Judges scoring

[Callum]

Like they do in Strictly where after someone's danced, they get scored out of 10 by each judge giving them a total out of 40. The judge's scores then get added on to the viewer's votes. Would you like this idea in X Factor or do you think this would not work for a singing competition?

[Z]

Like they do in Strictly where after someone's danced, they get scored out of 10 by each judge giving them a total out of 40. The judge's scores then get added on to the viewer's votes. Would you like this idea in X Factor or do you think this would not work for a singing competition?

I've always advocated this idea. It would prevent good singers going too early; and it would remove the sting of going on early.

[Tom4784]

It wouldn't work, the judges would vote tactically.

[Vicky.]

It wouldn't work, the judges would vote tactically.

Yup.

Its all about the judges now, not the contestants. We dont want to give them even more power to influence the winner D:

[GiRTh]

It wouldn't work, the judges would vote tactically.this. Katie would get scores over 30 even if she's sh*t and others would struggle to make 20. They do it on strictly and its so obvious what they're up to

[Patrick]

Well Idk, let's ask Louis.


Louis, what do you think of this idea hun?

http://i37.tinypic.com/10drsbp.gif

I think so too.