WTF is Stacey still in for?

[Billy]

I made this thread before the live shows but I cannot believe that Stacey is still in, let alone one of the favourites to win. She's been so inconsistant it's unbelievable! She's had (IMO) two decent performances, being her last two, but her Son of a Preacher Man was one of the worst performances EVER on the show. She's a total one trick pony, not done ANY uptempos (SOAPM isn't even an uptempo number and she murdered it), and I can't believe Lloyd gets the slating that he does when Stacey is still in the show.

And don't get me started on Danyl ...

[alc09]

Clueless, Billy, clueless.

If your signature is anything to go by, then you support Lloyd.

Enough said.

[Tom]

I like Stacey but its showing how weak this series is. Noone is a decent act this year, not one is marketable and not one will be successful in the music industry.

Before the live shows I thought Cheryl put the wrong three through, now I'm starting to think they put the entire wrong 12 through.

[Ninastar]

She is liked by the public and can sing well. She's never been in the bottom 2 so it shows how much she is loved.

[Shaun]

I like Stacey but its showing how weak this series is. Noone is a decent act this year, not one is marketable and not one will be successful in the music industry.

Before the live shows I thought Cheryl put the wrong three through, now I'm starting to think they put the entire wrong 12 through.

Simon definitely did too. Louis' decisions are always jokes. I think Dannii's decisions weren't bad - Lucie and Rachel should have gone through, but not Stacey.

[Tom]

Simon definitely did too. Louis' decisions are always jokes. I think Dannii's decisions weren't bad - Lucie and Rachel should have gone through, but not Stacey.

I think Despina was miles better than Lucie

Lucie was too polished and when she sang there was nothing there

[Stephanie]

despina was really good

[Twilight]

I agree with you Billy tbh.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Stacey has picked her game up in the last two weeks. She was the best by a mile two weeks ago and closely behind Joe this week. The others havent come close to those two

[Shaun]

ah yes, I couldn't think of her name. Despina, Lucie, Rachel would have been my three.

[setanta]

Stacey is not a good performer and her voice isn't that great. Bizarre stuff really.

[Billy]

She is liked by the public and can sing well. She's never been in the bottom 2 so it shows how much she is loved.

No ****.

All the judges made rubbish choices IMO except Louis haha. He picked two good groups but ****ed them up royally.

[NettoSuperstar!]

And Lloyd has had consistently bad performances throughout! Some of the worst in live show history

[Billy]

And Lloyd has had consistently bad performances throughout! Some of the worst in live show history

Yeah he has, what's your point exactly? It doesn't make Stacey any better. They both probably shouldn't be there.

[Tom]

Yeah he has, what's your point exactly? It doesn't make Stacey any better. They both probably shouldn't be there.

If Lloyd is your fave and you don't think he should be there then that just makes this thread irrelevant

[NettoSuperstar!]

Yeah he has, what's your point exactly? It doesn't make Stacey any better. They both probably shouldn't be there.

Stacey has been miles better...do you watch the show?

[Billy]

If Lloyd is your fave and you don't think he should be there then that just makes this thread irrelevant

Lloyd isn't even my fave, I do like him though, but I don't think it weakens my original point any less. Lloyd has a really good personality which makes me like him (in a year which you said yourself, isn't very good), but I know that based on singing etc he isn't the best, and shouldn't be there.

[Beastie]

Lloyd is the worst one, Lloyd should have never been chosen! He has been consistently bad :joker: I do agree however without Stacey's personality she would not have got this far. However her best performance was in Queen Week.

[Billy]

Stacey has been miles better...do you watch the show?

No, I just like to randomly start discussions I have no clue on. Has she really? Except from her last two performances, the rest of them have been just as bad as Lloyd. The Scientist and Son of a Preacher Man were two of the worst performances in XF history IMO.

[Beastie]

Lloyd isn't even my fave, I do like him though, but I don't think it weakens my original point any less. Lloyd has a really good personality which makes me like him (in a year which you said yourself, isn't very good), but I know that based on singing etc he isn't the best, and shouldn't be there.


I didnt know Lloyd had a personality?

[Billy]

I didnt know Lloyd had a personality?

TBH if you're just gonna make comments and snipes like that then is it even worth replying lmao?

[NettoSuperstar!]

No, I just like to randomly start discussions I have no clue on. Has she really? Except from her last two performances, the rest of them have been just as bad as Lloyd. The Scientist and Son of a Preacher Man were two of the worst performances in XF history IMO.

Hehe lovin the sarcasm...They were good singing performances man and shes got better as the shows gone on!

[Twilight]

The Scientist and Son of a Preacher Man Were crap fact.

[Billy]

Hehe lovin the sarcasm...They were good singing performances man!

I guess we'll have to agree to disagree :p

[NettoSuperstar!]

K lol

[alc09]

All the judges made rubbish choices IMO except Louis

On the wind up or are you just trying to be funny?

As for your original point, you have some ****ing cheek.

[NettoSuperstar!]

The Scientist and Son of a Preacher Man Were crap fact.

Utter nonsense

[Twilight]

On the wind up or are you just trying to be funny?

As for your original point, you have some ****ing cheek.

Why? its his Opinion.

[Billy]

On the wind up or are you just trying to be funny?

As for your original point, you have some ****ing cheek.

I'm being serious :S Miss Frank had amazing potential, Kandy Rain were better than the other bunch and John and Edward were one crap choice, but without them this series would hvae been dull(er than it was)!

[NettoSuperstar!]

Miss Frank were good, they should have gone furthur than some of the others

[Beastie]

TBH if you're just gonna make comments and snipes like that then is it even worth replying lmao?

I am being honest, okay I will be more honest, his personality is quite dull and its pathetic he has ALLEGEDLY threatened to quit when there is only a few shows left! He is still in because of the teeny bopper vote, if he wasn't cute, he would have gone at the start, he still would have been chosen because cheryl thought he would get the welsh vote too!

[Tom]

So what about this performance?

YRYLuICs4ZE

or this?

oWD2qnV1Yqo

She has had 2 crap performances, 1 OK one (week 4) and the rest have all been quite good

Meanwhile Lloyd had had 9 crap performances, Danyl and Olly have only done about 1 or 2 good ones. Joe has been really consistent but he's really boring and his voice goes through me.

[alc09]

I am being honest, okay I will be more honest, his personality is quite dull and its pathetic he has ALLEGEDLY threatened to quit when there is only a few shows left! He is still in because of the teeny bopper vote, if he wasn't cute, he would have gone at the start, he still would have been chosen because cheryl thought he would get the welsh vote too!

You are talking sense, but surely the same applied for the two muppets on the left of your avatar?

[Beastie]

You are talking sense, but surely the same applied for the two muppets on the left of your avatar?


but they have a personality and they made the show FUN! :D

[alc09]

I'm being serious :S Miss Frank had amazing potential, Kandy Rain were better than the other bunch and John and Edward were one crap choice, but without them this series would hvae been dull(er than it was)!

Louis is the first judge out of the competition, one of his acts went out in the 1st week, and the other was John & Edward. ;)

Miss Frank had potential, fully agreed, but were never going to have a chance of winning the competition.

So to say 'all the judges made rubbish decisions except Louis' is a quite frankly, laughable statement, seeing as the other 3 all have an act or more left in the competition.

[Twilight]

but they have a personality and they made the show FUN! :D

Its still the same

[alc09]

but they have a personality and they made the show FUN! :D
So you now agree that they were only kept in by the little girl vote?

Regardless of the fact that they 'may have a personality', they are the worst act to ever make the Live Shows, slightly worse than Lloyd.

They are a joke.

[Beastie]

So you now agree that they were only kept in by the little girl vote?

Regardless of the fact that they 'may have a personality', they are the worst act to ever make the Live Shows, slightly worse than Lloyd.

They are a joke.

Older people voted for them, my auntie liked him! They could sing, dance and rap! They had the whole package :D They were not the BEST ever singers, dancers and rappers but they were still good enough! They were amazing and should have won, their albulm should contain raps like vanilla ice! Would have been EPIC! Oh well they are out now but are going to do better than the x factor anyway :D

[Billy]

I am being honest, okay I will be more honest, his personality is quite dull and its pathetic he has ALLEGEDLY threatened to quit when there is only a few shows left! He is still in because of the teeny bopper vote, if he wasn't cute, he would have gone at the start, he still would have been chosen because cheryl thought he would get the welsh vote too!

ALLEGEDLY being the key word yes?
I love how Lloyd has to be slagged though to defend my OP.

[Billy]

Louis is the first judge out of the competition, one of his acts went out in the 1st week, and the other was John & Edward. ;)

Miss Frank had potential, fully agreed, but were never going to have a chance of winning the competition.

So to say 'all the judges made rubbish decisions except Louis' is a quite frankly, laughable statement, seeing as the other 3 all have an act or more left in the competition.

It's not really laughable considering it's only a decision. IMO I think Louis made the best decision, he just followed it by some really bad ones during th elive shows.

[Beastie]

ALLEGEDLY being the key word yes?
I love how Lloyd has to be slagged though to defend my OP.

I didnt bring up Lloyd first in this thread! My opinion is that I dont think Stacey is ****, but she is not overly good either but I still like her :D

[alc09]

They could sing, dance and rap!

They really couldn't though....

[Beastie]

They really couldn't though....


well we will agree to disagree lol

[LemonJam]

I agree, she's boring and easily the most overrated.

[Z]

Louis is the first judge out of the competition, one of his acts went out in the 1st week, and the other was John & Edward. ;)

Miss Frank had potential, fully agreed, but were never going to have a chance of winning the competition.

So to say 'all the judges made rubbish decisions except Louis' is a quite frankly, laughable statement, seeing as the other 3 all have an act or more left in the competition.


I can see where Billy's coming from. Relatively he made the best decisions - the other groups in the top 6 were dire; the only one who didn't get through that I thought were okay were Project A; but it would have been a massive tactical error from Louis to put through three girl groups. Simon should really have picked Daniel Pearce and possibly Treyc as part of his top 3 and Cheryl should have chosen Duane and Ethan for hers.

I think Dannii should have picked Despina over Rachel. I actually really like Stacey. I thought Nicole and Stacey McClean were rubbish, so Dannii made a good call overall.

[Jords]

Stacey is awesome, how can you call Stacey a one trick pony as an insult (which she isnt) when Lloyd cant even master one trick!

[Stacey.]

billy, you supported Diana last Year,,
You have no taste! :D lmfao
Sorry, but that says it all...

[Ninastar]

billy, you supported Diana last Year,,
You have no taste! :D lmfao
Sorry, but that says it all...

Oh dear. How can you say that when your faves are the twins. Diana made it further than the twins.

[LemonJam]

billy, you supported Diana last Year,,
You have no taste! :D lmfao
Sorry, but that says it all...

Do you seriously have the audacity to say that?

[Twilight]

billy, you supported Diana last Year,,
You have no taste! :D lmfao
Sorry, but that says it all...

Just wtf

[robb]

Agree with courtney123, Billy..............to moan about Stacey when you support the likes of Jedward and Diana is a bit of a self inflicted argument-losing strategy!!
As for Stacey, her performances overall have been good. Which is more than can be said for one or two of the others left in a show which, this year, hasn't exactly been sprinkled with Leona/alex/will young style stardust TBH.

[Twilight]

Agree with courtney123, Billy..............to moan about Stacey when you support the likes of Jedward and Diana is a bit of a self inflicted argument-losing strategy!!
As for Stacey, her performances overall have been good. Which is more than can be said for one or two of the others left in a show which, this year, hasn't exactly been sprinkled with Leona/alex/will young style stardust TBH.

Um like courtney is a Jedward fangirl so she can't talk tbh

[Chels]

Um like courtney is a Jedward fangirl so she can't talk tbh

She will be a Jedward groupie soon enough. :yuk:

[Adamw92]

billy, you supported Diana last Year,,
You have no taste! :D lmfao
Sorry, but that says it all...

OMG, just leave...now
Your serious? when you support Jedward
at least Diana can sing

[biglover]

She can sing REALLY well, what the hell are you talking about?