The BB Housemates vs. The CBB Housemates

[Jords]

Which on a whole is the better selected bunch (those picked from the normal series to go into UBB out of all the normal series housemates, or those picked from the celebrity version to go into UBB out of all the celebrity version housemates)?

And which do you prefer that are in UBB, the BB or CBB housemates?


Big Brother: Josie, Nadia, Brian, Makosi, Nikki, Nasty Nick, Victor, Michelle.

Celebrity Big Brother: Chantelle, Preston, Ulrika, John, Coolio, Vanessa.

Taken in mind there are 2 more BB housemates than CBB.


Selected - The CBB Housemates, as the recent series: BB8, BB9 and BB10 are all ignored from normal BB which had 'ultimate' housemates, but include 3 out of 8 from BB5. And from CBB they got a romance (Chantelle + Preston), a nutter (Vanessa), a rivalery (Ulrika + Coolio, not so much in UBB though) and a rebel (John). Which is great with only 6 places available to fill.

Prefer - The BB Housemates, contain a good range of personalities and memorable faces, and personally prefer normal housemates as you 'get to know them' better. I just dont like how theyve ignored all the housemates from recent series because the ratings wernt as good (those Im more familiar with, even though as a series I dont rate BB8 + BB9 but some of the housemates I do)...

[Mystic Mock]

i think normal bb housemates are better as they dont have to play as cagey as the celebs do.

[iRyan]

The normal BB group is perfectly casted.

Makosi, Nadia, Nick, Victor, Michelle, Nikki, and Brian all 100% are the best of the best and deserve to be on it.

The CBB group is a mess. Chantelle and John Mccririck are the only two that truely deserve a spot. Maybe Coolio too since he was entertaining

Instead of Preston, Ulrika, Vanessa, etc this is what it should have looked like:

Josie
Nikki
Victor
Michelle
Makosi
Nick
Brian
Nadia
Charley
Marcus
Rex
Chantelle
John Mc
Coolio
Pete Burns

[Jords]

i think normal bb housemates are better as they dont have to play as cagey as the celebs do.

Yepp thats a good point too JF.

[_Seth]

The 2nd option is the same as the 4th, and the same with the 1st and 3rd. :confused:

But the normal BB HMs are better. But tbh I class Chantelle as a normal HM since she wasn't already a celebrity.

[Jords]

The 2nd option is the same as the 4th, and the same with the 1st and 3rd. :confused:

But the normal BB HMs are better. But tbh I class Chantelle as a normal HM since she wasn't already a celebrity.

Its a bit unclear -

Selection as in the BB housemates picked out of all the BB housemates there have been, same goes with CBB.

Preference as in do you prefer the BB or CBB housemates that are in UBB.

Hope that makes more sense. :laugh:

[Patrick]

The normal BB group is perfectly casted.

Makosi, Nadia, Nick, Victor, Michelle, Nikki, and Brian all 100% are the best of the best and deserve to be on it.

The CBB group is a mess. Chantelle and John Mccririck are the only two that truely deserve a spot. Maybe Coolio too since he was entertaining

Instead of Preston, Ulrika, Vanessa, etc this is what it should have looked like:

Josie
Nikki
Victor
Michelle
Makosi
Nick
Brian
Nadia
Charley
Marcus
Rex
Chantelle
John Mc
Coolio
Pete Burns

See if this was the line up, we'd be sorted.

[_Seth]

Its a bit unclear -

Selection as in the BB housemates picked out of all the BB housemates there have been, same goes with CBB.

Preference as in do you prefer the BB or CBB housemates that are in UBB.

Hope that makes more sense. :laugh:

Oh I see now. Well I voted for the 1st and 3rd option, since it was multi vote

[Visage]

I much prefer the BB housemates over the CBB housemates.