Katie surviving over Treyc [MERGED]

[Jords]

And Cheryl didnt vote, she said she would take it to DEADLOCK but that bitch Dermot didnt account for it!!!

MADMADMADMADMAD.

[Z]

SINCE WHEN HAS IT BEEN STANDARD PRACTICE TO GO TO A MENTOR WITH BOTH THEIR ACTS IN THE BOTTOM TWO SECOND?!

Simon Cowell voted off Rachel Adedeji for appearing in the bottom two three times last year; but it's a whole different rule for Katie is it? Treyc Cohen got royally screwed over!!!!!!

['Conor]

Agreed!

[Mystic Mock]

why would you vote treyc off when she never forgot her words and hasnt hit the bottom 2 three times unlike katie?

[Smithy]

ik
It was completely unfair that they went to Cheryl second, they shoulda left her till last so she coulda taken it to deadlock :bored:

[Vicky.]

Pathetic show tonight. Really pathetic.

And simon, saying he is voting on who the viewers want to see next week? Well obviously it isnt katie, as shes been in the bottom so often...

[Benjamin]

Meh, Trayc wasn't very good anyway. Too bland for my liking.

[Z]

I could deal with Katie staying over Treyc if it had gone to deadlock - but that girl has been given too many second chances to merit staying in another week!!

[GypsyGoth]

Well Katie was that good that she didn't need to do her whole song.

[Mystic Mock]

katie couldnt even rebound so i think it was a waste of time keeping her in.

[Jords]

AMMA KILL DERMOT!!! kate ily.

[Maia]

So true. Katie's just gonna be in the bottom 2 for a fourth time probably next week because barely anyone likes her, they should've given TreyC another chance.

[GiRTh]

Oh yeah but I'm not too surprised. As Simon said TreyC is the better singer and dont forget Katie failed to finish the performance(again). This is why I'm totally for the Wagner to win campaign. This show needs a big shake up to get it back on track.

[Adamw92]

I hate Louis so much right now :mad: Treyc deserved a chance, should have gone to deadlock!

[Jords]

Well Katie was that good that she didn't need to do her whole song.

So good she didnt even need to finish it to get to the live shows even! :rolleyes:

*feels bad cause I like her*

[StGeorge]

This series has gone from one farce to another.

[Pyramid*]

ik
It was completely unfair that they went to Cheryl second, they shoulda left her till last so she coulda taken it to deadlock :bored:

SINCE WHEN HAS IT BEEN STANDARD PRACTICE TO GO TO A MENTOR WITH BOTH THEIR ACTS IN THE BOTTOM TWO SECOND?!

Simon Cowell voted off Rachel Adedeji for appearing in the bottom two three times last year; but it's a whole different rule for Katie is it? Treyc Cohen got royally screwed over!!!!!!

Pathetic show tonight. Really pathetic.

And simon, saying he is voting on who the viewers want to see next week? Well obviously it isnt katie, as shes been in the bottom so often...


All of the above.

Complete bloody rig....It's a pile of pish. I bloody well hope Wagner wins, I really do.

[Maia]

Oh yeah but I'm not too surprised. As Simon said TreyC is the better singer and dont forget Katie failed to finish the performance(again). This is why I'm totally for the Wagner to win campaign. This show heeds a big shake up to get it back on track.

:thumbs: Legend.

['Conor]

katies a joke, i really dislike her even more now

[MTVN]

At least Chery's refusal meant it was decided the way it's mean to; by the judges

Although did you hear how Cheryl said at the end "you can let me go last and I'll take it to deadlock" but Dermot ignored her

[Vicky.]

Oh yeah but I'm not too surprised. As Simon said TreyC is the better singer and dont forget Katie failed to finish the performance(again). This is why I'm totally for the Wagner to win campaign. This show heeds a big shake up to get it back on track.

You know, I'm getting that way.

What is the point of the public vote, if they constantly go against it?

I am starting to really understand this wagner thing this year. I thought it was pathetic to start with, but if this continues, I will be doing it myself.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

She wanted it to be deadlock, and she had the power?

[Patrick]

I get what you mean, But I'm too happy.

[Mystic Mock]

this is stupid,i wouldnt be surprised if they didnt get rid of rebecca and matt over katie.

