The praise for One Direction

[Callum]

Anyone else getting fed up of it? They aren't even very good (in my opinion), yet their praised as if they're the next Take That or 'Nsync. I doubt Simon would praise them half as much as he does if they weren't his act.

[Vicky.]

Anyone else getting fed up of it? They aren't even very good (in my opinion), yet their praised as if they're the next Take That or 'Nsync. I doubt Simon would praise them half as much as he does if they weren't his act.

ROFL. Sorry :laugh2:

[King Gizzard]

Just 5 pretty boys. If we were going on actual talent then even FYD would be above them

[setanta]

Oh, they're talking total crap about them. Sure they weren't singing half of the time.

[Jamietwo]

Just 5 pretty boys. If we were going on actual talent then even FYD would be above them

only zain and the main singer are pretty, the other 3 are disgusting

[Vicky.]

only zain and the main singer are pretty, the other 3 are disgusting

Haha I agree with that. Though the curly haired one is a bit cute :laugh:

[Stephanie]

zain is hot. liam is alright and harry is so cute. the other two are meh.

[MTVN]

Nah I don't like the, they're essentially just 5 pretty boys who couldnt make it as solo artists strung together into an average group. They dont deserve the praise they get, although a lot of acts dont tbf, the judges seem very reluctant to criticise the contestants this year.

[Callum]

ROFL. Sorry :laugh2:

I was trying to think of another well known boyband who were fairly good. :laugh: They had a few hits though!

[Christina]

I actually think they're really good (not saying this cos of their looks). Sure, they're deffo not the best singers but they're modern imo.

[Stacey.]

I like them! Not the best singers but they go well together and they;re cute guys.

Zain is the hottest. Liam is hot too though.

[Legend killer]

It's ridiculous , how many times do u think they sucked of Simon to get them

[Patrick]

It's just because some girls would quite happily let them eat them out even though they are 11.

It's a disgrace.

Liam and Matt, fair enough they can sing.
They'd be a good group together.

The others? G.T.F.O my screen now you wankers.

That blonde kid that stands there and smiles and acts so cheesy all the time gets on my tits.

The fact you can just hear little girls screaming their nipples off after they stop singing makes me vomit.

Simon 'You'll be the next big boy band'.

Sorry, but there is no ******ing way these little wanna-bes will EVER take over JLS [Who I'm not a big fan of] and become Britain's biggest boyband.

Dream on.
They'll be forgotten about about 2 weeks after they leave.

[Jack_]

They are actually really good...has everyone forgotten their Judge's Houses performance?

V5UQD61Tg3E

I admit they've not been great in the Live Shows But to be honest I'd put that down to the extremely loud backing track...completely drowning out their singing. No idea why it's so loud. Infact it's like that for a couple of the acts. They have talent...they're just not being allowed to show it. I hate how they're being criticised because they are attractive young guys that will pick up the young girl vote as well...that's not their problem. And if they have the talent to back it up [which they do, see Judge's Houses] then what's the problem?

[Kerry]

They're not my cup of tea but I guess I can see the schoolgirl appeal

[Z]

I liked the Kelly Clarkson performance but don't understand how she is a musical hero in any way. Both of the backing tracks they've had for the live shows so far have screamed wedding disco number to me...

[Mystic Mock]

dont get me started on there christmas carol version of viva la vida in week 1 and there stupid week 2 performance.

[Patrick]

They're not my cup of tea but I guess I can see the schoolgirl appeal

Really?
I'm not gay but I think I'm capable of understanding why a girl finds some blokes attractive.

And I have to say people like Justin Bieber are not attractive.
People like Aston from 2 years ago aren't he looks like a monkey.
Lloyd from last year most certainly wasn't either.
Eoghan who I loved 2 years back, looked like a bean.

And these douche bags are ******ing messes aswell, the only one I can actually maybe understand a girl finding attractive is Liam tbh.

Matt, The other guy and that annoying blonde bastard that needs to be shot aren't.




They are actually really good...has everyone forgotten their Judge's Houses performance?

V5UQD61Tg3E

I admit they've not been great in the Live Shows But to be honest I'd put that down to the extremely loud backing track...completely drowning out their singing. No idea why it's so loud. Infact it's like that for a couple of the acts. They have talent...they're just not being allowed to show it. I hate how they're being criticised because they are attractive young guys that will pick up the young girl vote as well...that's not their problem. And if they have the talent to back it up [which they do, see Judge's Houses] then what's the problem?

