X Factor 16/10 Episode 2 Live Discussion [7:30]

[Zippy]

Dannii slagging Brians choreography!

haha

It is dreadful tbf

[Smithy]

:bored:

He's sh*t get him out

[Vicky.]

She's not anorexic, clearly.

And Cher has lots of support so..

How is it clearly?! She certainly looks it

[Jordan.]

ROFL l

[Smithy]

:laugh2:

[Shaun]

wtf simon?

[Maia]

Wagner amazing as usual.

10/10.

[King Gizzard]

At least hes a nice guy unlike those horrible obnoxius Jedward bastards

[Vicky.]

What's Cher got to do with Wagner? D:

LOL I just find it highly hypocritical how you can slag wagner whilst supporting cher :spin:

[Bazladoo]

mary is such a slag

[Tom]

So Katie and Storm never materialised so the next logical option to throw to the press ... Wagner and Mary pmsl

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Louis shush. You know he's crap. He belongs in a holiday camp.

[Maia]

We must see what he has in store for us next week.

[Zippy]

At least hes a nice guy unlike those horrible obnoxius Jedward bastards

qft

well said

[Vicky.]

At least hes a nice guy unlike those horrible obnoxius Jedward bastards

Oh yeah, I love him as a person :D

Just think its a bit of a joke that he is there...

[MeMyselfAndI]

Cher just has that body type, she has a very athletic body and looks good. so you get jealous and call her anorexic :rolleyes:

[Stacey.]

KATIE! <3 l

[Jamietwo]

oh Katie i really liked her last week

[Shaun]

please no silly fashion gimmicks.

[King Gizzard]

sob sob sob sob story.

[Vicky.]

Cher just has that body type, she has a very athletic body and looks good. so you get jealous and call her anorexic :rolleyes:

Jealous? WTF :laugh:


I wouldnt want to look like a cheese string thanks

[Tom]

Cher just has that body type, she has a very athletic body and looks good. so you get jealous and call her anorexic :rolleyes:

She really doesn't just have that body type, you can tell by her face

[King Gizzard]

Wait...they didn't mention Lola Fontaine!?

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Cher just has that body type, she has a very athletic body and looks good. so you get jealous and call her anorexic :rolleyes:
Oh comeon!! I strongly disagree. :shocked:

[GypsyGoth]

Katie :lovedup:

[Tom]

Strip back the gimmicks and shes actually half decent :eek:

[Zippy]

I like her voice actually.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Alright this is sounding good. I'm glad someone has learned a lesson and taken advice!

[GiRTh]

What was that s**t she was spouting in her vt

[King Gizzard]

Shes just so bland even if she can sing..only thing keeping her is the ''I cant keep my eyes off her'' thing..because she is a damn beautiful :\

[MeMyselfAndI]

i hate katie lol

will never forgive her

[Smithy]

She sounds good :shocked:

[Vicky.]

Shes actually quite good this week :)

[Shaun]

love this song.

[Stephanie]

this is sorta boring.

[Stacey.]

She's great.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Oh my god, katie, i'm loving it tonight!:shocked:

[Jordan.]

Shes amazing this week.

[Zippy]

With the right song she is a wow

[Stephanie]

she was doing ok till the end bit, then ruined it.

[Shaun]

Etta James :love:

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Claps

[Stephanie]

6/10

[King Gizzard]

Mehhhh 5/10

[Jamietwo]

That was ok , but i'm still missing gamu

[MeMyselfAndI]

her voice and song choices bores me

[Jordan.]

Best of the night for me she was great.

[GiRTh]

Average

[Smithy]

That was ok , but i'm still missing gamu

rofl

[King Gizzard]

Did he just judge on her VT and not the song? Er

[setanta]

I'm still unsure about her. Don't think her voice is anything great, but she does have a presence on stage.

[Stacey.]

Simon's right on with his judging tonight.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

shut up cheryl.

[Jords]

Wow, Katie was really, really good. :D

[Zippy]

Did he just judge on her VT and not the song? Er

no at the end he said it was brilliant..

[Shaun]

I don't get why Katie is getting all the Gamu fans on her back? Cher is miles worse.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

I'm still unsure about her. Don't think her voice is anything great, but she does have a presence on stage.

She reminds me of Berlin.

[Zippy]

She reminds me of Berlin.

wut?

[red]

bellamie & mary are next so matt has the pimp spot!!!:D

[setanta]

She reminds me of Berlin.

That's the thing. I don't thing her voice is good enough to make her stand out on her own.... she'd be great in a band though.

[Stacey.]

Last three acts are boring...

[King Gizzard]

I liked Belle Amie at Judges houses, when they done a peaceful quieter peformance, Airplanes would of probably worked if it was in the same style, but they don't live up to it when they have to do a big performances on stage

[MeMyselfAndI]

Gamu > Katie

[Jords]

Last three acts are boring...

I love all 3 LOL.

[GypsyGoth]

Gamu > Katie

Gam-who?

[MeMyselfAndI]

Belle Amie :love:
not that great last week lol

[Smithy]

I hope they do well this week, otherwise they're out :/

[GypsyGoth]

I'm really glad these weren't first act off the show.

[Bazladoo]

bel ami suck ass

[Stacey.]

Hope they fail then they'll be out.

[Jordan.]

Gam-who?

:joker:

[Zippy]

they dont even look happy together! LOL

[Stacey.]

Rebecca's the only good one out of them.

[Shaun]

oh please leave the kinks alone.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Bye girls.:xyxwave:

[Shaun]

and AGAIN with the over-crowded backing vocals.

[Stephanie]

this sounds horrible.

[Zippy]

awful song choice...

their fanbase is young girls...they won't even know the song!

[Smithy]

They're a lot better than last week

[Vicky.]

I dont like this much...better than last week though :/

[setanta]

Simon cheating with a backing track again and loadsa sound effects. Oh, and it was still rubbish.

[Jordan.]

Storm - 4/10
Treyc - 8/10
Paije - 5/10
One Direction - 7/10
Cher - 7/10
John - 7/10
Diva Fever - 3/10
Rebecca - 8/10
Aiden - 6/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie - 8/10
Belle Amie - 6/10 - Better than last week.

[Stephanie]

john - 8/10
diva fever - 0/10
aiden - 5/10
wagner - 0/10
katie - 6/10
belle ami - 2/10

[MeMyselfAndI]

slightly better than last week

[Stacey.]

Better than last week by like loads.

But just no to them.

[King Gizzard]

Who's the tall one in pink? http://www.clubcommodore.com/forums/images/smilies/drool1.gif

[Tom]

christine bleakley on the end

[Jordan.]

Cheryl praises a girl group for once. :p

[Shaun]

have to agree, they look like they've raided the oxfam donation bins.

[Smithy]

john - 8/10
diva fever - 0/10
aiden - 5/10
wagner - 0/10
katie - 6/10
belle ami - 2/10

rofl!

but you missed out rebecca. ho.

[Conzors]

They were good. x

[Braden]

I absolutley love them!!!! <3

[setanta]

God Simon talks a loada crap.

[King Gizzard]

Shouting Mary up next?

[MeMyselfAndI]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Storm - 4/10
Treyc - 9/10
Paije - 6/10
One Direction - 8.5/10
Cher - 8/10
John - 6/10
Diva Fever - 3/10
Rebecca - 6.5/10
Aiden - 6.5/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie - 4/10
Belle Amie - 6.5/10

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Oh my god you've never lied so much!:shocked:

[Stephanie]

rofl!

but you missed out rebecca. ho.
woops LOL. 5/10

[Zippy]

The short hairede one is dressed hideously.

[Tom]

one had camel toe

[King Gizzard]

Whoever said week 2's are always crap was right

[Bazladoo]

mary do you spit or swalllow when wagner puts it in your mouth???

[Smithy]

woops LOL. 5/10

-.-

[Tom]

Whoever said week 2's are always crap was right

that would be me. and i was right :cool:

I think Mary will be good though but one performance out of 14 is terrible

[Jamietwo]

mary do you spit or swalllow when wagner puts it in your mouth???

errrrrrrrrrrrr feta

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

mary do you spit or swalllow when wagner puts it in your mouth???
It's so small she doesn't notice when it's in. :)

[GypsyGoth]

Mary needs to get back to Tescos there is a big queue at Till number 40.

[Stacey.]

Scared.

[Zippy]

We already have a Jane MacDonald thanx

[Stacey.]

Mary needs to get back to Tescos there is a big queue at Till number 40.

:laugh:

[red]

Whoever said week 2's are always crap was right

matt will save the night

[MeMyselfAndI]

she has a good voice tbh

[Shaun]

You Don't Have To Say You Love Me :love:

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Didn't she sing this last week?

comeon mary spice it up babe

[King Gizzard]

Mary needs to get back to Tescos there is a big queue at Till number 40.

Clean up on aisle 4!

[King Gizzard]

She's not as shouty tonight, much better

[MeMyselfAndI]

god she is boring though lol

[Bazladoo]

has mary been smoking a splif why her eyes so bloodshot??

[Tom]

We already have a Jane MacDonald thanx

Jane McDonald is rubbish, shes amazing on Loose Women though, she needs to hurry up and return :bawling:

ahem, beer and sport etc ...

[Smithy]

aww Tesco Mary :love:

[Stacey.]

Is it just me, or has she gone up about 4 dress sizes since last week?

[Shaun]

Didn't she sing this last week?

comeon mary spice it up babe

She sang It's a Man's, Man's, Man's World last week :p

[Stephanie]

mary sounds the same every week. it's getting boring.

[Smithy]

Jane McDonald is rubbish, shes amazing on Loose Women though, she needs to hurry up and return :bawling:

ahem, beer and sport etc ...

She's gone for the year :sad:

[Jordan.]

Is it just me, or has she gone up about 4 dress sizes since last week?

:laugh:

[Smithy]

mary sounds the same every week. it's getting boring.

Theres only been 2 weeks :L

[Jordan.]

Ugh not all this cheering again.

[setanta]

Well done lady. Great stuff.

[King Gizzard]

That was a Wagner type reaction from the crowd

[Stephanie]

Theres only been 2 weeks :L
audition, boot camp and jh included.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

You're not going to cry every week are you? That alone will get you voted off.

[Tom]

She was brilliant but it would be the death of this show if she won. They can't have 2 flop winners back to back

[Braden]

Was that some sort of supermarket gag, Dannii?

[King Gizzard]

Maybe its just the Malaria creeping back, Cheryl.

[Zippy]

This crowd overcheering Mary is gonna be a running thing now....Zzzzz

[Jordan.]

Storm - 4/10
Treyc - 8/10
Paije - 5/10
One Direction - 7/10
Cher - 7/10
John - 7/10
Diva Fever - 3/10
Rebecca - 8/10
Aiden - 6/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie - 8/10
Belle Amie - 6/10
Mary - 8/10

[Stephanie]

6/10.

[setanta]

You're not going to cry every week are you? That alone will get you voted off.

It's because she's a humble girl who's genuinely shocked at the response she's getting. I think it's lovely.

[Jamietwo]

wow she was great ! go mary

[GypsyGoth]

Was that some sort of supermarket gag, Dannii?

:laugh:

[Stephanie]

i wish the audience would shut the **** up.

[Stephanie]

nice wedding ring mary.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

It's because she's a humble girl who's genuinely shocked at the response she's getting. I think it's lovely.

It is but not every week.:bawling: I cry and scream too I don't get standing ovation. :bawling:

[Jordan.]

i wish the audience would shut the **** up.

:worship:

[MeMyselfAndI]

Storm - 4/10
Treyc - 9/10
Paije - 6/10
One Direction - 8.5/10
Cher - 8/10
John - 6/10
Diva Fever - 3/10
Rebecca - 6.5/10
Aiden - 6.5/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie - 4/10
Belle Amie - 6.5/10
Mary - 7/10

[Braden]

The groups are amazing this year, may I add :)

[MeMyselfAndI]

i hope treyc is not in the bottom 3 as she went 2nd

[Tom]

The groups are amazing this year, may I add :)

are you being serious? its the weakest groups category they've ever had

[King Gizzard]

ub40 :love:

[Jords]

Loved Belle Amie, but dont like that hard faced blonde cow >_> Kick her out! Rofl.

Ah Mary getting loads of cheers again, cracking voice.

[Bazladoo]

Your actually a disgustingly shallow, materialistic, vulgar bitch

lol make love not war

[setanta]

It is but not every week.:bawling: I cry and scream too I don't get standing ovation. :bawling:

You've never been singing in front of millions on a show like the X Factor though.

[Tom]

Daybreak is ****, stop plugging it. If it was any good you wouldn't need to, especially by using X Factor to plug a NEWS programme

[setanta]

The groups are amazing this year, may I add :)

Nah, the pre-recorded vocals and soundtrack are.

[Stacey.]

Ugh boringness..

[Stephanie]

more high notes, greaaat.

[Shaun]

who the hell is this vocal coach with the silly wig?

[Jordan.]

Tonight show has been boring.

[Zippy]

Loved Belle Amie, but dont like that hard faced blonde cow >_> Kick her out! Rofl.

Ah Mary getting loads of cheers again, cracking voice.

LOL Jords.

and Mary gets extra cheers coz she's seen as a big underdog and unlikely winner material.

[Smithy]

sounds like a whale :conf2:

[Stephanie]

shoot me. that first bit sounded like a whale song.

[Tom]

Matt is another one with no personality and hes had loads of airtime!!

He also can't sing that well, I don't get why he's one of the favourites

[King Gizzard]

Bruno Mars...musical hero?

[GypsyGoth]

who the hell is this vocal coach with the silly wig?

Savan Kotecha.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Clever song choice as it's popular.

[Jordan.]

shoot me. that first bit sounded like a whale song.

lmfao.

[Shaun]

Bruno Mars? Musical hero? Gaaaaaah **** off.

[Stacey.]

I really like it D:

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

You've never been singing in front of millions on a show like the X Factor though.
I walked right into that one didn't I! :D

[setanta]

Nah, not digging this at all.

[Zippy]

Oh Matt good song choice

keep it simple though....

[GypsyGoth]

Where the **** is his hat??

[Stephanie]

the high notes sound horrible.

[Tom]

Are we supposed to forget about the theme or are we to imagine he's got the Bruno Mars greatest hits album? Oh wait, there isn't one ..

[Shaun]

oh. well that was quite lovely.

[Stephanie]

5/10

[King Gizzard]

I loved it, but **** off calling new artists musical heroes

I hope someone calls in xtra factor tonight

[Stacey.]

He was quite on it tonight.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Louis would you stop insulting established artists!

[Smithy]

Are we supposed to forget about the theme or are we to imagine he's got the Bruno Mars greatest hits album? Oh wait, there isn't one ..

They're gonna make all the themes stupidly broad so that every week they can sing whatever they want :bored:

[Tom]

I loved it, but **** off calling new artists musical heroes

I hope someone calls in xtra factor tonight

Jenny will have something to say

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

I loved it, but **** off calling new artists musical heroes

I hope someone calls in xtra factor tonight
where Jenny?

[King Gizzard]

Whats it going to be next week? Motown? Then Mary will go and do a Slipknot song

[Vicky.]

Storm 3/10
TreyC 9/10
Paije 4/10
One direction 8/10
Cher 2/10
John 5/10
Diva fever 5/10
Rebecca 6/10
Aiden 7/10
Wagner 2/10
Katie 6/10...I thought she was good this week, strangely
Belle Amie 4/10...improvement on last weel...but still quite bad
Mary 7/10 Great vocals...but thats it :S But she is so likeble as a person...
Matt 8/10. Didnt like the song much, but he was fantastic

[Jordan.]

Storm - 4/10
Treyc - 8/10
Paije - 5/10
One Direction - 7/10
Cher - 7/10
John - 7/10
Diva Fever - 3/10
Rebecca - 8/10
Aiden - 6/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie - 8/10
Belle Amie - 6/10
Mary - 8/10
Matt - 8/10

[Zippy]

TreyC, Katie, Matt & Mary were best tonight.

[Shaun]

Prediction:
Bottom votes + automatic elimination: Storm
Bottom two: Paije and Belle Amie

[King Gizzard]

Wagner, Aiden, Rebecca were my favourites tonight

[Stephanie]

ones i watched..
-----------------
john - 8/10
diva fever - 0/10
aiden - 5/10
rebecca - 5/10
wagner - 0/10
katie - 6/10
belle ami - 2/10
mary - 6/10
matt - 5/10

[Vicky.]

Prediction:
Bottom votes + automatic elimination: Storm
Bottom two: Paije and Belle Amie

yeah same...


Maybe swap paije with storm for the auto elimination

[Shaun]

yeah I think there could be a shock with the auto-elimination. Maybe Rebecca.

I wouldn't rule Diva Fever safe either.

[King Gizzard]

Konnies dress D:

My eyes be a burning.

[Smithy]

yeah I think there could be a shock with the auto-elimination. Maybe Rebecca.

I wouldn't rule Diva Fever safe either.

:o

[Vicky.]

yeah I think there could be a shock with the auto-elimination. Maybe Rebecca.



-Watches smithy slit his wrists-

[King Gizzard]

I wouldnt rule out, as much as I love him, Wagner going this week

Unlike Jedward, he doesnt have all the little girls running around after him

Or does he?

No, no he doesnt..

[Tom]

Konnie on X Factor to Cher "you took a risk" .. err no

Cher looks like shes going to punch someone when she talks

[Smithy]

-Watches smithy slit his wrists-

keep up love

[Tom]

Konnies dress D:

My eyes be a burning.

She doesn't fill it very well either, bring back Willabooby

I wouldnt rule out, as much as I love him, Wagner going this week

Unlike Jedward, he doesnt have all the little girls running around after him

Or does he?

No, no he doesnt..

Well he got his chest out ...

[Stacey.]

Konnie > Holly.

[King Gizzard]

Wagner wants Mary for her clubcard.

[Tom]

Konnie > Holly.

are you actually for real?

[setanta]

I don't believe anything that comes out of Katie's mouth.

[Vicky.]

Konnie > Holly.

OMG :laugh2:

[King Gizzard]

Lol Wagners not even in the Xfactor house

[Braden]

PMSL at what Wagner said about John...Maybe it relates back to this?

http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/tv/s103/the-x-factor/news/a282021/x-factor-john-wagner-in-heated-row.html

[Braden]

+...Konnie is an amazing host! <3

[Stacey.]

OMG :laugh2:

What?! D:

[Tom]

Excuse me, where is Jenny?

[King Gizzard]

Attempted to damage his vocal chords, yeah right!

[King Gizzard]

Excuse me, where is Jenny?

She might be there you never know :crazy:

[Tom]

She might be there you never know :crazy:

Shes not on the list :(