X Factor Live Discussion Thread 28/11/09

[Adamw92]

The first half was a bit off, prefered the last half

Danyl - 5/10
Lloyd - 2/10
Olly - 5.5/10
Joe - 7.5/10

[Ross]

Danyl: 6/10
Lloyd: 7/10
Olly: 9/10
Joe: 10/10

[Chels]

7/10

[Twilight]

8/10<3

[LemonJam]

Danyl - 8
Lloyd - 5
Olly - 7
Joe - 8

[Smithy]

louis says that to everyone hes a senial old man someone should remove him

[Tom]

He's really creepy when he tilts his head

[Stephanie]

the first half was meh
7/10

[Ninastar]

Danyl-7/10
Lloyd-2/10
Olly-8/10
Joe-8/10

[Gemmer-x]

Joe was brill :D

[Stephanie]

danyl - 5/10
lloyd - 7/10
olly - 9/10
joe - 7/10

[MarkWaldorf]

amazinggggg JOE JOE JOE

[Ross]

:dance::dance:

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Joe 6/10
Olly 8/10
Lloyd 2/10
Danyl 4/10

[Marc]

he was by far the better of all the guys so far!

[Ross]

he was by far the better of all the guys so far!

this.

[Tom]

Bring on the talent after the break :dazzler:

[Smithy]

woooooo come on stacey

[Adamw92]

Come on Stacey!!!!!!!!!!! :D

[Jords]

Not that good for Joe tbh, bit of a let down, but far better than the other 3 so far :thumbs:

Danyl 6/10
Lloyd 5/10
Olly 6/10
Joe 7.5/10

[Smithy]

Joe and Lloyd bottom 2

there is no bottom 2:nono:

[Novo]

1. Olly ( Perfect )
2. Danyl ( great )
3. Joe ( worse then usual )
4. Lloyd ( Shite )

[andyman]

Staceeeeeeee!

[Shaun]

Bring on the talent after the break :dazzler:

stop being petty, thomas, you aren't david.

[Marc]

Lloyd will go this week

[Jords]

Come on Staceyyy

[Novo]

Bring on the talent after the break :dazzler:

Olly on again?

[Ross]

Danyl worst so far.

[Marc]

Do people hate Joe on here because they're homophobic? (he may not be gay but he gives off vibes)

[Tom]

stop being petty, thomas, you aren't david.

I'm not too keen on any of them this year, Stacey is the best of the worst. Lloyd, Stacey and Danyl deserve to make the final

[Chels]

Lloyd will go this week

You haven't seen his second performance yet.
It could be best of the night you never know.

[Shaun]

i really can't fathom how anyone can think lloyd's better than joe.

[Smithy]

Do people hate Joe on here because they're homophobic? (he may not be gay but he gives off vibes)

thats what i thought as well
same from rikki

[Ross]

i really can't fathom how anyone can think lloyd's better than joe.

joe > all of them

[Marc]

You haven't seen his second performance yet.
It could be best of the night you never know.

Could be! But its based on popularity and previous weeks. 2 times in the bottom two.

[Tom]

Do people hate Joe on here because they're homophobic? (he may not be gay but he gives off vibes)

No. Why does it always come down to race and sexuality if someone dislikes someone else? I hate his voice, and his stage presence (or lack of). Plus I find him a bit creepy.

[Marc]

joe > all of them

This

[Ross]

No. Why does it always come down to race and sexuality if someone dislikes someone else? I hate his voice, and his stage presence (or lack of). Plus I find him a bit creepy.

You have said his 'campness' is irritating, so it must play a part....

[Ninastar]

You haven't seen his second performance yet.
It could be best of the night you never know.

yeah but he wont.

[Stephanie]

olly and joe have been the best so far

[MarkWaldorf]

No. Why does it always come down to race and sexuality if someone dislikes someone else? I hate his voice, and his stage presence (or lack of). Plus I find him a bit creepy.

lol cause stacey standing there each week belting out the same ballad after ballad shows real stage presence.

[Smithy]

Olly on again?

yes but he said TALENT

[Marc]

You have said his 'campness' is irritating, so it must play a part....

Definately.

[Chels]

Could be! But its based on popularity and previous weeks. 2 times in the bottom two.

Yeah but Olly's popularity as dropping and not many people like Danyl.
I think Lloyd is gonna smash it next.

[Twilight]

Do people hate Joe on here because they're homophobic? (he may not be gay but he gives off vibes)

I think some do tbh

[Tom]

i really can't fathom how anyone can think lloyd's better than joe.

Vocally, Joe is the best out of everyone left. But he isn't a popstar. His performances have cabaret written allover them. So imo he isn't right for the show. Maybe I'd prefer him a bit more if he was on Joseph or something

[LemonJam]

i really can't fathom how anyone can think lloyd's better than joe.

Tonewise I find Lloyd more interesting. Pitchwise, Joe is better but you could see people like him at the west end.

If that makes any sense.

[Twilight]

lol cause stacey standing there each week belting out the same ballad after ballad shows real stage presence.

ily<3

[Princess]

Ugrh couldn't get online cos a massive storm,was scared! Of all the weeks I have to turn my laptop off *rolls eyes*

Right so far

That montage was mehish,no Shine and it was just songs,no 11 Number 1's,5 Number 1 Album's! etc.

Contestant wise

I hated Danyl singing Relight,I thought it was awful
Lloyd did well with AMSL,bit Welshy in parts but I can't be giving out to him for that,lol.
LOVED Olly,LAHA was amazing.
Joe also did brilliant with CIBM,love love love loved it!

[Marc]

Yeah but Olly's popularity as dropping and not many people like Danyl.
I think Lloyd is gonna smash it next.

Sorry I meant my view is based on popularity. :)

I hope Danyl goes! I will be backing Lloyd this week :tongue: only for 1 week though

[Stephanie]

danyl needs to go
he was awful

[Marc]

Right im off :)

[Ross]

My votes are going to Lloyd this week. I have no worries in Joe and Stacey being safe.

Danyl to go.

[Tom]

You have said his 'campness' is irritating, so it must play a part....

Duane who never made the live shows was camp. I wanted him to win. Danyl is a bit camp, no problem with him.

On some people its irritating, on others it isn't. Nothing to do with homophobia or whatever, its just how people act.

[Novo]

Llloyd is 7/10 Odds on to go

Ouch!

[Smithy]

Staceyy WOOOOOO

[Ross]

Stacey :) yay

[Stephanie]

urgh i can't even be bothered to listen to her

[Patrick]

Cant Wait To Im A Celebrity :D

[LemonJam]

Danyl is the best vocally. You all know it, even if you won't admit it.

Oh aye.

[Stephanie]

i've just noticed, she's talking properly now
edit: now she's back to her stupid talking

[Chels]

Her face makes me laugh.
I don't mean it nastily when I say that.

[Ross]

goose pimples!

[andyman]

Legs!

[Smithy]

Her face makes me laugh.
I don't mean it nastily when I say that.

thats what my m8 said
he pretty much said shes really pretty until she opens her mouth and she shows her horse teeth
soo mean

[Niamh.]

****

[GypsyGoth]

This is my fave Take That song.

[Stephanie]

when she does the high notes my ears hurt ;/

[Ross]

This sounds good with female vocals.

[Niamh.]

2/10

[Smithy]

amazing

[Shaun]

screechy. i don't like.

4/10.

[Adamw92]

I was worried but shes just amazes me again

[Chels]

thats what my m8 said
he pretty much said shes really pretty until she opens her mouth and she shows her horse teeth
soo mean

Lmfao I tried not to laugh when I read that, didn't work :P

[Alf]

round 1 to joe
a different class to the rest

[Stephanie]

4/10

[andyman]

Great song!

[Novo]

Nearly perfect 9.5/10

[Niamh.]

