24/10 Results Show Discussion Thread

[Maia]

http://www.gm.tv/media/images/i/h/X_FACTOR_LOGO_gal.jpg

Performers tonight are Cheryl Cole and Michael Bublé, whilst one act faces the chop in the first single eviction of the series.

Tonight at 8:00PM on ITV1. Discuss here :)

QOTD - Who do you think is in danger of elimination this week?

[Z]

I was expecting it to be a double again and reckoned it would be between Paije, Belle Amie, John and possibly Wagner and Katie because it's hard to gauge their popularity at the moment; but as it's only a single I think it might be Belle Amie vs Paije with Belle Amie going.

[arista]

But will this site Crash - Again?

[Stacey.]

Belle Amie and Paije I think will be the bottom two. Or replace Paije with Wagner maybe?

Hope Wagner goes anyway.

[Shaun]

Didn't see one...

[Tom]

the opening was just like Stars in their Eyes :lovedup:

[Stephanie]

will use this one instead, even though i made one.

[Jayson]

We'll use this one.

[Shaun]

sorry Steph :P

[Tom]

Dannii looks awful tonight

Cheryl one of the best I've ever seen her :lovedup:

[Stephanie]

sorry Steph :P
LOL it's fine. i didn't really wanna make it, just didn't see one :joker:

[Tom]

Michael Buble is hardly an exclusive.....

[Stephanie]

LOL!! forget you.

[Shaun]

oh god.

[Jayson]

More miming ****.

[GiRTh]

Paige should sing this song next week. Its perfect for his voice.

[Tom]

Paije makes me cringe

[Stephanie]

wtf at beiber-louis.

[Shaun]

LMFAO @ that One Direction mime.

[Thotmas]

Why do they all sound more decent than usual?

[Stacey.]

That guy just made it blatantly obvious they're miming LOL

[Stephanie]

pmsl. wagner.

[arista]

This is the 1st thread

[Jayson]

LOL I think Wagner gave the game away.

[Shaun]

John and One Direction always give it away :P

I quite liked Belle Amie's bit...

[Bazladoo]

jons hair has gotten even worse he thinks he's bart simpson

[Maia]

*cough*

[Tom]

Forget you with a big arrow pointing towards John, couldn't make it up

[Z]

Oh my goodness, I was hoping to hear Paije sing this at some point - ah well, achieved!

[GypsyGoth]

There are two other threads :conf2:

[Z]

Paige should sing this song next week. Its perfect for his voice.

I've been wanting him to sing this since the live shows started haha, delighted to hear it!

[arista]

Oh my goodness, I was hoping to hear Paije sing this at some point - ah well, achieved!



Zee can you merge the other 2 threads
as this was 1st

[Stacey.]

John's hair :L

[Shaun]

Hmm. I keep underrating Rebecca.

[Stacey.]

CHER! :lovedup:

[Thotmas]

Simon is too sexy for his own good. With that open collar shirt..phowar

[Tom]

I quite liked that performance of Chers. Shame shes an absolute ******

[GypsyGoth]

John's hair :L

I thought it was a furry hat.

[GiRTh]

Cher's on something. I'm sure of it.

[Stephanie]

where's the break!?

[Z]

Zee can you merge the other 2 threads
as this was 1st

Merged :)

[Zippy]

CHER! :lovedup:

She's a queen.

[Stacey.]

I thought it was a furry hat.

LOL seriously it looks like a bush or something.

[Shaun]

I missed last night's show.

How are Led Zeppelin a guilty pleasure?

[Thotmas]

Cheryl does not deserve TreyC

[Jayson]

Cher's production was quite good last night.

[Stephanie]

what's with all the cheryl coloured hair on the girls? (i missed last nights)

[Thotmas]

I missed last night's show.

How are Led Zeppelin a guilty pleasure?

Because black girls are only supposed to like rnb and songs that make your batty wind apparently

[Tom]

I missed last night's show.

How are Led Zeppelin a guilty pleasure?

Shes a young black girl. Led Zep will hardly be her most played on her iPod

Guilty pleasure is relative depending on what you normally listen to anyway, most of the songs weren't guilty pleasures

[Z]

I missed last night's show.

