The public has only ever got the winner right 3 times!! So why should we..

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

..expect the votes to pick the right winner this year. Brace yourself people Josie is going to win! :joker: I really think if John hadn't been an ally she would have been funny enough and active enough to be a deserving winner but alas she only ended up making me angry and embarassed for her as a woman.

Craig philips
Brian dowling was most entertaining of his series, right winner
Nadia-definitely.

That was it, Brace yourselves. :)

[smudgie]

Just as long as JJames or Dave don't win, I won't be that bothered.
Josie, Corin and Sam in the top three would be my ideal, but I won't lose sleep if it isn't. I am not writing the cheque out for the winner.:hugesmile:

[crystaltreasure]

have not picked up the phone for anyone for three years.. can't be bothered

[oddballmisfitsFTW]

IMO

Craig, Kate, Anthony, Pete, Rachel and Sophie were the right winners from the eventual finalists

cant remember BB2 but i do remember i didnt like Brian

Cameron was sh** winer

didnt watch BB5 but probably would have hated Nadia

Samanda should have beat Brian but didnt mind Brian winning either

for me it hasnt been that bad

save the worst winner for last in my case

[stonedape]

Like or dislike Josie, she would not be a Sophie "come from behind" win or a Rachel "come from nowhere" win. Josie has had public interest and a central position in the house from the beginning.

If JJ2 or Steve win this thing, then we'll need to start a little chat.

[30stone]

Pete was definately!

[oddballmisfitsFTW]

Like or dislike Josie, she would not be a Sophie "come from behind" win or a Rachel "come from nowhere" win. Josie has had public interest and a central position in the house from the beginning.

If JJ2 or Steve win this thing, then we'll need to start a little chat.


I would much prefer a Steve win over a Josie win

at least Steve would spend the money on some legs and it would be worthwhile

Dave also would be better winner if he is truthful about setting up that orphanage in india he said about

anyone is more deserving than nasty bitch Josie

Josie will just spend all her money on cakes and biscuits

[StGeorge]

..
Nadia-definitely.

That was it, Brace yourselves. :)

Well its all subject to personal opinion isnt it??

I personally thought Nadia was an awful winner, but heh....thats how the public voted so tough.

[vesavius]

Well its all subject to personal opinion isnt it??

I personally thought Nadia was an awful winner, but heh....thats how the public voted so tough.

See? this is just it. What one person thinks was an awful winner another thinks was a great winner. Thats what makes the entire thread ridiculous. No one has the ability or right to say what is right or wrong on a show based 100% on subjective taste.

As for people saying 'the public' getting it wrong... hate to tell you, but we ARE that public.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

As for people saying 'the public' getting it wrong... hate to tell you, but we ARE that public.
are forum users really the voting public though?

The housemates forum users seem to hate the most thrive/survive during eviction.

[Kaaarenn!]

I have only watched it since BB6 and only 3 people have won that I wanted to.
In BB6, I wanted Anthony to win and he did.
In BB7, I wanted either Pete or Glyn to win and Pete did soo that was good.
In BB8, I wanted Brian to win and he did.
From then on it went down hill for my winners :laugh: Even though, saying that, I didn't particulary mind Sophie winning last year :)

[Jarvio]

My opinions on each winner:

Craig (BB1) - Worthy winner
Brain (BB2) - Worthy winner
Kate (BB3) - Very worthy winner
Cameron (BB4) - Not great, but then again, probably the most deserving out of BB4 still
Nadia (BB5) - She annoyed the **** outta me. But I suppose she's a deserving winner
Anthonty (BB6) - I guess so. Indifferent, not fussed
Pete (BB7) - Overrated. Only won cos of his bloody tourettes
Brain (BB8) - ****ing wanker. Worst winner ever period. I'd rather anyone win than him
Rachael (BB9) - Not deserving, too boring. But I hated BB9 anyway
Sophie (BB10) - I think David should have won, but yeah Sophie was pretty deserving

Overall, my main issue is Brian Belo. What a tosser. And no I'm not racist

[vesavius]

are forum users really the voting public though?

