X Factor Live Discussion Thread 05/12/09 8PM

[Stephanie]

lol @ those giving danyl 10/10

[Brad.]

So far then

Joe 5/10
Stacey 5.5/10
Olly 8/10
Danyl 6/10

I would rate them exactly like that, maybe danyl a bit higher though.

[Jords]

Round 1
Olly - 6/10
Joe 7.5/10
Stacey 7.5/10
Danyl 6.5/10

[Marc]

Round 1
Olly: 5/10
Joe: 9/10
Stacey: 6/10
Danyl: 5/10

[Adamw92]

Urgh still another performance by Olly to get through and then Danyl right at the end...what joy!

[Novo]

Come on Olly and Danyl!

[Stacey.]

10/10 for dan tonight!:D
come on, danyl is fantastic:D

[Stephanie]

come on olly

[Damaris]

My Dad will kill me ive voted 20 times for Olly so far!

[Stacey.]

My Dad will kill me ive voted 20 times for Olly so far!

stop!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Smithy]

My Dad will kill me ive voted 20 times for Olly so far!

y waste the money

[Damaris]

Cmon olly

[Marc]

Good choice song

[Smithy]

wth is with the mike stand lol

[Chels]

Better than the other one.

[GypsyGoth]

I like this.

[Brad.]

Simply brilliant!

[Patrick]

WTF Happened to him singing Snow Patrol?

This song is ****

[Stacey.]

round 1
olly - 7/10
joe - 6/10
stacey - 5/10
danyl - 10/10

[andyman]

World class amazing! Olly at his best as always..

[Marc]

better than the other one.

much

[Chels]

I was worried he'd be singing Chasing Cars; he would have murdered that :mad:

[Adamw92]

And he ruins another performance with his disgraceful dance moves

[Alf]

*********g hell
talk about killing a song
*********g shite
goodbye olly

[Stacey.]

too much moving tonight for olly.
its doing him NO favours whatsoever.

[*mazedsalv**]

im sorry... coming from a fomer Olly fan, but i dont know whats happened.

[Jords]

Olly fans stop overrating, world class? Get real, its slightly better than round 1

[Tom]

Danyl was brilliant and stole round 1 ... 9/10, a bit flat near the end. people who hate him need to take a step back, pre conceived ideas and that

Joe was really good, he surprised me, 7/10

Stacey was crap, 5/10

Olly was shocking, 2/10

[Marc]

he's in trouble this week

[Stephanie]

8/10

[Adamw92]

Round 2

Olly- 5/10

[King Gizzard]

Class! 8/10

[Smithy]

yea likeability factor - lol

[andyman]

BRAVO! BRAVO! BRAVO!

Legend!

[Brad.]

9/10 fantastic!

[Chels]

Olly was shocking, 2/10

SEE I wasn't the only one!!
:rolleyes:

The Olly fans slaughtered me cos i gave him a 2.

[Jords]

Round 2
Olly 6.5/10

[Alf]

Class! 8/10
smell those smelling salts

[Smithy]

R2
olly 7/10

[Sam!]

Olly - 5.5/10
Joe - 7.5/10
Stacey - 7/10
Danyl - 5/10
Olly - 6.5/10 - better than the first.

[lily.]

He's ****. And, what was that dancing?? What is he?? George Sampson's embarrassing uncle? Holy crap.

[Alf]

9/10 fantastic!
wake up little snoozey

[Chels]

Round 2

Olly 5/10

[Patrick]

Oh **** Off Joe!

[*mazedsalv**]

IMO Simon has taken a wrong route for Olly.

IMO, a godo choice for him would be:
Jamiroquai- Little L.

[Chels]

OMG spitting image of his Dad!!

[King Gizzard]

Here comes Mr Dull

[Stephanie]

all this disney-like background music is pissing me off

[andyman]

Pure world class from Olly..

He will lift the singing World Cup!

[Novo]

that Tune in the back was in edward scissorhands

[Smithy]

mr million teeth

[Locke.]

#1
Danyl - 10/10
Joe - 9/10
Olly - 7/10
Stacey - 5/10

#2
Olly - 8.5/10

[GypsyGoth]

He does have a very good voice.

[Stephanie]

this is so flipping boring

[Sam!]

Joe has a good voice but seriously who would buy his music?

[Patrick]

*Falls Alseep*

If this prick doesnt leave now then the Final will make the nation fall asleep.

[Stephanie]

-yawn-

[King Gizzard]

cannot stand that overly vibrato voice ffs.

[Smithy]

i am actually yawning hes putting me to sleep

[Chels]

OMG he's amazing

[Adamw92]

Its good but I'm getting sick of him getting ballads

[GypsyGoth]

what is this song called?