[_Seth]

Pathetic show tonight. Really pathetic.

And simon, saying he is voting on who the viewers want to see next week? Well obviously it isnt katie, as shes been in the bottom so often...

EXACTLY!

I can't believe they went to Cheryl second... she should have been last. She can't be on the show if she refuses to do what she signed up for. The stupid bitch! :rolleyes:

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

because she didn't want to be hated for picking katie over Treyc again. she hardly looks devastated at the moment.

['Conor]

Katie is **** !

[MTVN]

You know, I'm getting that way.

What is the point of the public vote, if they constantly go against it?

I am starting to really understand this wagner thing this year. I thought it was pathetic to start with, but if this continues, I will be doing it myself.

But the public vote decides the bottom two, then the judges choose between those two, it's always been that way since the show started, today was no different.

[_Seth]

I will never understand.

[Jamie.....]

I dont understand why they kept her in, its clear the public dont like her

[Adamw92]

Because they're both t*ats, Simon more since thats twice he's now sent Treyc home in 2 years!

[hotleggs]

SINCE WHEN HAS IT BEEN STANDARD PRACTICE TO GO TO A MENTOR WITH BOTH THEIR ACTS IN THE BOTTOM TWO SECOND?!

Simon Cowell voted off Rachel Adedeji for appearing in the bottom two three times last year; but it's a whole different rule for Katie is it? Treyc Cohen got royally screwed over!!!!!!

i agree with all of that

[_Seth]

Oh yeah but I'm not too surprised. As Simon said TreyC is the better singer and dont forget Katie failed to finish the performance(again). This is why I'm totally for the Wagner to win campaign. This show needs a big shake up to get it back on track.

I agree with this.

['Conor]

i hope Simon gets alot of stick for this.

[Vicky.]

But the public vote decides the bottom two, then the judges choose between those two, it's always been that way since the show started, today was no different.

Yes, but when someone is in the bottom the third (?) time...isnt it obvious the public do not want them there?

And simon trying to say he is saving katie as the public prefer her is just such a joke :laugh:

[Mystic Mock]

Yes, but when someone is in the bottom the third (?) time...isnt it obvious the public do not want them there?

And simon trying to say he is saving katie as the public prefer her is just such a joke :laugh:

this,i also think treyc would have rebounded next week.

[bbfan1991]

XF has never been credible, it's a shame for TreyC because she's a good singer but Katie is more interesting and thats proved by people constantly discussing her:p.

It's all about the money, controversy and ratings and right now the producers will be high fiving each other with more PR than ever guaranteed this week and people getting wound up, will they care? HELL NO:joker:.

[StGeorge]

Oh yeah but I'm not too surprised. As Simon said TreyC is the better singer and dont forget Katie failed to finish the performance(again). This is why I'm totally for the Wagner to win campaign. This show needs a big shake up to get it back on track.

This....as i agree a vote for Vagner would be a slap in the face for the Scowell and his manipulation ever since the judges houses.

[Angus]

They have to keep in the crap acts to give their chosen one a chance of winning. Can't be having too many good singers up against Cheryl's clone now can we?:rolleyes:
At least Simon could try coming up with some more convincing reason why Katie, who crucified the song (at least the bits she remembered) was kept in over the talented Treyc. The show has become so farcical that they openly defy public opinion without any attempt to hid their bias.

['Conor]

all i can say now is... SCREW U X FACTOR, IM A CELEB HAS ARRIVED :D

[fruit_cake]

they kept her in because she's Cheryl's favourite and everyone has to dance around to keep Cheryl happy

[MTVN]

Yes, but when someone is in the bottom the third (?) time...isnt it obvious the public do not want them there?

And simon trying to say he is saving katie as the public prefer her is just such a joke :laugh:

Yeah true, although the public do like talking about her and she brings a lot more publicity to the show than Treyc ever could.

[Yuna]

Her performance was pathetic, she's begging for votes now instead of crying? What's next? Being a drama queen is never interesting, it's just annoying.

[nanaimo]

a pure set up to keep katie in by asking Cheryl first, i'm disgusted :devil:

[Locke.]

Aren't you supposed to be saying you love Novo at the moment?

[Jords]

because she didn't want to be hated for picking katie over Treyc again. she hardly looks devastated at the moment.

