Week 5 ratings

[Z]

Ratings out of 10?

Cher Lloyd
Mary Byrne
Katie Waissel
Aiden Grimshaw
Paije Richardson
Rebecca Ferguson
Wagner
Matt Cardle
Treyc Cohen
One Direction

[Vicky.]

Cher 3/10
Mary 4/10
Katie 4/10
Aiden 7/10
Paige 5/10
Rebecca 7/10
Wagner 4/10
Matt 9.5/10
TreyC 6.5/10
One Direction 6/10

[fruit_cake]

Rebecca 8/10
One Direction 8/10

Aiden 6/10
TreyC 6/10

Cher 5/10
Paige 5/10

Matt 4/10
Mary 4/10
Katie 3/10

Wagner 0/10

[StGeorge]

Cher 5/10
Mary 4/10
Katie 4/10
Aiden 3/10
Paige 6/10
Rebecca 9.9/10
Wagner 1/10
Matt 9.5/10
TreyC 8/10
One Direction 6/10

[nanaimo]

Cher Lloyd 4
Mary Byrne 5
Katie Waissel 3
Aiden Grimshaw 7
Paije Richardson 6.5
Rebecca Ferguson 9.5
Wagner 6.5
Matt Cardle 9
Treyc Cohen 5
One Direction 6

[Z]

Cher 4/10 - Very average performance, better than her lull in weeks 2 and 3 but not by much.
Mary 3/10 - I thought it was awful, her voice totally clashed with the backing track and she clearly didn't get the song at all.
Katie 5/10 - It was near enough a Gwen Stefani rip off in every way but, that aside, she did an alright job of it.
Aiden 6/10 - He did a much better job this week than last week; it was more his style I think.
Paije 6/10 - Well I can safely say that's the first Paije performance I've enjoyed! He did it well, it was a bit cheesy but I can forgive that for how well his personality came across in his performance!
Rebecca 9/10 - I was a bit annoyed when I realised it was Make You Feel My Love because they've done it to death this year, but Rebecca sang it amazingly...
Wagner 5/10 - I actually thought his singing was pretty good towards the end! I enjoyed watching his performance, still don't think he needs to go just yet.
Matt 9/10 - Wow; performance of the night (just - Rebecca not far behind) and THAT was more like my definition of "best of the series" - which I cannot believe Simon didn't comment on.
Treyc 7/10 - She did it far better than I thought she would, she managed to keep the shouty aspect out of her singing, but I still don't think it was a wise song choice.
One Direction 3/10 - I dunno what the judges were on about, I think they were very bad, the song was a weird choice and if that's the best Simon could muster for a song choice then I think he might be waving goodbye to his boyband sooner than he might think.

[Mystic Mock]

cher 8/10 i probably deserve to be shot for this but i thought her rapping was decent:shocked: and her singing was good.
mary byrne 2/10 i feel so sorry for this woman as shes getting sabbotaged by louis,she was all out of tune which is a shame because she has a very good voice.
katie waissel 2/10 not as good as i was expecting it to be,she lacked everything gwen stafani added to the song apart from the look.
aiden grimshaw 9/10 brilliant but it wasnt an american anthem.
paije richardson 10/10 he really surprised me as i never thought he could do uptempo,he certainly showed olly how to dance,sing and be a showman.
rebecca ferguson 9/10 another boring song and again lacks stage pressence,its a good thing shes got a very good voice.
wagner 0/10 an absolute disaster and not in a funny way either.
matt cardle 9/10 a very good comeback from his dreadful bleeding love performance.
treyc cohen 8/10 much better than i was expecting it to be.
one direction 0/10 wtf was up with these? they sounded so awful and generic,please vote these bastards off tommorrow?

[Miss_Mod]

Wagner 3/10
Aiden 4/10
Cher 5/10
Katie 5/10
Mary 6/10
One Direction 7/10
TreyC 7.5/10
Paige 8
Rebecca 9/10
Matt 9/10
___________

[IheartBB]

Cher - I wasn’t crazy about the song choice, mainly because she isn’t from New York, but also because she didn’t attempt to put her own stamp on it. Like Simon said - it was a bit “copycat“- 4/10
Mary - Wow. Horrifically out of tune throughout. One of the worst performances of the entire series - 1/10
Katie - Pretty weak. Awkward to watch at times - 3/10
Aiden - A bit samey and nowhere near as good vocally as week one, but it’ll do for now. Needs to step it up soon though - 5/10
Paije - Pointless medley in the middle, but an okay all round performance - 4/10
Rebecca - Singing this song after Gamu’s boot camp performance? Brave move. One that didn’t pay off. Her best performance yet, granted, but I still don’t see whatever the judges see in her - 5/10
Wagner - The last note of the song actually showed he has a pretty adequate voice. Probably the best we’re going to see from him… - 4/10
Matt - Best performance of the entire series by an absolute mile. Fitting that the song that put him on the map in the first place is also the song that re-establishes himself as the favourite to win - 9/10
Treyc - Not her best, but still one of the best of the night. She’s so utterly forgettable though. Could be in trouble tomorrow - 6/10
One Direction - Surely they were auto-tuned? By far their best performance, despite the avoiding of the theme (again) - 6/10

[Maia]

Cher - 4/10
Mary - 3/10
Katie - 5/10
Aiden - 6/10
Paije - 8/10
Rebecca - 4.5/10
Wagner - 10/10
Matt - 7.5/10
Treyc - 7/10
One Direction - 3/10

[nanaimo]

first 10 and its wagner, i like you theharbinger

[Mystic Mock]

first 10 and its wagner, i like you theharbinger

thats not good off them though considering last week they gave him 100/10.

but still its probably a very good score off them.

[Miss_Mod]

Rebecca - Her best performance yet, granted, but I still don’t see whatever the judges see in her...[/B]


I actually think this is her worst performance... but only because of poor choice of song. Her best performance to date is "Wicked Game", imo.

If you listen to what the judges say to her, you will know that they all are 100% certain she is a superstar in the making.

[fruit_cake]

I actually think this is her worst performance... but only because of poor choice of song. Her best performance to date is "Wicked Game", imo.

If you listen to what the judges say to her, you will know that they all are 100% certain she is a superstar in the making.

this.

[joeysteele]

Cher, 5. Can't even remember it really, but she sounded ok at the time.
Mary,5, Bad week for Mary,hope the viewers help her,not a song for her at all.
Katie,3, Awful, just awful.
Aiden,9, Love this guys voice, could never get sick of listening to him.great song choice
Paije, 8, maybe even a 9, where did this come from,another excellent song choice from Dannii.
Rebecca,9, Faultless performance, also a very amazing vocal.
Wagner,3, Has to be time for him to go,good showman.
Matt, 10, Love this song, love how he sang it, incredible.Dannii did good by him with this song.
Treyc, 8, Really liked her performance but somehow I feel the public may not have.
One Direction,4, Average, I can't see what the fuss is about and Zain can't sing, half the time I think he isn't when they are all singing.

[Tom4784]

Cher Lloyd: 5/10 Not half as good as last week's it was dull.
Mary Byrne: 6/10 She's getting worse week after week. She's becoming a one trick pony I fear.
Katie Waissel: 6/10 A bit of a mess but I liked the breath-y vocals.
Aiden Grimshaw: 8/10 Back on form after a terrible song direction last week.
Paije Richardson: 7/10 A good performance, nothing wrong with it.
Rebecca Ferguson: 8/10 The song's been done to death this year but she did a very good job of it.
Wagner: 8/10 Because I can.
Matt Cardle: 7/10 Great vocals but it was dull, I felt sleepy throughout the whole of it. He's becoming very repetitive and this is coming from a fan.
Treyc Cohen: 7/10 Good but unremarkable, Matt's criticisms apply to her as well.
One Direction: 6/10 It was okay, I think last week's was their best performance though.

This week's been pretty terrible in comparision to last week's. Very disappointing.

[Kaaarenn!]

Cher Lloyd 3/10
Mary Byrne 2/10
Katie Waissel 2/10
Aiden Grimshaw 6/10
Paije Richardson 4/10
Rebecca Ferguson 6/10
Wagner 1/10
Matt Cardle 8/10
Treyc Cohen 3/10
One Direction 7/10

[Jamietwo]

Cher Lloyd 5/10 - yeah ok , maybe over confident, not so great this week
Mary Byrne 2/10 - bless her, not a good week and she knows it
Katie Waissel 4/10 - weak
Aiden Grimshaw 3/10 - ideal song for him, but don't like his voice
Paije Richardson 4/10 - fun performance but breathless weak vocals
Rebecca Ferguson 6/10 - yeah she's good, above average singer with unique vocal
Wagner 1/10 - seemed to hit one or two notes ok,
Matt Cardle 10/10 !!!!!!! wow
Treyc Cohen 5/10 not bad, not great
One Direction 7/10 - sexy, cheeky, entertaining

[M X]

Cher Lloyd 4/10
Mary Byrne 4/10
Katie Waissel 5/10
Aiden Grimshaw 5/10
Paije Richardson 5/10
Rebecca Ferguson 10/10
Wagner 2/10
Matt Cardle 10/10
Treyc Cohen 6/10
One Direction 7/10

[Colbert-Bump]

Cher Lloyd 7/10
Mary Byrne 4/10
Katie Waissel 5/10
Aiden Grimshaw 8/10
Paije Richardson 6/10
Rebecca Ferguson 9/10
Wagner 7/10
Matt Cardle 9/10
Treyc Cohen 7/10
One Direction 7/10

[Kerry]

Crap week for me

Cher Lloyd - 5/10
Mary Byrne - 3/10
Katie Waissel - 5/10
Aiden Grimshawv - 7/10
Paije Richardson - 6/10
Rebecca Ferguson - 9/10
Wagner - 0/10
Matt Cardle 10/10
Treyc Cohen - 7/10
One Direction - 6/10

[Zippy]

Cher Lloyd 8 very good though last week better
Mary Byrne 3 just awful. been off for 3 weeks now.
Katie Waissel 7 liked it, like her raspy voice
Aiden Grimshaw 7 much better good song choice
Paije Richardson 6 too cheesy and irrelevent to today
Rebecca Ferguson 9 great song great voice! classy
Wagner 4 novelty nonsense not funny enough either
Matt Cardle 9 his first wow performance
Treyc Cohen 7 tired of her choices - SOUL not rock!
One Direction 8 really good fun. theyre still amateurish though

[Jack_]

Cher - 8/10 - I really liked the balance of rapping/singing. Vocals, rapping, styling and staging all much better. Great performance.
Mary - 4/10 - Pretty dire, it has to be said.
Katie - 6/10 - It was...okay. I liked the staging and the vocals were good. Still not good enough song choices though.
Aiden - 6/10 - Great vocal, bit dull. Much easier to watch though [as in it was less 'awkward'].
Paije - 7/10 - His best performance. Nice mix of songs, great vocals, great staging.
Rebecca - 9/10 - Very good vocals.
Wagner - 5/10 - Mildly amusing.
Matt - 10/10 - Absolutely outstanding. Vocally it was flawless, the emotion was displayed fantastically, he engaged with the audience etc.
TreyC - 7/10 - Good vocal, still a little dull.
One Direction - 7/10 - Not their best but I enjoyed it nonetheless. Nice to see some of the others [Niall, Louis] having some lines as well!

[LeatherTrumpet]

Cher Lloyd - safe 5/10
Mary Byrne - utter crap 2/10
Katie Waissel - wrong outfit, poor movement, 4/10
Aiden Grimshaw - his best but still excruciating 6/10
Paije Richardson - his best, no the hey ya bit tho, 7/10
Rebecca Ferguson - briliiant 9/10:spin:
Wagner - shocked that the girl judges did not clap, pair of bitches, entertaining 5/10:joker:
Matt Cardle - the best of the series 10/10:spin:
Treyc Cohen - f off you dull boot 1/10:sleep:
One Direction - they simply cannot dance or move, over rated fluff 4/10

[ElProximo]

I'm going by this week on its own.

Matt Cardle
Rebecca Ferguson
Treyc Cohen
Mary Byrne
Paije Richardson
Cher Lloyd
Katie Waissel
Wagner
One Direction
Aiden Grimshaw

[leahleaahleaah]

Cher Lloyd - 4/10 it was okay, still not impressed!
Mary Byrne - 5/10 i feel bad for her, she's usually amazing, hope she stays in
Katie Waissel - 5/10 i don't get her
Aiden Grimshaw - 8/10 much better than last week!
Paije Richardson - 7/10 he lit up the stage, i liked it
Rebecca Ferguson - 9/10 she can't go wrong for me, i love her
Wagner - 4/10 three points for actually sounding okay during the second part, one point for being slightly entertaining
Matt Cardle - 10/10 PERFECT
Treyc Cohen - 6/10 it was a good performance, but i can't connect with her
One Direction - 7/10 a good performance, their best, but not the best of the night.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Aiden - 9/10
Matt - 9/10
One Direction - 8/10
TreyC - 8/10
Cher - 7/10
Rebecca - 7/10
Paije - 6/10
Mary - 3/10
Wagner - 2/10
Katie - 2/10

[SacredDiablo]

Cher Lloyd - 1/10 did she perform yesterday?
Mary Byrne - 0/10 a disaster. worst performance of the series, wagner owned her in singing
Katie Waissel - 2/10 very bad but not terrible
Aiden Grimshaw - 5/10 most forgettable performance
Paije Richardson - 7/10 the only all round acceptable performance of the night
Rebecca Ferguson - 8/10 voice shaky at parts as usual, had some moments
Wagner Carrilho - 20/10 speechless
Matt Cardle - 2/10 average falsetto but like his chest voice. hate repeated song
Treyc Cohen - 8/10 dont like the song but she had some moments that gave me goosebumps
One Direction - 1/10 pathetic