who would you say has the weakest catagory so far?

[Merry Mockmas]

i think simon has because i thought fyd were strangled cats,belle amie wtf happened there? they killed such a brilliant song,diva fever should either **** off or come up with there own gimmick and one direction killed a really good song.

what do you think?

[Lee.]

Yeah, definitely Simon!

[Stephanie]

simon.

[Saph]

simon, the strongest are louis and cheryl.

[Jords]

Simon > Louis > Dannii = Cheryl

[Jordan.]

Simon.

[Tom]

Simon.

Louis' category has more car crash potential and he has Mary. Simon only has One Direction who can go far and they don't have any talent anyway

[Callum]

Simon

[In the Drunk Tank]

I originally thought Louis but now definitely Simon.

It's his own fault if you ask me, for making awful choices. FYD were never that good, and now he's left with a novelty act that will soon get tiresome in Diva Fever, and then two "bands" that are basically just solo rejects.

[Jack_]

Simon...oddly. Though Louis' category has the least chance of going far. At least Simon has One Direction.

[M X]

Cheryl > Louis > Dannii > Simon

[Ninastar]

Cheryl.


LOL JK

Simon

[joeysteele]

Simon, I now can't see him getting an act to the last 3 weeks let alone the finals.
Belle Amie can't last much longer,Diva Fever will be gone also in the next 3 to 4 weeks,One Direction are relying on 2 members of the group and though they have a bit of mileage,they are going to really struggle with the themed weeks, the Groups always do.

[joeysteele]

I also cannot believe Belle Amie are still in it next week, they were diabolical.

[Joelle.]

Simon has the weakest catagory overall. Cheryl has a half catastrophic catagory (Cher and Katie) and a half fantastic catagory (Rebecca and Treyc). Louis has the most entertaining catagory just for Wagner alone. Dannii probably has the most talented catagory overall (3 good ones - Aiden, Matt and Paije - and a bad one - Nicolo).

[Patrick]

Simon...oddly. Though Louis' category has the least chance of going far. At least Simon has One Direction.

Oh the mingebags.

It's like Louis has all the talent,

Big Mary brought the house down :love:

Storm Lee is a legend, reminds me of Jamie Archer :love:

And Wagner is just, words can't describe this man :love:

But it's quite vile Simon will probably win because of girls voting for One Erection when they aren't THAT good.

I think the curly haired dude is better alone, One of them gets on my tits so much like on the live shows he was like looking in the camera and acting so cheesy.

But yeah. :joker:

[HBB1508]

Simon by far - he made some dubious choices on who to put through in my opinion the same a Cheryl.

[ChristmasNeeve]

Simon followed by Louis. Simon has no potential winners imo Louis has one, I think that Cheryl and Dannii both have the equally strong categories

[StGeorge]

IMO Simon and Louis have the weakest cats, but Mary has the potential to do well for Louis. Her only problem is her age and image, as she probably wont appeal to the younger generation. She should go far though.
Storm Lee is limited with the "rockstar" tag and will fall flat in some themes just like Jamie Archer.
And unfortunately John is Mr Invisible. Smilie nice but no substance.
Belle Amie & One Direction should appeal to the youngsters, but their overall ability may not be up to it.
Simon must reap what he has sowed by ditching proper groups in favour of his own madeup groups, which smacks to me of someone with an oversized opinion of his own ego and more to do with trying to prove to Louis that he too can form and make a band successful from scratch.
Diva Fever....there's only so far that a mincing camp act can go.

Danni now has the 3 acts i believed were her strongest, and they should go far if not tinkered with, and are given good choices.

Cheryl is another that has put her reputation on the line with 2 of her choices. I think Rebecca & Treyc will be her strongest acts in the long run if she doesnt bugger them up in preference for the two chavs..

[ChristmasNeeve]

IMO Simon and Louis have the weakest cats, but Mary has the potential to do well for Louis. Her only problem is her age and image, as she probably wont appeal to the younger generation. She should go far though.
Storm Lee is limited with the "rockstar" tag and will fall flat in some themes just like Jamie Archer.
And unfortunately John is Mr Invisible. Smilie nice but no substance.
Belle Amie & One Direction should appeal to the youngsters, but their overall ability may not be up to it.
Simon must reap what he has sowed by ditching proper groups in favour of his own madeup groups, which smacks to me of someone with an oversized opinion of his own ego and more to do with trying to prove to Louis that he too can form and make a band successful from scratch.
Diva Fever....there's only so far that a mincing camp act can go.

Danni now has the 3 acts i believed were her strongest, and they should go far if not tinkered with, and are given good choices.

Cheryl is another that has put her reputation on the line with 2 of her choices. I think Rebecca & Treyc will be her strongest acts in the long run if she doesnt bugger them up in preference for the two chavs..

yep, and I think last week she did that already with Rebecca, the song choice was not good at all imo

[Vicky.]

Simon.

The only group I reckon might make it past the half way point are new direction..

[StGeorge]

I there are two acts going out for the first 4 weeks to compensate for the wildcard selections....then Simons acts might not even last halfway. :elephant:

[ChristmasNeeve]

I there are two acts going out for the first 4 weeks to compensate for the wildcard selections....then Simons acts might not even last halfway. :elephant:

I think they should get rid of two again, there's far too many there at the moment. I hope all the wild cards stay as well!!

[StGeorge]

yep, and I think last week she did that already with Rebecca, the song choice was not good at all imo

It scared the hell out of me when i heard it as it's so not her. She is more of a soulful Bluesey singer like Nora Jones and Corinne Bailey Rae.
Mobility and dance moves should also be avoided. She needs to concentrate on bonding with the audience with her eyes and not looking at the floor wondering where to put her feet.

[StGeorge]

I think they should get rid of two again, there's far too many there at the moment. I hope all the wild cards stay as well!!

I half agree with that as Wagner and Diva Fever make me cringe. Gimicky choices IMO.

[ChristmasNeeve]

I half agree with that as Wagner and Diva Fever make me cringe. Gimicky choices IMO.

yeah, not fans of either but you know they'll have a sort of cult following which will carry them through a few more shows yet

[stewart64]

I would have to go with Louis. I really can't see any winner there. The black guy and the Tesco lady can sing, but I don't think they have the star quality or X factor, they are middling at best.

Simon may have a winner in One Direction but his group look weak.

Aiden, Katie and Cher are getting all the press attention. And so long as they can avoid getting sectioned under the mental health act they look to have most potential.

[Miss Ivy Balls]

Definitely Simon. Belle Anal was shocking. Maybe they'll get better? One Direction was all over the place. Diva Fever, don't even think the other lad even sang, and no star quality. FYD, well they're gone and rightly so.

[Miss Ivy Balls]

Wagna should have gone last week, not Nicolo. Come on. I bet Wagna last a while too, but the reality is that he won't sell albums. Why didn't Louis pick that girl? Anastacia? Not sure of her name. She could have been really good. Wagna is just a joke.

[Stacey.]

Simon.

The groups don't normally do very well.

[red]

Wagna should have gone last week, not Nicolo. Come on. I bet Wagna last a while too, but the reality is that he won't sell albums. Why didn't Louis pick that girl? Anastacia? Not sure of her name. She could have been really good. Wagna is just a joke.

finally someone talking sense! the amount of support this guy is getting on the internet is scary:o