The housemates forum users seem to hate the most thrive/survive during eviction.

Forum users are the public, yeah, although a more mental entrenched part of it. No one here has a more informed or more correct take on the 'truth' then the general public, in fact it is usually harder to get to the truth here, due to the twisting outright lying and obvious agendas, then it is talking to a casual viewer.

[IheartBB]

Of course winners are disputable as everyone has different tastes, but anyone with a sufficient amount of logic and objectivity can pick apart the deserving few from the not-so-deserving-few.

BB1 - Out of Craig, Anna and Darren, Craig is the obvious choice.
BB2 - Brian or Helen. Both deserving. Neither had ‘haters’ and both were loved by the public.
BB3 - Four very worthy winners in the final. Open to debate, but not a bad winner by any stretch
BB4 - Who cares? We had no one to choose from, and a nobody won.
BB5 - Nadia or Jason. Nadia had the fairytale story, but Jason matched her in the entertainment stakes.
BB6 - Here we have the first real case of undeserving winner. The most entertaining housemate this series only came third, and we were left with two Mr Nice Guys. Boring.
BB7 - Entertaining housemates galore. Pete, Glyn, Nikki or Ashlene (sp?) would have been fine.
BB8 - The obvious choice of a winner, but we were not left with much in the final.
BB9 - See BB6 and replace Mr with Ms.
BB10 - Not left with much after Markus, Noirin, Bea and Freddie has supplied most of the entertainment for the series, so it was always going to be somewhat of a let down.

BB4, BB6, BB9 and possibly BB10 were the only real oddball winners if you ask me.

As for Josie, I think she'll go the same way as Brian Belo - she'll be left with a bunch of bores after Sam & John James are evicted, so she'll be the obvious choice.

[Lex]

Pete was my only successs!...But I really wanted Richard!!
As I knew that Richard had no-chance....Pete was so close that I considered it to be O.K!! :dance:

[moghirl]

have not picked up the phone for anyone for three years.. can't be bothered

I've only ever picked up the phone to vote once in BB and that was for Jason .. when he came second to Nadia, back in 2005, was it ?

[stoney]

..expect the votes to pick the right winner this year. Brace yourself people Josie is going to win! :joker: I really think if John hadn't been an ally she would have been funny enough and active enough to be a deserving winner but alas she only ended up making me angry and embarassed for her as a woman.

Craig philips
Brian dowling was most entertaining of his series, right winner
Nadia-definitely.

That was it, Brace yourselves. :)

cant agree with you in the slightest.

correct winners for BB1 , 2 but also number 3 in Kate.

but Nadia did feck all apart from have the operation that gave her a big secret to play on Jason:sleep:

[Mystic Mock]

the public havent got it right once yet.

[EzzaB]

Winners who SHOULDNT have won were

Cameron - BB4 - Did fck all
Anthony - BB6 - Makosi , Science , Derek and Kinga should have been in the final
Rachel - BB9 - All i cud say was w.t.f! Sara should have won , Mikey and Mo should never have been in the top 7

The rest were deserving i think

[InOne]

My opinions on each winner:

Craig (BB1) - Good winner, deserved it.
Brain (BB2) - Pretty decent guy, good winner.
Kate (BB3) - Best female HM of all time and possibly the best winner of all time.
Cameron (BB4) - Meh
Nadia (BB5) - Not too bad, plus she played a decent part in fight night.
Anthonty (BB6) - Absolute twat, a win for the plastics there.
Pete (BB7) - He was ok, but was soooooo obvious he was gonna win from the start
Brain (BB8) - Played the game and played the act. He a twat but what BB is all about.
Rachael (BB9) - Quite hot, but not a winner.
Sophie (BB10) - Worst winner of all time. Fat slobbering drunken mess.

[Peter Plunker]

The public cannot get it wrong, whoever wins, wins. Do you think that the majority vote is somehow inferior to your opinion?