Is Oily Really Recording Artist Material?

[yousoboo!]

The answer is no. You'd accept him as part of your Butlins evening entertainmnet but would you really go to see him at the O2? No.

He is Oily and cheesey.

[King Gizzard]

In your opinion.

[Smithy]

lmao love how u put oily
and yea i agree hes pretty cheesy drunk dad dancing

[arista]

With a Full backing Band he can Shine.

[Twilight]

I agree he ain't gonna sell records

[arista]

I agree he ain't gonna sell records


He can sell CD's
so long as a Good team is backing him.

[Scarlett.]

Is Stacey going to sell CDs? Probably not?
Is Joe going to sell CDs? Maybe, but I can see him disappearing like Ray Quinn

[yousoboo!]

I think Joe has a voice made for recording. Ray Quinn was a one trick pony. No comparison.

[Scarlett.]

I think Joe has a voice made for recording. Ray Quinn was a one trick pony. No comparison.

What other young male XF finalists have made it big? Eggnoggin and his 1,567,892,138,385 friends?

[teabag.]

to be honest, i think he would be great as a recording artist.
and as if butlins..

[arista]

Is Stacey going to sell CDs? Probably not?
Is Joe going to sell CDs? Maybe, but I can see him disappearing like Ray Quinn


Ray Quinn has moved on to Top Stage Shows.
He is still a Growing Artist.

[Z]

Yes. He's the only one who can tackle up tempo, modern songs out of the three finalists, which you need to be vaguely good at to sell a decent pop record - Joe has the best recording voice and should win, but Olly could definitely be a successful pop star.

[Scarlett.]

Ray Quinn has moved on to Top Stage Shows.
He is still a Growing Artist.

Sure he is :joker:

[InOne]

None of them are gonna make it really big. Come on...

[yousoboo!]

Sure he is :joker:


lol

[arista]

Sure he is :joker:


Yes he was Just on Five News
saying he is doing more than just singing.


You Chewy are so out of Touch on this.

[arista]

None of them are gonna make it really big. Come on...


Charging 40K for a Gig
is Big.

[InOne]

Charging 40K for a Gig
is Big.

I'm on about these finalists.

[arista]

I'm on about these finalists.


It is all down to them
if SonyBMG Invest into taking them to World Class Studios
with the Best Session players money can buy
it can all take off in a Mega way.

How much they want to do it,
and Never Give up.

[InOne]

It is all down to them
if SonyBMG Invest into taking them to World Class Studios
with the Best Session players money can buy
it can all take off in a Mega way.

How much they want to do it,
and Never Give up.

Bad bunch this year though.

[arista]

Bad bunch this year though.



You can not tell
until we see some Productions.

[InOne]

You can not tell
until we see some Productions.

You can tell, they don't have the star quality and will flop like the rest.

[Tom4784]

The problem with Olly is that he relies on gimmicks like dancing and such, his voice is good but it's not nothing special and you can't dance on a CD. He does decent performances but he'll bomb if he wins.

Stacey has potential, her voice unlike Alex and Leona is understated and such. I was kinda disapointed when the Chris Martin Duet rumour wasn't true because I could see her doing that kind of music quite well?

Recording wise Joe's the best and probably the easiest to market, They just need to give him some inoffensive pop music and he should have 1 or 2 albums easily.

[King Gizzard]

Ollys voice will do good

In the style of Robbie and Will young, through a bit of JT in there

Joes would be like a christmas present for your nanny in years to come

Stacey - just alot of fail. too many female artists already doing what she does, and doing it much better.

[Captain.Remy]

I agree he ain't gonna sell records

Joe and Stacey won't either anyway. None of the top 12 had superstar material to be honest.
Only Olly and Stacey have something more than the rest.

[xDramatick]

The problem with Olly is that he relies on gimmicks like dancing and such, his voice is good but it's not nothing special and you can't dance on a CD. He does decent performances but he'll bomb if he wins.

Stacey has potential, her voice unlike Alex and Leona is understated and such. I was kinda disapointed when the Chris Martin Duet rumour wasn't true because I could see her doing that kind of music quite well?

Recording wise Joe's the best and probably the easiest to market, They just need to give him some inoffensive pop music and he should have 1 or 2 albums easily.

I agree with every single word of this.

[InOne]

Joe and Stacey won't either anyway. None of the top 12 had superstar material to be honest.
Only Olly and Stacey have something more than the rest.

They might have something more, but it's still not enough.

[Scarlett.]

Yes he was Just on Five News
saying he is doing more than just singing.


You Chewy are so out of Touch on this.

"doing more than just singing"

Yeah, cause he failed at it

[yousoboo!]

Joe is young, likeable, sweet looking and can sing with lots of emotion. What more does the pop market want? And he appeals to the pink pound.

[Dr.Gonzo]

Maybe 3 singles, a few posters, and some girl will learn how to flick herself to his image. That's all.

[yousoboo!]

3 albums, 3 tours, 3 number 1's. Plus a doll.

[Dr.Gonzo]

3 bowls of cornflakes when you wake up.

[Adamw92]

Not really, he isnt even good live, he relies too much on his dancing which is plain awful and cringe worthy, thank god you wouldnt be able to see it on a CD but you'd still have to listen to his average and overrated voice.

[Patrick]

Well more people would rather watch him than boring Joe sing long slow and **** songs.

At least with Olly your getting more than a boring voice.

[WOMBAI]

Well more people would rather watch him than boring Joe sing long slow and **** songs.

At least with Olly your getting more than a boring voice.

Speak for yourself! With Olly you get - Mr Average - simple as!

[Tom]

He'll sell more than Joe McElderly