Should this BB11 Feature return in Big Brother 12?

[Patrick]

http://www.tvthrong.co.uk/files/u1465/sandr.jpg

What do you think?

Should it return in a different form? Like in a more serious way?

Maybe WE could vote on an online poll on the C5 Website?
Or should it return with the same 'fun' S+R tasks like last summer, although tbh they got abit boring after a while.

I think they need to be taken more seriously, like instead of riding a scooter threw a river of cabbage dressed as a mouse, to win immunity.

It should be like proper Gladiators, perhaps a Joust Challenge where the two nominated HMs face eachother on two separate podiums, on the ground lies Cow Manure - the first housemate to knock the other off, wins Immunity and replaces themselves with another HM.


It should feel more like a challenge, not a day out at the park or School Fun Day.

I loved how the BB11 Housemates took it though, I mean Shabby, John, Mario, Govan, Caoimhe, Keeley etc took the S+R so seriously sometimes.

It's just Big Brother took the piss out of it.

So what do you reckon?


Big Brother 11

http://unrealityshout.com/files/imagecache/image_460/Mouse-Suit-3.jpg
http://www.channel4.com/bigbrother/images/guid/62cc7c707a8663ba498c69d1066a70a3_extralarge.jpg


My Idea for Big Brother 12

http://www.nytimes.com/images/blogs/tvdecoder/posts/0108/gladiators1.jpg
http://mimg.ugo.com/201012/4/2/9/133924/cuts/earthquake_528_poster.jpg

[MTVN]

Yes, bring it back, it was funny how badly some of them took it :laugh:

[Patrick]

Yes, bring it back, it was funny how badly some of them took it :laugh:

I'll never forget Mario being a spoilt little bastard in the bedroom after he got put up :joker:

'And I worked so much harder than-'

*Slams Bedcovers Down*

'ANY OF YOU! To get my housemate status!'

[Smithy]

No, we lost poor Keeley because of this stupid thing

[Vicky.]

Tree of temptation :love:

[MTVN]

I'll never forget Mario being a spoilt little bastard in the bedroom after he got put up :joker:

:joker::joker::joker:

[Tom.]

bring it back, only bring back the HOH as well with the winner as HOH. That will ruffle a few feathers, ruling a house where everyone hates you :joker:

Just to up the stakes a little bit, as well as saving themselves from that eviction, they automatically get immunity from the next one too (as they'd be HOH at the time of nominations)

[Patrick]

bring it back, only bring back the HOH as well with the winner as HOH. That will ruffle a few feathers, ruling a house where everyone hates you :joker:

Just to up the stakes a little bit, as well as saving themselves from that eviction, they automatically get immunity from the next one too (as they'd be HOH at the time of nominations)

I like it.

Yeah H.O.H was brilliant, I loved how Darnell was the first person to call it 'HOH' rather than Head of House and it wasn't until recently, I figured out that was because he was American and probably knew that was how it was said :joker:

But yeah I like that idea, it could be fun and make them all really really competitive.

Oh and this has nothing to do with S+R but another way of deciding a new H.O.H would be to bring back Big Brother 5's 'Saturday Night Live Challenges'.

They were so good, I remember they had to literally fall into Thorns - not run up and down a half-pipe dressed as a Spider.

[daniel-lewis-1985]

Tree of temptation :love:

Erm no way the tree was so overused in the last series.

Im over it.

[Patrick]

Erm no way the tree was so overused in the last series.

Im over it.

This.
They killed it completely.

[HBB1508]

Loved S&R it mixes it up a bit so hope it comes back.

[Vicky.]

Meh I liked it. If they had decent ideas for it it could be ok :laugh:

[Jack_]

The Tree of Temptation was genius in CBB7, but it was was sh!t in BB11. I'm trying to remember some of the tasks now, what were they? Tell some lies or something? What sort of a ****ing task was that? If they're going to bring it back, I expect really evil tasks, ones that are going to cause arguments, ones that'll make conversations between friends awkward. Stuff like that really. Like having to take a sh!t on people's clothes [maybe that's too far], making a pube sandwich and giving it to someone [maybe that's too far as well], or just having to cut someone's clothes up or something.

[Patrick]

Plus the voice of the tree, if it does come back - will be different.
That'll seem strange.

Although, they could get Marcus Akin to do the tree's voice - they always sounded the same anyway.

The Tree of Temptation was genius in CBB7, but it was was sh!t in BB11. I'm trying to remember some of the tasks now, what were they? Tell some lies or something? What sort of a ****ing task was that? If they're going to bring it back, I expect really evil tasks, ones that are going to cause arguments, ones that'll make conversations between friends awkward. Stuff like that really. Like having to take a sh!t on people's clothes [maybe that's too far], making a pube sandwich and giving it to someone [maybe that's too far as well], or just having to cut someone's clothes up or something.

:joker::joker::joker::joker: :joker::joker::joker::joker::joker:

[CharlieO]

no who ever is nominated should be up in my opinion. if you have s&r makes it more of a game showw and i dont like that

[Jordan.]

No, it was annoying towards the end cause it was always the twat who no one wanted to be safe winning it.

[Beastie]

The Tree of Temptation better not come back. The tree just showed how sh!t BB11 was.

Anyway Save and Replace.. yeah.

But before that and before nominations all the housemates must take part in a task. The one or 2 people that loses are automatically put up for eviction!

Then it will be nominations.. the 2 or more housemates with the most votes are up for eviction. However these people will have a chance to save themselves in a s+r task. If they win they swap their up for eviction place with another housemate!

[Beastie]

No, it was annoying towards the end cause it was always the twat who no one wanted to be safe winning it.

Err yeah when Keeva kept winning the S+R task :yuk:

[BBDodge]

It ruined one series. That's enough.

[Benjamin]

Tree of temptation :love:

Tree of Temptation was possibly one of the worst BB twists ever. It was awful and cringey. :bored:

[Mac Hiavellian]

I quite liked the save and replace tasks. It gave the HMs something else to do each week. Sometimes the best HMs were replaced, sometimes the right ones were put up. So yeah, bring it back! :)
And the bigger the better!

[Mystic Mock]

yes,and just like it was in 2010 because it got the bores up for eviction and out the door alot of the time.

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

I like the idea of the Tree Of Temptation coming back, but not save & replace, it was already for the first couple of weeks, but got really boring after a while..IMO.

[karl100589]

I'm OK with Save and Replace coming back, it spread the week out better and gave the housemates more to do, plus it put floater housemates which weren't in danger in the firing line, nobody was safe. Had Save and Replace not happened we wouldn't have got rid of Nathan as early as we did, hell, Nathan probably would have made the final.

[penguinposse]

I think they should bring it back. If it wasnt for save and replace we would'nt have gotten rid of monobrow Nathan so soon last year.

[Patrick]

no who ever is nominated should be up in my opinion. if you have s&r makes it more of a game showw and i dont like that

Big Brother is a ******ing Game Show!

[_Seth]

Big Brother is a ******ing Game Show!

It's much more a reality show IMO.

[Patrick]

It's much more a reality show IMO.

Pretty much the same thing, it was a game show to begin with.

The actual format of Big Brother was intended to be a Game Show aswell as a social experiment. [Which is why they added a prize fund]

The USA one is treated alot like a game show, I despise BBUSA but I think the reason I enjoyed BB5 so much was because it was the first and only series to be treated like a game.

They all wanted to win and showed it, Victor and Jason were amazing at playing the game.
People should realize, playing 'the game' isn't a bad thing.

Poor Nasty Nick :(

[DigitalSid]

No. With a new production team, new people overseeing it, it being on a new channel and it being very much a new era for the show I feel any attempt to recreate C4BB as it was when it left off (battered and bruised and in need of surgery but instead just bandaged up) would fail, they should take the basic elements of the format and the branding and start again, they should treat it as a whole new adaption of the original worldwide success story Big Brother format rather than a continuation of the ailing last one the UK tried.

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

No. With a new production team, new people overseeing it, it being on a new channel and it being very much a new era for the show I feel any attempt to recreate C4BB as it was when it left off (battered and bruised and in need of surgery but instead just bandaged up) would fail, they should take the basic elements of the format and the branding and start again, they should treat it as a whole new adaption of the original worldwide success story Big Brother format rather than a continuation of the ailing last one the UK tried.

Have to say DS im in totally agreement with you, its a new era for C5BB.

[georgehudson]

I actually really liked that feature. But take it more seriously - there's £500,000 to be won! Thats 5X what it was on C4!!!

[Rob]

yes, loved save and replace!

[camertone]

bb aus had friday night live show, which was so good, maybe bb uk has the money, they should do the same, it will boost the show, bb should give weekly prizes to the winners, or winner is allowed to nominate 3 or 4 people instead of one, or save someone, etc. save and replace tasks were good, but can be bigger and better.