Noooooooooo Maria's Gone

[LawlerRulez_1991]

It's so unfair, I wanted her to win:puzzled:
Someone cheer me up please

[Dan_]

Louis Walsh is a complete joke.How biased can you get ffs?

[Romantic Old Bird]

This is a total travesty.

Simon had to support his own group, I understand that. he was sure Louis would keep Maria in.

And that is SOLELY why Louis saved the Conways. Nothing to do with the passport Sharon. Just Louis Wals h being evil.

For GOD'S SAKE SIMON, GIVE MARIA A RECORDING CONTRACT, NOW!!!!

[James]

That's a shocker. The Conway Sisters were poor tonight.

Louis Walsh knows that he put through the weaker act.

Apart from Louis just supporting the Irish act, it's also possible they wanted a controversial week to get the ratings movings.

[LawlerRulez_1991]

It's unfair, she had a bad song, but she didn't deserve to go, I wish Chico would go, I hate him so much. I like the conways but not as much as Shayne or Brenda, Maria was my favourite.
Louis Walsh smells like cats wee
:mad::mad::mad::mad::mad:

*runs away crying*

[Dan_]

Louis knows The Conway Sisters and I think that was the main basis behind his decision.

[LawlerRulez_1991]

Do you guys think Maria wil get a record contract.
I really really hope so.

[Dan_]

I think she has a great amount of talent and she's stunning. I don't see why she won't get a record deal.

[LawlerRulez_1991]

Originally posted by BB fernzy
I think she has a great amount of talent and she's stunning. I don't see why she won't get a record deal.

Hopefully she'll end up like WIll Young or Kelly Clarkson (apart from the fact they WON)

[Dan_]

Yer, good luck to her! She may have had a bad week this week but every other week she has been great.

[BigSister]

Yeah I agree with Rob simon had to suppport his own act but louis should have voted the Conways out I hope they go next week

[lily.]

I thought she was bl00dy fantastic tonight, and I reckon folk didn't vote for her because she is so good every week, and the public figured she was safe anyway. I don't think song choice even entered into it.

As for Louis Walsh. Point me in the direction of the "hate Louis Walsh" club.. I'm joining! He is a disgrace, and he is making a mockery of the show. I don't even want to watch it next week.

And, did anyone catch what Sharon asked on The Xtra Factor? She said to Ben: "Does that mean that if anyone besides Louis acts are up against the conways they are out?"..

She has a very good point!

[BigSister]

Yep you can join Stropz I think your number 4?

[lily.]

Excellent bigsis! Ta Much!..

[Arneldo]

Louis walsh is a (excuse my french) D**k!!

He wudnt now talent if it slapped him in the face!

He is a joke!

[BigSister]

Any1 else want to join:laugh:

Founder: Moi
1: Ruth
2: Pipez 9I think)
3: dan
4: Stropz
3

[Big_Man]

Sign me up to The Walsh is a W***ker Hate Club, BigSis

1: Ruth
2: Pipez 9I think)
3: dan
4: Stropz
3: Big_Man

Poor Maria - I'm looking forward to her giving the finger to Louis and coming back like Lemar did. She was fantastic.

[Big_Man]

Seems I can't count though, doh (!)
:eureka: I meant

1: Ruth
2: Pipez 9I think)
3: dan
4: Stropz
5: Big_Man

[BigSister]

:laugh: I cant count either Bigman welcome to the club. All is most welcome

[Dan_]

Originally posted by Stropz
I thought she was bl00dy fantastic tonight, and I reckon folk didn't vote for her because she is so good every week, and the public figured she was safe anyway. I don't think song choice even entered into it.

As for Louis Walsh. Point me in the direction of the "hate Louis Walsh" club.. I'm joining! He is a disgrace, and he is making a mockery of the show. I don't even want to watch it next week.

And, did anyone catch what Sharon asked on The Xtra Factor? She said to Ben: "Does that mean that if anyone besides Louis acts are up against the conways they are out?"..

She has a very good point!

I said the exact same thing as Sharon about 5 minutes earlier. Luckily Mr.Cowell has said he will vote off his own act if it means not losing a more talented act.

[lily.]

Originally posted by BB fernzy
Luckily Mr.Cowell has said he will vote off his own act if it means not losing a more talented act.
I don't believe him though. Because, I genuinely don't believe that Simon thinks the Conways are more talented than Maria.

But, in his defence, he did say "from now on..", as though he realised he had made a huge mistake tonight.

Although, how he couldn't see Louis decision coming is beyond me. Everyone else could!

[Lance]

What a disgrace.

Wouldn't know talent if it hit them on the nose.:bored:

[Pipergun]

Originally posted by BigSister
Any1 else want to join:laugh:

Founder: Moi
1: Ruth
2: Pipez 9I think)
3: dan
4: Stropz
3

Whoops, yeah - must've deleted my message from my avatar by accident. Travesty that Maria's gone! :bored:

[Ruth]

Absolutely shocking. I didn't think the Conways were that bad tonight - in fact I thought it was one of their best weeks - but they were not as good as Maria, and have not been on any week. I just can't understand what Louis was thinking. It gets ridiculous when people get knocked out of the show because of where they're from, or rivalry between the judges or something daft like that. Maria was one of the best acts on the show - a real talent has been lost.

I do think that she will probably get a recording contract anyway though, and do well in any event.

[jrc]

I missed the X Factor results last night as I had to go out. Are you serious? The 'King of Pop' picked the Conways over Maria?

