?

[setanta]

Can i ask how Fabregas has not won player of the month this season?

Defoe
Torres
Van Persie
bullard
Tevez
Rooney.

Really bullard has performed better than fabregas throught november?

Really!?!! Didn't know that.

[30stone]

Yeah come on sorry but for me

Fabregas has out performed every single player in the premier league this season bar rooney this season for me..

[setanta]

Yeah come on sorry but for me

Fabregas has out performed every single player in the premier league this season bar rooney this season for me..

He's been wonderful. Beautiful footballer.

[30stone]

Yeah so calm and so confident on the ball at 22, by 24 he will be the best in the world i think, only problem is.. he may not still be with Arsenal..

Right im off to bed..
leave you with one..


Richard Dunne vs Thomas Vermaelen

[setanta]

Yeah so calm and so confident on the ball at 22, by 24 he will be the best in the world i think, only problem is.. he may not still be with Arsenal..

Right im off to bed..
leave you with one..


Richard Dunne vs Thomas Vermaelen

Dunne. But yeah, I think he should stay with Arsenal for one or two more seasons.

[30stone]

Very hard choice but id take Vermaelen because of age.


Joe Hart vs Robert Green vs David James
?

[Alf]

Very hard choice but id take Vermaelen because of age.


Joe Hart vs Robert Green vs David James
?
that's a good question, none of us know who's the best, that's a big problem the national team have,.
james - we all know can produce brilliant save's, but let's face it none of us are confident of him.
green - has been the man in pole position, but hasn't really caught the eye.
hart - has had a good season with birmingham, but lets not get carried away with him, the world cup is a step up in level and he's a young and inexpeirienced for a keeper.

i dont fancy any of these 3, i'd pick paul robinson, it would be a gamble, i know that(but you need to gamble to win),when he's on it robinson is the best we got,

to answer your question, sadly james


shawcross or ramsey?

[30stone]

Joe hart has by far the best record this season.. paul robinson has let in 49 or 54 goals in 30 games, joe hart has let in just 31.

Ramsey.

Such a creative player learnt a lot off fabregas and has shown it.

Shawcross is great though.

[Alf]

Joe hart has by far the best record this season.. paul robinson has let in 49 or 54 goals in 30 games, joe hart has let in just 31.
that's what i mean by gamble, hart has played infront of a team that's played well (above expectations), and defended well as a team, dont get me wrong he's played his part. robinsons been in a team that's been inconsistant but yet still reached the league cup semi finals and look to be in a good position to survive the drop, and believe me robinson has been a big player for them this year.
he was spurs and england number 1, he made 1 mistake when mcclaran was manager, he had a little dip in form, and we chucked him on the scrap heap.

[30stone]

Thats true.
For me id of given hart a go at the friendly against egypt...
See how he performs. as birmingham havent had the best defence.. yet are doing the best hes done so well..