A Question

[_Seth]

Here's the scenario... you buy a CD for £10, you lend it to your friend who breaks it by accident and they give you replacement money for the CD. BUT, the CD's price has been reduced (since it's after a few months since you bought it) to £5. The CD is factory sealed, like the one you bought originally, so do you think you should have £10 or £5?

I'd say £10 because I did ORIGINALLY pay for that, and if I ever wanted to sell it I wouldn't want to make too much of a loss.

[GypsyGoth]

I agree, just £5.

[BB_Eye]

There is no "ought" in determining the monetary value of things. Only "is".

[Beastie]

£5

[King Gizzard]

10er

thats how much you paid for it so you should have that lol

[Stacey.]

you buy a CD for £10, you lend it to your friend who breaks it by accident

:joker:

£10.

[Jessica.]

£10 imo.

[Niamh.]

you miserable fecker, it was an accident let your friend off!!

[Jords]

£5, tis your friend afterall too!

[30stone]

Tenner.
I wouldnt go ohh lets find out how much it costs now, id say give me a tenner...

Dont think you will make much selling a cd..

I never sell anything!!

[Tom]

Just the replacement. You're not exactly losing out

[Shasown]

Does it really matter so long as it is replaced? So long as there is no bad feeling between mates.

[Vicky.]

I wouldnt ask for anything back off a friend accidently breaking something

[Claymores]

I wouldnt ask for anything back off a friend accidently breaking something

:thumbs::thumbs::thumbs:

why is this in serious topics sub-forum - answer is not £10 or 1p

[setanta]

Why is this in Serious Debates? You got a replacement. The end.

[Kerry]

Why is this in Serious Debates? You got a replacement. The end.

I second this. If they've replaced the CD whats the big deal?

[arista]

Here's the scenario... you buy a CD for £10, you lend it to your friend who breaks it by accident and they give you replacement money for the CD. BUT, the CD's price has been reduced (since it's after a few months since you bought it) to £5. The CD is factory sealed, like the one you bought originally, so do you think you should have £10 or £5?

I'd say £10 because I did ORIGINALLY pay for that, and if I ever wanted to sell it I wouldn't want to make too much of a loss.



Philip this is not a Serious Debate
I are you sure you did not mean to post it under General Chat.

[Crimson Dynamo]

depends if he is a homosexual, a muslim, black or a woman.

[Dr.Gonzo]

depends if he is a homosexual, a muslim, black or a woman.

Heh, you made a funny.

[Crimson Dynamo]

Heh, you made a funny.

it is a nasty habit i have picked up

like that time at naked Nun club

[Dr.Gonzo]

Naked Nun: This is my natural clothing

Trumpet: Needs ironing

[sooty]

I wouldnt ask for anything back off a friend accidently breaking something

Agree.