Shock Elimination Instore Tomorrow?

[Jords]

I think most people thought the bottom 2 would be made of Katie, Wagner and Paije but after tonight I think theyre all safe!

Katie - new image, last performance, 1 of her best.
Paije - his best performance (him and Katie both out singing the front runners).
Wagner - Cheryl's 'attack' on him will rake in the votes.

Which leaves Matt, Rebecca, Mary, One Direction and Cher, all considered worthy as finalists unlike the other 3 in most cases.

[Smithy]

tbh I think it could be Cher, she was on early and rather forgettable

[Patrick]

Rebecca will be in the Bottom 2.

If it's Cher I'm slitting my wrists x

[Novo]

Mary/Wagner/Paije/Katie

It will be any of those two but Katie will be saved against those 3 so it's okay

[Patrick]

tbh I think it could be Cher, she was on early and rather forgettable

Cher is the most iconic contestant of this whole series, hardly forgettable.

And she has a massive fan base.

But if you're talking about tonight, in order of who sang then yeah.

[Locke.]

Mary and Paije bottom 2 I think.

It's kinda unpredictable this week cos the favourites were all on first, but I think most their fans will be voting this week because of that. Paije was great but I think he has a small fanbase, Wagner has been saved thanks to Cheryl.

[Smithy]

Cher is the most iconic contestant of this whole series, hardly forgettable.

And she has a massive fan base.

But if you're talking about tonight, in order of who sang then yeah.

Iconic?? :laugh3:
Ok, she isn't iconic in anyway shape or form, she's one of the most talked about contestants this year of course, but that doesn't necessarily mean she's safe.

[red]

cher, matt & 1D are going nowere ..rebecca im not sure about

[ElProximo]

I haven't been following the polls but it was refreshing to see the public had spotted Aiden and Katie as the bottom two (despite Judges acting like they were good).

IF the public is still using this reasonable judgment then 1 Direction ought to be gone. I actually like Paige,
but,
Its possible Paige is one that hasn't quite fully 'connected' with any particular fan base?
Since he is not a Matt or Rebecca (in terms of singing skills) then yeah.. I could see him end up down there.

Katie should also find herself at the bottom again.

Of course the problem is that you get to these 'fan bases' and I'm told the Boy Band has the power of screaming phone-happy teenagers. So they may very well be safe.

I'm also hearing Mary has a big strong core fan-base? So she is probably safe.

Matt and Rebecca are so fantastically good and a league above the whole competition that I cannot imagine them anywhere but the finals.

[Z]

Good performances don't translate into safety though; there have been countless occasions where one or both acts in the bottom two were universally praised by the judges and then found themselves in the sing off. I'm thinking Paije and maybe Mary will be the bottom two; I think Katie will reel in enough sympathy votes to survive this week and Wagner's fanbase seems to grow stronger every time he gets criticised or something hypocritical happens.

[Zippy]

Rebecca kind of annoyed me on Xtra factor by saying she'd murdered a Beatles classic. Firstly, she really wasnt that bad at all. Just relatively below her usual high standards.

But to put such negativity out there about herself aint gonna do her any favours with voters. She needs to wise up.

[Tom4784]

It'll be Paije & Wagner/Katie.

[Iceman]

It'll be Paije & Wagner/Katie.

This

[ElProximo]

Rebecca kind of annoyed me on Xtra factor by saying she'd murdered a Beatles classic. Firstly, she really wasnt that bad at all. Just relatively below her usual high standards.

But to put such negativity out there about herself aint gonna do her any favours with voters. She needs to wise up.

Good point.
She was just a little too 'samey' (to borrow a phrase from another member) and just a little too pedestrian with it. But as you say it was, in fact, very very good.. just a smidgen below her usual great high standards.

So yeah, no need for her to beat herself up for being 'just excellent' instead of 'very excellent'.

[Mystic Mock]

aiden was meant to be the shock elimination,although i wouldnt be surprised at a predictable and a shocker in the bottom two.

[Locke.]

Aiden was not a shock

[Mystic Mock]

Aiden was not a shock

so you wouldnt call dodging the first 5 weeks without hitting the bottom two was meant to be a big contender to win and then gets lesser votes than katie waissel a shock?

