Wrong 12 picked + Over 25s robbed of places ... bad top 12

[Tom]

Firstly, only Dannii got it right. Cheryl completely ballsed up as usual, her only right decision was Rebecca and she would've been the weakest of the 3 that should have gone through (Gamu and Treyc) Louis didn't have much to chose from and Simon is too controlling with groups

The over 25s becoming over 28s is the worst decision ever made on X Factor. Treyc and Marlon both robbed of a place on the live shows to those 3 efforts they've put through that will never win (although Storm is my fave). In the case of Matt its had a knock on effect on the boys group not allowing another 1 through

So yeah, could've been better than series 5 this year but they've completely messed it up on epic proportions, I bet this twist is an attempt to fix it

on the + side omg @ Cheryl on the promo :lovedup:

[Jack_]

Simon made the worst choices IMO. Here's my take on it:

Dannii - Matt, Nicolo great choices. Aiden is dull...Paije was much more likeable and better.

Louis - Good choices although the black dude was forgettable...not really bothered though

Simon - F.Y.D are forgettable - bad choice. A girlband will never, ever win XF so Belle Amie is an awful choice. One Direction is a good choice but Diva Fever [this year's Jedward, except better] and The Reason should've gone through instread of F.Y.D and Belle Amie.

Cheryl - only one that got it right. Katie's a big personality, Cher is very popular, and Rebecca will grow as an act. I feel sorry for the two who got rejected again though.

[minty3]

it was only cheryl that got it wrong in my opinion it should have been gamu not katie all the rest were spot on