This is my fave Take That song.

mine too and she ruined it

[Ross]

Stacey: 9/10

[Tom]

9/10

Round 1- Stacey

[Chels]

6/10.
Ruined it :(

[Novo]

Round 1 - Olly

[Smithy]

stacey>olly>joe>danyl>lloyd

[Adamw92]

Danyl - 5/10
Lloyd - 2/10
Olly - 5.5/10
Joe - 7.5/10
Stacey - 9/10

Round 1 goes to Stacey :D

[Ross]

Round 1: Joe.
Second: Olly
Third: Stacey
Fourth: Lloyd






Fifth: Danyl

[GypsyGoth]

mine too and she ruined it

:laugh:

[Stephanie]

danyl - 5/10
lloyd - 7/10
olly - 9/10
joe - 7/10
stacey - 4/10

the high bits were too high lol

[Shaun]

robbie says he isn't engaged :\

[Chels]

Round 1 - Lloyd Daniels <3
even if you hated it, I thought he sounded beautiful.

[Novo]

Round 1 - Lloyd Daniels <3
even if you hated it, I thought he sounded beautiful.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHAHAHAHAAHHAAHA

Cmon less jokes

[Smithy]

danyl - 5/10
lloyd - 7/10
olly - 9/10
joe - 7/10
stacey - 4/10

the high bits were too high lol

u are clearly mental putting ever1 above her

[Twilight]

robbie says he isn't engaged :\

lol

[andyman]

Noooo.. Don't talk Stacey!

[Gemmer-x]

i feel bad but i have to mute it when she talks :/

[Ross]

chuckles.

[Shaun]

1. joe
2. olly
3. danyl
4. stacey
5. lloyd

[GypsyGoth]

Stacey and her damn stupid girl act :cloud:

[Smithy]

i feel bad but i have to mute it when she talks :/

thats so mean
:nono:

[30stone]

u are clearly mental putting ever1 above her

No shes a girl putting the girl bottom.

It happens.

[LemonJam]

Danyl was best for me, Olly second.

[Stephanie]

u are clearly mental putting ever1 above her
not really, her high notes were horrible

[Niamh.]

somebody shoot her pleaseeeeeeeeee

[Patrick]

If anyone should win its Stacey

[Princess]

Stacey was INCREDIBLE!

Simon was a twat for mentioning Rob,he left 14 years ago you idiot!! Glad Louis said so.

[andyman]

:shocked: Lines open!

[Stephanie]

No shes a girl putting the girl bottom.

It happens.
she's my 3rd fav lol

[30stone]

Stacey
Danyl
Olly/Joe
Lloyd.

Stacey got that for me.

[Smithy]

not really, her high notes were horrible

stacey is the best of a bad bunch .

[Adamw92]

not really, her high notes were horrible

Yes and Olly's was PERFECT :rolleyes:

[Niamh.]

Stacey and her damn stupid girl act :cloud:

It is such an act, atleast I hope it is, nobody could be that annoying really, could they????????

[Smithy]

Yes and Olly's was PERFECT :rolleyes:

lol

[Stephanie]

Yes and Olly's was PERFECT :rolleyes:
did i say they were? -looks around-

[Novo]

Voting olly like theres no tomorrow now

[Ross]

Elton John? Who's gonna sing Your Song.

I hope someone sings Can You Feel The Love Tonight. Pinball Wizard good song too.

[Adamw92]

did i say they were? -looks around-

well u gave him 5 more points than you gave Stacey

[Novo]

What was Olly's number i missed it?

[Shaun]

Elton John? Who's gonna sing Your Song.

I hope someone sings Can You Feel The Love Tonight. Pinball Wizard good song too.

Danyl is I think.

I don't think anyone's doing the others.

[Stephanie]

why are there plugs singing on my tv

[Smithy]

Voting olly like theres no tomorrow now

really?
why waste the money
he aint gonna win

[Chels]

Elton John? Who's gonna sing Your Song.