They are good actually,
But like people like Justin Bieber, I just want them out because I'm fed up with the girls acting like they should win based on looks.

Take me and Coco for example last year,
I loved her and wanted to ****** her from Kandy Rain so badly, but did I want her to win? No.
Because Kandy Rain were sh*t and up their own arses, girls just need to know when to draw the line.

[Twilight]

It's just because some girls would quite happily let them eat them out even though they are 11.


No, just no.

Anyway they aren't best singers in the world, but they aren't bad, i like them, and no not because their "hot"

[Mystic Mock]

its funny that the only people that like the 5 biebers are teenage girls or gay men.

[BGT-FAN!]

Anyone else getting fed up of it? They aren't even very good (in my opinion), yet their praised as if they're the next Take That or 'Nsync. I doubt Simon would praise them half as much as he does if they weren't his act.

You know what I dont even think Simon gives two sh*ts whether they are his acts or not. All the other judges care about is whether the acts they mentor win or not. Its Simons show so he wants a good act to win whether they are in his category or not. Thats why he was so happy Matt got through tonight and in the final of alexandras year, he wanted her to win and not his own act Eoghan.

[Pato]

By far the most over-rated act only 2 can sortta sing the other 3 WTF are they doing especally that Zane guy how did he even get to bootcamp he was so out of tune first 2 weeks unbelievable :@

[Twilight]

its funny that the only people that like the 5 biebers are teenage girls or gay men.

For gods sake, not everyone is the same, you're just being stereotypical.

[Mystic Mock]

For gods sake, not everyone is the same, you're just being stereotypical.

well the only people defending them are the stereotypes.

[Twilight]

well the only people defending them are the stereotypes.

Well its funny, i'm a teenage girl, and i don't just like them for their looks.

[Mystic Mock]

Well its funny, i'm a teenage girl, and i don't just like them for their looks.

well your favourite is one direction and your a teenage girl which=you fancy them.

[BB_Eye]

It's just because some girls would quite happily let them eat them out even though they are 11.

Lmao

[Twilight]

well your favourite is one direction and your a teenage girl which=you fancy them.

Haha no, i wouldn't vote to keep someone in a tv show, just because their hot.

[Jack_]

its funny that the only people that like the 5 biebers are teenage girls or gay men.

I think it's funny that quite a lot of people [straight, jealous teenage guys - if we're being stereotypical like you were] are not judging their talent and dismissing them because they're attractive young lads that some people are attracted to. As if they can help that, it's not their problem, is it?

[chiptek]

they are the bieberettes. it doesnt matter if they can sing, they are the preteen/teen market, all they need is the whispy hair

[Mystic Mock]

I think it's funny that quite a lot of people [straight, jealous teenage guys - if we're being stereotypical like you were] are not judging their talent and dismissing them because they're attractive young lads that some people are attracted to. As if they can help that, it's not their problem, is it?

because they are talentless,and women fancy matt yet i think his talented.:p

[cub]

its funny that the only people that like the 5 biebers are teenage girls or gay men.

You're wrong and that comment's a bit offensive.

[Mystic Mock]

You're wrong and that comment's a bit offensive.

does the truth hurt?

[Vicky.]

does the truth hurt?

Its not the truth though. Its a stupid, ignorant, stereotypical view that is lumping every viewer into the same category just because YOU personally do not think one direction are up to much.

And to blow your theory out of the water, I quite like them, I am no way a teenager. You may throw at me that I only like them for their looks...which couldnt be further from the truth as I think most of them are quite vile actually...but in that case, my partner likes them too. Oh dear, you were wrong D:

[Harry!]

Till one of them does something controversial I wont like them, same for most of the XF contestants. Bland and dull.

[Mystic Mock]

Its not the truth though. Its a stupid, ignorant, stereotypical view that is lumping every viewer into the same category just because YOU personally do not think one direction are up to much.

And to blow your theory out of the water, I quite like them, I am no way a teenager. You may throw at me that I only like them for their looks...which couldnt be further from the truth as I think most of them are quite vile actually...but in that case, my partner likes them too. Oh dear, you were wrong D:

1 straight guy likes them:joker: wow im well off.

[chiptek]

i actually dont think theyre bad, i think the whole thing works, but its more of a marketing thing than a group really, i mean simon put them together, he knew what he was doing.

[Vicky.]

1 straight guy likes them:joker: wow im well off.

I am pretty sure there is not only one straight guy in the whole of txf audience that likes them. If you cant see that then I think you need to give your head a wobble.

[Mystic Mock]

I am pretty sure there is not only one straight guy in the whole of txf audience that likes them. If you cant see that then I think you need to give your head a wobble.

what 15,000 straight guys like one direction? considering the x factor get about 13 million viewers i dont think 15,000 is that many.

[Jack_]

because they are talentless,and women fancy matt yet i think his talented.:p

Yeah, course they're talentless...I refer you to the video I posted and their individual Auditions [well, Harry and Liam's especially] :sleep:

[Mystic Mock]

Yeah, course they're talentless...I refer you to the video I posted and their individual Auditions [well, Harry and Liam's especially] :sleep:

the only one that did good at the judges houses was harry imo.

[Vicky.]

what 15,000 straight guys like one direction? considering the x factor get about 13 million viewers i dont think 15,000 is that many.

I dont know how many straight guys like therm, and neither do you. So stop pulling figures out of your ass to try and make a point.

[Mystic Mock]

I dont know how many straight guys like therm, and neither do you. So stop pulling figures out of your ass to try and make a point.

well i dont think many straight guys will like one direction because there talentless.

[Zippy]

Simon says there is a slot for them in the music scene?

Sorry Si, but I think The wanted have just taken that slot. And they do it so so much better tbh. Plus they have a strong singer upfront...which OD just don't, sadly.

I like them and want them to do well but really they are just not slick enough to cut it in the real world. Thrown together and it shows.

[Vicky.]

well i dont think many straight guys will like one direction because there talentless.

In your opinion they are talentless.

This does not mean they are ;)

[Mystic Mock]

In your opinion they are talentless.

This does not mean they are ;)

well it proves there talentless when they mimed most of there performance this week.

[Zippy]

well it proves there talentless when they mimed most of there performance this week.

They didnt mime. They sang the verses themselves then sang along with the backing track during the chorus. Not miming just added oomph to beef up the chorus.

[Mystic Mock]

They didnt mime. They sang the verses themselves then sang along with the backing track during the chorus. Not miming just added oomph to beef up the chorus.

they did mime because the asian guy was moving his lips out of sync when he was apprently meant to be singing.

[Vicky.]

well it proves there talentless when they mimed most of there performance this week.

LOL. They didnt mime. The backing track was just too loud in the chorus.

[Vicky.]

they did mime because the asian guy was moving his lips out of sync when he was apprently meant to be singing.

Why on earth would the producers allow ONE act to mime and make the rest of them sing live?

-Goes to rewatch this weeks performance to see if I can see this 'mistake', whilst doubting it-

[Zippy]

they did mime because the asian guy was moving his lips out of sync when he was apprently meant to be singing.

Well that may just be him lapsing or whatever. Doesn't mean they are all miming. Singing along is not miming technically.

[Vicky.]

rcrqezVGTug

Sorry, I watched it again twice, and didnt see what you reckon you saw JF. Please point out where 'the asian guy' goes wrong with his 'miming'?


And on another note, they sounded so much better on my tv than they do on there :laugh:

[Zippy]

A couple of the vocals were weak in the performance so that proves they sang live. Why would you pre-record a bad vocal?

Plus the other judges would be all over it.

[Legend killer]

The blonde irish one is the biggest twat i have ever seen with his cringey dance moves

[Mystic Mock]

Why on earth would the producers allow ONE act to mime and make the rest of them sing live?

-Goes to rewatch this weeks performance to see if I can see this 'mistake', whilst doubting it-

diva fever also mimed in week 1 aswell.

and yet simon pulled jedward up on everything last year yet his allowing his acts to mime.:mad:

[Vicky.]

diva fever also mimed in week 1 aswell.

and yet simon pulled jedward up on everything last year yet his allowing his acts to mime.:mad:

They didnt mime at all. Just because you dont like someone doesnt mean you have to make things up.

Still waiting for a time slot on the performance that proves where 'the asian guy' messed up...

[Jack_]

the only one that did good at the judges houses was harry imo.

...and Liam. The others might not be fantastic singers but their harmonies are good.

[Mystic Mock]

They didnt mime at all. Just because you dont like someone doesnt mean you have to make things up.

Still waiting for a time slot on the performance that proves where 'the asian guy' messed up...

not just the asian guy the rest looked like they werent singing.

and diva fever did mime the week 1 performance at least at points.

[Crimson Dynamo]

I saw a pic today of the tall one wearing a John James hat and these terrible grey lace up distressed boots that Brian Freidman would wear

he looked like he had been dressed by Simon from Inbetweeners new bird

what a plonker

[Vicky.]

not just the asian guy the rest looked like they werent singing.


Disregarding the random shot at diva fever...can you PLEASE just point out some points where it was so obvious that they were miming. Because as I said, I didnt notice it first time, and I just watched it twice again and still cant see it.

And if its as obvious and as often as you are making out, it shouldnt be too hard to point out a few examples :)

[Zippy]

I saw a pic today of the tall one wearing a John James hat and these terrible grey lace up distressed boots that Brian Freidman would wear


Oh dear

Most shocking; when stylists attack!

[Vicky.]

Also, the rest may not have been singing at times :S

Doesnt mean the performance was mimed. The backing track was just up WAY too high

[Mystic Mock]

Disregarding the random shot at diva fever...can you PLEASE just point out some points where it was so obvious that they were miming. Because as I said, I didnt notice it first time, and I just watched it twice again and still cant see it.

And if its as obvious and as often as you are making out, it shouldnt be too hard to point out a few examples :)

all of it.

[Vicky.]

As I thought, you cant. Case closed :)

[Jack_]

all of it.

LOL, have to admit, that was cleverly answered. But you aren't fooling anybody... :joker:

[Mystic Mock]

LOL, have to admit, that was cleverly answered. But you aren't fooling anybody... :joker:

im not pretending simon is allowing his ****ter acts in his catagory to mime.

[Zippy]

im not pretending simon is allowing his ****ter acts in his catagory to mime.

LOL. The irony of a Jedward fan.....

:P

[Mystic Mock]

LOL. The irony of a Jedward fan.....

:P

when did louis let jedward mime?

[joeysteele]

when did louis let jedward mime?

He didn't and they would not have got away with it either.

[Zippy]

when did louis let jedward mime?

LOLzzz. Im not even gonna go there with all the help they had to hide their vocal skills...or lack of. :joker:

[Chels]

Jedward fever, you're fighting a losing battle. Give up :L

[Mystic Mock]

LOLzzz. Im not even gonna go there with all the help they had to hide their vocal skills...or lack of. :joker:

jedward still didnt mime though so your argument has gone out the window.

[Zippy]

jedward still didnt mime though so your argument has gone out the window.

Funnily enough I dont even feel the need to argue this one. :whistle:

[Mystic Mock]

Funnily enough I dont even feel the need to argue this one. :whistle:

because you know bringing jedward into it made you look silly,and i very rarely say that about you zippy.

[Vicky.]

because you know bringing jedward into it made you look silly,and i very rarely say that about you zippy.

There is only one person looking silly here, and it certainly is not zippy.

You have had a lot of chances to PROVE what you are saying, yet you keep just dismissing the questions, which proves that you cant actually see any point which looks like they are miming, which in turn proves that you are making stuff up just because you personally do not like them.

[Mystic Mock]

There is only one person looking silly here, and it certainly is not zippy.

You have had a lot of chances to PROVE what you are saying, yet you keep just dismissing the questions, which proves that you cant actually see any point which looks like they are miming, which in turn proves that you are making stuff up just because you personally do not like them.

you must have missed the post where i said all of it.

[Vicky.]

you must have missed the post where i said all of it.

I didnt actually.

And if that is your only answer, then you were just spouting BS the whole time. Which most of us knew anyways :D

[Mystic Mock]

and zippy was being silly bringing jedward up on this disscussion when they never mimed.

[Vicky.]

and zippy was being silly bringing jedward up on this disscussion when they never mimed.

Neither has anyone this year.


Well...with the exception of the group performance, which is pre recorded I believe.

[Mystic Mock]

Neither has anyone this year.


Well...with the exception of the group performance, which is pre recorded I believe.

apart from simons acts.

[MeMyselfAndI]

i dont get their hate tbh i really like harry and liams voice. Plus there voices have mixed well together unlike Belle Amie lol

[Mr XcX]

Hate them want them out!!!

[Vicky.]

apart from simons acts.

Yeah right, you keep telling yourself that.

Everyone else, meanwhile, will see things the way they are instead of being blinded by hate ;)