Take That as a 4 or 5?

[Princess]

Do you prefer Take That as a four piece or a five piece? Or if you don't like do you think they're better as a 4 or 5? Just out of wonderment.

[Iceman]

5, I remember them as a 5 piece and IMO they're better that way.

[Stacey.]

I like them better as a five piece, Robbie's my favourite member of the group. :love:

[Smithy]

4, although they were overrated then, they're even more overrated now as a 5

[ILoveTRW]

Couldn't give a ****

[Princess]

Four,obviously.

[Beastie]

Four piece.

Robbie is better going solo.

[Z]

Much better as a four piece IMO!

[Jords]

4!

[Jack_]

Five.

[Malza]

Hard to say, I really loved the old 5 member stuff from Take that, and also the songs they did with only 4 of them...
But to be honest, the latest new is disappointing

So, I liked 5, I liked 4, but don't like them to be 5 again

[Locke.]

Don't mind really, I prefer Robbie's solo music to their work as a 5 piece though. (from what I've heard anyway).

I just want them to split up tbh so Mark releases another solo album.

[Princess]

Don't mind really, I prefer Robbie's solo music to their work as a 5 piece though. (from what I've heard anyway).

I just want them to split up tbh so Mark releases another solo album.

I can never see Mark realeasing another solo album,much as I love his two later albums.

[Locke.]

I can never see Mark realeasing another solo album,much as I love his two later albums.

It has said for ages on his wiki that he'd already written/recorded some songs for his next album but it's gone now :nono:

[Patrick]

Robbie and Garry.

****** the rest.

[Princess]

It has said for ages on his wiki that he'd already written/recorded some songs for his next album but it's gone now :nono:

Wiki also once said that Mark had a 18 year old daughter and that he was a squirrel farmer. Not the most reliable source going :tongue:

[Locke.]

Robbie and Garry.

****** the rest.

Mark is the best. He was on Big Brother aswell thought you would love him just for that :nono:

Listen to this great song

kCU5t1ip-To

[Visage]

4

I was never a fan of them in the 90s, but having heard their recent material they have really grown on me.

I get the excitement and nostalgia feeling as a 5 piece, but I don't think it would woke long term.

[InOne]

4.

They had a great thing when they came back as a 4 and now it's all about Robbie :bored:

[Kerry]

Not a fan but I prefer the original line up. 5 is Take That. 4 aint

[Jordan.]

4. Robbie is a twat.

[Tom4784]

4, Their new album is awful and Robbie's drug fuelled staring is off putting.

[Scarlett.]

Four definately, I even lost intrest in Robbie since he rejoined

[Lewis.]

Four. Only because I hate Robbie.

[Zippy]

They seem to be enjoying themselves more with Robbie back. Plus Robbie seems more confident on stage...I think he has big psychological issues about performing.

So five.

[Princess]

They seem to be enjoying themselves more with Robbie back. Plus Robbie seems more confident on stage...I think he has big psychological issues about performing.

So five.

They enjoyed themselves plenty before.

[Zippy]

They enjoyed themselves plenty before.

well having an old friend back makes it fresher for them and adds a whole new dynamic. I bet they enjoy it MORE now he's back.

[Marc]

Robbie is a tool.

[Pyramid*]

They seem to be enjoying themselves more with Robbie back. Plus Robbie seems more confident on stage...I think he has big psychological issues about performing.

So five.


Agree.

5.

[Stephanie]

5.