I hope someone sings Can You Feel The Love Tonight. Pinball Wizard good song too.

Danyl's singing Your Song.

[Tom]

Voting olly like theres no tomorrow now

Olly is safe, Danyl or Lloyd are going

[Niamh.]

Joe would suit Can you feel the Love tonight

[Shaun]

What was Olly's number i missed it?

he was third so 103 i guess?

[Ross]

Crap. I love Your Song. Stupid Danyl will make me like him :@

[Jords]

Stacey was amazing, as per usual, think the backing voice was too loud at times though, but really she should have this show in the bad unless silly girls vote for reasons like hes hawt babz.

Danyl 6/10
Lloyd 5/10
Olly 6/10
Joe 7.5/10
Stacey 9/10

[Novo]

right someone post Olly's number in here

No funny business either

[Chels]

Crap. I love Your Song. Stupid Danyl will make me like him :@

Unless he *****s it up and makes you hate him for ruining the song. ;)

[Stephanie]

right someone post Olly's number in here

No funny business either
103 at the end

[Damaris]

Danyl-8/10
Lloyd-2/10
Olly-9/10
Joe-7/10
Stacey-9/10

Voting

Olly-20
Stacey-5
Joe-2

[Smithy]

Stacey was amazing, as per usual, think the backing voice was too loud at times though, but really she should have this show in the bad unless silly girls vote for reasons like hes hawt babz.

Danyl 6/10
Lloyd 5/10
Olly 6/10
Joe 7.5/10
Stacey 9/10

^ that is a fair representation of the first performances

[Shaun]

Olly's will be epic. [Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting] Lloyd's will be cringeworthy [I'm Still Standing]

[MarkWaldorf]

voted joe 3 timess

[30stone]

Ladies ladies relax yourselves.

[Princess]

Stacey-10/10
Joe-9/10
Olly-8/10
Lloyd-7/10
Danyl-5/10

[Damaris]

and Danyl-3 votes

[Ross]

Unless he *****s it up and makes you hate him for ruining the song. ;)

I want this to happen please.

I want someone to sing Nikita too. Tune! Kay, I'll wait and see what they all sing.

[Adamw92]

Crap. I love Your Song. Stupid Danyl will make me like him :@

He'll ruin it and you'll hate him more, don't worry ;)

[Stephanie]

i love the nina perfume ad lmfao

[Chels]

Cba to vote yet.
Will later.
Lloyd only.

[andyman]

Stacey was INCREDIBLE!

Simon was a twat for mentioning Rob,he left 14 years ago you idiot!! Glad Louis said so.He is still part of Take That history, former Take That star, Robbie Williams.

[Ross]

Anyone singing Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me?

[Alf]

joe 10/10
stacey 7/10
olly 4/10
danyl 4/10
lloyd 4/10

[Princess]

ARGH Heat RT'ed me!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Marc]

stacey was aweomse! :D

[Shaun]

Anyone singing Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me?

joe did last week? :p

[Jords]

^ that is a fair representation of the first performances

Thanks, and I mean bag not bad lol :tongue:

[Chels]

Anyone singing Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me?

Mr McElderry <3

[Novo]

6 Times for Olly

Couldn't get through the first time :/

[MarkWaldorf]

yay at joe mentions!

[Stephanie]

round 2

[Ross]

kk -listens- if Danyl ruins this I'll punch him.

[Shaun]

elton is a ****ing legend <3

[LemonJam]

Elton!

[Chels]

Lloyd's line engaged! ;)

[Smithy]

kk -listens- if Danyl ruins this I'll punch him.

u should do a calvin harris and run on stage and do it

[Damaris]

omgah guess what,Elton John worked in my Grandads old pub before he was famous ny grandad fired him and said he would never make it LOL

[Shaun]

Elton John, Joe will know all about him

what the **** is that supposed to mean?

[Tom]

Ugh. Elton is crap

[Chels]

Oh ffs at the start again :/

[Jimmi5bellies]

Stacey has just done herself proud.