How are Led Zeppelin a guilty pleasure?

Matt, Wagner and (controversially for Cheryl) Belle Amie were the only ones to sing a guilty pleasure IMO!

[GypsyGoth]

I missed last night's show.

How are Led Zeppelin a guilty pleasure?

She cheated.

[Stacey.]

Wagner's just a joke...

[GypsyGoth]

Matt, Wagner and (controversially for Cheryl) Belle Amie were the only ones to sing a guilty pleasure IMO!

And Katie :love:

[Thotmas]

Katie should stay! Cher must go away.

[Jayson]

I liked Katie's performance last night, looking back.

[Z]

Katie looked the spitting image of Edie Falco (Carmela Soprano from The Sopranos) last night, anyone else agree?

[Tom]

Because black girls are only supposed to like rnb and songs that make your batty wind apparently

:laugh3:

one for the sig

Wagner's just a joke...

Coming from Jedwards #1 fan?

[Zippy]

Zzzz

[Shaun]

oh. time for a nap.

[Thotmas]

:laugh3:

one for the sig




:shrug:

Aw not Bubble!!:bawling: he's got nice eyes though :p

[Stacey.]

Coming from Jedwards #1 fan?

At least they actually were likeable and entertaining. There's nothing good about Wagner.

[Stephanie]

right, i'm off to bed. LOL

[Tom]

How is this an exclusive performance? He's on every bloody year

He actually is Westlife rolled into one

[Stacey.]

Michael! :love:

[Maia]

The modern day Sinatra as some might say.

[Bazladoo]

hate this guy he's such a *****

[Thotmas]

How is this an exclusive performance? He's on every bloody year

He actually is Westlife rolled into one

You actually made it a sig? :laugh:

[Shaun]

The modern day Sinatra as some might say.

some very stupid people...

[Zippy]

He doesnt have a very strong voice.

Like a weaker James Morrison

[james130]

Someone needs to tell this show to turn down it's backing tracks!!

[Tom]

someones been taking advantage of the free bar ...

You actually made it a sig? :laugh:

yeah it actually made me laugh out loud and nearly wet myself (trying not to laugh because gf giving me funny looks whilst shes perving over Michael Buble). ahh well its my turn when cheryl is on later

[Maia]

some very stupid people...

:laugh:

[Jayson]

I swear he's drunk...

[Thotmas]

Why does bubble dance like a grand dad with something stuck up his arse:bawling:

[Z]

http://assets.nydailynews.com/img/2007/04/06/amd_sopranos.jpg
Katie Waissel

http://www.femalefirst.co.uk/image-library/partners/bang/square/250/1/1287153628-17.jpg
Edie Falco


:o

[Shaun]

Miming. Look how far away he's singing from the mic, rofl

[Zippy]

Is he miming? the mike is nowhere neaar his mouth most the time!

[Tom]

i think anyone would break off their holiday if there was £££££££££££££ in it tbh

[Z]

http://assets.nydailynews.com/img/2007/04/06/amd_sopranos.jpg
Katie Waissel

http://www.femalefirst.co.uk/image-library/partners/bang/square/250/1/1287153628-17.jpg
Edie Falco


:o

Somebody please see the similarities with me :bawling:

[Shaun]

At least Cheryl mimes half-convincingly :)

[Shaun]

No, Greg.
No.

[Zippy]

Cheryl can't be worse than that crap.

[Tom]

Somebody please see the similarities with me :bawling:

She looks like Kate Garraway (not Katie)

[Jayson]

"This is the 5 minute warning, Cheryl Cole will be performing on stage after the break and I sincerely recommend you watch Antiques Roadshow on BBC1 instead".

[Jords]

Not that keen on Michael's new single, great voice on him though.

[Jayson]

Somebody please see the similarities with me :bawling:

They don't look the same at all :p

[Stephanie]

..oh it's over. *wakes up*

[Shaun]

Hmm. Is there really space for One Direction, what with JLS and The Wanted?

[Maia]

Somebody please see the similarities with me :bawling:

Katie looks more like Pixie Lott's less attractive older sister.

[Z]

Hmm. Is there really space for One Direction, what with JLS and The Wanted?

