I can see Katie staying again this week.

[Lewis.]

I've got a good feeling that the bottom 2 will be Katie and either Paije or Wagner. If it's Paije he will probably stay, but if Katie does a good enough survival song then she could stay. And would the judges really save Wagner over Katie? Not after the Jedward controversy last year, surely?

[Shaun]

They'll have a difficult time justifying saving someone who's been in the bottom 2, probably actually bottom 1, for a 4th time.

[Thotmas]

She would fit in well in bands like the sundays, or cardigans. That's the only way her voice might be tolerated. she should know her place like Aiden learned his earlier on. Again this is not a trial show. you beta know yourselves lil girls.

[Stacey.]

I think she'll go this week, her performance was quite forgetful.

[Jordan.]

I think she'd stay over Paije and Wagner.

[Lewis.]

They'll have a difficult time justifying saving someone who's been in the bottom 2, probably actually bottom 1, for a 4th time.

I think that they'd have a harder job saving Wagner over her. If she's in the B2 with Paije then she'd probably go.

[Thotmas]

I think she'll go this week, her performance was quite forgetful.

as cher as it's the same every week. a bit of singing then shrieky rapping.

[Smithy]

Quite a few were crap this week, although they may question her popularity and send her home because she's been in the bottom 2 four times

[dannyboy]

i dont think she did one of the bottom 2 perfromances tonight really. But it certainly wasn't great. She shoulda done 'the bitch is back'. in what was a pretty meh live show overall, i think that couldve stood out and got her some votes. but apparently she wouldnt sing it. silly goose.

[Shaun]

I think that they'd have a harder job saving Wagner over her. If she's in the B2 with Paije then she'd probably go.

even so - he's got more support than her and has consistently done for the past 6 weeks. It'd be unfair on the people voting for him for her to survive.

[_Seth]

Well it looks like it's not a double, so I think she'll stay. :(

[nanaimo]

Not a katie fan but i am being honest when i say she was dreadful tonight

[Vicky.]

Would be fun seeing them trying to justify their decision again if she is in the bottom and they save her again...

I cant see her gaining much support this week though, not with that performance. So its pretty much certain she will be in the bottom :/

[Tom]

I want a Wagner v Katie bottom 2 at some point and lets see how they justify who they save

[Novo]

Before tonight i was 80% she is going now i am about 50%

[Stacey.]

as cher as it's the same every week. a bit of singing then shrieky rapping.

Cher varies it.. like she does the rapping one week, then the singing, then puts them together.

She doesn't shriek :pat:

[Merry Mockmas]

i think katie will hit the bottom 3,dodge bottom of the votes but i think the judges will vote her off.

[Novo]

i think katie will hit the bottom 3,dodge bottom of the votes but i think the judges will vote her off.

Aiden was ****e this week

should be him going if anything

[Pyramid*]

Not a katie fan but i am being honest when i say she was dreadful tonight


this.

She really hasn't got a versatile voice, she was bloody awful tonight.

oh... to Philp - Dermot said at the end it was a single,not a double... I reckon the 'double' is nothing more than rumour.

[nanaimo]

Aiden was ****e this week

should be him going if anything

so you honestly think Katie was better than Aiden tonight, i know you are a fan but as a music listener, do you really think that?

[Novo]

so you honestly think Katie was better than Aiden tonight, i know you are a fan but as a music listener, do you really think that?

Sounded much much much better to listen to.. actually looked like Aiden was dying in some parts

[Pyramid*]

Sounded much much much better to listen to.. actually looked like Aiden was dying in some parts


Oh, and Katie didn't try to pull that little stunt last week with her 'fake' legs not holding her up ala collapse onto knees on stage. Pfft.

[Novo]

Oh, and Katie didn't try to pull that little stunt last week with her 'fake' legs not holding her up ala collapse onto knees on stage. Pfft.

She had cramp show some mercy you horrid beast

[Pyramid*]

She had cramp show some mercy you horrid beast

~ah so we can add that to her list of 'problems' as well as faux fainting attacks, panic attacks, anxiety, breakdowns blah blah blah:sleep:

[Novo]

~ah so we can add that to her list of 'problems' as well as faux fainting attacks, panic attacks, anxiety, breakdowns blah blah blah:sleep:

You are one horrible man

:bored:

But Katie will have the last laugh as always

[Pyramid*]

You are one horrible man

:bored:

But Katie will have the last laugh as always


And clearly, you aren't as smart as you think you are. :)

[Novo]

And clearly, you aren't as smart as you think you are. :)

Beast*

[Merry Mockmas]

Aiden was ****e this week

should be him going if anything

i thought he was good and definetly better than katie imo.

[Pyramid*]

Beast*

Yes, I agree, Katie is a beast. She does look very peculiar !:joker:

[Shaun]

-enters this thread into the 'Lamest Trade of Insults' 2010 Competition-

[Pyramid*]

i thought he was good and definetly better than katie imo.

I love his 'Shirley Bassey' type mouth style when he sings !! He's definately got more depth to him than the Weasel, that's for sure.

[Lewis.]

I think Katie is amazing, personally. She really does seem like she was 'born to be on stage'... as cliché as it sounds. Her voice has such a lovely tone. It's a shame that the public just have not 'got' her.

[nanaimo]

Yes, I agree, Katie is a beast. She does look very peculiar !:joker:

http://img.thesun.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00897/SNN2826B-280_897461a.jpg

yes and here is the evidence:dance:

[Pyramid*]

-enters this thread into the 'Lamest Trade of Insults' 2010 Competition-

LOL :joker:

Katie is lame, that's for sure

[Pyramid*]

http://img.thesun.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00897/SNN2826B-280_897461a.jpg

yes and here is the evidence:dance:

she's scrubbed up pretty well there.

Oh wait.....................


:devil:

['Conor]

if she survives a 4th time in the bottom it will actually be laughable

[Pyramid*]

if she survives a 4th time in the bottom it will actually be laughable

It will be very interesting to see if Simon stands by what the said last week about what the public want. You don't get voted into the bottom two, four times, if you are liked.

One thing's for sure: it's rigged, that's certain.

[joeysteele]

I think if Katie is in the bottom 2 again and it seems now there isn't a double elimination so this is the chance to get her on the tour, but, it will be grossly unfair and in fact unacceptable to not give some other act their first 2nd chance from the bottom 2 when Katie has already had 3 2nd chances.
To over any other act, to give her a 4th 2nd chance would be to totally discredit the X Factor.
However I think they will save her again! Unless Aiden, Matt, Rebecca or One Direction are the the other act in the bottom 2.

[Pyramid*]

I think if Katie is in the bottom 2 again and it seems now there isn't a double elimination so this is the chance to get her on the tour, but, it will be grossly unfair and in fact unacceptable to not give some other act their first 2nd chance from the bottom 2 when Katie has already had 3 2nd chances.
To over any other act, to give her a 4th 2nd chance would be to totally discredit the X Factor.
However I think they will save her again! Unless Aiden, Matt, Rebecca or One Direction are the the other act in the bottom 2.

XFactor was discredited a long time ago. To emphasise that point, 2 females who couldn't make the grade at bootcamp were put through - with one of them being so unpopular (Katie) that she's been in the bottom 2 for 3 weeks. Proves she should never have been put through.

[joeysteele]

Aiden was good again this week, he at least varied the song and didn't just sing it like Elton John did, I only wish Dannii had got hold of the version by Kate Bush and used that arrangement of it for him.
Not that much different to the original but it would have been great for his style of performing.He could have intensified it easier.

Is it just me but did it seem like everyone had to rush through the songs tonight or is it that Elton John songs were ill suited to near all the acts.

[fancydressmasks]

I think she'd stay over Wagner. Not sure about Paije. I'm glad it's a single this week though. I think they should forget doubles and just have a massive final.

[Merry Mockmas]

Aiden was good again this week, he at least varied the song and didn't just sing it like Elton John did, I only wish Dannii had got hold of the version by Kate Bush and used that arrangement of it for him.
Not that much different to the original but it would have been great for his style of performing.He could have intensified it easier.

Is it just me but did it seem like everyone had to rush through the songs tonight or is it that Elton John songs were ill suited to near all the acts.

i actually thought they were rushed because paije was getting into his performance and then it ended shortly afterwards.

[fancydressmasks]

Aiden was good again this week, he at least varied the song and didn't just sing it like Elton John did, I only wish Dannii had got hold of the version by Kate Bush and used that arrangement of it for him.
Not that much different to the original but it would have been great for his style of performing.He could have intensified it easier.

Is it just me but did it seem like everyone had to rush through the songs tonight or is it that Elton John songs were ill suited to near all the acts.

I agree actually. They all seemed really rushed, it was kind of odd. None of them worked at all for me, really.