[Ross]

Elton is a legend, I swear some of you wouldn't know music if it hit you in the face.

[LemonJam]

PMSL WHAT ****ING HEIGHTS!??!

lawl.

[Shaun]

Tom you do post some **** from time to time but that goes down as the very worst.

[Chels]

**** Louis you turd.

[Twilight]

**** louis you turd.

ikr

[Ross]

OMG HOTTY :shocked:

[Adamw92]

how is Lloyd on now, wasn't he 2nd before?

[andyman]

Elton John is the worlds biggest mega gay, but some great tracks by the man.

[Chels]

OMG So Lush!!!! <33

[Damaris]

EW llyold this is terrible

[Stephanie]

fit

[Smithy]

it'd have been so funny if he'd have missed the cane and dropped it

[Novo]

1/10 so far

[Ninastar]

lloyd - (again) 3/10

[Chels]

how is Lloyd on now, wasn't he 2nd before?

Yeah :/

[biglover]

Stacey was the best by FAR! What is Lloyd doing the mess

[andyman]

I'm still standing
Yeah yeah yeah

[Novo]

Actually 0.5/10

[ButterflyGirl]

eeek

[Twilight]

This is actually amazing imo<3

[Shaun]

great song.
ruined.

GO HOME.

[Jimmi5bellies]

I really like Lloyd, but just don't know if he has the X Factor.

I did not know the site automatically refreshes when somebody posts. Makes it hard to know what your typing lol.

Yea, Lloyd does not suit this song.

[Smithy]

whats with the fat topless dancers

[GypsyGoth]

His first song was way better.

[Stephanie]

4/10
first song was alot better

[Chels]

5/10 :/

[Ross]

First song better. Second was meh. Still 5/10.

[Damaris]

TAKE THAT
Danyl-8/10
Lloyd-2/10
Olly-9/10
Joe-7/10
Stacey-9/10

Elton John

Lloyd-1/10

Overall
Lloyd 3/20

[Twilight]

Lloyd 9/10

[Smithy]

11/20 (Overall)
lol cheryl

[LemonJam]

Cheryl just pwned him.

[Tom]

Tom you do post some **** from time to time but that goes down as the very worst.

He is rubbish

Lloyd took that songs to even new lows

[Stephanie]

better than the first song wtf?

[Damaris]

lloyd 9/10

lmfao rofl lolololololololol

[Novo]

Simon is always right

[Chels]

I really think Lloyd is going now.

[Stephanie]

he's gone ;/

[Tom]

week aftarr week aftarr week

[Novo]

I hope wales gets right behind you and keeps you in

Nice try cheryl.... ****ing Moron

[Adamw92]

Round 1
Danyl - 5/10
Lloyd - 2/10
Olly - 5.5/10
Joe - 7.5/10
Stacey - 9/10

Round 2
Lloyd - 2.5/10

[biglover]

TakeThat:
Stacey 10/10
Lloyd 2/10
Olly 4/10
Danyl 7/10
Joe 8/10

Elton John
Lloyd 1/10

Overall
Lloyd 3/10

[Smithy]

omg its the semi's next week its gone so fast :(

[Shaun]

yeah k tom, some of the greatest songs/albums of all time, worldwide platinum-selling and been going for nearly 40 years.

rubbish.

[Patrick]

Cheryl "So much critizisem and i hope the World gets behind you and keeps you in"

WTF!

1. Hes got NO Critizisem compared to what Jedward got and still get!
2. Its The UK not the world!

[Stephanie]

danyl bleh

[biglover]

come on Danyl!!

[Smithy]

his lisp really annoys me

[Ross]

TAKE THAT:

Danyl: 6/10
Lloyd: 7/10
Olly: 9/10
Joe: 10/10
Stacey: 9/10

ELTON JOHN:

Lloyd: 5/10

OVERALL:

Lloyd: 12/20

[andyman]

This is actually amazing imo<3The song is good, not the wet shít singing..