[Jords]

so you wouldnt call dodging the first 5 weeks without hitting the bottom two was meant to be a big contender to win and then gets lesser votes than katie waissel a shock?

Did you not see his performance? Shocking.

[bbfan1991]

I hope it's not Cher, Katie or Wagner:). If Mary got to the final they would have her duet with SuBo which is my worst nightmare:shocked:. One Direction will be there till the final:bawling:.

[Locke.]

so you wouldnt call dodging the first 5 weeks without hitting the bottom two was meant to be a big contender to win and then gets lesser votes than katie waissel a shock?

He wasn't a big contender to win, other than his few fans everyone else has known for week that the big contenders are Matt, Rebecca, One Direction and Cher, no on else has had a chance to win for a while now.

[Jamietwo]

this is where it gets interesting, especially if wagner is not in the bottom two

[Z]

He wasn't a big contender to win, other than his few fans everyone else has known for week that the big contenders are Matt, Rebecca, One Direction and Cher, no on else has had a chance to win for a while now.

I agree, I think it was shocking that Aiden went the week he did, but he was never going to get anywhere near the final. He'd have been gone this week or next if he was still in.

[Adamw92]

As long as Rebecca is safe I'll be happy :D

[Vladimir]

As long as Rebecca is safe I'll be happy :D

this.

[MeMyselfAndI]

so you wouldnt call dodging the first 5 weeks without hitting the bottom two was meant to be a big contender to win and then gets lesser votes than katie waissel a shock?

i know
ray quinn was in bottom 2 in week 5. and he came 2nd! So Aiden easily could of came 2nd or even won

[ElProximo]

i know
ray quinn was in bottom 2 in week 5. and he came 2nd! So Aiden easily could of came 2nd or even won

No, never in one million years. He was terrible. Sorry.

[joeysteele]

Mary/Wagner/Paije/Katie

It will be any of those two but Katie will be saved against those 3 so it's okay

I really liked Katie last night, she did that song exactly as I like it sung because the real strength of the lyrics are evident when its sung as a ballad.

I still think Katie should not be in the competition though.
However,I actually don't think Katie will be in the bottom 2 but even if she was I am reminded of Ms Cole saying to Louis, watch out she's like a cat, they have 9 lives and she's only used 4. So on that I guess if she was in the bottom again, she would be saved 'again' against likely all but One Direction.

[joeysteele]

so you wouldnt call dodging the first 5 weeks without hitting the bottom two was meant to be a big contender to win and then gets lesser votes than katie waissel a shock?

You are right Jedward f, it was massive shock Aiden went, even all the people around me at Uni who didn't like Aiden at all were stunned he went out last week and even more so that he had less votes that Katie.

Also everyone including presenters of most TV programmes who comment on X Factor were also stunned and saw it a as a great shock that Aiden went out,even the man who let it happen, Simon Cowell, said after last weeks shock result no one can be considered safe.

[Damaris]

I can imagine the voting being like this

1st-Matt
2nd-One Direction
3rd-Rebecca
4th-Paije
5th-Wanger
6th-Cher
7th-Katie
8th-Mary

[Jack_]

I imagine it being this:

#1 - One Direction
#2 - Matt
#3 - Cher
#4 - Rebecca
#5 - Wagner
#6 - Mary
#7 - Paije
#8 - Katie

[joeysteele]

I can't see Katie in the bottom 2 this week,I don't think it will matter if she is, unless its against One Direction, she will be saved again over anyone else,even Matt.

[Z]

I really think this week is wide open; Paije obviously has a larger fanbase than anyone has given him credit for, Katie will be benefitting from the sympathy rebound vote and she actually sang well tonight, Wagner will benefit from the fact that Cheryl tried to shoot him down and he handled it well and responded diplomatically - I really think that Mary and the four "favourites" are all at just as much risk as the three weak links, I'm thinking it could be Mary vs Cher tonight.

[Smithy]

tbh I think it could be Cher, she was on early and rather forgettable
*saw it coming*
Rebecca will be in the Bottom 2.

If it's Cher I'm slitting my wrists x

*fetches knife*

[Patrick]

Cher's bollocked.