Yes; I believe bad things come in threes.

[Maia]

Yes; I believe bad things come in threes.

LOL :joker:

[Thotmas]

Doesn't the panel look better without Chery? :p

[Shaun]

-was just about to ask where she was-
fail.

[GiRTh]

Simon just had to mention One Direction. He couldn't stop himself.

[Stephanie]

simon: matt, rebecca.. one direction. LOL

[Maia]

Doesn't the panel look better without Chery? :p

Totally.

[Zippy]

standback

[Maia]

Simon mentioning One Direction but not Belle Amie...blatant favouritism.

[Stephanie]

pmsl.

[Jayson]

Hang on a minute... is she actually performing?

[GiRTh]

standbackLOL Are you bracing yourself. Me too.:joker:

[Stacey.]

:love:

[Jordan.]

:love:

[Tom]

i love how shes recorded a live version and they've autotuned it

but OMG CHERYL :lovedup:

[Shaun]

-approves of the outfit-

[Jordan.]

:love:

D:

[Zippy]

wow

[james130]

Pre-recorded track much?
Just like last year.

Although, so do all the acts who "perform" and this song is catchy.

[GiRTh]

-approves of the outfit-And not much else.:joker::spin:

[Maia]

Oh dear.

[Shaun]

well no prizes for guessing what's Number #1 next week :tongue:

-cuts wrists-

[Tom]

Pre-recorded track much?
Just like last year.

Although, so do all the acts who "perform" and this song is catchy.

none of the result show guests sing live

[Z]

Oh, the song isn't actually as bad or cringe as I remembered it being when I listened to it for the first time a few weeks ago. Is she performing it live? I'm not sure!?

[Angus]

Oh dear.

Quite!

[Stephanie]

urgh this is horrible.

[Thotmas]

Performance is ok. Glad it's less Janet Jacksony than fight for this love
Can't they provide better audio.

[Z]

none of the result show guests sing live

I think Katy Perry's atrocity of last week contradicts you completely :tongue:

[GiRTh]

For a minute there I was sure she sang one line live; then the autotune kicked in.

[Zippy]

brilliant!!!!!!!

[Stacey.]

She looks so hot.

[GypsyGoth]

That was a great performance.

[Tom]

I think Katy Perry's atrocity of last week contradicts you completely :tongue:

no, thats just the reason why they don't sing live :joker:

[Jordan.]

She done good. :D

[Bazladoo]

I wouldn't kick her outta bed

[Shaun]

'when did you get the time to do that?'

WOT? RUSHED PRODUCTION? WOT?

[Jords]

I thought Cheryl was epic.

[Z]

I'm awful at spotting mimes/pre-recordings, I rely on people on here to point them out for me haha.

[GiRTh]

Loreal adverts in both breaks. :rolleyes:

[Zippy]

I thought Cheryl was epic.

she was

awesome choreography and what pop should be about.

[Shaun]

-can assure everyone that album is ****e-

[Stephanie]

i would honestly rather watch the yeo valley ad on repeat for a week than listen to that song again.

[GypsyGoth]

I thought Cheryl was epic.

Me too.

[Maia]

i would honestly rather watch the yeo valley ad on repeat for a week than listen to that song again.

This.

[Zippy]

i would honestly rather watch the yeo valley ad on repeat for a week than listen to that song again.

well go on then.

[Jords]

Looks like next week is a battle between Cheryl Cole - Promise This and Rihanna - Only Girl (In The World) for #1

[Tom]

i would honestly rather watch the yeo valley ad on repeat for a week than listen to that song again.

the yeo valley ad must be really amazing

[GiRTh]

I'm getting nervous for TreyC.

[Maia]

Here we go.

[Stacey.]

Scared.

[Stephanie]

aah.

[Tom]

Did the 28+s get their introduction?

[Thotmas]

I wonder if tHey get headaches with all those flashing lights.


2nd through JOHN!!

[Zippy]

whats Danni dressed as?

a cocktail umberella?

[Zippy]

yes!!!!!

[GypsyGoth]

Yes!

[Stacey.]

OMFG! :love:

[Jordan.]

:love:

*doesnt care what happens now*

[Tom]

whats Danni dressed as?

a cocktail umberella?

retro toilet roll holder

[james130]

Promise This is already number One on iTunes.
And YES CHER!

[bbfan1991]

Yes Cher!!!:D.

[Jayson]

Boo Cher...

WHEY AIDEN!!! :D

[Z]

I'm glad Aiden's through, and well done to Cher!

[GypsyGoth]

Wtfff!

[Stephanie]

booooooooooooooooooo.

[GiRTh]

Go Wagner

[bbfan1991]

WAGNER!!!!:cheer:.

[Zippy]

retro toilet roll holder

LOL :joker:

[Jordan.]

**** off you fat hobo ****.

[Maia]

Yes!!!! Wagner! :dance:

[Stacey.]

Uncool.

[Jayson]

WAGNER!!! :D:D:D:D

Katie...

[Stephanie]

**** sake.

[Thotmas]

boom boom boom gawn vagner lol:p

[bbfan1991]

Yay for Katie too:D.

[GypsyGoth]

YEs!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WoooHoooo!!! Katie made it :D

[Tom]

yay Katy :)

I hope Rebecca & Treyc get through, Matt too but one of them won't :(

[Maia]

One Direction - obvious.

[bbfan1991]

Wand Erection:rolleyes:.

[Jayson]

One Direction :^/

Rebecca :)

[Tom]

yay Katy :)

I hope Rebecca & Treyc get through, Matt too but one of them won't :(

[Stephanie]

oh my god.

[GypsyGoth]

WoW!

[Jordan.]

Yay for Belle Amie :)

[Maia]

YAY!!!!!! Thank god for that!

[Thotmas]

Treyc your big arse beta be on the other side!! :cloud: Otherwise I swear i am not watching anymore!

[Stacey.]

NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*Dies*

[bbfan1991]

WTF Belle Amie:shocked:.

[Jayson]

YEY Belle Amie :D

urgh, Matt...

[Tom]

Treyc & Mary please

[Stephanie]

oh god. i am having a ****ing heart attack.

[Maia]

Don't really mind who goes now, both my favourites are safe :)

[bbfan1991]

No TreyC:(.

[Tom]

please be Treyc......

[Tom]

noooo :(

[Stacey.]

RACISM! :love:

[GiRTh]

******

[GypsyGoth]

TrayC and JOhn have great voices.

[Jordan.]

UGH fat Paije.

Bye John.

[Maia]

WTF @ TreyC in the bottom 2?

[Zippy]

Johns OUT

[Stephanie]

oh. my. god. no.

my two favourites :|

[Thotmas]

how embarassing the 3 black ones at the bottom :p

TREYC!:bawling:

Yeah whatever. to be honest not surprised

[Jayson]

How on earth is TreyC in the bottom two?!

At least Paije is in, and dull John is gone :D

[GypsyGoth]

I like John's song.

[Maia]

Guess it's time for John to go then.

[Shaun]

I so predicted this on msn.

Shaun; no more dreaming says:
*-prepares ahh/s or //AHs-
Gregalitarian says:
*QUICK PREDICTIONS IN
Shaun; no more dreaming says:
*JOHN V TREYC
Edgar says:
*john & paije with john going
Gregalitarian says:
*ok
*I think Belle Amie will go

[Jamietwo]

OMG didn't see that coming bye john

[Z]

How the hell did Paije and Belle Amie scrape their way out of the bottom two? Treyc should NOT be there.

[Stacey.]

TreyC should go. She won't though. :rolleyes:

[Thotmas]

I suddenly crave prawn salad :amazed:

[Bazladoo]

hope john and his awful hair go

[james130]

Lucie Jones <3

[GiRTh]

Cheryl stitched up TreyC. An RnB singer singing Led Zep WTF

[bbfan1991]

I can't stand Paije:nono:.

[Zippy]

I love TreyC but found that song too shouty for her

She's better at soul/RnB imo

[SocietyIsRuined]

TreyC should be gone for trying to murder on air Led Zeppelin. John will go but she commited the cardinal sin and hopefully will be gone in the next couple of weeks.

[Jords]

Treyc. :( :( :( :( :(

Had a feeling she'd be bottom 2, think shes seen as confident and people like voting for those who are a bit unsure :///

[Thotmas]

TreyC should be gone for trying to murder on air Led Zeppelin. John will go but she commited the cardinal sin and hopefully will be gone in the next couple of weeks.

why can't others make mistakes yet cher has been making mistakes since the beginning and is forgiven. The voting public can **** off with their "righteousness" :shrug:

[Z]

Well, I have maintained that Treyc would end up in the bottom two in a shock result but I didn't think it would be so early; and with John it was always inevitable... I'm just amazed Paije and Belle Amie aren't there.

[bbfan1991]

TreyC is this years Ruth IMO, going to be in the sing offs for a bit and then eventually defeated:(.

[setanta]

Cheryl stitched up TreyC. An RnB singer singing Led Zep WTF

Oh yeah, big time. And then Louis gives John a totally rubbish song.

[Adamw92]

Can't believe Treyc is in the bottom two, if she goes I won't be at all pleased :( :mad: :(

[Braden]

So happy for Belle Amie!!!! :love:

Please get through Treyc! The Judges might feel threatened by Cheryl because she has all of her acts :(

[Jords]

RACISM! :love:

:love:

[Stacey.]

Ruth > TreyC

By loads.

[Stephanie]

D:

[Jords]

Can't believe Treyc is in the bottom two, if she goes I won't be at all pleased :( :mad: :(

I will be fackin mad!

[Thotmas]

Now craves baked beans :amazed:

[SocietyIsRuined]

why can't others make mistakes yet cher has been making mistakes since the beginning and is forgiven. The voting public can **** off with their "righteousness" :shrug:

Cher should have been gone by now because she's awful but singing Led Zeppelin the way she did that's just wrong. If you're given a song by the greatest rock band of all time then respect it.

[Shaun]

Ruth > TreyC

By loads.

how is Ruth relevant? :conf2:

[Zippy]

TreyC should be awesome with One night only!!

Byee John

[bbfan1991]

LOL I am enjoying reading the DS peed off views about Cher and Wagner getting through, take that!:joker::elephant::hugesmile:.

[Stacey.]

how is Ruth relevant? :conf2:

bbfan said something about them being similar...

[Shaun]

oh yeah, BOO @ Wagner's boos. :bored: sucks when people can't recognise talent

[Tom]

Million Pound Drop advert... looking forward to playing it online, I couldn't last time because I wasn't in the UK and got blocked :mad:

[Adamw92]

Ruth > TreyC

By loads.

TreyC > Cher.

By loads and loads.

[Jords]

TreyC > Cher.

By loads and loads.

and loads.

[Thotmas]

how is Ruth relevant? :conf2:

She was only relevant for one song but a question mark for the rest of the show for me

[Stacey.]

TreyC > Cher.

By loads and loads.

Clearly more people like Cher better anyway :love:

[Stephanie]

:bawling:

john's gonna go. i can tell.

[Thotmas]

Comeon brotha help a sista out and fail so she can go through :p

[Adamw92]

Clearly more people like Cher better anyway :love:

Not as many as the people who dislike her

[Zippy]

Ew no John

[Stacey.]

He sounds so good.

[james130]

Wow, that's pretty bad. :|

[Jordan.]

crap

[GiRTh]

He's gone

[bbfan1991]

Cock up;).

[GypsyGoth]

:bawling:

john's gonna go. i can tell.

I think so too, TreyC will be much more passionate.

[Tom]

terribly out of tune and out of time

[Bazladoo]

that performance is about as good as his hair! not at all.

[Stephanie]

oh my god :|

[Zippy]

Oh God whats happened to his voice? Mess

[Maia]

Poor guy.

[Shaun]

Wow. It's possible to murder Kelly Clarkson.

[Thotmas]

Now craves sausage. :amazed:

[Jayson]

*kills self*

[Stacey.]

Not as many as the people who dislike her

They're all silly people though :nono:

[Z]

Does the backing track in the real song do that? Pause? He cocked that up royally, oh dear!

[Jordan.]

He should have gone in the first week anyway. :sleep: