Random Observations.

[johnx]

Cheryl-Whats the point making people sing for their chance whan they can f#ck it up and you still put them through.
Over 28s-What a mess-how the hell did Wagner make the last 8.Mary's not a bad oul chanter but the X-factor? Storm Lee is the biggest drama queen on it.
Groups-Cowell obviously wants ones he assembled himself so he can take the credit if they're sucessful.In that case why bother asking established grops to audition.Hustle should have def went through-fit and sounded alrite too.
Katie Waissel-shes not much of a singer-on the rare ocassion she manages to finish a song.Annoying little stage school brat.
Cher's rapping on that Coldplay song was cringe-tastic.Needs to stop that kinda thing.Looks like a little chav to me.

[Niamh.]

lmao I agree with your random observations

[Lee.]

Cheryl-Whats the point making people sing for their chance whan they can f#ck it up and you still put them through.
Over 28s-What a mess-how the hell did Wagner make the last 8.Mary's not a bad oul chanter but the X-factor? Storm Lee is the biggest drama queen on it.
Groups-Cowell obviously wants ones he assembled himself so he can take the credit if they're sucessful.In that case why bother asking established grops to audition.Hustle should have def went through-fit and sounded alrite too.
Katie Waissel-shes not much of a singer-on the rare ocassion she manages to finish a song.Annoying little stage school brat.
Cher's rapping on that Coldplay song was cringe-tastic.Needs to stop that kinda thing.Looks like a little chav to me.

Yeah John, I agree with most of that aprt from the bit about Katie..

I think if she can get it together and show some determination, she'll do well. When she does actually sing, she's got a beautiful tone to her voice. I just think she has something.. There'ssomething about her if you know what I mean?? :)

[Zippy]

Random observations #38

1) why not wait and see how they perform on the show before passing full judgement?

2) its called Xfactor not "Britains best technical singer".

3) speaking of bizarre choices; how did Naimh ever become a moderator?

4) I jest, Niamh. You are the best mod on this thread.

[Jords]

Agree with a lot you said, except I dont think Storm Lee is a drama queen just passionate and I think Katie is very good - just unfair if she has a record contract already!

You got Simon down to a T with the formed group observation though, so true.

[Zippy]

But when pop groups form by themselves there is always gonna be weaker and uglier members in the group because they just bring their mates into it.

So it makes sense for them to be selected individually. Thats how pop groups have been formed for 40 odd years now. Theyre not credible musicians but pop eye candy to be screamed at and lusted over. Nobody really cares how acts are formed at the end of the day.

[johnx]

Dont see any of them having the talent or charisma to sustain a long term career in music.No one's gonna risk backing them with the kinda money you need in todays market.Look at Joe McElderry-they obviously dont know what to do with him and have given him a turkey of a song to release.Like Leon Jackson he will soon sink without a trace.

[Mystic Mock]

Dont see any of them having the talent or charisma to sustain a long term career in music.No one's gonna risk backing them with the kinda money you need in todays market.Look at Joe McElderry-they obviously dont know what to do with him and have given him a turkey of a song to release.Like Leon Jackson he will soon sink without a trace.

poor joe mcceldery his just been compared to leon jackson.

[Zippy]

I love Joe's single and it will be a huge hit for sure. Not released for a few weeks yet even.

So youre way premature with implying he's a flop.

[alc09]

So to get through with Cheryl you've got be ****e, bottle it, look a bit different and be ****e again. That scrawny bint with the tonsilitis needs a bloody good meal.

[Mystic Mock]

what do people think of my new location?

[alc09]

Not funny.

[Niamh.]

Dont see any of them having the talent or charisma to sustain a long term career in music.No one's gonna risk backing them with the kinda money you need in todays market.Look at Joe McElderry-they obviously dont know what to do with him and have given him a turkey of a song to release.Like Leon Jackson he will soon sink without a trace.

I think maybe Matt and Rebecca have, possibly Belle Amie and FYD too

[Marc]

Everybody will have their own opinions about people in this competition. Let the public decide and just sit back and enjoy the rideee