X Factor or American Idol?

[Patrick]

What do you love watching the most?

The Americans 'American Idol'
or
The British 'X Factor'

[King Gizzard]

In my opinion, the standard in AI is MUCH higher

But then again its a much bigger country and more to choose from

[Firewire]

AI has had better winners.

Kelly Clarkson
Carrie Underwood
Jordin Sparks

and big contestants like

Chris Daughtry
Ruben Studdard etc.

But I watch X Factor. :P

[Patrick]

AI has had better winners.

Kelly Clarkson
Carrie Underwood
Jordin Sparks

and big contestants like

Chris Daughtry
Ruben Studdard etc.

But I watch X Factor. :P


Not to fond on their winner but Chris Daughtry was brilliant!

[SoFarSoGood282]

X factor...

[Smithy]

AI has had better winners.

Kelly Clarkson
Carrie Underwood
Jordin Sparks

and big contestants like

Chris Daughtry
Ruben Studdard etc.

But I watch X Factor. :P

ive never watched AI but
:lovedup:Kelly Clarkson = Amazing :lovedup:

[Spike]

I think the perfect combination would be The X Factor with the talent of American Idol
Both are really good shows and have their strengths.
I prefer AI auditions and Hollywood week to the XF audition and bootcamp. But I prefer the XF judges houses and live shows to all the AI live shows
Overall I do prefer The X Factor and when there is a good bit of talent its obvious its the better show

[Stacey.]

they are actually both great,, but American Idol for me!
Itss a fab programme ;)
And they all have great talent;)

[MiuMiu]

American Idol.
X Factor has been abismal this year.
It's really sealed the deal in my mind as to what show is better.

AI all the way.
:)

[Marc]

Idol

[Tom]

In my opinion, the standard in AI is MUCH higher

But then again its a much bigger country and more to choose from

X Factor gets more applicants I think

[Patrick]

they are actually both great,, but American Idol for me!
Itss a fab programme ;)
And they all have great talent;)


Im shocked at your choice! :joker:

AI dont have 2 Irish Twins who never fail to entertain do they?

[Beastie]

I like both but X Factor!

[James]

Whenever I have watched American Idol (which is not that often) I have thought the talent levels were way higher than our shows.

The singers on AI look more experienced and comfortable on stage.

[Firewire]

Yeah exactly James.

I'm gonna watch the new season when it starts in January.

ELLEN!

[MiuMiu]

Ya ano more Paula Abdul :(
I loved how she was always drunk and telling contestans the they were 'Truly talented" and the she "loves them all so much" each and every week, no matter who it was or what season it was.

Ellen deGeneres on AI will be weird.
Hopefully funny though.

Kara Dia Guardi can suck it though.
She's shite.
:(

GO RANDY! lol!
Yeah Daawwg! :joker:

[30stone]

Very surprised some of those people said american idol.

[Patrick]

They should air X Factor in USA.

No not X Factor USA.
Like our version in America.

Because on Youtube and stuff, alot of Americans like X Factor and can only watch through Youtube.

Yet AI is showen in the UK.
So I think its about time they show X Factor UK in America.

[Tom4784]

AI, It's got more variety in musical styles it's less OTT and it doesn't feel as staged as XF.

[MiuMiu]

AI, It's got more variety in musical styles it's less OTT and it doesn't feel as staged as XF.

This!

[Twilight]

X Factor
But i wanna start watching American Idol in January.

[Vladimir]

AI.

I loved season eight, Adam Lambert made it good. <3

[Stacey.]

Im shocked at your choice! :joker:

AI dont have 2 Irish Twins who never fail to entertain do they?

Yerr, i know lmfao :joker:
Jedward are the best ever, but the programme of AI i find is better!!

[Stacey.]

AI.

I loved season eight, Adam Lamberd made it good. <3

megan joy, and kris allen for me;)

[Stacey.]

They should air X Factor in USA.

No not X Factor USA.
Like our version in America.

Because on Youtube and stuff, alot of Americans like X Factor and can only watch through Youtube.

Yet AI is showen in the UK.
So I think its about time they show X Factor UK in America.

im sure theyre doing that , arent they?
I thought dermot was goiingg to present it!!!

[xDramatick]

AI for the talent, and career aspect.
XF for entertainment.

AI's created Kelly Clarkson, Fantasia Barrino, Jennifer Hudson, Katharine McPhee, Daughtry, Jordin Sparks, Blake Lewis, Adam Lambert (<3!!), Kris Allen, Allison Iraheta etc.
XF's created Shayne Ward, Alexandra Burke, Leona Lewis, JLS, Diana Vickers, Laura White etc.

Voted for AI.

[LemonJam]

American Idol

[WOMBAI]

American Idol - more talent and I prefer most of the judges!