Matt is by far the best singer on the show...

[Stevep]

No doubt about it for me, his voice is so powerful and rich with emotion. Tonights performance coupled with that one he did two or three weeks ago have got to be up there with the best performances ive seen on the show.

[Kerry]

His voice is amazing. When he sang 'the first time' I must have listened to it about 60 times over and over on YouTube

[fruit_cake]

Harry is better than Matt

[Mystic Mock]

aidens madworld is the best performance of this series imo.

[Jordan.]

True but he is so bland.

[Stacey.]

I think Rebecca's the best singer, then Matt.

But he does have a really good voice, he's just normally boring.

[Ninastar]

I agree, but he isn't my favourite. I can love him for his voice, but thats about it for me

[fruit_cake]

aidens madworld is the best performance of this series imo.

Rebecca's wicked game, then Aiden's madworld for me!

[Supermum]

Matt & Rebecca but Matt has better songs cos he has a better mentor!! Cheryl is concentrating on the hood rat & bruce forsythe's love child

[bbfan1991]

Danyl> Jamie> Matt> Olly> Paije> Aiden

My personal opinion;).

[Niamh.]

Matts second song tonight was thee best performance of the series so far (imo) even surpased First time

[Lee.]

Nights in White Satin is one song that makes me shudder.. I can't stand it. Tonight, however, I loved it! :D

[bbfan1991]

Seriously does anyone want Matt to work under Cowell?, he ruined Jamie last year by trying to turn him into a popstar when he was at his best with Rock, he's a total hypocrite and Matt would be better under a different recording label IMO:)...

[Pyramid*]

Nights in White Satin is one song that makes me shudder.. I can't stand it. Tonight, however, I loved it! :D

He did sing it spectacularly well. Fantastic singer and seems to be quite a humble chap into the bargain. He's a delight to watch and to listen to. :blush:

[fruit_cake]

Seriously does anyone want Matt to work under Cowell?, he ruined Jamie last year by trying to turn him into a popstar when he was at his best with Rock, he's a total hypocrite and Matt would be better under a different recording label IMO:)...

Simon only likes them while they have to lick his arse.. once they get famous enough to go it alone he gets competitve and bitchy with them.

[Lee.]

He did sing it spectacularly well. Fantastic singer and seems to be quite a humble chap into the bargain. He's a delight to watch and to listen to. :blush:

I think I love him :lovedup:

[Niamh.]

I think I love him :lovedup:

you should join the fan club:hugesmile:

[bbfan1991]

Simon only likes them while they have to lick his arse.. once they get famous enough to go it alone he gets competitve and bitchy with them.

Indeed it's just about the cash/controversy/marketability etc, we hardly hear a word out of his mouth about his pet Leona, it's more about Alexandra and JLS but that will be changed into One Direction till next year:joker:.

[Stevep]

Seriously does anyone want Matt to work under Cowell?, he ruined Jamie last year by trying to turn him into a popstar when he was at his best with Rock, he's a total hypocrite and Matt would be better under a different recording label IMO:)...

I agree Cowell would ruin what he is about, but i think there is some sort of clause when you join the x factor that once you appear on the show you cant join another label untill 3 years have passed. Im not entirely sure that this is the case but i remember hearing something along those lines last year or so.

If that is the case, then he has no choice but to let Cowell take control over him. Otherwise its go into hibernation for 3 years, accept that the public will forget about you and try to make a fresh start from that. Which of course would be extremly difficult.

[Mystic Mock]

Nah. :xyxwave:

Open your ears.

this.:hugesmile:

[fruit_cake]

give Harry a chance and you'll see:thumbs:

[Stacey.]

this.:hugesmile:

Are you a Matt fan or Wagner fan? Make your mind up.

[Mystic Mock]

Are you a Matt fan or Wagner fan? Make your mind up.

both.:joker:

[Niamh.]

give Harry a chance and you'll see:thumbs:

Harry is by far the best singer in One Direction, he would have done well on his own

[Tom4784]

I'm starting to get bored of him again, I liked Goodbye Yellow Brick Road but I thought he was disappointing this week. Good singer yes but he's showing little else at the moment.

[Mystic Mock]

i noticed what time it is,can anybody guess what time it is? well its chico time.:hugesmile:

[Stacey.]

both.:joker:

There's quite a difference between them. Matt's miles ahead.

[Mystic Mock]

There's quite a difference between them. Matt's miles ahead.

in vocals but i think wagner did creep good tonight and he has alot of stage pressence.

[Stacey.]

in vocals but i think wagner did creep good tonight and he has alot of stage pressence.

In that song he didn't do anything, he just stood there. D:

It was the best performance of his ever though actually... he sounded much better than normal.

Still, Matt's better in every way.

[Tom4784]

Chels and Fruitcake, stop it.

[Pyramid*]

I think I love him :lovedup:

Just burst out laughing ....that's funny and you are mad! :blush:

I can see his allure though !! :blush:

[Lee.]

Just burst out laughing ....that's funny and you are mad! :blush:

I can see his allure though !! :blush:

http://i83.photobucket.com/albums/j295/bowen192/wibble.jpg


...and o yeah, he's HOT!!!!

[Niamh.]

I'm starting to get bored of him again, I liked Goodbye Yellow Brick Road but I thought he was disappointing this week. Good singer yes but he's showing little else at the moment.

they go and sing, not much else tbh:conf: his second song tonight was outstanding, I'd buy his album

[Stacey.]

Tonight was the first time I've actually really liked him, since like the first week of the live shows. Don't think he'll win though, but he'll probably do well anyway.

[Pyramid*]

they go and sing, not much else tbh:conf: his second song tonight was outstanding, I'd buy his album

I would too. I think he has a fab voice, and he's pretty versatile.

[Niamh.]

I would too. I think he has a fab voice, and he's pretty versatile.

and I dont say that lightly either, I've never bought an X Factor contestants music before, last I did was Will Young from Pop Idol

[ElProximo]

No doubt about it for me, his voice is so powerful and rich with emotion. Tonights performance coupled with that one he did two or three weeks ago have got to be up there with the best performances ive seen on the show.

Rebecca is right there with Matt but you are right he is astonishing.

Put it this way - If you wanted to make an example of the very very best in singing and what is the very worst on stage?
Go to Youtube X-Factor and watch Matt and Katie back-to-back.

The gap between them is the gap between 'lowest requirements' and 'ideal excellence'.

[Pyramid*]

and I dont say that lightly either, I've never bought an X Factor contestants music before, last I did was Will Young from Pop Idol


Will Young was good, absolutely no denying that.

[Niamh.]

Rebecca is right there with Matt but you are right he is astonishing.

Put it this way - If you wanted to make an example of the very very best in singing and what is the very worst on stage?
Go to Youtube X-Factor and watch Matt and Katie back-to-back.

The gap between them is the gap between 'lowest requirements' and 'ideal excellence'.

Matt and rebecca are both fantastic, she always gets it right, he doesn't but when he does he surpasses her imo which is why he's just about ahead for me

[Tom4784]

they go and sing, not much else tbh:conf: his second song tonight was outstanding, I'd buy his album

Anyone can just sing though, he's ten a penny at the moment. I want to see something unique to him and his own style but nothing is sticking out except for being a good singer. If he wins or otherwise he'll be a massive flop because from what I see there's nothing there.

I'd probably take him out of my sig if I could be bothered to, he's been disappointing too many times now.

[ElProximo]

Matt and rebecca are both fantastic, she always gets it right, he doesn't but when he does he surpasses her imo which is why he's just about ahead for me

Yep, and Rebecca has, at times, squeaked to my top spot (though they are very close imo),
but,
Matt, tonight, though I wasn't crazy about "i love rocknroll" he just about won X-Factor with 'Knights in White Satin.'
I think I just saw the winning performance. Amazing.

To put this in perspective (speaking of the gaps in talent) this is what I see when I watch X-Factor (for weeks now).

There is an amateur talent show. Pop Idol wannabe competition.

Each week, 'last years winner' Rebecca is 'returning' to show off what the best talent winners can become and make of themselves!

Each week they have a guest appearance by a top singer and international recording star - Matt Cardle.

Afterward everyone in the talent show wants to get Matt Cardles autograph and ask Rebecca lots of questions about what its like to start a career.

This is what I feel I may as well be watching now if you see what I mean?

[fruit_cake]

Matt was definitely back to his best with his Knights in White Satin

[Dr.Gonzo]

Big fan of Matt. I wasn't really into his first song--I just didn't feel it. But his second song was one of my favourites I've ever seen on the show.

[Crimson Dynamo]

No doubt about it for me, his voice is so powerful and rich with emotion. Tonights performance coupled with that one he did two or three weeks ago have got to be up there with the best performances ive seen on the show.

thankfully it is called the x factor and not the singing contest

[Stevep]

thankfully it is called the x factor and not the singing contest

I agree, 'the singing contest' would stink as a title for the show...