X Factor Discussion Thread 06/11/10 - 07/11/10

[Novo]

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2010/10/19/article-1321707-0BA748B5000005DC-664_468x663.jpg


Questions of the day

Should Cher and Katie have a lesbian affair and make a sex tape?

How Amazing is Katie on a scale of 10-10

Who is going to steal the show tonight... Katie...Katie...or....Katie?]

[nanaimo]

Q1 Yuck..hell no
Q2 -10 (thats a minus btw)
Q3 Wagner

[Miss_Mod]

1. No, they should just remain good friends instead.

2. I'd give Katie 6.5

3. Rebecca will steal the show tonight, as usual. :dance:

[GypsyGoth]

1. Sure, that would be cool.

2. 10

3. Katie :love:

[SacredDiablo]

im curious if its a prominent female out tomorrow:conf:

[Smithy]

Corrie advert :amazed:

[Tom]

I love how they think we're thick and can't hear what he's saying so they spell it out word for word on screen

[Ninastar]

Should Cher and Katie have a lesbian affair and make a sex tape? yes

How Amazing is Katie on a scale of 10-10? 1000000000

Who is going to steal the show tonight... Katie...Katie...or....Katie?] Katie cause shes amazing <3

[GypsyGoth]

:bouncy:

[Ninastar]

umfg. im off to a friends like halfway through the show and If I miss katie, I will cut myself.

[MTVN]

Questions of the day

Should Cher and Katie have a lesbian affair and make a sex tape?
[/CENTER]

Yes!! :amazed:

[Smithy]

If they put Rebecca on before Cher and Katie I will cut Cheryl :nono:

[Tom]

How many introductions in the space of 5 minutes do these judges need?

[Smithy]

Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Ninastar]

If they put Rebecca on before Cher and Katie I will cut Cheryl :nono:

as long as its not katie that you cut I dont mind <3



omfg cher <3

[Vicky.]

Cher first :eek:

[Tom]

Oh good, getting the **** one out of the way

[Miss_Mod]

The show has started!

:dance:

[Smithy]

ugh, she's back to the rapping :/

[Vicky.]

Shes taken on the biggest song of this year...get out of her arse simon :bored:

[GypsyGoth]

Oh wow! I love this song :dance:

[Ninastar]

umfg its the alica keys one she did herself right?

[Tom]

she has puma trainers on .. TRAMP

[GiRTh]

Cher in the death slot. This should be interesting.

[Vicky.]

:rolleyes: Who on earth told her she sounds good when she 'raps'?

They should be shot.

I think this sounds awful by the way. Missing notes left right and centre...and just bad in general. What a difference from last week :(

[GypsyGoth]

umfg its the alica keys one she did herself right?

Yep I think so, cause JZ one has a lot of rapping in it.

[Tom]

Cher in the death slot. This should be interesting.

and its week 5. previous casualties include Maria, Laura and Lucie

[Smithy]

She was brilliant last week, what a flop this week :/

[Shaun]

Silly stage stuff. Alright singing. Bad rapping. Not a fan :(

[Tom]

Dannii looks like a christmas present

[Adamw92]

That was very blah

[GiRTh]

Sounds like her voice was enhanced.

[bbfan1991]

Enjoyed that:D.

[Miss_Mod]

A good attempt, but the performance was a bit lack-lustre. I think vocally she was quite weak. Not as good as last week.
Sorry Cher fans. x

[Harry!]

Very dull.

[Shaun]

Simon not up her arse for a change :o

[Vicky.]

Cher 3/10 - Back to normal

[Smithy]

well, at least Simon's being honest for once :rolleyes:

[Tom]

She even has a chav necklace with her name on

Bet its from Argos and she dyed it blue

[SacredDiablo]

who was that who just sang???:joker:

[Vicky.]

Simon not up her arse for a change :o

No... Dannii appears to have switched places with him this week :p

[GiRTh]

Nice one Simon. About time someone pointed out the lack of originality.

[Smithy]

Mury Burn

[Tom]

OMG MARY

highlight 1 of 2 tonight. the other being Wagner

[Shaun]

omg. Cher first AND next to the Curse of Mary :o could it be?

[bbfan1991]

Chers gone first this week so that will please some:p.

[Miss_Mod]

Here comes Mary. I'm sure she'll deliver once again. :)

[Ninastar]

Yep I think so, cause JZ one has a lot of rapping in it.

yah it had rap in it.

[MTVN]

Thought Cher was really good, some of the chereography was a bit lame though

[Vicky.]

omg. Cher first AND next to the Curse of Mary :o could it be?

http://westmonttheatre.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/fingers-crossed_sxc-776014.jpg

[Tom]

omg. Cher first AND next to the Curse of Mary :o could it be?

and the week 5 curse where a leading female goes

[Smithy]

omg. Cher first AND next to the Curse of Mary :o could it be?

Did the curse strike last week?

[Vicky.]

Wow that picture went big :blush2:

[GypsyGoth]

Mary sounds shaky.

[Shaun]

Did the curse strike last week?

Not sure. Mary was first - who was 2nd? Actually yes, Belle Amie were third. The two closest to Mary = in trouble *nods*

[Smithy]

and the week 5 curse where a leading female goes

:o
Week 5 Curse :o!!!

*frantically votes for Rebecca*


and omg this is shocking

[Harry!]

Did the curse strike last week?

Yes Bell Amie were close to Mary's preformance.

[Vicky.]

I dont think this suits her at all...

[MTVN]

Mary sounds shaky.

Yeah, that lead-up to the chorus was a bit off

[Tom]

Whats wrong with Mary tonight? Shes crap, shes normally faultless

[Smithy]

Not sure. Mary was first - who was 2nd?

I think it was Aiden

[King Gizzard]

She sounds absolutely awful, its the songs fault

[MTVN]

She looks very uncomfortable singing this

[Shaun]

REALLY bad song choice, this is poor.

[Miss_Mod]

Surprisingly, Mary's performance didn't shine for me this week. I think the song choice is to blame. :(

[SacredDiablo]

i think it will be cher considering the **** performance she just gave:dance:

[Vicky.]

Terrible song choice, she doesnt look or sound comfortable at all.

I feel sorry for her, I think she knows it was crap :/

[Smithy]

I can see a big firework display from my window :D

[King Gizzard]

For **** sake she gets massive cheers whatever she does

That didnt deserve them

[GypsyGoth]

The crowd are drunk.

[MTVN]

For **** sake she gets massive cheers whatever she does

That didnt deserve them

And Dannii gets booed for the slightest bit of criticism :bored:

[bbfan1991]

:o
Week 5 Curse :o!!!

*frantically votes for Rebecca*


and omg this is shocking

Lmao you're pratically having a wank at the thought:joker:. I hope she isn't in the bottom 2 but you never know;).

[Ninastar]

that was kinda rubbish

[Miss_Mod]

Yeah, the judges have picked up on this. Song choice sucked, for sure. Poor Mary.

[MTVN]

Oh shut up Simon

[Vicky.]

Do the judges hear different to what we do? just I generally have the total opposite opinion to whatever they say :S

[Miss_Mod]

Advert break. Off to put the kettle on... :wavey:

[Ninastar]

I wanna see my hot mess <3

umfg yaaaaaaaaaaay shes next after adian <33333333333333333333333333333

[Smithy]

Lmao you're pratically having a wank at the thought:joker:. I hope she isn't in the bottom 2 but you never know;).

O_O

[Smithy]

I think Rebecca will be the last girl on :amazed:

[Vicky.]

O_O

:laugh:

[nanaimo]

maybe simon reads these forums ;)

[Vicky.]

maybe simon reads these forums ;)

Maybe someone has told him what a fool he looks, praising people who are obviously crap :D

['Conor]

poor Mary :(

[bbfan1991]

Maybe someone has told him what a fool he looks, praising people who are obviously crap :D

Obviously some disagree if she's got this far, voting done the talking!:D:D:D

[Miss_Mod]

I think Rebecca will be the last girl on :amazed:

Some things are worth waiting for. :)

[MTVN]

Katie's on :D

[Harry!]

Katie also first :shocked:

[GypsyGoth]

:lovedup:

[Ninastar]

omfg omfg *orgasm*

[Smithy]

Katie weasel :bored:

[GypsyGoth]

Katie weasel :love:

:thumbs:

[Miss_Mod]

I like Katie's vocals. Looking forward to her performance.

[bbfan1991]

Katie's on :D

I like Katie:), I will LOL if she and Cher get through tomorrow then see people taking it too seriously getting wound up:joker:.

[King Gizzard]

Wow theyve finally decided to acknowledge shes already an artist.

*****

[Tom]

She hasn't been a mess this week, shes just a mess in general

[Smithy]

:thumbs:

You didn't correct her surname :L

[King Gizzard]

No you are not doing a No Doubt song you wench!!!

[Miss_Mod]

OMG. That image suits her. I love her diversity.

[MTVN]

I like Katie:), I will LOL if she and Cher get through tomorrow then see people taking it too seriously getting wound up:joker:.

Yeah, add Wagner to that list as well :thumbs:

[Ninastar]

she looks really different. I miss her roots :(

umfg <3

[King Gizzard]

She's so boring

[Shaun]

what the **** @ the background

[GiRTh]

Another easy song. :bored:

[bbfan1991]

Yeah, add Wagner to that list as well :thumbs:

Yeah and him:D.

[MTVN]

she looks really different. I miss her roots :(

umfg <3

She looks really good :love:

[Vicky.]

I love this song, and thought it would suit her. But it doesnt :(

Everyones been crap so far

[Smithy]

her crying on the big screens :|

[Shaun]

cannot take her seriously at all.
Absolutely pathetic.

[GypsyGoth]

You didn't correct her surname :L

Oh yea :hugesmile:

[King Gizzard]

Looks like she is getting raped in the background

[Vicky.]

Cher 3/10
Mary 4/10 Very very bad for her.
Katie 4/10 Bad again, most of the points are for how she looks. She looked fantastic.

[MTVN]

The background :shocked:

:laugh2:

[Miss_Mod]

Oh dear. This isn't one of Katie's best performances. Tuning problem... :(

[Tom]

Is this one of the worst live shows ever? they're all crap

[GiRTh]

Awful.

[Ninastar]

n''aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwwwwwww

[Smithy]

Is this one of the worst live shows ever? they're all crap

tbf there's only been 3 :L

[King Gizzard]

Haha Simon

[GypsyGoth]

They are pciking on her :bored:

[King Gizzard]

Is this one of the worst live shows ever? they're all crap

Deffinetly the worst, even worse than week 2

[Vicky.]

tbf there's only been 3 :L

When the first 3 on are that bad...theres really not much hope :p

[Smithy]

Curse of Mary & a shocking performance

:xyxwave: Bye Bye Katie

[King Gizzard]

Not a whinger? lol whut?

[Miss_Mod]

After this performance, I fear that Katie could find herself in the bottom two. :shocked:

[Shaun]

not a whinger?

Oh so those tears on the background were of joy?

[Smithy]

When the first 3 on are that bad...theres really not much hope :p

You've clearly never heard the saying "leave the best till last"

[Vicky.]

They are pciking on her :bored:

By not licking her feet after a quite bad performance?

[MTVN]

They are pciking on her :bored:

Yep, her performance was a lot better than Mary's but Simon refused to criticise her.

[Ninastar]

Curse of Mary & a shocking performance

:xyxwave: Bye Bye Katie

:bawling:

[King Gizzard]

Why do they keep putting the effort in with her when they know the majority of the public don't like her?

[Vicky.]

You've clearly never heard the saying "leave the best till last"

Not on the x factor. usually the **** ones are last :p

[GypsyGoth]

:love:

[Smithy]

Not on the x factor. usually the **** ones are last :p

last week, Cher and she >

['Conor]

i still dont like her :L

[GiRTh]

Go on Dermot, call her a ****** again.

[bbfan1991]

They are pciking on her :bored:

She deserves criticism but some of the comments about her are very personal and out of order, this not about the judges but whats being said on the net:(.

[Tom]

from bad to worse ...

[Harry!]

You've clearly never heard the saying "leave the best till last"

Katie was last a few weeks ago...

[GypsyGoth]

Go on Dermot, call her a ****** again.

:laugh:

[Vicky.]

last week, Cher and she >

jesus, dont tell me you thought cher was the best last week :shocked:

It was HER best performance, but no way the best of the night...

[Miss_Mod]

I hope Aiden doesn't bother being all "intense" again. I'm actually waiting for him to hold a note or two and show me he can actually 'sing a song'.

[Smithy]

Katie was last a few weeks ago...

well theres bound to be the odd anomaly

[Smithy]

jesus, dont tell me you thought cher was the best last week :shocked:

It was HER best performance, but no way the best of the night...

well apart from Rebecca (but I am rather bias) it was the best of the night

[MTVN]

Aiden always comes across as a bit awkward.

[Tom]

he has a silly haircut, i'd love to take a pair of clippers over that

[Smithy]

he looked like he was having a stroke :shocked:

[GiRTh]

This guy has so gone downhill.

[Vicky.]

:laugh: at the faces he pulls when hes singing.

Looks like hes pilled off his face :D

[Tom]

This guy has so gone downhill.

I swear he was nothing like this in the auditions and bootcamp

[Miss_Mod]

"Nuthin Compares 2 U" is one of my fave songs of all time. He didn't do it justice. It's a song that requires emotion and power... Aiden doesn't have it.

Sorry Aiden fans. x

[MTVN]

This guy has so gone downhill.

Agreed.

['Conor]

this isnt an american anthem? sinead o connor sings this?

[Kazanne]

Oh dear he is dire,feel sorry for him,awful tonight

[bbfan1991]

Joe mark2 but I don't think he will win;)

[King Gizzard]

Amazing!

[Shaun]

this isnt an american anthem? sinead o connor sings this?

It's a Prince song.

[Smithy]

this isnt an american anthem? sinead o connor sings this?

Sineads was a cover

[King Gizzard]

Best of the night so far really

[Tom]

It's a Prince song.

Sinead did it better though

Shes a hilarious mess now though

[GiRTh]

Awful tone to his voice. Pitchy too.

[Miss_Mod]

this isnt an american anthem? sinead o connor sings this?
Yes. But it was penned by Prince. :)

[MTVN]

Louis just thinks everyones amazing.

[Shaun]

-wonders why Tom insists on doing this every time I mention a cover-

[Vicky.]

I thought he was good actually... :)

[Maia]

Everyone loves Aiden tonight :shocked:

['Conor]

Sinead did it better though

Shes a hilarious mess now though

yeah her version was succesfull

[Tom]

-wonders why Tom insists on doing this every time I mention a cover-

why not? :hugesmile:

[Miss_Mod]

OMG, I am really surprised that Simon liked this performance! :conf:

[Braden]

Cheryl is such a ****e judge.

[Shaun]

yeah her version was succesfull

...and?
God. You'd get on great with MeMyselfandI.

The fact of the matter is she'd be nowhere without Prince writing it.

[GypsyGoth]

I expected better from him, he was still good though.

[Braden]

Cher: 5/10
Mary: 5.5/10
Katie: 6.5/10
Aiden: 6/10

['Conor]

...and?
God. You'd get on great with MeMyselfandI.

The fact of the matter is she'd be nowhere without Prince writing it.

alri ok dont need to be snappy

[SacredDiablo]

whats happening tonight? all the performance so far are just a disaster.. except katie's which i could at least listen to her whole performance. mary was absolutely ****. cher was average but on the verge of being ****

[Vicky.]

Cher 3/10
Mary 4/10
Katie 4/10
Aiden 7/10...again, unpopular opinion on here no doubt, but I thought he was great

[Miss_Mod]

Yay. Paige and Rebecca next.
Paige is consistently good... hopefully he'll be the first to deliver an acceptable performance for tonight's show and make up for the bad start.

Looking forward to hearing Rebecca, of course.

:dance:

[Smithy]

Ugh.

Why is Treyc the last girl on again!!
WTF!!!

[SacredDiablo]

Ugh.

Why is Treyc the last girl on again!!
WTF!!!

its only her second time! bitch! thats like week 1 until now... are you ****ing dumb?

[Shaun]

Aiden > Mary > Cher > Katie, so far.

[Smithy]

its only her second time! bitch! thats like week 1 until now... are you ****ing dumb?

My point is that all the other girls have been the last one on except Rebecca, are you ****ing retarded?

oh yes. you are. never mind.

[james130]

Sorry, Danni is the only judge that makes a constructive comment and she gets booed for it.
Simon's lost his touch and is nice to everyone.
Danni is by far the best judge.
I hate the heckling audience.

[Jords]

Cher 5/10
Mary 5/10 :(
Katie 6.5/10
Aiden 4/10

[Tom]

whens Wagner on?

[Shaun]

it makes you wonder, of all of the auditionees in that queue, they just happened to film a finalist.

[King Gizzard]

He mentioned the ****ing cinema again

He needs a cinema-o-meter

['Conor]

yeah i think Dannii is actually a really good judge.

[Tom]

it makes you wonder, of all of the auditionees in that queue, they just happened to film a finalist.

They have cameras everywhere and leave them there whilst the queue goes down ... its more a shock if you're not on tape

[Vicky.]

This song reminds me of donkey from shrek :/

[Novo]

What the ****

LOL

['Conor]

ah Shrek :)

[King Gizzard]

http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/kenan_kel_th.jpg

[GypsyGoth]

This is rubbish. He should just go now.

[Smithy]

This song reminds me of donkey from shrek :/

lmfao

I was just thinking that

[Shaun]

*waves arms*

[Maia]

Paije has excelled himself :o

[GypsyGoth]

http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/kenan_kel_th.jpg

:love:

[Tom]

He's like a middle aged black female soul singer in a male teenagers body

[King Gizzard]

Can they ban medleys please?

Apart from Wagner of course

[Smithy]

ewwwww

Hey Ya

*vomits*

[GiRTh]

Like the Outkast song choice not sure about the other

[King Gizzard]

We love Paije

[Vicky.]

Hey nate, did you know you remind thebeast of paije? I dont think you were here when she did her thread :D

[GypsyGoth]

This is silly.

[Miss_Mod]

FABULOUS!

Great mix of the two tracks. It works.
At last! A decent performance delivered. :dance:

[Shaun]

The Monkees vs. OutKast...

wouldn't have guessed it before. But at least he can sing :) great stuff.

[GiRTh]

up and down

[james130]

I'm watching on delay but sorry Katie's Cheesy background video was such a fail.
Proper cringey.

[King Gizzard]

Simons clapping ferociously

[Vicky.]

Cher 3/10
Mary 4/10
Katie 4/10
Aiden 7/10
Paige 5/10 Dislike the song/songs anyway, but vocals were ok.

['Conor]

I always forget that Paije is still in the show, i dont no why :confused:

[King Gizzard]

Paije - 9/10

[Maia]

His best performance so far IMO.

[Shaun]

-is scared by how much his face looks like mine-

[Tom]

Gotta love Louis

[Braden]

Cher: 5/10
Mary: 5.5/10
Katie: 6.5/10
Aiden: 6/10
Paige: 7/10

[Tom]

-is scared by how much his face looks like mine-

I always thought thats what you would be like if you were black, I just didn't want to say :blush:

[Smithy]

Rebecca now eeeeeeek

:D :D :D

[Miss_Mod]

OMG! Bring it on, Rebecca!!!! :cheer:

[Vicky.]

That bloody accent :mad:

[Braden]

yay yay yay Rebecca!

[Shaun]

I always thought thats what you would be like if you were black, I just didn't want to say :blush:

lmao no it's fine - I called it as soon as I saw his audition

[Tom]

I want to like Rebecca but she bores the sh*t out of me

[MTVN]

Love this song.

[King Gizzard]

Shouldnt get to do this song as it was raped beyond repair in the auditions

[Shaun]

This song is NOT an American Anthem, it's just American.

[Braden]

<3

[GiRTh]

Oh great. She's gonna stand there like a scarecrow again.

[MTVN]

Who sang this?

[Vicky.]

She always looks stunning :love:

[King Gizzard]

lmao no it's fine - I called it as soon as I saw his audition

Don't worry I got the comparisons to :bawling:

[Shaun]

Who sang this?

Bob Dylan originally.

[Tom]

Who sang this?

Gamu

who?

Bob Dylan and Adele covered it

[Miss_Mod]

OMG. Nobody can deny her unique and powerful vocals. She's a winner already. Love her.

[Shaun]

Gamu

who?

Bob Dylan and Adele covered it

pmsfl

[Ninastar]

Okay wow, shes really amazing



I still love katie more though...

[King Gizzard]

Damnit I thought Adele wrote this lol

[Vicky.]

Erm...sorry to say it, but boring. Not clicking for me at all this week :/

[Braden]

Oh great. She's gonna stand there like a scarecrow again.

Stacey from last series did her best performances when she just stood there. And when she did a routine on stage, I personally thought it was her worst week.

[Smithy]

:cheer2:

AMAZING1!!!!l

[MTVN]

Bob Dylan originally.

Oh yeah! I knew that actually, they said it this morning on the radio when they played Adele's version :blush:

[Tom]

yeah I liked that, maybe not worth a standing ovation though thats a bit OTT

['Conor]

she was really good :D

[Vicky.]

Cher 3/10
Mary 4/10
Katie 4/10
Aiden 7/10
Paige 5/10
Rebecca 7/10. Perfect vocals. Just a bit too...boring :S

[Ninastar]

Damnit I thought Adele wrote this lol

same pmsl, I said to my parents, I thought adele was british then my dad was like BOB DYLAN so i just walked away in shame

[Braden]

She is special <3

[Shaun]

Rebecca > Paije > Aiden > Mary > Cher > Katie
tonight

[Maia]

oh great. She's gonna stand there like a scarecrow again.

LOL! :laugh:

[Shaun]

didn't like the random squealing of "feel" at the end, though.

[Miss_Mod]

Cher 5/10
Mary 6/10
Katie 5/10
Aiden 4/10
Paige 7/10
Rebecca 9/10

Matt could possibly score as high as Rebecca. We will have to wait and see. ;)