How is Stacey still in the competition?

[LemonJam]

I can't get around my head how Stacey has seriously got this far. Here's my reasons why:

She's a fair singer, but she doesn't have any interesting tone in her voice.
She's not always pitch perfect
She's got no versatility
She's not exactly a looker
When you look at Lucie and Rachel and previous female contestants from other series, she's as dull as dishwater.

So Stacey fans can you tell me why you like her please because I literally can't get my head around it.

P.S. Anyone who uses the 'BUT YOU LIKE DANYL LOL' argument shows that they cannot prove a point so don't bother using that. :bigsmile:

[InOne]

She is a joke. She should get back to looking after that kid of hers.

[\PJ/]

Whos that in your avatar?

[Smithy]

shes a good singer unlike a lot of other people in the final 12
and shes just funny & sweet even though she is a bit dopey

[setanta]

I agree but she's playing a good game with her ditzy character. Oh, I want to say something about Danyl so badly!!

[Dr.Gonzo]

She's not a bad singer, but I personally think she gets through from her talks with Dermot - they're much more enjoyable than her performances.

[LemonJam]

Whos that in your avatar?

Josh Farro of Paramore :bigsmile:

Took a different route from my usual Hayley Whoring.

[Jords]

You like Danyl who is boring, what you on about? And he isnt always picth perfect. Why do you like him?

First off, shes a great singer, she might not be very versitile, but shes one of the most out the 4 left - she has coped well with all the male themes.

She isnt always pitch perfect no, but better than Danyl and Olly who are still in, and when she gets them big long notes, shes ace.

Are you gay? Cause Stacey is beauts :lovedup:

And if she is so dull, why did both Rachel and Lucie try acting like her on a few occasions? Face it, her personality is the most vivid and people love her for it!

[Niamh.]

I agree with you 100% LJ

[Chels]

You like Danyl who is boring, what you on about? And he isnt always picth perfect. Why do you like him?



You ignored his warning LOL.
Fear the wrath of Lemon Jam :P

[setanta]

You like Danyl who is boring, what you on about? And he isnt always picth perfect. Why do you like him?

First off, shes a great singer, she might not be very versitile, but shes one of the most out the 4 left - she has coped well with all the male themes.

She isnt always pitch perfect no, but better than Danyl and Olly who are still in, and when she gets them big long notes, shes ace.

Are you gay? Cause Stacey is beauts :lovedup:

And if she is so dull, why did both Rachel and Lucie try acting like her on a few occasions? Face it, her personality is the most vivid and people love her for it!

Jords, she's not a great singer and her personality is being totally exaggerated for the cameras.

But yeah, Danyl is rubbish - I'll agree with you on that.

[LemonJam]

You like Danyl who is boring, what you on about? And he isnt always picth perfect. Why do you like him?

First off, shes a great singer, she might not be very versitile, but shes one of the most out the 4 left - she has coped well with all the male themes.

She isnt always pitch perfect no, but better than Danyl and Olly who are still in, and when she gets them big long notes, shes ace.

Are you gay? Cause Stacey is beauts :lovedup:

And if she is so dull, why did both Rachel and Lucie try acting like her on a few occasions? Face it, her personality is the most vivid and people love her for it!

1. Take note.

P.S. Anyone who uses the 'BUT YOU LIKE DANYL LOL' argument shows that they cannot prove a point so don't bother using that. :bigsmile:

I don't think pitch is OVERLY important, more the tone as they're going to be recording artists. He sounded the best on the single along with Rikki and Rachel so thats that ****ing argument out the window.

2. I'm not gay, I just don't want genital mutilation if she were ever to give me head.

Thirdly;

Face it, her personality is the most vivid and people love her for it!

I think you may have summed up why people like her in that one sentence.

[LemonJam]

You ignored his warning LOL.
Fear the wrath of Lemon Jam :P

-explodes everwhere-

Take that how you will...




















...;)

[Stephanie]

LMAO
everyone else left > stacey
if she didn't act like an idiot no-one would like her. fact.

[Raph]

i like her because...

Lucie and Rachel were the best,
so I just want Dannii to win as a mentor! <3

[Stephanie]

i like her because...

Lucie and Rachel were the best,
so I just want Dannii to win as a mentor! <3
stupid reason

[Jords]

1. Take note.



I don't think pitch is OVERLY important, more the tone as they're going to be recording artists. He sounded the best on the single along with Rikki and Rachel so thats that ****ing argument out the window.

2. I'm not gay, I just don't want genital mutilation if she were ever to give me head.

Thirdly;



I think you may have summed up why people like her in that one sentence.


