Best Performance???

[SacredDiablo]

the only performance i wanted to watch it over and over again was Treyc Cohen - Whole Lotta Love

[fruit_cake]

Matt

[Merry Mockmas]

mine was aidens but the only problem i had with it was that i hate the song.

[Jamietwo]

the only performance i wanted to watch it over and over again was Treyc Cohen - Whole Lotta Love

I do like treyc but I didn't think she was right for that song. they were all really good tonight except wagner and belle amie , i thought katie performed very well

[fruit_cake]

cher was good

[Maia]

TreyC/Wagner/Belle Amie

[joeysteele]

I put Aidens as the best, there were some good performances tonight though, loved Matts too,
Aiden has amazing talent and although I thought it a strange song for him, he gave it all he had and the result was amazing.

[Jordan.]

Cher

[Stacey.]

Cher.

[Joe.]

Treyc and Katie tonight, 'nuff said.

[GypsyGoth]

Katie :lovedup:

[Vicky.]

Matt and Aiden. Quite liked Rebecca this week too

[Kazanne]

Matt

[red]

Matt by a clear mile

[Locke.]

Matt was the best, Cher was good, Wagner was hilarious once again.

[Callum]

Aiden, Cher and Katie

[GiRTh]

Some good performance tonight. I didn't get the praise for Katie she sang a song with a range of about 6 notes. It was the kind of song you sing in your 2nd singing lesson.

Cher was sh*e. Biting rhymes from Queen Pen this week. Who will it be next week?

Matt was good, TreyC too but I think that song was al wrong for TreyC. I think my fave might be in trouble.

Bellamy were awful.

Wagner was legendary. He's going nowhere. Cant wait to see what he's gonna do next week

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

the only performance i wanted to watch it over and over again was Treyc Cohen - Whole Lotta Love

preach!

i :love: treyc i think she is my fave xf contestant ever! after alexandra ofc

i actually did watch it like 4 times :amazed:

[SacredDiablo]

preach!

i :love: treyc i think she is my fave xf contestant ever! after alexandra ofc

i actually did watch it like 4 times :amazed:

im watching it for the 40th time already:dance:

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

im watching it for the 40th time already:dance:

:love:

imma watch on youtube now

[setanta]

Wagner. What a legend. There wasn't an outstanding performance this week.

[Jords]

Katie then Matt then Treyc.

[Tom]

Mary, Treyc, Matt, Katie, Rebecca and Aiden were the best ones, genuinely can't pick one

[Iceman]

As much as it pains me I have to say Cher, she put on the shw without her tonight it may aswell have been Xfactor series 1...... Mary did great too though

[Kerry]

Matt Matt Matt Matt Matt

[BB_Eye]

Aiden (first time I really liked his performance), Paije, Katie.

After them, Wagner.

Matt was good, but hated hated hated the song.

[M X]

Katie/Matt/Rebecca

[yellowzebra8]

It pains me to say it but I loved Cher tonight, Paige also stood out for me :)

[Thotmas]

rewatched it this morning.

Loved Rebecca.
Aiden

Thank you Treyc for smashing stereotypes a bit, love you for that. :lovedup:

Who else.....Oh that Katie is really beginning to do some thangs! LOL. If you're good i'm not going to hate but if you're **** and people pretend we're supposed to believe you're the best thing since sliced bread *coughs cher* than i'll hate. Goood girl katie. :)

[Lee.]

Matt or Katie for me

[Jevans]

John, Wagner, Mary and Treyc was amazing! Oh and Aiden!

[mizzy25]

matt

[ElProximo]

the only performance i wanted to watch it over and over again was Treyc Cohen - Whole Lotta Love

*Matt is so excellent every single time I feel like it goes without saying he was pretty much the standard of excellence again.*

Rebecca came out even better than ever and really really impressed me!

Paige really proved he is the dark horse - really impressed me! Contender!
------------------------------------------
Not best but not bad:

Tra Cohen:
Actually liked the idea and the voice power demonstration but not a lot else happened there.

Mary:
Calling it a 'neutral' because it was a 'repeat' - an amazing repeat and her voice is just amazing. But nothing 'new' this time out so can't say much.
--------------------------------
Least best?

*The boy band i just don't care about and i suppose they are good by boy band standards I guess. whatever.

*don't care about girl band. whatever. I suppose they are good enough for a girl band.

Aiden is not working. nerves and simply not enough. squashes lines, unappealing natural voice quality.

Cher is once again undeservedly hyped by judges. She is in a play where she can't quite sing, can't dance at all and she is 'acting out' the role and when is this getting called out?

Katie was terrible. I guess the set and costume were great but close your eyes and you are hearing some average karaoke singer. Im serious.. listen and don't watch and nothing is going on.

*goes without saying that Wagner was terrible. Somehow he has actually gotten worse though not in a way making it funnier.

[Adamw92]

Treyc was my favourite last night, haven't stopped listening to it since!

[ChristmasNeeve]

Matt by a mile followed by Rebecca and Aiden

[ChristmasNeeve]

*Matt is so excellent every single time I feel like it goes without saying he was pretty much the standard of excellence again.*

Rebecca came out even better than ever and really really impressed me!

Paige really proved he is the dark horse - really impressed me! Contender!
------------------------------------------
Not best but not bad:

Tra Cohen:
Actually liked the idea and the voice power demonstration but not a lot else happened there.

Mary:
Calling it a 'neutral' because it was a 'repeat' - an amazing repeat and her voice is just amazing. But nothing 'new' this time out so can't say much.
--------------------------------
Least best?

*The boy band i just don't care about and i suppose they are good by boy band standards I guess. whatever.

*don't care about girl band. whatever. I suppose they are good enough for a girl band.

Aiden is not working. nerves and simply not enough. squashes lines, unappealing natural voice quality.

Cher is once again undeservedly hyped by judges. She is in a play where she can't quite sing, can't dance at all and she is 'acting out' the role and when is this getting called out?

Katie was terrible. I guess the set and costume were great but close your eyes and you are hearing some average karaoke singer. Im serious.. listen and don't watch and nothing is going on.

*goes without saying that Wagner was terrible. Somehow he has actually gotten worse though not in a way making it funnier.

absolutely agree with pretty much everything here except about Aiden, I really liked him last night.

[fruit_cake]

yeah I agree with Niamh, well said mr proximo, I always enjoy reading your posts :dance:

[Vicky.]

*Matt is so excellent every single time I feel like it goes without saying he was pretty much the standard of excellence again.*

Rebecca came out even better than ever and really really impressed me!

Paige really proved he is the dark horse - really impressed me! Contender!
------------------------------------------
Not best but not bad:

Tra Cohen:
Actually liked the idea and the voice power demonstration but not a lot else happened there.

Mary:
Calling it a 'neutral' because it was a 'repeat' - an amazing repeat and her voice is just amazing. But nothing 'new' this time out so can't say much.
--------------------------------
Least best?

*The boy band i just don't care about and i suppose they are good by boy band standards I guess. whatever.

*don't care about girl band. whatever. I suppose they are good enough for a girl band.

Aiden is not working. nerves and simply not enough. squashes lines, unappealing natural voice quality.

Cher is once again undeservedly hyped by judges. She is in a play where she can't quite sing, can't dance at all and she is 'acting out' the role and when is this getting called out?

Katie was terrible. I guess the set and costume were great but close your eyes and you are hearing some average karaoke singer. Im serious.. listen and don't watch and nothing is going on.

*goes without saying that Wagner was terrible. Somehow he has actually gotten worse though not in a way making it funnier.

Agree on every part of that. Except for Aiden.

I love Aiden so much, I love his voice I love his vulnerability, I love how he KNOWS he isnt the best but still tries damn hard. Mad world was fantastic, and I generally hate that song, I loved his version. I dont think he did very well at the john lennon song, but it still wasnt bad. And this week I thought he was great again, though still not as good as mad world. I really think he is the one to watch out for, when he sorts his nerves out, and with the right song he could be brilliant

[Rawrbear]

Matt,Bella amie,Cher and katie waissel one of those 4

[Twilight]

Matt or One Direction were my favorite.

[bbfan1991]

Cher, Katie, Wagner, Matt and Rebecca:).

[saraholeila]

Paije is a fantastic singer, I don't know why ppl don't seem excited about him. Mary and Katie also good, although Katie's a gowl. PAIJE to win!

[Z]

Paije is a fantastic singer, I don't know why ppl don't seem excited about him. Mary and Katie also good, although Katie's a gowl. PAIJE to win!


He's in the same category as John and, until this week, Treyc: good singers, just not done anything surprising or challenging. Treyc did that this week though.

[robb]

Becky has been good in the live shows so far. But on Saturday she was brilliant.

[Stacey.]

Becky has been good in the live shows so far. But on Saturday she was brilliant.

Who the hell is Becky?

[SacredDiablo]

Who the hell is Becky?

i presume its rebecca?

[Twilight]

Matt.