Which Judge Should Leave after this year?

[Smithy]

Which Judge Should Leave after this year

i think louis because i find him the most retarded person on earth, he keeps saying JLS are doing better than alexandra in the charts and have sold more records, no they didnt Louis **** and piss off you stupid leprachaun

i feel better now i've vented

[Stephanie]

cheryl, will never happen though.

[Stacey.]

DANNII... most rubbish unfair judge.

[Tom]

Replace Cheryl with Denise Van Outen as I said last week :)

Shes a good fair judge and looks good too, plus relatable in the same way Cheryl is (ie from normal background)

[Smithy]

DANNII... most rubbish unfair judge.

danniis the best judge, your just annoyed coz she got rid of jedward

[Stacey.]

danniis the best judge, your just annoyed coz she got rid of jedward

yeh, thats part of the reason.
Sheee diid that to stop people from disliking her!
UNFAIR

[Smithy]

yeh, thats part of the reason.
Sheee diid that to stop people from disliking her!
UNFAIR

no she did it because it was a singing competition and olly was far better than them

[Jords]

Simon>Dannii>Cheryl>Louis

Although I find Dannii the better judge,
Simon is more important purely for the show

[MarkWaldorf]

I think its great as it is...

[Stacey.]

no she did it because it was a singing competition and olly was far better than them

she did it, also because for her own acts.
she didnt want jedward to get any further in the competition, or they could have gone all the way.

[Smithy]

she did it, also because for her own acts.
she didnt want jedward to get any further in the competition, or they could have gone all the way.

no they couldnt that was their second time in the bottom two, they defo wouldnt have gone the whole way

[Lewis.]

I agree with Markwaldorf, It's fine as it is.

[Stacey.]

no they couldnt that was their second time in the bottom two, they defo wouldnt have gone the whole way

And how do you know that?:joker:
this series has been very unpredictable. :)
and thats a good thinggggggg :D

[Tom4784]

Louis, I hate him.

[Smithy]

And how do you know that?:joker:
this series has been very unpredictable. :)
and thats a good thinggggggg :D

it wasnt really the only unpredictable thing was lucies "eviction"
the rest when you look at quality of performances etc wasn't

[Stacey.]

it wasnt really the only unpredictable thing was lucies "eviction"
the rest when you look at quality of performances etc wasn't

stacey last night.....

[Jordan.]

DANNII... most rubbish unfair judge.

:shocked: Dannii is the best judge!!!!

& i dont want any judges to leaves its okay how it is, but still wish Sharon was a judge

[Smithy]

stacey last night.....

well when you look at the comments the judges are giving her "you need to dance/perform" it was highly probable that she would have done a song which would have allowed her to do that

[Patrick]

Which Judge Should Leave after this year

i think louis because i find him the most retarded person on earth, he keeps saying JLS are doing better than alexandra in the charts and have sold more records, no they didnt Louis **** and piss off you stupid leprachaun

i feel better now i've vented



1. JLS are doing better than Alexandra I think Louis would know.
2. I hate Louis but..
3. Dont call him a Leprachaun because hes irish im sure there are plenty of things he can call YOU for being British.
4. Yes I agree he is a ****** :)

[Patrick]

And BTW you shouldnt of put (as if) beside Simon, he is leaving.
Next year is his last year

[Adamw92]

Louis

then maybe Alexandra can be discussed without shitty JLS being brought into it, he needs to get over it, Alexandra wiped the floor with them and won fair and square

[Beastie]

None of them!

I thought though.. Sharon could come back and there could be 5 groups..

the groups
the girls (who are under 25)
the boys (who are under 25)
the men (who are over 25)
the women (who are over 25)

5 judges would be great, they would not be able to go to deadlock! muahaha!

[Smithy]

1. JLS are doing better than Alexandra I think Louis would know.
3. Dont call him a Leprachaun because hes irish im sure there are plenty of things he can call YOU for being British.
4. Yes I agree he is a ****** :)

1. she sold 1 million singles in 3 weeks i dont think jls are anywhere near that
3. fair enough but he is small and irish
4. good

[WOMBAI]

Cheryl and Louis. Cheryl because I don't think she is qualified to be a judge of a singing competition and Louis because it is just one big game to him. He always seems to put through contestants from Ireland - regardless of their talent. I don't think he gives a stuff about talent - he is far more interested in beating Simon and promoting the Irish.

[Stacey.]

well when you look at the comments the judges are giving her "you need to dance/perform" it was highly probable that she would have done a song which would have allowed her to do that

but thats not what does her any favours

[Smithy]

but thats not what does her any favours

i think if people are fans of stacey they arent going to be put off by one dodgey dance routine

[Stacey.]

i think if people are fans of stacey they arent going to be put off by one dodgey dance routine

i wasnt saying that, Im justt saying that it WAS unpredictable!! :shocked:
Calm it!

[Smithy]

i wasnt saying that, Im justt saying that it WAS unpredictable!! :shocked:
Calm it!

i am calm

[Stacey.]

i am calm

shh please!!

[Smithy]

shh please!!

dnt tell me to shh on my own thread

[Tom]

1. JLS are doing better than Alexandra I think Louis would know.


Are JLS going to America? I think not

[SiaSiaSia]

cheryl... absolutley love her but i loved girls aloud more

[SiaSiaSia]

None of them!

I thought though.. Sharon could come back and there could be 5 groups..

the groups
the girls (who are under 25)
the boys (who are under 25)
the men (who are over 25)
the women (who are over 25)

5 judges would be great, they would not be able to go to deadlock! muahaha!

LOVE this idea

[Dom:)]

I really hope Louis leaves I cannot stand him anymore.
And in an ideal world,replace him with Beyonce.
But that will never happen:(

Denise van outen would be a great judge

[Jack_]

Loving thebeast's idea.

Other than that, I think the current line-up is fine. But if they have to get rid of someone, make it Dannii and bring back Sharon.

[Arneldo]

If one HAD to go. Maybe, Cheryl. Replace her with a younger good-looking judge with no experience...oh,wait.

[Patrick]

Cheryl and Louis. Cheryl because I don't think she is qualified to be a judge of a singing competition and Louis because it is just one big game to him. He always seems to put through contestants from Ireland - regardless of their talent. I don't think he gives a stuff about talent - he is far more interested in beating Simon and promoting the Irish.

Bollocks

He put Jedward through thats the only Irish act hes put through.

[WOMBAI]

Bollocks

He put Jedward through thats the only Irish act hes put through.

Bollocks!

He has put other Irish acts through in previous years!

[Kazanne]

Cheryl.she is not impartial and gets too personal,plus she's arrogant and cocky.

[Z]

Bollocks

He put Jedward through thats the only Irish act hes put through.

Azi from Kandy Rain.

[yousoboo!]

DANNII... most rubbish unfair judge.

Dani is the best judge there.

[WOMBAI]

but thats not what does her any favours

That's why I have never agreed with this 'theme' crap. People have their own style - and particular niche' - this versatility nonsense interferes with that. People should sing the type of music they excel at.

[atieah2009]

Louis.

[yousoboo!]

Cheryl is so boring. She says the same thing every week. No personality.