[Z]

:mad:

Can I join the club too???

[BigSister]

Yeah sure Ziola:thumbs:

Founder: Moi
1: Ruth
2: Pipez
3: dan
4: stropz
5: BBfan
6: Ziola

[sol]

NOOOOO another of my favourite has gone in the 2nd concesive week!! :mad:

I dont think that song choice was anything to do with Maria being in th bottom 2 last night, i think (like someone said) it was down to people thinking she was safe and not voting, and voting for the underdog (Chico) :mad:

Even though I like the Conways (look below) I would rather have them go than Maria, as Maria is obviously such a stronger act than the Conways!

However, I had already figured out that whoever went against the Conways in the final showdown (except Shayne and Nicholas) would go because i knew that Louis would save them, so when Maria went up against them i started cringing :shocked:

Bad decision in my book - but i think that Maria will get a recording contract defo :thumbs:

[Princess]

The coI cant believe it!Chico is still there and the most talented person in the competion has gone:mad::mad:The Conways would have gone evuntally Maria could have won it easy.

I think as well that it was because people though she was safe

BTW can I join the Hate louis club?

[Corkie]

me and my mum said oh louie will deffo choose conways just cos there irish

and it was right it stupid i think maria was one of the best she does rock music can of and i cant believe shes gone


well done louie you might of been an enemy in ireland if you voted conways out but you got booed on saturday you better get used to it

also ive got irish in my blood and i hate conway there so bad

[Ruth]

Originally posted by jrc
I missed the X Factor results last night as I had to go out. Are you serious? The 'King of Pop' picked the Conways over Maria?

It was shocking! The vote was between Maria and the Conways obviously (even though neither of them deserved to be in the bottom two IMO), and naturally Simon and Sharon saved their own acts, and it came down to Louis to pick. I couldn't believe it when he said he was sending Maria home. Favouritism at its ugliest. Sharon came on stage with Maria and said it was a travesty - which was true - and that Louis had voted with his passport - also true.

[James]

Louis made it clear, with his decision, last night that he will vote to save The Conways Sisters over anyone else apart from his own acts.

That means that if the Conways find themselves in the bottom two with Andy, Brenda or Chico it will be the Conways that stay.

The Conways have got a big chance of getting to the final three or four now.

[~Kizwiz~]

Why oh why is Louis so hell bent on keeping them in??? They have a small amount of talent but could never make it as recording artists!

[BigSister]

Yeah sure you can join the club Princess your number 7

[Pipergun]

Woo! Go us!! :bigsmile:

We should all go to a live show and chase him around with a big stick! Muahaha! :bouncy:

[Dan_]

Lol pipergun.

Simon's fallen out with The Conways and I think he will vote them out when they are next in the bottom 2.

[BigSister]

lol pipez I wouldnt dare though

[Ruth]

Originally posted by kizwiz
Why oh why is Louis so hell bent on keeping them in???


He knows them personally and has done since before the show began. He also knows their family, and is obviously incapable of being impartial. If he felt compromised, then (a) he shouldn't be doing the job of judging in the first place, and (b) he should have said that he couldn't pick between the two and gone to the public vote. I wouldn't normally say that it should go to the public vote, but it would have been better than having an obviously biased judge.

[CharlotteSometimes]

Originally posted by Romantic Old Bird
This is a total travesty.

Simon had to support his own group, I understand that. he was sure Louis would keep Maria in.

And that is SOLELY why Louis saved the Conways. Nothing to do with the passport Sharon. Just Louis Wals h being evil.

For GOD'S SAKE SIMON, GIVE MARIA A RECORDING CONTRACT, NOW!!!!

Indeed it is.

I don't think he had to - the winning act is signed to Simon's label, so it's in his own best interests to sacrifice his own act if necessary. He most certainly knew that Louis would save the Conway Sisters, too. I think Simon wants Shayne to win, as he has the most money-making potential.

I think it was 100% 'a passport decision'. And regardless of how they do on XF, there's still money to be made from them back in the Emerald Isle. Louis is every bit as likely to think with his wallet as Simon is.

It won't happen though, as he's said all along that the only XF act he'll ever sign will be the winner.

[LawlerRulez_1991]

Can I join the Louis Walsh Hate CLub too please?

[Pipergun]

BigSis is the founder, but I'm sure it'll be fine! :spin:

I think it's:

Founder: BigSister
1: Ruth
2: Pipez (Moi!)
3: dan
4: stropz
5: BBfan
6: Ziola
7. Princess90
8. LawlerRulez_1991

(In case you haven't noticed, that'd mean you're number 8 :thumbs:)

Glad to have you on our side!! :wavey:

[CharlotteSometimes]

Originally posted by Romantic Old Bird

For GOD'S SAKE SIMON, GIVE MARIA A RECORDING CONTRACT, NOW!!!!

They said on This Morning earlier that Simon apparently has offered Maria a contract with his Syco / BMG label. Apparently, they asked her if it was okay for them to say so on the show, and she said it was. He's on the show himself on Monday, so he'll no doubt confirm or deny it then, if he doesn't do so before on one of the XF shows over the weekend. It still seems strange though, as he's always maintained that he'll only ever sign the act that wins the show. This way, he gets the eventual winner and the act that really deserved to win. But he was quoted earlier this week saying that he never thought she had a chance of winning, anyway. He thinks it will be between Shayne, Andy & Journey South, apparently.