What do you think about Joe McElderry?

[kjtnation]

So Joe won X Factor 2009 and he released his single, The Climb. But have you got it and listened to it? We want to know what YOU think of it.

[Smithy]

I think he is a penis

[kjtnation]

I think he is a penis

personal insult removed - Darenn

[xDramatick]

eh, i can't see him being successful.
i reckon he's more suited to musical theatre.

[Ross]

I don't like the song but I think Joe's version is good. I like Joe overall as an artist and a person so I hope he does well because he really deserves it. Some of his performances on X Factor were the world class. He deserved to win and deserves to do well.

[Smithy]

Weirdo.

its my opinion, and my opinion is that he is a giant cock

[CaraRawr]

I absoleutly love him.

[Stacey.]

i like him :)
nice person, great singer!
i think he`ll do well :thumbs:
and I really hope he does.

[MrGaryy]

I think he's a really nice guy who's very talented but should be on brodway. He had zero artist potential and seems to be no niche for him at all. He might do well in the US though. From a personal point of view, I find him extremely dull and I hate his version of Don't Stop Believin'. oh and he murdered The Climb.

[kjtnation]

i like him :)
nice person, great singer!
i think he`ll do well :thumbs:
and I really hope he does.

I quite like him.

[Vladimir]

I think he's a really nice guy who's very talented but should be on brodway. He had zero artist potential and seems to be no niche for him at all. He might do well in the US though. From a personal point of view, I find him extremely dull and I hate his version of Don't Stop Believin'. oh and he murdered The Climb.

He murdered The Climb? I thought Miley destroyed it enough.

Joe's version is much better, because he's a better vocalist than her.

[kjtnation]

He murdered The Climb? I thought Miley destroyed it enough.

Joe's version is much better, because he's a better vocalist than her.

OK.

[Stu]

What do I think about Joe? Not much to think about, really. That's the problem. If Lady GaGa is symbolic of how overzealous and whacky pop can be, then Joe is right down the other end of the spectrum. Stick him in broadway. Not on my telly.

[MrGaryy]

He murdered The Climb? I thought Miley destroyed it enough.

Joe's version is much better, because he's a better vocalist than her.

There's more to a song then vocals, Joe's version is so dry, no emotion, the arrangement is so ludicrously dramatic it just ruins the whole vibe of the song in my opinion.

[InOne]

Boring, and a result of the idiocy of today.

[King Gizzard]

A whole lot of z's

[Stephanie]

dull. boring. not a popstar.

[Firewire]

I like him, and I hope he does well.

[Patrick]

Who?


Seriously couldnt care about XF anymore its so last year.

[Simone.]

Awww Gay Joe.
I love him personally, really hapy he won.
I think if the contestants this year were stronger in general then maybe not, but it really wasn't the best.

[kjtnation]

Awww Gay Joe.
I love him personally, really hapy he won.
I think if the contestants this year were stronger in general then maybe not, but it really wasn't the best.

I did want Joe to win.

[kjtnation]

Who?


Seriously couldnt care about XF anymore its so last year.

I thought X Factor 2009 was to boring.

[kjtnation]

I like him, and I hope he does well.

I don't really like him that much

[Vicky.]

Hes lovely. Nice voice, sweet young lad..

Dont think too much of the climb though...I sing it better :D

[MeMyselfAndI]

He's very VERY boring and dull, although i do like "The Climb" Of his. That's only because im a Miley fan, although i prefure Miley's version :P

[Shaun]

He's got a nice voice but that does not make one a musical artist.

[kjtnation]

He's got a nice voice but that does not make one a musical artist.

I agree

[MarkWaldorf]

i think everyone knows my answer :p

[Tom]

****

[Jords]

Meh, hes a good singer but not my thing. Will have to see when his album comes out!