Do you think the punishment's fair?

[BB-Rocks]

I don't think it is .. i'm a Preston fan and think it is really funny but i do think it isn't fair as they broke the rules so they should face eviction

[Jay]

I think the punishment is harsh it was George and Preston who broke them so they should have really been put up for the public vote

[kilkennycat]

I think that what they did to George and Preston was absolutely disgusting and uncomfortable to watch. They have sank so low to do such a horrible thing to embarass all of the participants. They are trying to cause rows and bad feelings. Also what was Feria on about getting upset about being evicted. Do they think they are staying for life. Its a game! All of them will be evicted all of the time. Now Rula has been really upset when her best friend in there has been to look like a snake. What has she done to deserve this. Now they are all feeling bad about each other. I think they should all tell big brother to go ............ themselves.

[Mike]

Preston and George have been punished to an extent, they now have to go around and explain their reasons to the other housemates, well Preston is anyway George has dissapeared into the garden Lol.

[BB-Rocks]

George is still speechless .. lol Preston is upset and is still explaining to Rula and Traci why he picked them

[Jay]

To be honest i don't think George cares

[GlitterEyes]

I think it only helps them stay nomination free in the long run. Its a plus not a punishment.

[abbashop79]

It's helped everybody more than hindered them. Apart from one of the three is leaving, which isnt so good, but at least theyve laid cards on table and know eachother a bit more. I think it was more than fair!

[abbashop79]

I think Preston will get evicted, from his (ex) home when he gets home to his (ex) GF!! (meeow)

[GabrielleisLove]

I think there still may be another twist beacuse the numbers arent up yet and usually they like to get every penny ouit of us :joker:

[Kore]

they broke the rules. simple, they should of got nominated. otherwise people will keep breaking rules expecting to get 'appraised'

[Fangz]

This reminds me of how some teachers will punish a small group of pupils by giving the whole class detention/de-merits, so that the offenders peers will have reason to gang up on them.

[Razmataz]

This all seems to similar to erm.......
But yeah.
I like the twist.
And realistically i do think its 'evil' and dont we all like that.

[Slartibartfast]

It seems to me they got off a little too easy on the punishment. They broke the rules and they should both be up for eviction themselves.

It would have been better if BB had made them give their nominations with all the housemates watching, and then announce to the house that their nominations didn't mean a thing and either everyone is up for eviciton or George and Preston are automatically up for eviction. That would teach em!

[Razmataz]

Maybe you just dont know whats gonna happen.
Have phone lines opened for voting yet.

[Ruth]

I missed it. Am I right in assuming that they had to pick who would be up for eviction this week, and nobody else has to nominate? If so, that's daft I think. They should both be put up for eviction automatically.

[broonbreed]

what has actually happened last night, i didn't find out what the punishment was. Are they nominated or are they having to nominate other people for eviction?

[Slartibartfast]

I didn't see it, midnight is way past my bedtime!!but it seems that George and Preston had to nominate three people who would be up for eviction. The twist was that the rest of the housemates got to see them making their nominations, which Preston and George didn't know.

As I said above, a bit of a weak punishment. They should have made them do this and then tell them that their nominations didn't mean a thing and were purely a way to embarress the two of them.

[broonbreed]

Who did they nominate?

[Sunny_01]

I thought it was a bit harsh to make them do that and show it to the rest of the house! that said it is BB :hello:

Felt sorry for Preston trying to talk his way out of why he had chosen the people that he had.

George - well just showed himself for what he is - he left Perston to mop up the mess while he became sulky and wandered round the garden.

Was nice to see Pete sticking up for Preston though and encouraging him not to feel bad.

[roofy]

Didn't see it!! Hope they show it tonight though!

I'm a bit two-way on this one. I think it was good and bad. 1, they broke the rules so should really have been punished themselves, not given the opportunity to get the people they dont like out. 2, they were kind of punished by the other housemates knowing they had nominated.

I still dont think it's a proper punishment though.

[Nikkos]

the punishment was fair in my opinion...and funny lol i just hope maggot goes

[BigSister]

I think its a bit meh because 1 they got away with not being up themselves but 2 on the other hand will proably be up next time anyway so its good/bad

[Kore]

Originally posted by nikkos12345
the punishment was fair in my opinion...and funny lol i just hope maggot goes

rula to go imo!

[BB-Rocks]

I hope Maggot goes then Rula .. i hope Traci stays!

[BusyBee]

To be honest would have been fairer if George and Preston had been put up for eviction. They were the people who had done wrong, why should others be up for eviction and they stay in the house. Not on BB.

[BigSister]

Yeah that was what I was thinking too BB but on the other hand they will proably be up for nomination next time anyway

[cc100]

It was very harsh on Preston- he was purely showing he was not a racist. Anyone would have done the same.

[Siouxsie]

big brother is so mean

[InTheHood]

The punishment should have been they were both up.

But then, the entertainment from this would not have happened.