Katie vs. Cher

[Jords]

If both were to be in the bottom 2, who would you want out?

Seems a few members think this will be a possibilty, and both girls have been quite controversial for whatever reasons so would be interesting who majority prefer.

Cher out for me.

[Novo]

They are my two favourites and wouldn't want either of them to go but if i had to pick it would have to be Cher

[Mystic Mock]

katie to go,she shouldnt even be there still.

[Stacey.]

Katie.

There's only room for one Queen.

[Locke.]

This won't happen, but if it did it would have to be Katie that I'd want out.

[Smithy]

Probably Cher, her fans are the most ignorant on here

[Mystic Mock]

Probably Cher, her fans are the most ignorant on here

this.

[Vicky.]

Katie...shes outstayed her welcome. Dont particularly like cher, but she is better than katie, and there is no justification for katie being saved for a fifth time. none at all.

[King Gizzard]

Deffinetly Cher

[Zippy]

Katie because she doesnt stand much chance of a career in music. But Cher does with the right songs.

[joeysteele]

Katie because she is totally talentless, Cher has some aspects of originality but yes, definately Katie to go over Cher.

[Jordan.]

Hope this never happens but Katie.

[fruit_cake]

I can't decide.. I like both but I don't think either is very talented tbh

[Legend killer]

i h8 both but i think i would prefer Mini-Me to go first

[fruit_cake]

I think Cheryl would keep Cher

[Stacey.]

I think Cheryl would keep Cher

I actually don't think she'd choose, she said she never would again if she had the choice, like last time.

[fruit_cake]

she wouldn't choose, but she'd want Cher to stay

[Legend killer]

I think Cheryl would keep Cher

Nah she wld just refuse to vote again :sleep:

[fruit_cake]

ok ok she wouldn't choose but she prefers Cher I mean

[Novo]

Cheryl will concentrate more on Rebecca now that Katie and Cher have been in the bottom two :/

[30stone]

I like Katie but yeah shed have to go..

[Mystic Mock]

Cheryl will concentrate more on Rebecca now that Katie and Cher have been in the bottom two :/

especially with katie still there.:joker:

[Novo]

especially with katie still there.:joker:

Katie is the Gem in the Competition she will be okay

[Mystic Mock]

Katie is the Gem in the Competition she will be okay

:laugh3: her track record says the opposite,bottom two 4 times.

[Novo]

:laugh3: her track record says the opposite,bottom two 4 times.

Record breaker that is what she is and she is still standing and going strong

[Mr XcX]

Cher please.

Queen BIATCH Katie needs to stay!!

[nanaimo]

i have to agree about Cheryl getting on the bandwagon now with rebecca, cheryl wants to win and katie is not going to do it for her and Cher in bottom two this week, is probably worrying her a bit, so do the right thing cheryl and back the best singer on the xf this year, you might redeem yourself a tiny bit.

[MTVN]

Like Cher, Love Katie. So Cher would have to go.

[_Seth]

I hate Katie quite a lot less, so definitely Cher.

[Callum]

Katie because I think she has the better voice and Cher comes across slightly cocky sometimes but I'm still a fan

[M X]

Neither really, but Cher.

[Niamh.]

Katie to go, Cher has a far superior voice imo

[stewart64]

Katie to go, Cher has a far superior voice imo

But then again Katie has the personality. So she just edges for me.

Sadly they will both struggle from here on in, they have the same fans in common. Matt, by contrast, as the only remaining male solo vocalist has a free pass to the final.

[Niamh.]

But then again Katie has the personality. So she just edges for me.

Sadly they will both struggle from here on in, they have the same fans in common. Matt, by contrast, as the only remaining male solo vocalist has a free pass to the final.

lmao, personality?! if you like annoying attention seekers than yeah I suppose........

Matt will be in the final because he's one of the best (well thee best imo) left

[stewart64]

lmao, personality?! if you like annoying attention seekers than yeah I suppose........

Matt will be in the final because he's one of the best (well thee best imo) left


No doubting that Matt is best vocally. Not surprised he led and ended the charity single, where was Wagner by the way.

I don't think Dannii has done a good mentoring job, having lost three already including the early favourite Aiden. Matt should be shining more than he is.

[Niamh.]

No doubting that Matt is best vocally. Not surprised he led and ended the charity single, where was Wagner by the way.

I don't think Dannii has done a good mentoring job, having lost three already including the early favourite Aiden. Matt should be shining more than he is.

I think he's doing well and she's doing well with him. In fact if she saves his best performances for the last few shows it would work more in his favour than having him peak too early

[Dr.Gonzo]

Katie or Cher? Not arsed at all. I'm indifferent about them.

[Z]

Hated them both to begin with, both have had a couple of performances that I liked; so based entirely on whose music taste I prefer, I'd rather have Katie than Cher.

[Adamw92]

Out of them 2 it would have to be Cher to go for me.

[cub]

I like them both, but Katie is the more interesting.

[fuzzylovin]

cher to go i dislike her singing and even more her rapping, Katie isnt a brilliant singer but shes better than that.