This.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

because she didn't want to be hated for picking katie over Treyc again. she hardly looks devastated at the moment.

If anyhthing her picking tracey over katie would of got her lots more love.

[nanaimo]

Aren't you supposed to be saying you love Novo at the moment?

just did...hehe

[MTVN]

Well at first she stated outright that she would not choose so I guess Dermot was happy to accept that considering how pressed they were for time.

[Benjamin]

Still happy for Katie :tongue:

[nanaimo]

Was the mentor ever asked second in a situation like that or is this a first?

[Jack_]

Katie is a lot more interesting than Rachel ever was...

[Vicky.]

EXACTLY!

I can't believe they went to Cheryl second... she should have been last. She can't be on the show if she refuses to do what she signed up for. The stupid bitch! :rolleyes:

Its not the first time eithr.

Was it last year when she refused to judge some guy in the auditions...just because she knew him from years back?

[Novo]

Katie is keeping this show alive all by herself at the minute.. should be honoured with some kind of medal or trophy.. all the viewers are tuning in to see what she does next like tonight for example " You know what just sod it " and sitting down.. Next week bottom two with Rebecca or Matt give her a little bit of a test :) but let's face it the judges will save her because they need her on the show

[Mystic Mock]

the reason they didnt do the bottom 3 was because katie was bottom of the votes i think.

[fruit_cake]

the reason they didnt do the bottom 3 was because katie was bottom of the votes i think.

she's probably going to be bottom every week from now on too

[bbfan1991]

Oh well at least whilst being disappointed TreyC is dignified and won't hold anything against Katie or the judges, some can be outraged on their own behalf or wave Gamu was robbed flags in the air:rolleyes::joker:.

[Angus]

Katie is keeping this show alive all by herself at the minute.. should be honoured with some kind of medal or trophy.. all the viewers are tuning in to see what she does next like tonight for example " You know what just sod it " and sitting down.. Next week bottom two with Rebecca or Matt give her a little bit of a test :) but let's face it the judges will save her because they need her on the show

Yeah, next week when she's in the bottom 2 again, why bother doing the sing off at all? - she should just stand there and not attempt to sing (which she can't do anyway), perhaps with a generous helping of waterworks, a panic attack or two, and Simon & Co can keep her in because she's "so very interesting".:bored::sleep:

[Livia]

Outrageous Treyc has gone after the pig's ear Katie made of her song. Again. I really can't see why some people think Katie's entertaining. Maybe some people find desperation coupled with a lack of commitment enchanting qualities.

It seems they change the rules too. What happened to taking it to deadlock? Why was Cheryl allowed to abstain like that?

[MeMyselfAndI]

It's patheic.. uuugh see i just hate ****ig Cheryl

[Mystic Mock]

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

[Zippy]

Cheryl said she would go last in the decisions. Not the same as abstaining.

Katie is at least a fighter with passion. TreyC is kinda cold and lacks the drive and ambition. Neither will be a success but IMHO Katie is a far greater asset to the show in drama terms.

[Jack_]

It's patheic.. uuugh see i just hate ****ig Cheryl

Again, you've changed your tune - two months ago you 'loved her'. Kids these days :sleep:

[MeMyselfAndI]

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

this

[Jords]

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

Thats a good point too, actually.

[bbfan1991]

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

Hate is a strong word dislike more better, Katie deserves criticism but some go way too far IMO and get personal which must be hurtful:(, we hardly know the girl and can only judge by what the papers print which some can be rubbish of course..

Katie knows that is part of the package of doing the show but she's just a contestant on a TV show and theres worst stuff going on elsewhere in the world?, hate.. give me a break:joker:.

[bbfan1991]

Thats a good point too, actually.

Not Katie's fault Simon wants to keep her for the PR for the show and Louis kept her in for whatever reason, Cheryl couldn't choose between her two acts and could have sent it to deadlck but it's all show for the controversy:rolleyes:.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Again, you've changed your tune - two months ago you 'loved her'. Kids these days :sleep:

- Loius was my favouite judge, the only one who actually judges it as a singing competitions.

- Dannii is the best judge

Katie forgot her words she is so **** lmao

[Livia]

Cheryl said she would go last in the decisions. Not the same as abstaining.

Katie is at least a fighter with passion. TreyC is kinda cold and lacks the drive and ambition. Neither will be a success but IMHO Katie is a far greater asset to the show in drama terms.

But she did end up abstaining. She said that she would take it to deadlock but I didn't hear one word of protest from her when they decided to allow her to abstain and throw Treyc out. Funny that.

Katie is desperate to be famous but she doesn't have the skills, the talent or the personality despite her repeatedly telling us how quirky she is and how this is "really her". People see through her and that's why she's not popular with the public. Being desperate isn't the same thing as being a fighter with passion. If she's so passionate about her "art" why does she keep forgetting her words?

[Mystic Mock]

Hate is a strong word dislike more better, Katie deserves criticism but some go way too far IMO and get personal which must be hurtful:(, we hardly know the girl and can only judge by what the papers print which some can be rubbish of course..

Katie knows that is part of the package of doing the show but she's just a contestant on a TV show and theres worst stuff going on elsewhere in the world?, hate.. give me a break:joker:.

shes reaching hate,on digital spy the website broke down temporarily and threads have been merged here because most people are hating her.

[MeMyselfAndI]

uugh katie is a ugly ****ing freaky dramaqueen bitch

[Novo]

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

Not really

If your not in it you can't win it

[Jords]

Not really

If your not in it you can't win it

But if youre clearly not gonna win it why waste time?

[fruit_cake]

But she did end up abstaining. She said that she would take it to deadlock but I didn't hear one word of protest from her when they decided to allow her to abstain and throw Treyc out. Funny that.

Katie is desperate to be famous but she doesn't have the skills, the talent or the personality despite her repeatedly telling us how quirky she is and how this is "really her". People see through her and that's why she's not popular with the public. Being desperate isn't the same thing as being a fighter with passion. If she's so passionate about her "art" why does she keep forgetting her words?

this, good post, Livia!

[Jack_]

- Loius was my favouite judge, the only one who actually judges it as a singing competitions.

- Dannii is the best judge

Katie forgot her words she is so **** lmao

Nah, you definitely used to praise Cheryl all the time until she sent Gamu home. Funny that.

And hey, at least she's more interesting than Treyc...oh, and Gamu :xyxwave:

uugh katie is a ugly ****ing freaky dramaqueen bitch

OTT much? To be honest it's this sort of behaviour [essentially bullying] that is probably making her so upset. Grow up.

[Livia]

this, good post, Livia!

How sweet, thank you, FC.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Katie is a lot more interesting than Rachel ever was...

its a ****ing singing contest...

get that in your head, i know you've came from big brother but surely your not that stupid.

Rachel was a better singer than Katie..

[Novo]

But if youre clearly not gonna win it why waste time?

TreyC wasn't going to win it either.. she was in the same position as Katie

[Jack_]

its a ****ing singing contest...

get that in your head, i know you've came from big brother but surely your not that stupid.

Rachel was a better singer than Katie..

...well, no it's not, or else it would be called the 'Singing Factor'. I suggest you Google for the definition of the phrase 'X Factor', because it's not just the name of a TV show, it has definition - maybe then you'll understand why it's not just a singing competition, and it incorporates a lot of other factors.

So it looks like you're the stupid one here, darling. But then we always knew that :xyxwave:

[GiRTh]

Cheryl said she would go last in the decisions. Not the same as abstaining.

Katie is at least a fighter with passion. TreyC is kinda cold and lacks the drive and ambition. Neither will be a success but IMHO Katie is a far greater asset to the show in drama terms.But as soon as she said that Dermot made it clear Louis would have the deciding vote.

What kind of fighter gives up, sits on the floor and says 'sod it' half way thru a song like some petulant 9 year old.

[Novo]

its a ****ing singing contest...

get that in your head, i know you've came from big brother but surely your not that stupid.

Rachel was a better singer than Katie..

Get it in your ****ing head that it's not just about the singing, the X factor has never been just about singing the judges have mentioned this countless times.. I am not sure what you class good tv... 12 ****ing bores with no personality what's so ever singing depressing love songs like your ****e idol leona lewis

[Livia]

How come then, if its all about having the X Factor, Katie is still in it? Because she clearly doesn't have it.