[Jimmi5bellies]

omg its the semi's next week its gone so fast :(

Yea it has gone quick. Soon will be CBB :blush:

[LemonJam]

Danyl and Lloyd 1st and 2nd. 3 favourites are last. Ha.

[Adamw92]

danyl bleh

My thoughts exactly, shouting here we come...

[Damaris]

This sounds weird

[Smithy]

Yea it has gone quick. Soon will be CBB :blush:

omg i know so excited about that its gona b amazing

[Ross]

SHUT UP NOW DANYL.

STOP.
Don't ruin this song.

NO AHH/ -SCREAMS-

-PUNCH-
-KILL-
-SLAP-
-STAB-

[Smithy]

yawwwwnnn

[Damaris]

wth is wrong with this? it sucks

[Shaun]

stupid beginning. but it's showing signs of improvement.

[Jimmi5bellies]

My thoughts exactly, shouting here we come...

He always goes OTT at the end. His gob is massive. At least he has a garage to park his car in.

[Adamw92]

SHUT UP NOW DANYL.

STOP.
Don't ruin this song.

NO AHH/ -SCREAMS-

-PUNCH-
-KILL-
-SLAP-
-STAB-

Breathe, breathe, BREATHE! :joker:

[Stephanie]

how many songs are they going to ruin

[biglover]

TakeThat:
Stacey 10/10
Lloyd 2/10
Olly 4/10
Danyl 7/10
Joe 8/10

Elton John
Lloyd 1/10
Danyl - 9/10

Overall
Lloyd 3/20
Danyl 16/20

[Ninastar]

Omg i hate him so much but i am really loving this!

[Chels]

I'm so pissed off :(

[Tom]

Danyl has his spark back

[Stephanie]

i liked this song.. but now i will only think of it like this. fail.

[Ross]

Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh omg.

Shut up Danyl.

Right he's ruined it. I ****ing hate him more now. I HATE YOU DANYL.

[Smithy]

how many songs are they going to ruin

staceys the only good singer
so tonite it will be 8

[Chels]

P.s. this Danyl ****

[Niamh.]

hhhmmm, his voice does nothing for me

[Novo]

Danyl

8/10 - 8/10 = 16/20

[Stephanie]

2/10

[LemonJam]

Bar the beginning, that was brilliant.

[Damaris]

TAKE THAT
Danyl-8/10
Lloyd-2/10
Olly-9/10
Joe-7/10
Stacey-9/10

Elton John

Lloyd-1/10
Danyl- 7/10

Overall
Lloyd 3/20
Danyl 15/20

[Braden]

ugh, sit down simon !

[andyman]

Fleetwood Mac week? :(

[Shaun]

quite good. not amazing, but quite nice. but gtf that song.

[Ross]

AWFUL!!!!!!1

Ruined a good song. Utter twat. Useless man. I hate you.

[biglover]

That was amazing Danyl!

[Twilight]

Danyl 7/10

[Stephanie]

pmsl overall = 7/20

[biglover]

AMAAAZZZIIIINNGGGG!!! Danyl Rocks!

[Adamw92]

Round 1
Danyl - 5/10
Lloyd - 2/10
Olly - 5.5/10
Joe - 7.5/10
Stacey - 9/10

Round 2
Lloyd - 2.5/10
Danyl - 5.5/10

[Ross]

Danyl 1/10

[Shaun]

Fleetwood Mac week? :(

i'd love that. in a way. but they'd probably ruin more of my favourite songs :\

[Stephanie]

simon ****

[Ross]

TAKE THAT:

Danyl: 6/10
Lloyd: 7/10
Olly: 9/10
Joe: 10/10
Stacey: 9/10

ELTON JOHN:

Lloyd: 5/10
Danyl: 1/10

OVERALL:

Lloyd: 12/20
Danyl: 7/10

[biglover]

Louis is a grade a ******

[Jimmi5bellies]

"Little Children that wanted to be on the show, let them" - Is he talking about Jedward :D