Who has the better single? Cheryl vs. Nadine

[Shaun]

Released around the same time, which is better?

hln5z4vx1xY

NG3ICpyGByM

Poll coming.

[LaLaLand]

This is a no-brainer. Nadine!

[Jords]

Both not brilliant.

Nadine...

If it was first single then it would be FFTL.

[Firewire]

Chezza!

[Smithy]

alouette ette ette

is the only bit I like from Cheryl, so Nadine

[Callum]

Cheryl

[Smithy]

Cheryl's video is premiering on ITV2 now

[Locke.]

Cheryl's is ****ing awful

Can't be bothered listening to the other one

[Stacey.]

Probably Cheryl's Promise This, but love them both.

[MTVN]

Chery Cole's songs have been getting worse and worse. Fight For This Love was good, 3 Words was decent, Parachute was pretty poor and then this is just awful.

Nadine's isn't great but it's a lot better

[Jords]

Just saw the video to Promise This, quite a good music vid and found myself tapping to the chrous, dont think its as bad as I initally thought. Probably prefer to Nadine's actually.

[MrGaryy]

Nadine's by milessssss. Promise This is weak imo.

[M X]

Both good songs, but I prefer Promise This.

[Z]

Nadine's > Cheryl's, but that's not saying much.

[Tom]

Good lord, what the hell is Cheryls? It sounds like a ballad thats been given the club treatment

[Jordan.]

Promise This.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Like both :D
but Nadines

[InOne]

Both terrible.

[Tom4784]

If I had to choose I'd say Cheryl.

[Tom]

Cheryls song is growing on me :blush2:

One for my thread that

[Jords]

Cheryls song is growing on me :blush2:

One for my thread that

Yepp has with me, at first I thought it was crap but damn its catchy.

[Marsh.]

I don't really like either but Nadine obviously has the better singing voice.
But Cheryl's song I would say is better because more of a beat to it that I like. She's not got the better voice but definitely the better music.

I have a feeling Nadine will become like a Leona Lewis or Mariah Carey; great voices but very bland.

Edit - I've just thought that "Insatiable" could be released as a new Girls Aloud single and no one would notice the difference. You hardly ever hear the others anyway except in the background.

[Strictly Jake]

defo cheryl. Love it! But cheryl cole? Thought she was cheryl tweedy now?

[Legend killer]

For me it is Nadine's one. When i first heard it i was not to keen but it is actually quite catchy and she looks quite fine in it aswell

As for Cheryl's well it is just as bad as herother ones IMO

Nadine http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mG8XGXMB0gU

Cheryl http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AsM6x--1lYU

[Callum]

Cheryl's for me

[MeMyselfAndI]

Nadines :D

[Jords]

Cheryl's.

[james130]

Cheryl's songs catchier but Nadine's always gonna be the better singer.

[SacredDiablo]

nadine, definitely

[Saph]

Nadines is amazing :D

I havnt heard Cheryl's but I dont need to, coz its most likely ****.

[Stephanie]

Nadines is amazing :D

I havnt heard Cheryl's but I dont need to, coz its most likely ****.
omg i love your sig. chris is epic!

[Saph]

omg i love your sig. chris is epic!

yay chris ;D

[Stephanie]

yay chris ;D
:dance:

[Z]

Cheryl's new song is pants; but I preferred her debut to Nadine's, which is also distinctly unimpressive. I would have thought after over a year working on it, she'd have had something better than a trumpety hair flicky rubbish lyricy affair!

[Shaun]

oh wow, hey thread I made a fortnight ago

http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/showthread.php?t=162522

[Smithy]

Mr Showtime >

[Joelle.]

Would rather die than listen to either of those ****ing **** excuses for songs again. How much of a chav does Cheryl look in that video with her council house facelift. :joker:

[troy4783]

cheryls for me