Order by weekly average positions

[James]

Here's the order based on average positions each week.

As you can see Mary is second using that method, though 2nd, 3rd, 4th are all close and Mary's position was dropping as the show went on. Pretty much everyone finished close to where they should, apart from Aiden.

http://img262.imageshack.us/img262/5251/99741.png (http://img262.imageshack.us/i/99741.png/)

I quite enjoyed making that. :blush:

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

mary 2nd :eek:

[Jessica.]

I quite enjoyed making that. :blush:

:joker::joker::joker:

[Vicky.]

So basically...as we knew, aiden had one bad week and left because of it :bored:

So much for the judges vote being to save people who had just had a bad week :laugh2:

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

So basically...as we knew, aiden had one bad week and left because of it :bored:

So much for the judges vote being to save people who had just had a bad week :laugh2:

ya then you jumped on the wagner bandwagon after that

you sure can pick em <3

0_o

[Vicky.]

ya then you jumped on the wagner bandwagon after that

you sure can pick em <3

0_o
I did not jump on any bandwagon :nono:

Wagner actually started to appeal to me before Aiden left...

[Stacey.]

Mary was so boring it's unreal, the only reason she did so well was because she had Ireland's votes too.

[Vicky.]

Mary was so boring it's unreal, the only reason she did so well was because she had Ireland's votes too.

Do you really think people from ireland vote like that?

This annoys me, especially when Louis says it all the time. Would YOU vote for someone just because they were from england? Would you refrain from voting for someone because they were from Ireland? Of course you wouldnt.

[arista]

http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Media/Pix/pictures/2010/12/13/1292259514477/The-X-Factor-voting-graph-008.jpg

From the Guardian

[Braden]

It suprises me that Matt won by quite a small margin. Considering he took over first place for all the weeks.

[Stacey.]

Do you really think people from ireland vote like that?

This annoys me, especially when Louis says it all the time. Would YOU vote for someone just because they were from england? Would you refrain from voting for someone because they were from Ireland? Of course you wouldnt.

Yeah..

Cher's from Malvern which is near me, that's part of the reason I wanted her to win even, probably wouldn't have voted as much if she hadn't lived so close.. she'd have still been my favourite though anyway if that makes sense :/

[MTVN]

Do you really think people from ireland vote like that?

This annoys me, especially when Louis says it all the time. Would YOU vote for someone just because they were from england? Would you refrain from voting for someone because they were from Ireland? Of course you wouldnt.

The majority of acts are from England though, Ireland is never represented very well comparitively, and if they only have one act in the competition it will make them more inclined to back them because she is essentially their sole representative

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

Wagner actually started to appeal to me before Aiden left...


D:

[Vicky.]

Yeah..

Cher's from Malvern which is near me, that's part of the reason I wanted her to win even, probably wouldn't have voted as much if she hadn't lived so close.. she'd have still been my favourite though anyway if that makes sense :/

D:

Well theres me proven wrong then...didnt think people were petty enough to vote just based on where the acts come from...surely talent means something too?!

Joe lived like 10mins away from me and I supported Danyl, as did most other people from where I lived at the time :laugh:

The majority of acts are from England though, Ireland is never represented very well comparitively, and if they only have one act in the competition it will make them more inclined to back them because she is essentially their sole representative

Well tbh, thats quite sad. Its not the country winning the show, its the contestants, and people should not get support based on where they are from.

[arista]

mary 2nd :eek:

no
check the better Guardian Graph
I posted

[Stacey.]

D:

Well theres me proven wrong then...didnt think people were petty enough to vote just based on where the acts come from...surely talent means something too?!

Joe lived like 10mins away from me and I supported Danyl, as did most other people from where I lived at the time :laugh:



Yeah obvz, I thought Cher was talented too though

[MTVN]

Well tbh, thats quite sad. Its not the country winning the show, its the contestants, and people should not get support based on where they are from.

No but I think they would like it if a winner came from their country because it's something to relate to. I'm no fan of Andy Murray but, as a Brit, it's nice to see him do well in tournaments even though he's not officially representing any particular country

[Z]

I never support the Scottish acts, I don't know many from here who do, there's a tendency to be annoyed by the judges saying "Scotland needs to get behind _____" because it implies we're petty like that. That was interesting James!

[Locke.]

90% of people from here were voting for Rebecca, when I posted a status on Facebook saying she was ****e I had people saying I should want her to win cos she is from Liverpool. So some people do vote for people just cos of where they are from. Stupid really.

[Z]

90% of people from here were voting for Rebecca, when I posted a status on Facebook saying she was ****e I had people saying I should want her to win cos she is from Liverpool. So some people do vote for people just cos of where they are from. Stupid really.

Maybe it works on a city basis, but nationally I just don't think that's the case at all, the only acts I've ever voted for on the X Factor were Miss Frank and Hope, neither had any Scottish members.

[robb]

So Mary DID beat Cher in week nine!!

[MTVN]

Maybe it works on a city basis, but nationally I just don't think that's the case at all, the only acts I've ever voted for on the X Factor were Miss Frank and Hope, neither had any Scottish members.

Not even the McDonald Brothers? :shocked:

[Z]

Not even the McDonald Brothers? :shocked:

Especially not them, they were really annoying!

[Vicky.]

So Mary DID beat Cher in week nine!!

I dont think that will surprise anyone really :p

[Z]

I dont think that will surprise anyone really :p

I'm surprised there's not been (well, yet) much of a backlash over that, I mean we all knew it but still...

[Vicky.]

I'm surprised there's not been (well, yet) much of a backlash over that, I mean we all knew it but still...

Yeah I know.

Mind once its all over, the hype dies down pretty quick.

[MusicXian]

How the heck did Aiden only come 5th on Mad World week and 6th on Diamonds are Forever week? Must have been something about him alot of people didnt like (weird face movements etc.) because in terms of delivery they were 2 of the best performances on the whole show. Also I think Cheryl's and Simon's comments on certain weeks about his intensity really affected his image from the audience.

I mean Diamonds are Forever for me was the performance of the show. Every note was hit absolutely perfect and I am unsure any other contestant this year could have hit that final note of the song.

[cub]

Do you really think people from ireland vote like that?

This annoys me, especially when Louis says it all the time. Would YOU vote for someone just because they were from england? Would you refrain from voting for someone because they were from Ireland? Of course you wouldnt.

Some might if a British person was competing in a foreign country. There have been British and Irish people on American Idol in the past, if British people could have voted I'm sure they would have attracted votes.

Also Irish and Scottish people seem more passionate about their country than the Brits.

[Niamh.]

Some might if a British person was competing in a foreign country. There have been British and Irish people on American Idol in the past, if British people could have voted I'm sure they would have attracted votes.

Also Irish and Scottish people seem more passionate about their country than the Brits.

As an Irish person here is my honest opinion on it. When an Irish person gets on one of these shows (X factor or BB) I always hope I will like them cos yeah I do want them to do well and they do, to a certain extent, represent the country in that particular show but I never vote for them just because they're Irish. Me wanting them to be good and them actually being good are two different things. And I can honestly say, hand on heart, that the only time my favourite was an Irish person and I actually voted for that person was Brian Dowling from BB and that was because he genuinely was my favourite. I thought Mary was good and I'm glad she did so well but she wasn't my favourite and I didn't vote for her, in fact out of the people I know here in r/l none of them voted for her or had her as their favourite.

[Kazanne]

D:

Well theres me proven wrong then...didnt think people were petty enough to vote just based on where the acts come from...surely talent means something too?!

Joe lived like 10mins away from me and I supported Danyl, as did most other people from where I lived at the time :laugh:



Well tbh, thats quite sad. Its not the country winning the show, its the contestants, and people should not get support based on where they are from.

Both Cher and Liam from OD are from near me,but I voted for who I thought best and that was Matt.The only time I ever voted like that was in BB1 with Craig but he was actually a friend so a bit different I think.

[prkp12]

Notice how the 3 weeks before Aiden went his placings were 666? ooooooo.

[James]

Here's the same thing for 2009 and 2008, if anyone's interested.

http://img821.imageshack.us/img821/1160/xfactor2009weeklyaverag.png (http://img821.imageshack.us/i/xfactor2009weeklyaverag.png/)

http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/6622/xfactor2008weeklyaverag.png (http://img232.imageshack.us/i/xfactor2008weeklyaverag.png/)

[Iceman]

James you really like oing these dont you? :tongue:

[James]

Quite easy to update the first one for previous series. ;) :p

[StGeorge]

Also Irish and Scottish people seem more passionate about their country than the Brits.

Blimey....i was so entrenched in Xfactor i missed Scottish independance. :shocked:

And an answer to whether voting for a local makes sense....yes..nonsense. :shrug:

And for those who vote for a nationality....its X-FACTOR not Eurovision. :nono:

I cant stand scousers, but Bex was my No1 from day 1.

[Jords]

Interesting, cheers for doing this James.

[MusicXian]

Wow 2008 and 2009 were much more all over the place. This time it seemed reasonably consistent with the voting.

Like in 08 Eoghan was number 1 until the very end then dipped to number 3 suddenly or Rachel in 09 was mostly in 10th then went number 1 for a week.