What I don;t understand is...

[fizzy]

..if he thought Sam not Josie was in the right, as he said in the DR. Why did he tell Sam to shut it and stick up for Josie to her face?

Did he simply change his mind after...wait for it.... considering himself?!

[Jords]

Andrew told Sam he wasnt being helpful, referring to him repeating 'shut the **** up'.

[CaudleHalbard]

Because whatever Andrew says in the DR he:

(a) Hates Sam

(b) Has a crush on Josie.

:)

[AtomicKitty]

He does not have a crush on Josie....
Please come on you really think this Oxford math student as geeky as he is he going to have a crush on thunder thighs from Bristol! just on the intellectual gap he would not go for it.
he is just has a small game plan that will buy him a little time in the house, he knows he wont win it but he is giving it a go for fun.
and she is 25! looks like 35 like she has 4 kids already and talks like plays the country pumpkin too much.. and sucks her thumb.... there is no way he would go for a girl like that.. think what a right idiot he would look like to on front of his fellow Mathwizzs

and he just stood by her because he is in conflict of personalities with sam and knows sam would own him. he needs to nurture few alliances he has in the house ( Josie, Dave)

[CaudleHalbard]

Andrew has no friends - let alone a girlfriend.

He certainly has an unpleasant streak as well.

[fizzy]

Andrew told Sam he wasnt being helpful, referring to him repeating 'shut the **** up'.

Oh right I see.


So he thinks sam is in the right BUT goes too far with the swearing.

I get it now.