[Jack_]

Get it in your ****ing head that it's not just about the singing, the X factor has never been just about singing the judges have mentioned this countless times.. I am not sure what you class good tv... 12 ****ing bores with no personality what's so ever singing depressing love songs like your ****e idol leona lewis

:laugh3:

Class.

How come then, if its all about having the X Factor, Katie is still in it? Because she clearly doesn't have it.

She clearly does - stage presence, image and personality. All three traits she definitely has. Her vocal talent isn't the strongest, but it's certainly not awful. So looks like she does have the 'X Factor' after all, hence why she's still there :xyxwave:

[Novo]

How come then, if its all about having the X Factor, Katie is still in it? Because she clearly doesn't have it.

She clearly has a lot more then all the other acts put together because everyone seems to be talking about her

[Mystic Mock]

:laugh3:

Class.



She clearly does - stage presence, image and personality. All three traits she definitely has. Her vocal talent isn't the strongest, but it's certainly not awful. So looks like she does have the 'X Factor' after all, hence why she's still there :xyxwave:

i dont think she has stage pressence.

[Livia]

She clearly does - stage presence, image and personality. All three traits she definitely has. Her vocal talent isn't the strongest, but it's certainly not awful. So looks like she does have the 'X Factor' after all, hence why she's still there :xyxwave:

Yeah, she's still there. Down in the bottom two... same again next week I reckon. You're in the minority I reckon.

[rosebay11]

The whole thing - going to the mentor 2nd - and then ignoring her seemed very weird, I must say. Pity Treyc is gone, IMO.

[BB_Eye]

But she did end up abstaining. She said that she would take it to deadlock but I didn't hear one word of protest from her when they decided to allow her to abstain and throw Treyc out. Funny that.

Katie is desperate to be famous but she doesn't have the skills, the talent or the personality despite her repeatedly telling us how quirky she is and how this is "really her". People see through her and that's why she's not popular with the public. Being desperate isn't the same thing as being a fighter with passion. If she's so passionate about her "art" why does she keep forgetting her words?
I think she is talented, but it's apparent to me that she just doesn't put the necessary work in and that she isn't taking it seriously enough. Some "passion".

[bbfan1991]

uugh katie is a ugly ****ing freaky dramaqueen bitch

Charming, would you say that to her face?.

It must be worrying for her mom to hear all this abuse aimed at her daughter and then turn up to Xtra Factor like it's alright, Katie has chosen to be on the show but I would feel the same if I had a son or daughter in that position.. I may dislike someone e.g. Paije based on personality even though I do like his performances but I don't hate the guy or start getting personal:).

[Vicky.]

She clearly does - stage presence, image and personality. All three traits she definitely has. Her vocal talent isn't the strongest, but it's certainly not awful. So looks like she does have the 'X Factor' after all, hence why she's still there :xyxwave:

Shes still there because the judges bum her. Nothing more.

The public dont seem to have taken to her 'x factor' ;)

[Livia]

She clearly has a lot more then all the other acts put together because everyone seems to be talking about her

Yes, but were mostly saying negative stuff. Clearly.

[Zippy]

How come then, if its all about having the X Factor, Katie is still in it? Because she clearly doesn't have it.

Katies been grabbing headlines and getting people talking since her first audition. So she clearly has something...passion, desperation..whatever, its SOMETHING.

Meanwhile, TreyC hovers in the background unnoticed.

[Vicky.]

uugh katie is a ugly ****ing freaky dramaqueen bitch

harsh much?

And no way is she ugly anyway :)

[Novo]

Yes, but were mostly saying negative stuff. Clearly.

Doesn't matter really they are all still talking about her she is making all the headlines :)

[Jack_]

She clearly has a lot more then all the other acts put together because everyone seems to be talking about her

Katies been grabbing headlines and getting people talking since her first audition. So she clearly has something...passion, desperation..whatever, its SOMETHING.

Meanwhile, TreyC hovers in the background unnoticed.

THANK YOU. This is the point. Dullards do not get press attention. So she clearly has stage presence and personality.

Yeah, she's still there. Down in the bottom two... same again next week I reckon. You're in the minority I reckon.

I blame the press.

[Livia]

Doesn't matter really they are all still talking about her she is making all the headlines :)

Yeah, so did Gary Glitter. Didn't mean he was popular.

[bbfan1991]

Yes, but were mostly saying negative stuff. Clearly.

Forums can count for good and bad press and like Simon says it's better than having nothing, at least she's making an impact even if you dislike her.. TreyC should have made more of an impact hence why some forgot who she was and Cheryl should have focused on her more;).

[GiRTh]

The fix stories have started lol
Daily Mail (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-1327498/X-Factor-2010-Cheryl-Cole-refuses-vote-Treyc-Cohen-evicted.html?ito=feeds-newsxml)

[Jack_]

The fix stories have started lol
Daily Mail (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-1327498/X-Factor-2010-Cheryl-Cole-refuses-vote-Treyc-Cohen-evicted.html?ito=feeds-newsxml)

The Daily Fail starts things off then :sleep:

[Novo]

Yeah, so did Gary Glitter. Didn't mean he was popular.

Can't really compare Gary glitter to Katie FFS :joker: :joker: :joker: He is a Peado and Katie is a singer on the X factor

[Zippy]

Like Rufus said on Xfactor; its better to have a few fans that are passionate about you than everybody thinking youre good but...meh.

Katie attracts those few passionate fans and they can get you far in this business.

[Livia]

Can't really compare Gary glitter to Katie FFS :joker: :joker: :joker: He is a Peado and Katie is a singer on the X factor

I was making the point that not "all publicity is good publicity". Katie's press has been negative. Just because they're writing about you in the papers it doesn't mean that it's going to help make you popular. That's where I was going with that, as I think you probably know.

[GiRTh]

The Daily Fail starts things off then :sleep:
It wont end there.

[Jack_]

Like Rufus said on Xfactor; its better to have a few fans that are passionate about you than everybody thinking youre good but...meh.

Katie attracts those few passionate fans and they can get you far in this business.

This. I completely agreed with him when he said that.

[Livia]

Like Rufus said on Xfactor; its better to have a few fans that are passionate about you than everybody thinking youre good but...meh.

Katie attracts those few passionate fans and they can get you far in this business.

Won't help her record sales and concert tickets though. When she goes back to working in the hairdresser's maybe they can all go along and admire her there. There are probably enough chairs in reception for all of them.

[Jack_]

It wont end there.

Of course not, the low-rate tabloids have got to have some bullsh!t to fill their papers with for the next week :sleep:

[Novo]

I was making the point that not "all publicity is good publicity". Katie's press has been negative. Just because they're writing about you in the papers it doesn't mean that it's going to help make you popular. That's where I was going with that, as I think you probably know.

He committed one of the worst crimes possible though... so he is obviously going to get bad publicity, Katie has done nothing much of note to get bad publicity but she gets it anyway because they know people want to hear about her and it will sell unlike most the others on the show

[Livia]

He committed one of the worst crimes possible though... so he is obviously going to get bad publicity, Katie has done nothing much of note to get bad publicity but she gets it anyway because they know people want to hear about her and it will sell unlike most the others on the show

Yeah, I refer you to my previous explanation. I genuinely thought you would understand the loose analogy. It's quite simple really.

[Novo]

Yeah, I refer you to my previous explanation. I genuinely thought you would understand the loose analogy. It's quite simple really.

Any Publicity is good... it keeps you in the public eye.. the publicity from this won't harm her it will probably gain her more votes from her fans next week actually

[Livia]

Any Publicity is good... it keeps you in the public eye.. the publicity from this won't harm her it will probably gain her more votes from her fans next week actually

Not all publicity is good publicity and it's naive to think so. Careers can be ruined by the press. Bad publicity colours people's judgement. I understand you like her, and that's fine. However, she is not popular generally.

[Novo]

Not all publicity is good publicity and it's naive to think so. Careers can be ruined by the press. Bad publicity colours people's judgement. I understand you like her, and that's fine. However, she is not popular generally.

Not yet anyway but she will be very very soon :)

[Mystic Mock]

Like Rufus said on Xfactor; its better to have a few fans that are passionate about you than everybody thinking youre good but...meh.

Katie attracts those few passionate fans and they can get you far in this business.

what 4 people lol?

[Livia]

Not yet anyway but she will be very very soon :)

LOL... You're a 'glass half full' kind of person. I kind of like that.

[Novo]

LOL... You're a 'glass half full' kind of person. I kind of like that.

How many times have i told you katie haters but every week you never seem to get it sometimes i swear it is like talking to a brick wall :bored:

[Mystic Mock]

How many times have i told you katie haters but every week you never seem to get it sometimes i swear it is like talking to a brick wall :bored:

but we are not wrong as she more than likely came bottom of the votes this week,and before you say anything,howcome the bottom 3 mysteriously changed to a bottom 2? and why did it go to cheryl second to make a decision on who done better in the sing off? i think it was because katie was bottom of the votes.

[Novo]

but we are not wrong as she more than likely came bottom of the votes this week,and before you say anything,howcome the bottom 3 mysteriously changed to a bottom 2? and why did it go to cheryl second to make a decision on who done better in the sing off? i think it was because katie was bottom of the votes.

You have been wrong every week so far you all think she is going to go every week but she always hangs on because she is Amazing... the bottom 3 changed to the bottom 2 because they stopped doing double eliminations.... and who cares about that now nothing is going to change what has happened Katie is through and TreyC is going home.

[Mystic Mock]

You have been wrong every week so far you all think she is going to go every week but she always hangs on because she is Amazing... the bottom 3 changed to the bottom 2 because they stopped doing double eliminations.... and who cares about that now nothing is going to change what has happened Katie is through and TreyC is going home.

it was meant to be a bottom 3 this week,and i wouldnt be so bothered if it was 3 times in the bottom 2 each but it wasnt.

[Novo]

it was meant to be a bottom 3 this week,and i wouldnt be so bothered if it was 3 times in the bottom 2 each but it wasnt.

That was just a rumour a double eviction was never confirmed this week at all

[Mystic Mock]

That was just a rumour a double eviction was never confirmed this week at all

it was confirmed.

[Novo]

it was confirmed.

No it wasn't it was bull****..

[joeysteele]

Well as I said before we know at least one of the acts who will be in the bottom 2 or 3 next week,Katie again for the 4th time, as the public will be livid that Katie was saved again and the way she was saved too. Even after a terrible sing off performance.

The girl is simply awful and the poublic overall clearly don't like her at all unless she sings Jungle Book songs.

[Truth Teller]

Pathetic show tonight. Really pathetic.

And simon, saying he is voting on who the viewers want to see next week? Well obviously it isnt katie, as shes been in the bottom so often...

Simon is losing a lot of credibility this year - imagine if this was Americcan Idol and the Judges saved a contestant who forgot their words and didn't perform well - he wouldn't dare there but feels its ok on the x factor.......

this is stupid,i wouldnt be surprised if they didnt get rid of rebecca and matt over katie.

As much as i think they wouldn't dare.....you never know - their excuse will be -oh katie gave the strongest performance and based on that she should stay.....

[Beastie]

And Cheryl didnt vote, she said she would take it to DEADLOCK but that bitch Dermot didnt account for it!!!

MADMADMADMADMAD.

Not Dermot's fault. It will be the producer in his ear ;)

[Beastie]

Well let's see what happens next week. Katie is in trouble next week if she is in the bottom 2 with ANYONE except Wagner.

9 acts left. 8 can only go on tour. They will be all sh!tting themselves.

I predict Wagner will perform 1st next week too!

[ElProximo]

And Cheryl didnt vote, she said she would take it to DEADLOCK but that bitch Dermot didnt account for it!!!

MADMADMADMADMAD.

Yeah I think there is more contrived drama in this that we know and more voting 'for' future drama.

Treyc is the better singer. In fact, one of the best singers in the competition. She is a league above Kaitie,
HOWEVER...
...Katie is a mediocre singer yet has some kind of odd low-level lovey-hatey thing with the audience, stirs low-level press scandals and can develop into this anti-hero bad-girl and maybe even 'lovable loser' character for a few more weeks.

Treyc was one of my favourites but I could totally understand how she just failed to connect in any sort of way.

[Miss Ivy Balls]

iT IS ANNOYING WHEN PEOPLE THINK IT IS A FIX.

iT ISN'T. tHE PUBLIC VOTED. tHEY WERE IN THE BOTTOM.