Well peoples tastes vary, you think Danyls tone is the beast whereas Staceys fans think hers is the best obv (same with Joe & Olly), its no argument its just all based on taste. Her voice is my favourite out all of this years bunch, like Danyls is yours.

You would not get genital mutilation, so thats just a daft comeback.

Yepp, her main appeal is her personality, thats what all good artists should have to draw in fans, imagine her in interviews, would be epic! But her voice is great too, she stole the show in week 6, and won Take That round this week by far.

And Steph, thats not true, her personality is a big draw but its not everything, her voice is great too.
Thats like saying, Joe wouldnt have as much support if he was a bully, or he couldnt sing, you judge on what the person is/has, not what they would be without something or with something.

[Sam!]

BUT YOU LIKE DANYL LOL :wink:

[LemonJam]

BUT YOU LIKE DANYL LOL :wink:

http://i49.tinypic.com/2wbu5ww.gif

[Chels]

2. I'm not gay, I just don't want genital mutilation if she were ever to give me head.


:laugh3::laugh3:

[Sam!]

http://i49.tinypic.com/2wbu5ww.gif

You voted to eliminate me twice in Elimination. :thumbs: so called FRIEND.

[robb]

It's the liking of Ricki Lonely that should be of more concern!!!
Stacey is a good singer, not great.......but you can say that about any of the remaining acts......even Joe is Neil Sedaka lite!!
Stacey is also the fave of Jedward,Lloyd, and Lucie...........all of whom want her to win, none of whom have said anything other than she's the real deal. She has as much right to be in the last 4 as anyone else left in there. (And I liked Lucie too!!)
There, I got through without mention of u know who............

[Jords]

It's the liking of Ricki Lonely that should be of more concern!!!
Stacey is a good singer, not great.......but you can say that about any of the remaining acts......even Joe is Neil Sedaka lite!!
Stacey is also the fave of Jedward,Lloyd, and Lucie...........all of whom want her to win, none of whom have said anything other than she's the real deal. She has as much right to be in the last 4 as anyone else left in there. (And I liked Lucie too!!)
There, I got through without mention of u know who............

Well said, and good point, shes the most geniune :thumbs:

I had to mention Danyl, hes slating Stacey when you can say the same things back about him :nono: :joker:

[LemonJam]

You voted to eliminate me twice in Elimination. :thumbs: so called FRIEND.

It's called tactics love.

It's the liking of Ricki Lonely that should be of more concern!!!


Rikki at least had an interesting tone to his voice though. That's why I liked him.

I had to mention Danyl, hes slating Stacey when you can say the same things back about him :nono: :joker:

Indeed you can. I'll admit tuning wise he's the worst in the compeition, but at least you can tell his voice apart from other singers. Stacey blends in with the crowd.

[Ninastar]

I can understand what you mean and everything but I think alot of people find her talented, they can kinda relate to her, shes (again) kind of a good role model and people love her personality.
Thats why I like her anyway lol.

[InOne]

Lets settle with they are all crap. You might support someone but you know they are **** really.

[Jords]

Indeed you can. I'll admit tuning wise he's the worst in the compeition, but at least you can tell his voice apart from other singers. Stacey blends in with the crowd.

Nah I love Staceys voice, but dont get me wrong, I think Danyl is a good singer too, want him in the final along with Stacey and Joe :)

[*mazedsalv**]

1. She can sing
2. She has personality, she's sweet with it.
3. Role Models to teens, believe me, most people that know who she is would call her a role model. She kind of gives out the impression that you dont have to be skinny to be beautiful, just smile, laugh and be yourself... the reason why she is a big attraction.

[Smithy]

I can understand what you mean and everything but I think alot of people find her talented, they can kinda relate to her, shes (again) kind of a good role model and people love her personality.
Thats why I like her anyway lol.

yes and shes better than olly and danyl by miles

[Chels]

1. She can sing
2. She has personality, she's sweet with it.
3. Role Models to teens, believe me, most people that know who she is would call her a role model. She kind of gives out the impression that you dont have to be skinny to be beautiful, just smile, laugh and be yourself... the reason why she is a big attraction.

Role model to teens?
Just out of curiosity (because I don't know LOL) how old was she when she was pregnant with little Zach? :)

[Smithy]

Role model to teens?
Just out of curiosity (because I don't know LOL) who old was she when she was pregnant with little Zach? :)

who old or how old?
:joker:

[InOne]

Role model to teens?
Just out of curiosity (because I don't know LOL) who old was she when she was pregnant with little Zach? :)

She shows you can have a drunken shag in the park and still blag your way into thinking you're worth something.

[Ninastar]

Role model to teens?
Just out of curiosity (because I don't know LOL) who old was she when she was pregnant with little Zach? :)

No idea but yeah shes a good role model because she has done well raising him and no one knows if maybe she planned it or it was an accident because of being drunk or w.e
I remember dannii saying that stacey couldnt even talk about sex and I though ifs shes had sex why cant she talk about it? so there is obviously something weird about it all.

[Chels]

who old or how old?
:joker:

LOL thanks for the correction :P

[setanta]

Lets settle with they are all crap. You might support someone but you know they are **** really.

Pretty accurate there dude.

[Chels]

No idea but yeah shes a good role model because she has done well raising him and no one knows if maybe she planned it or it was an accident because of being drunk or w.e
I remember dannii saying that stacey couldnt even talk about sex and I though ifs shes had sex why cant she talk about it? so there is obviously something weird about it all.

Yeah I suppose you're right :) although I'm only 16 and if I got bloody pregnant at this age I'd scream + die. lol.
Oh that is sort of strange... some of the bans they give the contestants are ridiculous.

[InOne]

Pretty accurate there dude.

I don't get why people get so offended when you say something bad about their favourite. It's like BB, they will be bored of them once they're out or it is over.

[setanta]

I don't get why people get so offended when you say something bad about their favourite. It's like BB, they will be bored of them once they're out or it is over.

Very, very true, especially since they're all fairly crap right now.

[Adamw92]

Shes still there because she can sing and it's a singing competition (and before anyone says its an entertainment show, I havent said it isn't) and yeah she may not have the best singing voice but so what, she CAN sing and thats the point.

Plus she has the likeability factor and isn't arrogant like a certain couple of contestants that are left.

[Ninastar]

Yeah I suppose you're right :) although I'm only 16 and if I got bloody pregnant at this age I'd scream + die. lol.
Oh that is sort of strange... some of the bans they give the contestants are ridiculous.

no i didnt mean she was banned from it lol! I made it sound like that though, sorry! lol.
I mean that she feels really uncomfortable about it and things. I don't understand why she would when she has obviously had sex? If that makes sense lol. I think she was maybe pursuaded into it or something, then ended up pregnant.
Then again I have no idea, she might have been a total slag about it. Thing is we cant really say what we dont know.

[Chels]

no i didnt mean she was banned from it lol! I made it sound like that though, sorry! lol.
I mean that she feels really uncomfortable about it and things. I don't understand why she would when she has obviously had sex? If that makes sense lol. I think she was maybe pursuaded into it or something, then ended up pregnant.
Then again I have no idea, she might have been a total slag about it. Thing is we cant really say what we dont know.

Oh LOL I get what you mean :tongue:
I hope she wasn't pressurised into it or anything, and I don't get the impression she's a slag, she seems a sensible girl and I think she has done a good job raising Zach :) they're so cute together!

[Ninastar]

Oh LOL I get what you mean :tongue:
I hope she wasn't pressurised into it or anything, and I don't get the impression she's a slag, she seems a sensible girl and I think she has done a good job raising Zach :) they're so cute together!

hehe yeah I agree! he is adorable.

[alc09]

Agree with the first post.

I'm not the greatest fan of Leona Lewis and Alex Burke, wasn't at the time either, but those 2 were miles ahead of Stacey when at the same stage.

She simply isn't up to the standard of the last 2 winners who were also girls, I think one of the 3 boys should win really.

Personality doesn't make her a worthy winner.

[Jords]

Agree with the first post.

I'm not the greatest fan of Leona Lewis and Alex Burke, wasn't at the time either, but those 2 were miles ahead of Stacey when at the same stage.

She simply isn't up to the standard of the last 2 winners who were also girls, I think one of the 3 boys should win really.

Personality doesn't make her a worthy winner.

I would love Stacey to win,
but I can see why people want a male winner,
weve only really had Will Young a winner who did quite well,
but where is he now?

[alc09]

I would love Stacey to win,
but I can see why people want a male winner,
weve only really had Will Young a winner who did quite well,
but where is he now?
Do you agree that Stacey isn't any where near the standard of the last 2 winners?

That said, I have a very strong feeling that she will win, sadly.

And regarding Will Young, I could not give a **** about him. Didn't like him then and don't like him now.

[lily.]

1. Genital Mutilation .. epic!

2. Sensible Girl? Really Chels?

3. I don't think she's pretty.

4. I think her dumb act is a bit contrived. I have no doubt she's dizzy, but she's definitely playing it up now.

5. She's an average singer. Lucie was better.


.. and on a different note ..

You voted to eliminate me twice in Elimination. :thumbs: so called FRIEND.

How do you know he voted you?

