The X Factor Finalists - Have Your Say!

[Pipergun]

Last night, Addictiv Ladies were booted out of the competition: Out of the remaining 11 acts:

16-24 Solos

Chenai Zinyuku
Nicholas Dorsett
Phillip Magee
Shayne Ward

25+ Solos

Andy Abraham
Brenda Edwards
Chico Slimani
Maria Lawson

Groups

4Tune
Journey South
The Conway Sisters

In what order would you rate them? Start with your favourite at No. 1, and your least favourite at No. 11.

Enjoy posting!

Tom. :thumbs:

[Pipergun]

My order would be as follows:

1. Brenda
2. Maria
3. Andy
4. Chenai
5. Shane
6. Journey South
7. The Conway Sisters
8. Nicholas
9. Phillip
10. 4Tune
11. Chico

[Lance]

1. Chenai
2. Brenda
3. Maria
4. Andy
5. Conway Sisters
6. Journey South
7. Nicholas
8. 4Tune
9. Phillip
10. Shayne
11. Chico

[Dan_]

1.Andy
2.Shayne
3.Chenai
4.Maria
5.Nicholas
6.4tune
7.Journey South
8.Phillip
9.Brenda
10.Chico
11.Conway Sisters

[Ruth]

I would choose:

1. Andy
2. Brenda
3 and 4. Maria / Journey South (can't choose between them)
5. Shayne
6. Chenai
7. Conway Sisters
8. Nicholas
9. 4Tune
10. Philip
11. Chico

[BigSister]

1: Andy
2: Journey South
3: Shane
4: Chenai
5: Brenda
6: 4tune
7: Maria
8:Philip
9: Conway Sisters
10: Nick
11: Chico

[Romantic Old Bird]

I would choose
Andy
Shane
Brenda
Maria
Chenai

(Not at all exciting:)

Philip
Journey South
4Tune
Nicholas Dorsett





(long way down)



Conway Sisters




(so far down you are in the Antipodes)
Chico

[makosifan]

1.) Chenai and Andy (cant chose)
2.) Maria
3.) Journey South
4.) Shayne
5.) Brenda
6.) Nicholas
7.) Philip
8.) 4tune
9.) conway sisters
10 Chico

[lily.]

1. Andy
2. Maria
3. Journey South
4. Shane
5. Nicholas
6. Brenda
7. Chenai
8. Phillip
9. 4Tune
10. The Conway Sisters
11. Chico

[Pipergun]

Sorry for the long wait for the current results: So far, your ratings have produced the following leaderboard:


(Average scores out of 11)

1. Andy (1.6)
2. Maria (3.5)
3. Chenai (3.9)
4. Brenda (4.3)
5. Shayne (4.5)
6. Journey South (4.8)
7. Nicholas (7.4)
8. 4Tune (8.1)
9. Phillip (8.3)
10. The Conway Sisters (8.6)
11. Chico (10.9)

Keep those votes coming in!!

Tom. :bouncy:

[ThaGazBoi]

Mine are:

LOVE:
1. Brenda Edwards
2. Maria Lawson
3. Andy Abraham

LIKE:
4. Shayne Ward
5. Nicholas
6. Chenai Zinyuku
7. Philip Magee

DONT REALLY LIKE:
8. Journey South
9. Conway Sisters
10. 4Tune

CANT STAND:
Chico Slimani

[BigSister]

gazza you put Journey south in twice

[ThaGazBoi]

aww ill edit

[Arneldo]

LOVE:
1. Brenda Edwards
2. Andy Abraham
3.Shayne Ward

LIKE:
4. Maria Lawson
5. Nicholas
6. Chenai Zinyuku

DONT REALLY LIKE:
7. Philip Magee
8. Journey South
9. Conway Sisters
10. 4Tune

CANT STAND:
Chico Slimani

[Princess]

LOVE
1.Chenai
2.Andy
3.Maria
4.Brenda

LIKE
5.Nicholas
6.Shanye
7.4tune

DONT REALLY LIKE
8.The Conway Sisters
9.Journey South
10.Phillip

CANT STAND
Chico:mad:

[Pipergun]

Alritey, after updating the latest ratings, the leaderboard is as follows:

1. Andy: 1.8
2. Maria: 3.4
3. Brenda: 3.6
4. Chenai: 4.0
5. Shayne: 4.5
6. Journey South: 5.7
7. Nicholas: 6.7
8. Phillip: 8.2
9. 4Tune: 8.4
10. The Conway Sisters: 8.6
11. Chico: 10.9

Any more votes for any more?? :bigsmile:

[Pipergun]

Btw, whoop! I'm over the 500 posts mark!! :dance::spin2::spin:

[katieee]

11.SHAYNE WARD<33333333333:love:
10.nicholas dorsett
9.4tune
8.andy
7.journey south
6.chico
5.philip
4.chenie
3.maria
2.brenda
1.conway sisters

[lily.]

Originally posted by Pipergun
Btw, whoop! I'm over the 500 posts mark!! :dance::spin2::spin:

U GO !!! ... :dance::dance::dance:

[Pipergun]

I take it Shane's your fave then Katie, then Nicholas?? Just thought I'd check, altho the :love: does tend to give that away Lol! :laugh:

[Pipergun]

Originally posted by Stropz
Originally posted by Pipergun
Btw, whoop! I'm over the 500 posts mark!! :dance::spin2::spin:

U GO !!! ... :dance::dance::dance:

Yeehaw! Watch those lil' red men boogeh on down!! :dance::dance::dance::dance::dance::dance::dance:

[katieee]

lmao i LOVE shayne<33333333

[lily.]

Shayne is a babe... right enough... put it mildly.. "I SO WOULD"..

ahem.. anyways.. moving swiftly on... Does anyone think Chico can survive another week?

[katieee]

omg I SO WOULD TOOO

same with chico lmao hes sexy as:blush:

[lily.]

oh jeez no.. i just don't see it with Chico.. I SO WOULDN'T.. with him! lol..

but, also.. let's be honest.. he has nada talent. he shouldn't be there!

[Pipergun]

Tbh I really don't want Chico to last another week. He is admittedly quite lively, altho I find his performances are extremely predictable:

1. Croak & screech patheticly
2. Throw of jacket
3. Lift up shirt
4. Run around
5. Croak & screech
5. Et hoila!

Ps. Sorry to any Chico fans, I'm obv not one of you!! :spin:

[lily.]

Bravo! Well said. And, I wholeheartedly agree.

I'm not a chico fan either. He is a poor man's Ricky Martin, and Ricky Martin is sh!te! Lmao

[BigSister]

Chico to go Saturday pleaseeeeee I dont think he will though

[Pipergun]

Originally posted by Stropz
Bravo! Well said. And, I wholeheartedly agree.

I'm not a chico fan either. He is a poor man's Ricky Martin, and Ricky Martin is sh!te! Lmao

Ricky Martin's latest song isn't that bad... I put great emphasis on THAT bad! :hugesmile:

I agree BigSis - If Louis get's his own way, Chico will be in there for a while just to annoy Simon! :mad:

[lily.]

If they continue to play games with each other, we will end up losing the real talent and being left with a pile o sh!te to pick from. I don't think the judges ought to get any say in it at this stage. It's BS!

[Pipergun]

Exactly, tactics aren't right at this stage!

Righty, me be about to hit the sack!

Last day before 2 wks of half term, whoopee! :thumbs:

Nitey night! :sleep:

[BigSister]

nope and I dislike Louis Walsh anyway and being a stupid idiot doesnt help much
Im off too Pipez night!

[lily.]

nite u 2.. sweet dreams.. xx

[Ruth]

I really hope Chico goes on Saturday, but I've got the sinking feeling that he might wing it through a couple more weeks yet. In a lot of shows where people get voted off, it seems to me that if there's one person who seems most likely to go and that person survives the first vote, they very often last a few more weeks.

I reckon the Conway Sisters will be out on Saturday.

[texbex]

i think chico should stay he is fab entertainment and i think brenda is great

[Pipergun]

Agree with you on Brenda, Bex. Although I wouldn't call Chico entertaining. His performances just involve ripping his shirt off! Plus, he can't sing IMO!! :nono::bouncy:

[BigSister]

I like Brenda too:dance:

[lily.]

Piper, we need to start a club. The Anti-Chico club.. we could call it the CHICO to GO-GO club! lol

[BigSister]

Can I join too Stropz:thumbs:

[lily.]

certainly.. just add it to ur sig.

[makosifan]

i might join too :thumbs:
i really want him to go this week but i have a feeling Chenai and Philip will be the bottom 2 :puzzled:

[Pipergun]

Yay Stropz, good idea!! :eureka:

I know what you mean Makosi: I don't know whether it'll be Phillip & Chenai, although there's almost always a week when the public consider someone "safe", don't vote for them and then they end up in the bottom three! :bored:

If it's Chenai v Phillip - which I'm a bit sceptical about, I'd want Phillip out! :bouncy:

[BigSister]

Chenai wont be in the bottom 2 if she is I will be v surprised

[Romantic Old Bird]

Actually, you could be right about Philip, because I can't even remember which one he is. Not a good sign!

Please, please let it be Chico.

He can't sing
He's not attractive
I find him excruciating to watch.


Poor old Simon got the short straw with the groups. None of them are worth the space in the finals.

I'm an Andy, Brenda, Maria and Shane fan

[BigSister]

ill pray its Chico for you ROB as I agree but I doubt he will be going tonight but I really want him to go am I contridicting myself there:puzzled:

[Pipergun]

Join the club Rob! Lol! :spin:

I seem to share your faves too! : Brenda, Andy, Maria although I'd probs swap Shayne for Chenai! :bouncy:

[Dan_]

Nah, you wan't him to go but you don't think he will.

I think The conway sisters and Philip will be the bottom 2.

[Ruth]

I think it will be Philip and the Conways as well. I would say that Andy, Maria, Brenda, Shayne, Chenai, Nicholas and Journey South are all definitely safe.

I want Chico to go - he is the least talented of all the acts, by quite some degree, and doesn't deserve to be in the finals. For me, he exhausted his entertainment levels on his very first audition. I didn't think he should have got through to boot camp, and Sharon and Louis only put him through in the first place to wind Simon up (it worked)! Why Sharon stuck with him after that is beyond me:puzzled:

ROB, I agree completely about Phillip - I think I've also said somewhere that he is very forgettable, and he looked decidedly uncomfortable on stage last week. He does have quite a nice voice, but I don't think he has the X Factor.

[makosifan]

I do like Chenai but the reason i think she may be in the bottom 2 is because unlike Phlip and the conway sisters she doesnt have Ireland supporting her! Also shes singing first this week and that always seems to go against contetestants. AND i think Louis has chosen a poor song for her yet again.
I hope the judges dont boot her out as i think with the right song she does have a lot of potential. :thumbs:

[Pipergun]

How do you know she'll be singing first? I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm sure your not, just curious! :spin2:

I read somewhere, that Sharon had admitted in an interview that she's prepared to vote Chico out, although I wish it were true, I find it hard to believe: It's probably just more hype reflecting the attitude of many fans! :bigsmile:

[makosifan]

Ben said on x trafactor that shes singing first.
But yes i think well HOPE Chico is in the bottom 2 as well and is voted out. Hes making a mockery of the entire show!

[Pipergun]

Know what you mean Makosi - I believe he's denied a 25+ soloist a place in the final who actually has talent unlike himself! Did you know his actual name is Yousseff? Not sure of the spelling though! :spin:

Ok, before the show tonight, the leaderboard looks as follows:

1. Andy: 2.0
2. Maria: 3.8
3. Brenda: 4.2
3. Shayne: 4.2
5. Chenai: 4.3
6. Journey South: 5.7
7. Nicholas: 6.3
8. 4Tune: 7.9
9. Phillip: 8.1
10. The Conway Sisters: 8.8
11. Chico: 10.5

If any of you want to add any more ratings of the final 11, you can do so up untill the start of the live show at 6.15pm tonight! :thumbs:

Tom. :bouncy::dog:

[makosifan]

hmm i still think it will be Chenai and phil/chico
I was Chenai to stay so i hope the judges ditch th eother one.

[Dan_]

:shocked: 4tune shouldn't have gone, or even been in the bottom 2. How Philip managed to avoid being in the bottom 2 is beyond me.

[BigSister]

Can I just say 1 thing Louis walsh is a oh I cant even say it

[lily.]

He guilt tripped Sharon something terrible tonight.

[Dan_]

Felt like strangling the bloke, I am with Simon in telling Louis to shut up. How many times does Louis have to say that camp 'Hello'?

[BigSister]

"Keep chenai Keep chenai"
Sharon can make her mind up you know!

[Dan_]

I wish Simon would just slap him.

[jrc]

He's a stupid idiot for trying to talk her into keeping Chenai, and she's an even more stupid idiot for being fooled by it. Chenai should have gone!

[BigSister]

lol Dan I agree.:hello:

[lily.]

yeah TV violence rocks! :laugh:

[Ruth]

Louis is a disgrace to that show. Always trying to humiliate Simon, and telling Sharon that she should save Chenai because he saved Chico last week (which he only did to spite Simon anyway). It's not about doing favours for each other, it's about saving the best act out of the two who are up for the chop.

Louis is just a weasley little man, who enjoys making Simon squirm.:mad:

[Pipergun]

Exactly, spot on!

What's annoying me now is that 4Tune are complaining that it's completely down to politics between the judges that they were voted out. It was to an extent with Mr Leprechaun, but it was their fault for being too forgettable and not getting enough votes to stay out of the bottom 2!! I forgot about their performance - that's never a good sign!

I predict they'll be selling their story to as many people that'll listen in the upcoming weeks! :sleep: Soo predictable. 4Tune should just admit it, they were'nt good enough to be winners! :hugesmile:

[makosifan]

i think thats unfair for them to say that, ii think sharon made the right choice.

[jrc]

Originally posted by Pipergun
Exactly, spot on!

What's annoying me now is that 4Tune are complaining that it's completely down to politics between the judges that they were voted out. It was to an extent with Mr Leprechaun, but it was their fault for being too forgettable and not getting enough votes to stay out of the bottom 2!! I forgot about their performance - that's never a good sign!

I predict they'll be selling their story to as many people that'll listen in the upcoming weeks! :sleep: Soo predictable. 4Tune should just admit it, they were'nt good enough to be winners! :hugesmile: But Chenai was, was she? :rolleyes:

[Pipergun]

Originally posted by jrc
Originally posted by Pipergun
Exactly, spot on!

What's annoying me now is that 4Tune are complaining that it's completely down to politics between the judges that they were voted out. It was to an extent with Mr Leprechaun, but it was their fault for being too forgettable and not getting enough votes to stay out of the bottom 2!! I forgot about their performance - that's never a good sign!

I predict they'll be selling their story to as many people that'll listen in the upcoming weeks! :sleep: Soo predictable. 4Tune should just admit it, they were'nt good enough to be winners! :hugesmile: But Chenai was, was she? :rolleyes:

No! Not in my opinion anyway! :bigsmile: - Sorry just realised my previous post sounds quite snide and malicious! Oops, It wasn't meant in that way! :blush:

[jrc]

No probs, I see where you're coming from now. :thumbs:

[ThaGazBoi]

I like Brenda, Maria, Philip (Starting to grow on me) as is Conway Sisters and Andy. Cant stand Chico.I WANT TO BE PART OF THE CHICO TO GO GO CLUBBB

[Nicola]

My faves are Shayne and Journey South, and my worst is Chico (but everyone thinks I secretly like Chico, which I don't!)

[BigSister]

oooh ditto Nicola Shaybe and Journey south are my faves too JS are kinda ahead because of Shaynes mentor *ahem* but I still like Shayne:wavey:

[jrc]

My favs are Andy and Nicholas and my worst are Chenai and Chico. They both need to go ASAP.

[BigSister]

I also like Andy as well hes my 3rd fave. In my middle ground are Chenai Marie and Brenda and in my bottom half are Conways Philip Nick(Sorry to those who like him but hes not really my cup of tea hes good though) and Chico (Thinks thats all)

[Pipergun]

Chenai does nothing for me, but I'd rather either Chico or Phillip went on Saturday :bigsmile:

My current faves (although they're switching all the time :laugh:) are:

1. Brenda - Although I don't think she'll win!
2. Maria - Her vocals seem very versatile at the minute
3. Journey South - They look like they're enjoying themselves and that helps me enjoy the performance! :spin:

[Dan_]

My favs are Nicholas, Andy, Shayne and Journey South.

[BigSister]

apart from Nick its the same Dan although Nick is growing on me its just im not too keen on his genre of music

[Princess]

I like Chenai,Brenda,Andy,Maria a lot.

I dont mind everyone else expect Chico and Phillip who are both starting to get on my nerves:mad:

[katieee]

loves:
SHAYNE WARD
4tune:bawling:
Nicholas
Journey south

likes:
chico
brenda

dont really get:
chenia
conways

[BigSister]

woo yay Katie oh yeah you like Chico dont you:shocked:

[katieee]

lmao oui:hello:

[ThaGazBoi]

Chico :mad:

[jrc]

You should join the Chico-to-Go-Go club GazzaP.

[Pipergun]

Yeah! We could do with more recruits!! What number has it got up to?

[BigSister]

6 but Sol and gazza have expressed intrested Piper so it should be 8

[Pipergun]

Apparently the contestants will perform in the following order this Sat. :

Information obtained from ITV Website after posting the information by mistake:
29th October 2005

SHAYNE
BRENDA
PHILLIP
CHICO
THE CONWAY SISTERS
CHENAI
ANDY
NICHOLAS
MARIA
JOURNEY SOUTH

As expected, this info hasn't been comfirmed. Do you think the order in which the contestants performs affects their voting figures?? :puzzled:

[James]

Apparently they are introducing some new rule this week because of what Louis did last week.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/tm_objectid=16298294%26method=full%26siteid=94762% 26headline=mr-nasty-brags-of-a-victory--name_page.html

[Legend]

1. Maria
2. Journey South
3. Brenda
4. Chenai
5. Conway Sisters
6. Shane
7. Andy
8. Nicholas
9. Chico
10. Phillip

[ThaGazBoi]

Ive joined the chico club :xyxwave: GET HIM OUT!!

Brenda should win :xyxwave:

[Ruth]

Originally posted by James
Apparently they are introducing some new rule this week because of what Louis did last week.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/tm_objectid=16298294%26method=full%26siteid=94762% 26headline=mr-nasty-brags-of-a-victory--name_page.html

That's good. I think Louis has behaved pretty apallingly throughout.

[Pipergun]

I completely agree! :thumbs:

The little manipulative leprechaun!! :laugh:

[Ruth]

There's more about the alleged tactical voting here:

http://www.wanadoo.co.uk/entertainment/television/thexfactor4.htm

The more I hear about Louis Walsh, the more I dislike the weasly little man.

[BigSister]

*nods* agrees with ruth and Pipez