Matt Smith > David Tennant.

[Shaun]

Discuss.

[Smithy]

Disagree, didn't see tonights ep, but after the past 3 I still prefer David

[Firewire]

I still prefer David but it's early days.

Matt has brought on a great first impression though.

[Stephanie]

i thought i was going to hate matt, but i really like him haha.

[Braden]

I totally agree, he has made a massive impact on the show already.He has filled those massive shoes of David Tennant.

[Gemmer-x]

David = king.

[BB_Eye]

The new guy is better than David Tennant, but that's not saying much.

[Angus]

Discuss.

I quite liked Tennant till he decided to throw his lot in with the odious Brown -just goes to show how someone who seemed reasonably intelligent is in fact a total moron.

Matt Smith is already shaping up to be the best Doctor Who ever - an inspired casting.

[Tom4784]

I actually really like him, It's still a bit too early to say but I think he'll be the best Doctor with time.

[Loukas]

I love him.. I didn't know i was going to say that but has impressed me. I seriously didn't think he would!!

[Lucy.]

I totally thought I would hate Matt but after the first few episodes I really like him, he's really funny and I think the role of the Doctor needed some comic genious :D

[Kerry]

Not watched Matt yet. I can't bring myself to :bawling:

[Princess]

To be honest,I mainly miss David because he was gorgeous. Matt is alright,the assisant Amy is brilliant.