[Kerry]

TreyC (stupid spelling) sounded crap for the past two weeks and even worse in the singoff tonight

[lime]

But as soon as she said that Dermot made it clear Louis would have the deciding vote.

What kind of fighter gives up, sits on the floor and says 'sod it' half way thru a song like some petulant 9 year old.
This!
It's really getting tiresome now with judges calling Katie a fighter,she gave up last night just as she did in the judges houses and didn't complete the song.It's not Katie being a fighter that keeps her there ,it's the judges.

It's sad really as Katie has been a mess for a few weeks now and I really don't think they are doing her any favours keeping her there.I know Simon has invested alot in her financially to get her out of sony record deal but the poor girl looks as if she is on the verge of a breakdown.
Ah well it has everyone talking about X-factor this morn so Simon will be happy.

[M X]

I'm glad Katie is still in, let's face it she is one of the most interesting people on X Factor ever, Treyc was a good singer but she was boring.

[Niamh.]

Pathetic show tonight. Really pathetic.

And simon, saying he is voting on who the viewers want to see next week? Well obviously it isnt katie, as shes been in the bottom so often...

Exactly.

[Ammi]

This!
It's really getting tiresome now with judges calling Katie a fighter,she gave up last night just as she did in the judges houses and didn't complete the song.It's not Katie being a fighter that keeps her there ,it's the judges.

It's sad really as Katie has been a mess for a few weeks now and I really don't think they are doing her any favours keeping her there.I know Simon has invested alot in her financially to get her out of sony record deal but the poor girl looks as if she is on the verge of a breakdown.
Ah well it has everyone talking about X-factor this morn so Simon will be happy.
Ah clever Simon - he made a comment about the negative press and said it was better to have that negativity than no press at all. If you look at it that way the right decision was made for the show because Katie keeps it high profile with her spoilt drama queen antics - carefully mentored by the queen of drama Cheryl - just a shame that his message to us is that our votes are pointless.

[Niamh.]

Ah clever Simon - he made a comment about the negative press and said it was better to have that negativity than no press at all. If you look at it that way the right decision was made for the show because Katie keeps it high profile with her spoilt drama queen antics - carefully mentored by the queen of drama Cheryl - just a shame that his message to us is that our votes are pointless.

yes and also that the sing off is pointless as well.

[tate]

Simon's manipulation has hit new heights IMO

For 'interesting' read ' free publicity'. I personally dont find Katie interesting, I find her manipulative, childish, petulant and untrue but not interesting. I would suggest to Simon that her being in the bottom 2 3 out of 5 weeks tells a story that the voting public ALSO dont find her interesting. Headlines are one thing but peeing off your voting viewers has taken it to a new level.

I think Simon needs to take a reality check - he is always saying that the show belongs to the public and that he has great faith in the public and that they usually vote in the right way ... if that is the case Simon then why keep arguably the most unpopular contestant ever in? Surely this is prolonging HER agony, giving her more negative press, building on the bandwagon of hate etc etc etc, this cannot be good for her in any way

If you are in the bottom 2 3 weeks out of 5 then what chance do you actually have of selling records in the future?

And regarding Cole, well I do find it unfair that Dermot went to her 2nd, she should have been last so that if 3 majority decisions had been made she would be spared but if not then she could have forced the deadlock. HOWEVER ... you are a judge, there to make critiques (which musically and vocally you dont do), you are there to make a decision on who out of the bottom 2 should go home (which last night you didnt do). You get paid millions, have a huge budget for your hair . makeup / clothes yet flit off and leave your acts midweek for your own personal gain without a word to them ... IMO the backlash is deserved on her

[johnx]

What does she have to do to get elliminated.Shes fluffed lines of the song at her audition,judges house and now in a sing off.People slag off Wagner but at least he finishes the song-and Louis usually gives him two to perform on the night.Flopping to her backside like a petulant child while pleading with us not to give up on her.Katie,you are all sizzle and no steak-a complete chancer of the first order.

Looks like Simon was engineering a fix to keep her in which Cheryl played along with.Dermot usually comes to the mentor last if both their acts are in the bottom 2.This would most likely have sent katie packing.

[nanaimo]

all true

[bbfan1991]

Peeps should have voted for TreyC more then:p.