[Stephanie]

i nearly fell asleep and choaked on my popcorn

[King Gizzard]

There will always be work on a cruise ship Joe

[Smithy]

*thump*
head hits laptop

[lily.]

That was amazing.

[Jords]

Joe, great voice but tbh really quite dull, shame really, he could have been great. I give his 1st preformance 8/10 not 7.5

Round 2
Olly 6.5/10
Joe 8.5/10

[Stephanie]

6/10 good but boring

[Patrick]

Joe has a good voice but seriously who would buy his music?

He`ll probley win.
And will flop like Leon!

He will be **** at singing 'The Climb'
Stacey would be miles better.

So even if he wins, he`ll fail straight away when the Climb comes out and its him singing it.


People will forget all about him a Day after the Final.
At least if Stacey or Olly won people would buy their album and would go to see them in Concert.

[Smithy]

R2
olly - 7
joe - 7

[Locke.]

#1
Danyl - 10/10
Joe - 9/10
Olly - 7/10
Stacey - 5/10

#2
Olly - 8.5/10
Joe - 6/10


http://i49.tinypic.com/2ivxpid.jpg

He gave a better performance of Open Arms than Joe last year

[Gemmer-x]

Joe was amazing!

[Sam!]

Olly - 5.5/10
Joe - 7.5/10
Stacey - 7/10
Danyl - 5/10
Olly - 6.5/10
Joe - 7/10 - good voice but pretty boring

[Smithy]

oh simons voice is going, it must be coz hes chatting so much ****

[Chels]

10/10
his voice is so amazing.

[Patrick]

God!
So over rated!

[Stephanie]

olly - 8/10 - 8/10
joe - 7/10 - 6/10
stacey - 5/10
danyl - 2/10

[Brad.]

8/10

[andyman]

Can't stand Money Bags Super Chav Mrs Cole.. Vile witch!

[Smithy]

move over joe let the real talent come on stage
enter - stacey -

[King Gizzard]

Wheres that coffee

Im falling asleep

[GypsyGoth]

I think Joe is the only one who is in the final for sure.

[Stephanie]

i'm feeling sleepy now

[Smithy]

i'm feeling sleepy now

i think everyone does lol

[*mazedsalv**]

I havnt been wrong about a winner since XF2, I guessed that all of Shayne, Leona, Leon and Alexandra would all win when watching semi final night.

And i am getting this vibe from Joe.

[lily.]

Joe is the best singer on the show. It is a singing competition, in case anyone forgot that.......

[King Gizzard]

Okay Stacey has tooken over Joe in my ranks

Still both pretty poor but yeah..

[Stephanie]

it's obvious joe's going to win
there's no point in everyone else even singing, we might aswell cancel the final

[lily.]

i think everyone does lol

Not everyone watches the show to see a dodgy-dad-dancer. I'm not falling asleep when Joe is on.

[King Gizzard]

Singing competition yes..but its more ''the xfactor'' doesnt have to be the best singer

[Princess]

Joe was absolutely incredible,I love him more and more every week. Olly did great,really not fussed about Danyl at all.

[Locke.]

Joe is the best singer on the show. It is a singing competition, in case anyone forgot that.......

And Danyl has a stronger and better voice. Pick up the phone and vote for Danyl.

[Chels]

Not everyone watches the show to see a dodgy-dad-dancer. I'm not falling asleep when Joe is on.

Lmfao this.

[Novo]

Voted 8 times for Olly

he is safe now

[Patrick]

I really do hope half of the UK thinks Joe is safe and doesnt vote.

Or I just hope I wasnt the only one who fell alseep during those 3 minutes and maybe everyone missed his performance and didnt vote :)

He cant be in the final, if he is then he`ll win and it will be a waste.
If Stacey wins it wont be a waste!

Vote Stacey or Olly!

[lily.]

Danyl's voice is incredibly nasal in my view.

[Raph]

Olly 7/10 and 6.5/10
Joe 9/10 and 9.5/10
Stacey 4/10 and..
Danyl 4.5/10 and...


Joe MUST win... that way although Rachel went out it still shows that the best singer wins! <3

[lily.]

Patrick, your opinion ceased to matter when you stated that Rage Against the Machine were probably an act Simon refused to put through the X-Factor.

[Patrick]

Joe is the best singer on the show. It is a singing competition, in case anyone forgot that.......


You realise he wouldnt of got past the first few weeks if he was Ugly.

[lily.]

You realise he wouldnt of got past the first few weeks if he was Ugly.


Bollocks. Olly is there.

[Jords]

Staceyyy :D

[andyman]

Danyl > Joe... When it comes to singing!

[Stephanie]

oh ffs stacey 2.0 (her sister)

[Smithy]

Not everyone watches the show to see a dodgy-dad-dancer. I'm not falling asleep when Joe is on.

ew i really cant stand olly dont say anything like that again

[Brad.]

oh ffs stacey 2.0 (her sister)

uglier as well, but just as annoying.

[Chels]

This will save her

[Adamw92]

Come on Stacey <3

[MrGaryy]

Bollocks. Olly is there.

Ikr he talks so much bollocks. if Joe was to survive on his looks he would be **** out of luck.

[Patrick]

Bollocks. Olly is there.

Girls dont think Olly is fit though.

Girls would cry if Joe didnt get through.

Joe and Lloyd were only saved because of looks.
Joe however won more people over because of his voice where as Lloyd relied only on his stupid Looks.


But addmitt it girls went GaGa over Joe weeks ago and they still do.

[Smithy]

amazing already

[*mazedsalv**]

Go Stacey!!!

[lily.]

ew i really cant stand olly dont say anything like that again


haha.. I apologise. I just assumed you were one of the Olly-followers..

[Patrick]

Stacey HAS to Win.

[Jords]

Absolutely stunning!!

[arista]

This to slow and gentle

[Locke.]

Stacey is gonna go tomorrow now

[GypsyGoth]

Wow, beautiful song, great singing.

[Stephanie]

this is kinda boring

[Smithy]

haha.. I apologise. I just assumed you were one of the Olly-followers..

ew i was just sick a little reading that

[Ninastar]

Okay wow. she is doing amazing.

[Marc]

Wow....!

[Brad.]

dull. 4/10

[lily.]

Girls dont think Olly is fit though.

Girls would cry if Joe didnt get through.

Joe and Lloyd were only saved because of looks.
Joe however won more people over because of his voice where as Lloyd relied only on his stupid Looks.


But addmitt it girls went GaGa over Joe weeks ago and they still do.


That's my point. You said ugly people wouldn't get thru, yet Olly did.

[arista]

A Judge standing up Early
that is wrong

[MrGaryy]

Stacey honey, I couldn't care less.

[Chels]

Blaaaaaaddy hell that was outstanding!
9/10 :D

[Ninastar]

she got her mojo back??

[Stephanie]

all i heard was _____________________________ a whole line of a held note.

[King Gizzard]

Probably my favourite song by her

7/10

Great song choice as well

[Smithy]

stacey 20/10
even cheryl stood up the first person to get more than just there own judge standing up

[Novo]

That pretty much sealed Olly's fate :(

[Sam!]

Olly - 5.5/10
Joe - 7.5/10
Stacey - 7/10
Danyl - 5/10
Olly - 6.5/10
Joe - 7/10
Stacey - 9/10; best so far tonight

[Gemmer-x]

Stacey was great

[Jords]

Fantastic! Incredible! Got to get through! Best preformance by her and of the night :lovedup:


Round 2
Olly 6.5/10
Joe 8.5/10
Stacey 10/10

[Stephanie]

7/10

[Smithy]

im so gonna but that on my ipod as soon as it comes online

[Patrick]

That's my point. You said ugly people wouldn't get thru, yet Olly did.

Oh right

Read it wrong :spin:

[lily.]

Ikr he talks so much bollocks. if Joe was to survive on his looks he would be **** out of luck.



Don't make me get ninja finn ..

http://i46.tinypic.com/bfnp05.gif

[Stacey.]

stace was fab :)

[Locke.]

#1
Danyl - 10/10
Joe - 9/10
Olly - 7/10
Stacey - 5/10

#2
Olly - 8.5/10
Stacey - 8/10
Joe - 6/10

[arista]

all i heard was _____________________________ a whole line of a held note.


Yes I can see and hear that point of view.

[Brad.]

the audience laugh at her when she talks, how embarassing. :(

[Stephanie]

someone shut her up please

[Patrick]

im so gonna but that on my ipod as soon as it comes online

lol

The only song from X Factor 09 I have on my iPod is Jamies Audition :)

[Adamw92]

Stacey was incredible <3 <3

[Smithy]

#1
Danyl - 10/10
Joe - 9/10
Olly - 7/10
Stacey - 5/10

#2
Olly - 8.5/10
Stacey - 8/10
Joe - 6/10

how the hell was olly better than stacey in round 2???

[King Gizzard]

Then she ruins it with her silly annoying talking.

[andyman]

What did Stacey say? She English?

[lily.]

Stacey can't possibly be that thick. Is anyone really that thick? I think it's put on .. to an extent.

[arista]

someone shut her up please


She is like a Sloppy Dog

[MrGaryy]

Don't make me get ninja finn ..

http://i46.tinypic.com/bfnp05.gif

some of us don't need martial arts, my point speaks for itself.

[Smithy]

this advert is stupid its like the bitch in the middle of all the flowers is high

[Locke.]

how the hell was olly better than stacey in round 2???

First half wasn't very good. All of Olly's was great, only the last half of Stacey's was great.

[arista]

What did Stacey say? She English?


Put the Subtitles on , helps

[GypsyGoth]

Stacey can't possibly be that thick. Is anyone really that thick? I think it's put on .. to an extent.

I think it is put on too.

[Jords]

Round 1 - Joe (vocally) & Stacey (preformance wise, but as its a singing contest, Joe is ahead of Stacey on this one)
Round 2 - Stacey

So far, dont think Danyl will top Stacey

[lily.]

some of us don't need martial arts, my point speaks for itself.

Honey, just face it.. your act is a mess of irrelevance.. a bit like you are..

[Smithy]

First half wasn't very good. All of Olly's was great, only the last half of Stacey's was great.

:shocked:

[Novo]

What a great song on that advert now

On FIFA as well

[arista]

some of us don't need martial arts, my point speaks for itself.



Yes I can Feel Your Force.

[Tom]

So far for round 2:

Olly- 4/10
Joe- 6/10
Stacey- 9/10

[lily.]

Yes I can Feel Your Force.

There are laws against that.

[MrGaryy]

Honey, just face it.. your act is a mess of irrelevance.. a bit like you are..

and you're act is buck toothed closet case. more than a bit like you are.

[lily.]

and you're act is buck toothed closet case. more than a bit like you are.


I resent that.. my teeth are gorgeous. :D

[andyman]

Leon Jackson also won...

[Stephanie]

ugh danyl

[Stephanie]

offkey. average nasal. BIG NOTE

memba i told ya

[MrGaryy]

I resent that.. my teeth are gorgeous. :D

I'm sorry gurl you're right you're teeth are fierce xo.

[Jords]

Danyella

[Arneldo]

Danyl is the worst singer left, factual.

[Smithy]

*turns up alejandro*
phew some proper music

[Chels]

my dad is listening to chav music downstairs :|

[Adamw92]

offkey. average nasal. BIG NOTE

memba i told ya

*closes eyes and holds fingers to ears* I'm afraid lol I know exactly whats about to come! :joker:

[Brad.]

Danyl is a legend!

[Novo]

Amazing!

[lily.]

I'm sorry gurl you're right you're teeth are fierce xo.

You're forgiven..

http://i46.tinypic.com/tahveh.gif

[Chels]

This is sheeeeet.

[Stephanie]

this is rubbish

[Novo]

Am starting to Believe danyl could beat Joe

[Stephanie]

yeh that's right, you have nothing cos you don't have me.

[Brad.]

10/10 Brilliant!

[arista]

Amazing!


What better than Olly?

[Smithy]

simon will say best performance of the night

[Jords]

Danyl was pretty good :)

[andyman]

my dad is listening to chav music downstairs :|DJ Daz and MC Nut Job?

[lily.]

Am starting to Believe danyl could beat Joe

Not guna happen..

[King Gizzard]

thought that was pretty boring to be honest

[Gemmer-x]

i don't know what everyone else was listening to but i thought that was pretty good!

[Damaris]

Why did olly go first

[Adamw92]

Round 1

Olly- 4/10
Joe- 8.5/10
Stacey- 8/10
Danyl- 4.5/10

Round 2

Olly- 5/10
Joe- 7.5/10
Stacey- 9/10
Danyl- 6/10
Overall

Olly- 9/20
Joe- 16/20
Stacey- 17/20
Danyl- 10.5/20

[Jords]

Round 1
Olly - 6/10
Joe 8/10
Stacey 7.5/10
Danyl 6.5/10

Round 2
Olly 6.5/10
Joe 8.5/10
Stacey 10/10
Danyl 7.5/10

Overall
Stacey 17.5/20
Joe 16.5/20
Danyl 14/20
Olly 12.5/20

I find my marks quite realistic, not OTT and not silly like 2/10.

[Chels]

DJ Daz and MC Nut Job?

I don't know :L
Ian something lmao

[Smithy]

omg louis is so retarded he just keeps repeating himself hes told evry1 they need to be in the final

[Alf]

olly was in a different league
that league being division 3

[Patrick]

Am starting to Believe danyl could beat Joe

Wouldnt that be amazing.
If Joe went tonight

[Arneldo]

Song #1:
Joe
Stacey
Olly
Danyl

Song #2:
Stacey
Joe
Olly
Danyl

Overall:
Joe
Stacey
Olly
Joe

[Chels]

Danyl 6/10

[Smithy]

overall

stacey
joe
olly
danyl

[Sam!]

Olly - 5.5/10
Joe - 7.5/10
Stacey - 7/10
Danyl - 5/10
Olly - 6.5/10
Joe - 7/10
Stacey - 9/10
Danyl - 4.5/10

Overall:
Danyl: 9.5/20
Olly: 12/20
Joe: 14.5/20
Stacey: 16/20

[Stephanie]

olly - 8/10 - 8/10 - 16/20
joe - 7/10 - 6/10 - 13/20
stacey - 5/10 - 7/10 - 12/20
danyl - 2/10 - 5/10 - 7/20

[MrGaryy]

Danyl is so ****.

[Patrick]

I like Danyl now.
Hope he stays, Joe to ****!

[Chels]

Overall....
Joe 18/20
Stacey 14/20
Danyl 10/20
Olly 9/20


Joe ftww<3

[Damaris]

Olly 8/10 8/10
Joe 9/10 7/10
Stacey 5/10 9/10
Danyl 5/10 6/10

Olly 16/20
Joe 16/20
Stacey 14/20
Danyl 11/20

[Patrick]

Im a Celebrity is over, which means I can watch Xtra Factor straight after the show again :D
Woo!

[Smithy]

Song #1:

Overall:
Joe
Stacey
Olly
Joe

you put joe twice

[arista]

But will this go to a Judge Vote tomorrow

[Arneldo]

you put joe twice


The last one should be Danyl, sorry. I have Joe on the brain.

[Smithy]

Im a Celebrity is over, which means I can watch Xtra Factor straight after the show again :D
Woo!

yay :thumbs2: i've missed the public slagging off the judges

[setanta]

Simon is on drugs or he obviously just thinks he can continually fool the British public because his two act were dire tonight.

[Smithy]

But will this go to a Judge Vote tomorrow

no y would it

[Arneldo]

But will this go to a Judge Vote tomorrow


No.

[andyman]

If Joe wins... Just another Leon Jackson unless he is given some good songs.

Last two.. Joe and Stacey.

[King Gizzard]

I think for me at this rate id be relatively happy with anyone but Joe winning, and Stacey, but to a lesser extent

[Smithy]

Last two.. Joe and Stacey.

hopefully, then staceys version of the climb will blow them all away :hugesmile:

[Stephanie]

ugh this has decided it for me, anyone but joe PLEASE

[Smithy]

Gaga tomorrow :D

[Sam!]

Looking forward to Gaga. :thumbs:

[Jords]

Good shot, Lady Gaga tomorrow, should be great!

[andyman]

Big Brother 12, launch night Friday 1st June 2012 @8.30pm on Channel 5.

It could happen :(

[Shaun]

okay. well. rankings.

1. Joe - Open Arms
2. Joe - She's Out of My Life
3. Danyl - I Have Nothing
4. Stacey - Somewhere
5. Olly - Can You Feel It
6. Danyl - Man in the Mirror
7. Stacey - The Way You Make Me Feel
8. Olly - whatever that second abomination was.

Sorry, and I like Olly, but he's most in jeopardy.

[andyman]

Will Joe get the gay vote?

[Locke.]

#1
Danyl - 10/10
Joe - 9/10
Olly - 7/10
Stacey - 5/10

#2
Danyl - 8.5/10
Olly - 8.5/10
Stacey - 8/10
Joe - 6/10

Overall-
Danyl - 18.5/20
Olly - 15.5/20
Joe - 15/20
Stacey - 13/20

Either Stacey or Joe to go, preferably Joe.

[lily.]

Will Joe get the gay vote?

Yes. I'm voting for him. ;)




BTW get some of that **** off yer sig.. yer taking up half the page!

[andyman]

Yes. I'm voting for him. ;)




BTW get some of that **** off yer sig.. yer taking up half the page!Not a great year for X Factor.. I think Joe will win with Stacey coming close 2nd.

[Novo]

Andyman get on your phone

Vote for Olly

[Princess]

I Have Nothing was the first Danyl song I've loved in a long while! Amazing.

Fav performances of the night for me were both of Joe's and Stacey's Somewhere which was phenomenal.

[andyman]

Andy you know Olly is going tomorrow, i want him in the final but i can't see it.

[Tom]

A bit late and I say the same every week, but Holly would totally get it tonight :lovedup: