Rank the Guest Judges

[Jords]

On how well they did. Obviously Nicole got more time than the others and theres more to come again in tomorrow's show (you can edit if ya change your opinion on her after).


1. Nicole Scherzinger
2. Geri Halliwell
3. Katy Perry
4. Pixie Lott
5. Natalie Imbruglia

Honestly think Nicole would make a good addition to the panel if she became a judge permenetely. :)

[Smithy]

Nicole is also doing bootcamp

1. Nicole
2. Katy
3. Natalie
4. Geri
5. Pixie

[Jords]

Nicole is also doing bootcamp


Oh really? Good stuff!

[Jack_]

#1 - Nicole
#2 - Geri
#3 - Pixie
#4 - Katy
#5 - Natalie

In terms of hotness:

#1 - Pixie
#2 - Nicole
#3 - Katy
#4 - Natalie




#5 - Geri

[Callum]

1. Nicole
2. Katy
3. Pixie
4. Natalie
5. Geri

[Ninastar]

#1 - Nicole
#2 - Geri
#3 - Pixie
#4 - Katy
#5 - Natalie

In terms of hotness:

#1 - Pixie
#2 - Nicole
#3 - Katie
#4 - Natalie




#5 - Geri
Pixie over katy? I mean I can nearly understand Nicole, but Pixie!!! :shocked:

[Firewire]

1. Nicole
2. Katy
3. Pixie
4. Natalie
5. Geri

[Jack_]

Pixie over katy? I mean I can nearly understand Nicole, but Pixie!!! :shocked:

Yep, can't really understand the attraction to Katy myself... :p

[Jords]

Yep, can't really understand the attraction to Katy myself... :p

http://userserve-ak.last.fm/serve/_/40305509/Katy+Perry++Glamour+Mag+2010.png

Saaay whhaaaaaat?

[Ninastar]

she sooooo nice!!

[Jack_]

http://userserve-ak.last.fm/serve/_/40305509/Katy+Perry++Glamour+Mag+2010.png

Saaay whhaaaaaat?

Meh

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/09/01/article-0-063E2F4F000005DC-50_468x613.jpg

Much better :love:

[Vicky.]

1. Nicole Scherzinger
2. Katy Perry
3. Geri Halliwell
4. Natalie Imbruglia
5. Pixie Lott

[Princess]

1.Katy Perry
2.Nicole Scherzinger
3.Pixie Lott
4.Geri Halliwell
5.Natalie Imbruglia

[Jords]

Meh

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/09/01/article-0-063E2F4F000005DC-50_468x613.jpg

Much better :love:

Shes hot but Katy Perry is yum.

http://userserve-ak.last.fm/serve/500/13523071/Katy+Perry+normal_02.jpg
Her eyes are frigging amazing too.

1. Katy
2. Pixie
3. Nicole
4. Natalie
5. Geri

[Jack_]

Shes hot but Katy Perry is yum.

http://userserve-ak.last.fm/serve/500/13523071/Katy+Perry+normal_02.jpg
Her eyes are frigging amazing too.

1. Katy
2. Pixie
3. Nicole
4. Natalie
5. Geri

I seriously just don't get the attraction. She would probably get it but I'd not be chasing after her like I would for Pixie.

Then again I've always generally preferred blondes :p

[Stacey.]

As in judging:
1. Katy
2. Nicole
3. Geri
4. Pixie
5. Natalie

As in hotness:
1. Pixie
2. Katy
3. Nicole
4. Geri
5. Natalie

[roddyj]

I haven't liked any of them, maybe Nicole was the best of them but not really bothered.

[Rob]

Rating by hotness

1 - Pixie
2 - Katy
3 - Nicole
4 - Natalie
5 - Geri

[Braden]

1. Nicole Scherzinger
2. Katy Perry
3. Geri Halliwell
4. Natalie Imbruglia
5. Pixie Lott

[Ninastar]

Nicole is also doing bootcamp

1. Nicole
2. Katy
3. Natalie
4. Geri
5. Pixie

this tbh

[Tom]

Stop arguing over who is the sexiest between Pixie and Katy. Its completely irrelevant when Nicole is on the panel!!! Nicole = perfection :lovedup: shes a woman not a girl, anyone who disagrees is blind, gay or female :hugesmile:

and as I'm male and therefore think with my willy, my fave judges have been:

1- Nicole
2- Katy
3- Pixie

I don't really remember the other 2, dunno if i even watched them

[Strictly Jake]

haha tom that was funny and totally agree with you! In terms of judging 1. Nicole 2. Katy 3. Natalie 4. Geri 5. Pixie. In terms of hotness 1. Katy 2. Nicole 3. Pixie 4. Natalie 5. Geri

[30stone]

1. Nicole Scherzinger
2. Katy Perry
3. Pixie Lott
4. Natalie Imbruglia
5. Geri Halliwell



I dont understand how are they going to do the live shows?

Boys
Girls
Groups
Over 25's (reported over 27/28's)

3 judges?

[Strictly Jake]

when it comes to the live shows. Danni is back. Its back to normal. But think natalie is back for judges houses and nicole and katie are going to be back to do some mentoring but not as judges

[Chantel]

1. Nicole
2. Katy
3. Pixie
4. Natalie
5. Geri

[Jordan.]

1. Nicole
2. Katy
3. Natalie
4. Pixie
5. Geri

:)

[Jack_]

Boys
Girls
Groups
Over 25's (reported over 27/28's)

3 judges?

Danni and Cheryl both return for Judge's Houses [which have just been filmed].

[BBfan46]

1. Nicole Scherzinger
2. Katy Perry
3. Geri Halliwell
4. Natalie Imbruglia
5. Pixie Lott

This.

Although Pixie did ruin the traditional 1 more yes to go through - sad music cliche which was brilliant until Louis forced her to change her mind :shocked:

[BBfan46]

Stop arguing over who is the sexiest between Pixie and Katy. Its completely irrelevant when Nicole is on the panel!!! Nicole = perfection :lovedup: shes a woman not a girl, anyone who disagrees is blind, gay or female :hugesmile:

and as I'm male and therefore think with my willy, my fave judges have been:

1- Nicole
2- Katy
3- Pixie

I don't really remember the other 2, dunno if i even watched them

but Lesbians are females :P

Katy's far better looking than both of them FYI

[Marsh.]

Pixie wasn't as good as I thought she would be. Pretty empty headed.
Great voice but letting someone as senial and passed it as Louis change her mind was stupid. Get a backbone and stick to your decision.
I'm sick of the cliche long pauses with the music aswell, wish Cowell and the editors would realise it doesn't work it's just cheesy.

But Nicole has been the best. I actually think she has the right to be a judge; given she actually has lots of experience and is talented.
Didn't like Katy Perry either, except for "Tell the truth ginger".

[InOne]

Pixie Lott owned them all.

[Maia]

Pixie had the best musical judgement IMO.