[30stone]

She's a fair singer, but she doesn't have any interesting tone in her voice. - Shes the one i most look forward to, is entertaining to watch and i dont know you mean by interesting tone.. i just think if i am attracted to it and like it... then its interesting
She's not always pitch perfect - Generally better than the rest, along with tackling far harder songs
She's got no versatility - She isn't the worst we have seen
She's not exactly a looker - no not really
When you look at Lucie and Rachel and previous female contestants from other series, she's as dull as dishwater.- stacey shows more personality than both of them

[Jords]

Do you agree that Stacey isn't any where near the standard of the last 2 winners?

That said, I have a very strong feeling that she will win, sadly.

And regarding Will Young, I could not give a **** about him. Didn't like him then and don't like him now.

Nah i dont really like Will Young, but he was quite successful.

And she is wayyy better than Leon, but Alex is better than her.
But like Simon said, she isnt a big song belter like Leona/Alex (although give her the right song and she can be - week 6 :thumbs:), shes more of a softer song singer, if Dannii gives her a few of them, shell be very good - like wonderful world.

[alc09]

She's not a performer either, be nice too see her move for once.

[alc09]

When you look at Lucie and Rachel and previous female contestants from other series, she's as dull as dishwater.


Is this comment a joke, or are you on about a different Lucie?

She was so ****ing dull it was beyond belief.

[Vicky.]

I dont get the attraction at all. She is decidedly average. Only week she stood out for me was george michael week.

And her dumb act is wearing thin now.

[Tom]

'The X Factor' isn't vocal ability.

[LemonJam]

'The X Factor' isn't vocal ability.

It's acting like a twat then?

[Tom]

It's acting like a twat then?

Whether she acts like a twat is subjective. Clearly people like her

[Marc]

P.S. Anyone who uses the 'BUT YOU LIKE DANYL LOL' argument shows that they cannot prove a point so don't bother using that. :bigsmile:

Okay but you like Rikki.. :tongue:

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Shes intresting and can sing, and has a personality, unlike whats his face, the gay teenager one!

[Patrick]

When you look at Lucie and Rachel and previous female contestants from other series, she's as dull as dishwater.



LMFAO :joker:
Rachel more intresting than Stacey? :joker::joker:

[Stephanie]

stacey isn't intresting, all she does is act like an idiot.

[Z]

Her personality carried her for the first two-three weeks; shock eliminations carried her for the following month or so, and then by default she's going to make the final because there are worse singers than her left.

(shock eliminations = Miss Frank (possibly), Lucie and Jamie)

[teabag.]

i like her but i agree that out of the three girls she was the worst, shes getting through because of her personality

[Beastie]

She is a single mum
She is from Essex
She has a great big personality!

This is why Stacey is still in the competition. She has had some average performances but a few good ones too!

[Lewis.]

She's a likeable girl with a really great voice.. what's not to like?

[Smithy]

i like her but i agree that out of the three girls she was the worst, shes getting through because of her personality

no she wasnt shes much better than rachael and lucie(mayb on a par with her)

[Jords]

no she wasnt shes much better than rachael and lucie(mayb on a par with her)

Stacey > Lucie = Rachel

Rachel had great vocals, but was fake, cant stand people who try act somebody they are not.

Lucie had good vocals, buttt, I found her screachy at times, and also had no personality whatsoever on the show.

Stacey, great vocals, great personality, geniune, better than the other girls, but the other girls were not bad :)

[Smithy]

Stacey > Lucie = Rachel

Rachel had great vocals, but was fake, cant stand people who try act somebody they are not.

Lucie had good vocals, buttt, I found her screachy at times, and also had no personality whatsoever on the show.

Stacey, great vocals, great personality, geniune, better than the other girls, but the other girls were not bad :)

:thumbs:

[LemonJam]

LMFAO :joker:
Rachel more intresting than Stacey? :joker::joker:

Easily.

[LemonJam]

Stacey > Lucie = Rachel

Rachel had great vocals, but was fake, cant stand people who try act somebody they are not.

Lucie had good vocals, buttt, I found her screachy at times, and also had no personality whatsoever on the show.

Stacey, great vocals, great personality, geniune, better than the other girls, but the other girls were not bad :)

...so you're supporting people as if it were big brother?

[LemonJam]

Okay but you like Rikki.. :tongue:

It's called an interesting tone and difference. People round here might want to try it sometime. :tongue:

He sounds amazing on the charity record.

[Jords]

...so you're supporting people as if it were big brother?

Partly, they got to have appeal as well as a great voice, if you read what I wrote, I said Stacey had great vocals :) But she is also the most geniune :thumbs: