Katharine McPhee

[Lance]

I know she's on Idol, but I think she's that good she deserves her own topic.:tongue:

Any fans out there?

[BB-Rocks]

I want her to win now!

[Pipergun]

She'd get my vote out of the final 3! :thumbs:

"Black Horse and the Cherry Tree" was great! :bigsmile:

[Lance]

I also loved her version, Tom.

She really put her stamp on it.:spin2:

[Pipergun]

Sadly, although I'd rather Taylor went, I have a feeling she'll be out this week! :sad:

.... I really should stay more positive, eh!? :spin:

[Lance]

Hmm.. I really don't like Taylor. He just looks like a drunken grandad who shouts his way through every song.:puzzled:

[Z]

I'm still reeling from Kellie Pickler being kicked off. -___-;;

[Pipergun]

Originally posted by Lance
Hmm.. I really don't like Taylor. He just looks like a drunken grandad who shouts his way through every song.:puzzled:

Agree completely! :thumbs:

Sorry to disagree with you, Zi, but I wasn't such a fan of Kellie - her voice had begun to grate on me a tad! :blush2:

[xWee-Babezx]

I hope Kat wins now shes the only decent 1 left x

[Dan_]

Too inconsistent for me.

[BusyBee]

Quite agree BB Frenzy - thought last week she deserved to go.

[Lance]

Zi, I have to disagree. Kellie was sweet but just average and nothing more, IMO. She wasn't better than any of the people that outlasted her.

I don't think Katharine is inconsistant btw. She has had a less than lacklustre performances but so does everyone on these shows. Just my opinion. But, for me, she's great and I hope she wins.:thumbs:

[GlitterEyes]

I want Katherine to win, she is the only one which will sell over the years and last. I think Taylor is popular BUT he will only sell a certain amount then people will tire of him. I really wanted Chris to win the whole thing but im going for kat now:bigsmile:

[Legend]

Kellie was my favourite too Zi. Katherine to win now though yeah, great voice.

[GlitterEyes]

Kelly annoyed me her talking voice was awful, so was Paris's talking voice.

[Lance]

Katharine is miles better than Taylor. I still don't know what on earth he doing in the final. He looks like he's in pain when he sings.

Kat's version of SOTR this week was fab. Loved it!:wink: