BB Allstars Ideas - which is worse?

[Mac Hiavellian]

Just for fun, which of these 2 BB Allstars ideas would cause the most amusement, annoyance or WTF reactions?

Idea 1) The 'stars' are the first voted out of their respective series e.g.
BB1 - Sada
BB2 - Penny
BB3 - Lynne
BB4 - Anouska
BB5 - Vanessa
BB6 - Mary
BB7 - Bonnie
BB8 - Shabnam
BB9 - Steph
BB10 - Sophia
CBBs - Chris Eubank, Goldie, Jackie Stallone, Jodie Marsh, Jackiey Budden, Lucy Pinder, Katia Ivanova

OR

Idea 2) The HMs are only people that walked or were ejected e.g.
BB1 - Nick
BB3 - Sunita, Sandy
BB5 - Kitten, Emma
BB6 - Orlaith
BB7 - Shahbaz, Dawn, George
BB8 - Emily, Leslie, Jonathan, Chanelle
BB9 - Alex, Dennis, Maysoon
BB10 - Safia, Tom, Kenneth, Isaac
CBBs - Germaine Greer, Donny Tourette, Ken Russell, Leo Sayer, Mutya Buena

???

[Lostie!]

The second idea is better, the house would explode with some of those volatile characters :eek:

[MrWong]

Just for fun, which of these 2 BB Allstars ideas would cause the most amusement, annoyance or WTF reactions?

Idea 1) The 'stars' are the first voted out of their respective series e.g.
BB1 - Sada
BB2 - Penny
BB3 - Lynne
BB4 - Anouska
BB5 - Vanessa
BB6 - Mary
BB7 - Bonnie
BB8 - Shabnam
BB9 - Steph
BB10 - Sophia
CBBs - Chris Eubank, Goldie, Jackie Stallone, Jodie Marsh, Jackiey Budden, Lucy Pinder, Katia Ivanova

All the nutters, i love it!! :cheer2:

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

I like some of both of those lists.

[Zippy]

Can't believe how memorable some of those first out people are. Seems like they were in for ages.

Forget the second lot. Can't stand quitters and theyre not worth a 2nd go.

[daniel-lewis-1985]

Vanessa wasnt the first person to be evicted from bb5

[fuzzylovin]

idea 1 would be so funny

[MrWong]

Can't believe how memorable some of those first out people are. Seems like they were in for ages.

Forget the second lot. Can't stand quitters and theyre not worth a 2nd go.

I know yet hm's still whine about being first out because 'nobody remembers you'

Far easier to list the 1st evictees then the ones that leave 3rd, for instance.

It's the housemates inbetween that get forgotten.

[aliacid]

Vanessa wasnt the first person to be evicted from bb5

I thought this too, wasn't it Kitten? Even though she was sort of ejected it was still an eviction right? Didn't Big Brother chose who they wanted to evict?

[Mac Hiavellian]

Forget the second lot. Can't stand quitters and theyre not worth a 2nd go.

It's strange that BB excommunicates with some walkers/ejectees and doesn't even invite them to the finales e.g. Sandy, Alex, Dennis but some are still lauded as 'legends' such as Chanelle or even Nasty Nick who, despite being the first ejected, has starred in BB Panto and was invited back for the BB10 anniversary task

Vanessa wasnt the first person to be evicted from bb5

I know there's debate about whether Kitten was first evicted but I consider her 'ejected' because she broke the rules and Davina joked that Vanessa was finally the first evictee - in Week 4! :eek:

[Niamh.]

I quite like the second idea, not the first though!

[ILoveTRW]

Kitten was ejected, Vanessa was evicted. simple as.

[aliacid]

She was evicted, they don't play the 'you have been evicted loop' for ejected housemates. I look at it this way; Big Brother were on the brink of ejecting her but decided to conduct a quick twist that was unplanned before the series where Big Brother picked the first HM to leave and they chose Kitten instead of ejecting her later on.

[ILoveTRW]

She was evicted, they don't play the 'you have been evicted loop' for ejected housemates. I look at it this way; Big Brother were on the brink of ejecting her but decided to conduct a quick twist that was unplanned before the series where Big Brother picked the first HM to leave and they chose Kitten instead of ejecting her later on.

The definition of an ejection, is a housemate leaving the house through big brothers chose.
The argument about "you have been evicted" being played into the house doesnt really wash, because there was no crowd and she got no best bits so its not as if it was even a typical eviction anyway.

[Jarvio]

Kitten was evicted, because Davina told her she had been evicted. So Vanessa was 2nd out. And for BB10, Benezir was 1st out, not Sophia.

[Jarvio]

Idea 1 would be hillarious, and I've often come up with that idea too. Imagine how bad the first person evicted from that lot would feel!

Also, funny how the only men on the 1st out list are Chris Eubank and Goldie! :joker:

[ILoveTRW]

Kitten was evicted, because Davina told her she had been evicted. So Vanessa was 2nd out. And for BB10, Benezir was 1st out, not Sophia.

in bb2 davina said bubble had been ejected when he was evicted?
so i guess you think bubble was ejected?

[Mac Hiavellian]

The night Kitten left was supposed to be the fake eviction/bedsit twist but that got postponed because of her rulebreaking and subsequent ejection. I think evictions are generally something the public has a say in such as in BB3 when Lynne and Jade were the most voted by the public but the HMs chose to evict Lynne - there was still public involvement. The only exceptions are Kinga in the secret garden and Jonathan BB7 because they weren't technically classed as Hms because they weren't in the main house.
I consider Kitten's departure an ejection as it was based on her rule breaking and had to postpone the already planned bedsit twist. But obviously BB played "Kitten - you have been evicted" which makes it confusing.

If she is classed as ejected then it's interesting that she was at the BB5 final when, like I said, some ejectees blacklisted by BB except for Nasty Nick

[aliacid]

The definition of an ejection, is a housemate leaving the house through big brothers chose.
The argument about "you have been evicted" being played into the house doesnt really wash, because there was no crowd and she got no best bits so its not as if it was even a typical eviction anyway.

Well the argument clearly does wash because why would they play 'you have been evicted' if she was ejected?

[Jarvio]

in bb2 davina said bubble had been ejected when he was evicted?
so i guess you think bubble was ejected?

When did Davina say that?

I thought Davina said "Paul and Bubble, the votes have been counted and verified, and I can now reveal that the 4th person to be evicted from the BB house is............. Bubble"

If she did say "ejected", then it was clearly a mistake.

As for Kitten, she had an eviction night. She was kicked out for breaking the rules, but still, it was treated as an eviction

[Mac Hiavellian]

Kitten was evicted, because Davina told her she had been evicted. So Vanessa was 2nd out. And for BB10, Benezir was 1st out, not Sophia.

The Beinazir thing's interesting cos she was also not classed as an official HM because of the whole non-HM twist on launch but that also had a public vote. I think I class her as the first eviction of BB10

[BBDodge]

It's supposed to be All Stars, not All Rejects.

[_Seth]

The second, but chuck Shabnam in there, too. :D

[Mac Hiavellian]

It's supposed to be All Stars, not All Rejects.

Lol that's why I'd like it to be just the winners as they're technically 'all stars' but some people have their favourites, other people won't agree with them and some will have different ranks to others i.e. Nikki (5th place in BB7) against Billi (3rd evicted in BB8) and Brian (BB2 winner) - so it won't seem fair unless the chosen allstars are all on more equal terms rather than randomly selected.

That's why I thought as a big joke which would be a better/worse idea? Only the first people out? Or the people that didn't even finish cos they quit or were removed? Lol

[ILoveTRW]

Well the argument clearly does wash because why would they play 'you have been evicted' if she was ejected?

they probably only played it because it was such short notice that she was going to be ejected so they the didnt have time/couldnt be bothered to make a tape saying you have been ejected

[ILoveTRW]

When did Davina say that?

I thought Davina said "Paul and Bubble, the votes have been counted and verified, and I can now reveal that the 4th person to be evicted from the BB house is............. Bubble"

If she did say "ejected", then it was clearly a mistake.

As for Kitten, she had an eviction night. She was kicked out for breaking the rules, but still, it was treated as an eviction

where was the crowd? where was her best bits?

[aliacid]

they probably only played it because it was such short notice that she was going to be ejected so they the didnt have time/couldnt be bothered to make a tape saying you have been ejected

Or maybe the played it because she was evicted?

With regards to the crowd... correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Jade Goody evicted to no crowd during CBB?

[ILoveTRW]

Or maybe the played it because she was evicted?

With regards to the crowd... correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Jade Goody evicted to no crowd during CBB?

Define what the word eviction means in BB
and then what the word ejection means

[ILoveTRW]

yeah, didn't think you would be able to without totally contradicting yourself

[ILoveTRW]

lol BBLB just had a clip package showing all the first evictees, and what do you know, Vanessa pops up

[Niall]

Number 2 for me please -- wouldn't be a day in that house without some kind of fight going on lol.

[Mac Hiavellian]

lol BBLB just had a clip package showing all the first evictees, and what do you know, Vanessa pops up

Good good lol. Who was for BB10? Was it Beinazir or Sophia?

[ILoveTRW]

Good good lol. Who was for BB10? Was it Beinazir or Sophia?

sophia

[Mac Hiavellian]

Number 2 for me please -- wouldn't be a day in that house without some kind of fight going on lol.

Lol I imagine they'd all try to escape the house or break the rules again.

Sandy, Kenneth and Kitten on the roof again, Shahbaz playing with the bins, Chanelle fuming in the diary room, Emma locked in a bedsit, Nick hiding names under his bed once more. And Dawn walking along saying "Oh shoht op. Shoht op. Shoht op."
She might have refused to do it in BB3 but I can picture Sunita hiding in the kitchen cabinets now mwahahaha