If Alexandra had made Louis' final 4 in 2005 ...

[Tom]

Would she have won that series or been out quite early on? Quite odd how things work out sometimes

[Princess]

It's weird to think but I say Shayne would still have won. Lucky for Alex that she didn't get through that time.

[Tom]

I think she would've went out in the earlier weeks. We had Brenda that year who was really popular and Alexandra wasn't anything special back then. Plus it was still pre-Leona so it wasn't really about finding a genuine star but a short term pop star to last until the next series. Simon didn't really take the show seriously until Leona won.

[Stacey.]

i definitely think that Shaynee would still have won ;)
Sharon liked him :wink:

[ILoveTRW]

im sure alex was in leonas year not shaynes???

edit: just looked on wiki and she was in shaynes year :conf:

[Jords]

I think Alexandra :)

[Harry!]

If Alex won would Leona have the same success?

I think Shayne would of won anyway.

[atieah2009]

Yes.

[Tom]

If Alex won would Leona have the same success?

I think Shayne would of won anyway.

Probably, because whilst I think Alex is better than Leona, there are a lot of people like her around and the industry wasn't exactly lacking, and Leona is something pretty different and rare to come across. Because of that Simon took it a bit more seriously after Leona won (thats when the 'wait until October to release an album' trend started), so if Alex did win she would've had a rushed album out full of Whitney covers, then back to obscurity for her.

[Stacey.]

leona is obviously better than Alex.
wherever leona had have comee,she would be doing well :thumbs:

[Patrick]

Shayne is the best winner we have had.

So he still would of won, Cant stand that big headed **** Alex.

[Beastie]

Shayne would have won. Alex's voice was not as good back then.