Should a HM be able to nominate someone based on....

[starry]

....their religious beliefs? Or even political beliefs?

I would prefer if it was concerned more specifically with behaviour in the house really.

[bansheewails]

I think as long as they have a valid reason it can be anything. I thought Corin's reasons tonight were the most orginal and valid I had heard in a long time! :laugh:

[_Seth]

As long as it isn't stupid, like David's retarded anti-gay marriage attitude.

[starry]

I think it should be more solidly about what happens in the house though. I mean if they think he is preaching, ok. But if it's just that they disagree with a religious belief then I'm not sure, does that mean he should just have kept quiet about his beliefs or even LIED about them?

[bansheewails]

I think it should be more solidly about what happens in the house though. I mean if they think he is preaching, ok. But if it's just that they disagree with a religious belief then I'm not sure, does that mean he should just have kept quiet about his beliefs or even LIED about them?

I think its the fact that he mentioned them more than once, and they just don;t like him, so they use any reason then to nominate. Its a more valid reason than the usual 'I dont get on with them as much as other people in here'. But its early days yet, I expect someone will use it soon! :hugesmile:

[GiRTh]

They're supposed to give frank reasons so in theory you could nominate someone for being gay if say you were a Muslim. Interesting. I'd love to see if someone would get away with that.

[MissKittyFantastico]

I thought that at first but then Josie nommed him because she thought he was being insensitive saying it when they was a gay person sat right next to him when he was banging on about it and THAT'S why she nommed him.And that's perfectly fair reason imo.

[pixee]

You do realise people that this show isn't about just 14 people in a house so yes you could go an nom someone because you don't like gays but you aint going to win 100 000k and you just caused a lot of problems for yourself when you get out.

[Stacey.]

i don't really think that's right either actually.

because to be honest, it's just their opinion.

[bringbackscience]

i don't really think that's right either actually.

because to be honest, it's just their opinion.

Its also THEIR nomination though.