They should do a Christmas charity single...

[Jack_]

...instead of the normal covers they do. I've had the idea before but after seeing this on a music channel earlier it reminded me:

L8141iRI3is

Classic.

Or if not have the winner's single as a Christmas song. Thoughts?

[Mystic Mock]

i agree as i think a christmas charity single would be a huge hit.

[Patrick]

I'm a Yeo Valley for Christmas #1 2010 Supporter you see, but if the winner's song was to be Christmassy, it would be the first time in about 10 years we got a Christmas Song as Christmas Number 1, It still bugs me why the ******ing dolts behind last year's 2009 Campaign didn't pick a good Christmas song rather than some vile American rockers. :rolleyes:

But yes, If they were to release a Christmas Winners song I'd so support that rather than our Yeo Valley Campaign.

[Tom]

The level of talent on Pop Idol was dreadful

When is this years charity single out?

[Niamh.]

The level of talent on Pop Idol was dreadful

When is this years charity single out?

Will Young is brilliant and still around too

[Tom]

Will Young is brilliant and still around too

I meant as a whole

A fair bit of the Pop Idol lot are still about e.g. Sam & Mark and Michelle McManus are doing TV presenting

[_Seth]

I thought they always did. Maybe not a Christmas charity single, but still one for charity.

[Jack_]

The level of talent on Pop Idol was dreadful

When is this years charity single out?

Tomorrow to download, Monday physically. They're performing it tomorrow night.

I thought they always did. Maybe not a Christmas charity single, but still one for charity.

They do. But a Christmas charity single has never been done on X Factor - that's why I made the suggestion in this thread.

[Niamh.]

I meant as a whole

A fair bit of the Pop Idol lot are still about e.g. Sam & Mark and Michelle McManus are doing TV presenting

I remember Simon being so pissed off that Gareth Gates didn't win, that was the last time I voted on one of those shows. It shows that Simons eye for talent may not be as good as he thinks, Will did something after that is so unusual for a contestant from one of these shows, he's actually lasted more than a year

[Niamh.]

I think a Christmas song would be a great idea Jack