Mariah Carey and Justin Bieber for XF USA?

[Jack_]

http://www.mirror.co.uk/celebs/news/2010/10/24/mariah-carey-tipped-to-get-u-s-x-factor-slot-over-cheryl-cole-115875-22654543/

http://m.digitalspy.co.uk/ustv/s141/the-x-factor-us/news/a283684/justin-bieber-wants-to-judge-us-x-factor.html?locale

Massive names. Mariah would be great as would Bieber, although I'd be worried about his age.

A panel consisting of Simon, Mariah, Nicole Scherzinger and Bieber would be pretty fantastic IMO.

[Jords]

I would feel patronized being judged my a 16 year old (if I was an adult).

[Kerry]

Thank God I don't watch it

[Jordan.]

Great panalist but just no to Bieber.

[Beastie]

As much as I am not a fan of Bieber.. a part of me would find it funny him being a judge...... lol.

[Iceman]

Last I heard of her was in an Eminem song.........OHHHHHHHHH

[_Seth]

Beiber supposedly wants to judge SOME episodes? WTF you idiot, it should be all or nothing.

It should be Cheryl, Simon and someone else.

[Jack_]

I would feel patronized being judged my a 16 year old (if I was an adult).

That's the problem, though he has a couple of years experience of the industry under his belt so I can't see why not.

I doubt he'd get the gig cause of his age though.

[Zippy]

You dont wanna fill your panel with big stars. Thats boring and will be very egotistical.

And Im sure Bieber is booked up for lots of other stuff right now thats more important to his career.

Theres lots of rumours...most nonsense.

[Jack_]

Simon did promise lots of 'surprises' regarding the panel in the press conference the other say though. Maybe these huge names coming forward are what he was on about?

[Zippy]

Simon did promise lots of 'surprises' regarding the panel in the press conference the other say though. Maybe these huge names coming forward are what he was on about?

I think these names are just maybe guest judges or stars lined up to perform. Not actual mentors and judges.

Bieber being a judge and mentor would be ridiculous.

[_Seth]

I hope to **** it's not gonna be a constantly changing, inconsistent judges panel. :( It should just be 3, and STAY as them forever.

[Patrick]

LMFAO
:joker: :joker: :joker:


JUSTIN BIEBER WANTS TO TELL OTHER PEOPLE HOW TO SING?

Oh jesus, I've heard it all now.

Kill me.
Shoot my cock off and feed it to the ducks.

I don't want to be around for this bollocks.

[Tom4784]

I wouldn't watch it if that little cretin was in it.

[Iceman]

I wouldn't watch it if that little cretin was in it.

I know Mariah looks hideous these days.......

[Patrick]

I wouldn't watch it if that little cretin was in it.

I wasn't going to watch anyway but god I'm never going near it now :joker:


The fact that little wanker gets to meet Cheryl when we don't is a disgrace too.

It's like, ugh.
Can you imagine it?


*American Singer Finishes Singing*

American: So Guys How Did I Do? :D
Cheesy Presenter: Let's ask our judges how you did shall we?
Cheryl: I thourely enjoyed it pet and me arms got goosebumps through it.
Audience: What the hell did she just say?
Simon and Mariah give good comments


And then Justin's little girly voice comes on, him talking down to people you know, because he's so talented himself...

And then you've got thousands of 11 year old american school girls screaming in your ear over his high pitched voice.

I'd rather jump off a Ferris Wheel to be honest.

[_Seth]

American: So Guys How Did I Do? :D
Cheesy Presenter: Let's ask our judges how you did shall we?
Cheryl: I thourely enjoyed it pet and me arms got goosebumps through it.
Audience: What the hell did she just say?
Simon and Mariah give good comments

LOL. :joker: :hug:

[Z]

It'd be a monstrosity to give either of those two egos extended screen time. Mariah's not doing very much nowadays so she's a more realistic suggestion than Justin "everywhere" Bieber. I'd expect Simon, a big female name and then two lesser known names but all would be well known in America.

[Zippy]

I'd expect Simon, a big female name and then two lesser known names but all would be well known in America.

I think maybe Paula abdul and Nicole if she's not busy with her career. Plus a relative unknown business end type.

[Z]

I think maybe Paula abdul and Nicole if she's not busy with her career. Plus a relative unknown business end type.

Nicole Scherzinger is a younger version of Paula Abdul; Simon would never put them on the same panel. Plus he's launching the X Factor as competition to American Idol, so he won't have any of the American Idol panel on X Factor I wouldn't have thought?

[Zippy]

Nicole Scherzinger is a younger version of Paula Abdul; Simon would never put them on the same panel. Plus he's launching the X Factor as competition to American Idol, so he won't have any of the American Idol panel on X Factor I wouldn't have thought?

But he loves Paula and she is a big fave there. AI did head downwards after she left...although it was heading that way anyways I know.

I honestly see her doing it. She'd be good too as a mentor. Hey Paula!

[Z]

But he loves Paula and she is a big fave there. AI did head downwards after she left...although it was heading that way anyways I know.

I honestly see her doing it. She'd be good too as a mentor. Hey Paula!

Oh she left American Idol? I only watched it way back in its second series, I had no idea... Maybe then!

[Zippy]

Oh she left American Idol? I only watched it way back in its second series, I had no idea... Maybe then!

Yes similar to Sharon in that she asked for more money. They called her bluff and she then didnt back down in time for the series and got replaced by Ellen. Wasn't a huge success and Ellens now left too...and Kara.

[Harry!]

Mariah Scary to judge talent :joker: you must be kidding me?

[Zippy]

Mariah Scary to judge talent :joker: you must be kidding me?

:joker:

I think she'd be good fun tbh. Can't see it happening though as it would take up too much of her time.