Poll:If there is a 5th judge who would you like it to be???

[Legend killer]

For me it is Katy Perry all the way :blush:

[Niamh.]

Katy would be good

[Novo]

Chico

[King Gizzard]

The same with Cheryl and Danii in relation to Jay Kays valid comments, how the **** could Katy judge someone else?

Probably Gary Barlow

[Jordan.]

Katy Perry :worship:

[bbfan1991]

Katy Perry and Nicole to replace Cheryl and Dannii:p.

[Patrick]

Pixie Lott.

[nanaimo]

legend killer for me :)

[Stacey.]

Sharon Osbourne <3

Or Katy Perry.

[Mystic Mock]

the legend killer.:dance:

[Maia]

The Legend Killer; or

Pixie Lott.

this.

[Mr XcX]

By other you mean me of course.

[Legend killer]

legend killer for me :)

the legend killer.:dance:

The Legend Killer; or



this.

PMSL If i get the job i will make sure to give each of you a mention on my first live show

[nanaimo]

PMSL If i get the job i will make sure to give each of you a mention on my first live show

i can arrange some fixing if needed :dance:

[Legend killer]

i can arrange some fixing if needed :dance:

Will keep that in mind lol :devil:

[Shaun]

Other: Shirley Phelps.

[Beastie]

Katie Price.

[Livia]

I'd like it to be someone who knows about the music business and isn't afraid to tell someone that they suck. But I guess if there was a 5th judge we'd end up with someone else who spouts the usual old cliches... you owned the stage... you made it your own... you're what this show is all about... you nailed it... etc.

[tate]

Gary Barlow for me ... multi talented within the pop arena, sings, writes, plays instruments, knows all about stage oresence and performance, produces etc etc etc

He would be perfect but I doubt he would have the space in his diary to commit

[Princess]

I love that Gaz is an option,obviously Mr. Barlow although I'd rather it was Jason or Mark :p You know the amount of TT fans who would audition just to see Gary though? Feck loads.

[cub]

From that selection - Gary Barlow.

With Katy Perry or Nichole Scherzinger it would be too unbalanced with Dannii and Cheryl. And yet another fashion contestant.

Another Judge would have to be younger and male.

[_Seth]

Sharon Osbourne.

[nanaimo]

Billy Idol

[Lee.]

I would love it if Nicole became a judge.. I thought she did a great job before.

...and Katy Perry? Nooooooooooooooooooo!! After her erm "interesting" performance a few weeks ago, I don't think she should be permitted to judge talent! :nono:

[nanaimo]

Nicole is miles better than Cheryl, think she was very honest judging and is a better singer :)

[dannyboy]

Sharon Osbourne. Or failing that, Pixie Lott cos she's lovely! :)

NOT Katy Perry. That woman does ma tits in! Lol.

[Legend killer]

I would love it if Nicole became a judge.. I thought she did a great job before.

...and Katy Perry? Nooooooooooooooooooo!! After her erm "interesting" performance a few weeks ago, I don't think she should be permitted to judge talent! :nono:

lol TBF Cheryl is on the panel and she is not even half the singer Katy is , also she is nowhere as hot as her either

[Lee.]

lol TBF Cheryl is on the panel and she is not even half the singer Katy is , also she is nowhere as hot as her either

:xyxwave: Pfft! Have a word with yourself!! I'm not a huge Cheryl fan but to give her her due, she did win a smiilar type competition and she is fairly hot?!

Katy Perry is ambarrassingly bad when she attempts to sing.. and I kinda think she looks a bit vacant, if you know what I mean? :)

[Legend killer]

:xyxwave: Pfft! Have a word with yourself!! I'm not a huge Cheryl fan but to give her her due, she did win a smiilar type competition and she is fairly hot?!

Katy Perry is ambarrassingly bad when she attempts to sing.. and I kinda think she looks a bit vacant, if you know what I mean? :)

Yes she did win that competition but let's be honest she didnt win it for her angel like voice , it was becasue of the way she looked pure and simple

And as for the Vacant comment :bawling: No she doesn't lol

[fancydressmasks]

Nicole Scherzinger - I thought she was great, grew to really like her during her time as a judge. I didn't see Katy Perry though, so don't know how good she was.

[Z]

A young male, somebody who's just generally a lot more relevant than Simon and Louis in terms of relating to popular culture. I think part of the reason why Cheryl's had three good years in a row is that she knows what to look for in a contestant and their song choices; she knows what young people want to see. I don't think any of the options in the poll are any good. I think I should be the 5th X Factor judge; I mean I've contributed nothing to the music industry but that doesn't stop me having an opinion :D

[Adamw92]

Nicole Scherzinger

[Danielle1232]

Pixie Lott Or Katy Perry.

[fruit_cake]

Legend Killer please

[james130]

Everyone said Nicole was best but I thought Katy was brilliant and she made it much more entertaining.
Get rid of Cheryl and replace her with Katy.

Although I have the horrible feeling that Simon's gonna get rid of Louis and Danni.
Not bothered about Louis but Danni is the only one who makes truthful and constructive points.

[Jords]

Nicole!!!

[CaraRawr]

Katy Perry OBVIOUSLY. :lovedup: :lovedup: