Lady GaGa - Judas

[Smithy]

aAWpkZSCMXU

Will some people dislike it?
Yes, and it is important that these people are able to accept that they are wrong. They will need your love and your respect while they come to terms with this difficult truth. Do not pity them, just offer them your help.

I'll update with HQ when I get it :tongue:

[Tom4784]

Jesus christ it's a mess so far.

EDIT: Okay it's finished so my final verdict is that it's a complete trainwreck....but a trainwreck I could grow not to hate.

[Callum]

Not as good as Bad Romance but a lot better than Born This Way

The chorus is quite weak, I prefer the verses.

[Zippy]

much better than BTW

but overall sounds like a weaker version of Bad romance

and please remove that annoying quote from your OP. Patronising crap.

[Niall]

:love:

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

-likes-

[Stu]

The whole stealing the Chuck Norris surreal greatness thing with the quotes doesn't really hide the fact that she's starting to sound like a David Guetta B-Side.

And I genuinly want to like it. But no. It's just ****ing garbage, really. It's amazing to think that this is the same artist who gave us Bad Romance and Paparazzi.

[Shaun]

it's pretty decent...not her best, easily, but an improvement on BTW.

[Vladimir]

It's better than BTW, but it certainly isn't great.

[Stacey.]

It sounds okay, sort of annoying though

Born This Way >

[mkdfan]

I LOVE it!

[Jords]

Its **** :/ Better than BTW but thats really not hard, may have potential to grow..

[Doogle]

I love it so much! Prefer it to Bad Romance. Yeah I went there.

[Jordan.]

Her best since Telephone, is it better than Bad Romance? - No.

[Shaun]

oh god no, Alejandro >>>>

in terms of singles, I'd put it:

Bad Romance > Alejandro > Poker Face > Paparazzi > Telephone > Judas > Eh Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) > Just Dance > Born This Way

[KG.]

I like the fact she's doing a bit more techno and this sounds alright, think it could probably grow on me, much better than Born This Way in any case.

[Callum]

Billboard already predicting it will sell near 400,000 copies in the US to secure it debuts at #1 next week. Poor Brit and Rihanna. :(

[Shaun]

Judas > a 6 month old song "remixed" by a glitching robot.

[Smithy]

I'm astounded by those sales, 2 and a Half days

http://i1224.photobucket.com/albums/ee369/jasminealexandrea/tumblr_ldge0uqGpw1qdagoe.gif

[M X]

Incredible! Just amazing! And those days are like previously unheard of for 2 days of sales. Only Gaga. *bows*

[Doogle]

Personally I think:

Judas > Bad Romance > Paparazzi > Eh Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) > Poker Face > Just Dance > Born This Way > Telephone > Alejandro

[Marsh.]

but overall sounds like a weaker version of Bad romance

and please remove that annoying quote from your OP. Patronising crap.

Judas > a 6 month old song "remixed" by a glitching robot.

Completely agree with both these posts. Doesn't take much to be better than the computer that Britney mimes to though.

It sorta sounds like Juda - Juda - arse - arse, Juda - Juda - arse - arse.

[Smithy]

Just so y'all know, be prepared for some 10 minute long Religiously themed Video where she's Mary Magdaline http://www.spillitnow.com/images/smiles/juggle.gif

[Stu]

Good on her for bringing the crucifix to popular music at long last.

Oh wait ...

[Smithy]

Who said anything about a Crucifix http://www.spillitnow.com/images/smiles/juggle.gif

[Doogle]

I'm not a fan of her videos, to be honest. They're just so over the top now and I don't understand what half the random things in it have to do with the song. Well, I understood Telephone, but that was about it.

[Stu]

Who said anything about a Crucifix http://www.spillitnow.com/images/smiles/juggle.gif
Your sig I guess. And countless other GaGa fans who have rocked the Jesus tree. Original bunch http://www.spillitnow.com/images/smiles/juggle.gif.

[Marsh.]

I'm not a fan of her videos, to be honest. They're just so over the top now and I don't understand what half the random things in it have to do with the song. Well, I understood Telephone, but that was about it.

You do? Out of all the videos that was the most random.

[Harry!]

Just typical pop can't see nothing outstanding about it. And oh joy Gaga tries to offend the Christian religion again, how original and overdone. How about offending another faith, that would be more interesting. I am sure she would cause a bigger storm if she offened the Muslim faith or other faiths. Get some new ideas. :pat:

[Marsh.]

Just typical pop can't see nothing outstanding about it. And oh joy Gaga tries to offend the Christian religion again, how original and overdone. How about offending another faith, that would be more interesting. I am sure she would cause a bigger storm if she offened the Muslim faith or other faiths. Get some new ideas. :pat:


I agree. This "new" material of hers proves she's a one trick pony. People thought her the next legend in music, but she's ran out of steam already.
Bye bye Gaga.


Although, give her credit, she's a lot better than Britney Spears miming to a computer and dancing like an incontinent aunt at a wedding.

[Stu]

Just typical pop can't see nothing outstanding about it. And oh joy Gaga tries to offend the Christian religion again, how original and overdone. How about offending another faith, that would be more interesting. I am sure she would cause a bigger storm if she offened the Muslim faith or other faiths. Get some new ideas. :pat:
I don't nessacerily think she is trying to offend it, Harry. Just nicking their iconography. Islam isin't really sexy.

As much as I hate the song myself your just running on autopilot with your hate and it's a bit boring.

[Smithy]

Your sig I guess. And countless other GaGa fans who have rocked the Jesus tree. Original bunch http://www.spillitnow.com/images/smiles/juggle.gif.
FYI, that is me showing my faith http://www.greendaycommunity.org/Forum/public/style_emoticons/Dark/hmph.png
Just typical pop can't see nothing outstanding about it. And oh joy Gaga tries to offend the Christian religion again, how original and overdone. How about offending another faith, that would be more interesting. I am sure she would cause a bigger storm if she offened the Muslim faith or other faiths. Get some new ideas. :pat:

From someone who listens to Aqua and tries to preach about their music, calling this a typical pop song doesn't mean much

Where did it say she was trying to offend them? http://gagadailyboards.com/images/smilies2/toofunny.gif

[Marsh.]

I don't nessacerily think she is trying to offend it, Harry. Just nicking their iconography. Islam isin't really sexy.

As much as I hate the song myself your just running on autopilot with your hate and it's a bit boring.

:joker:

[Stu]

I have to say though Smithy the song - however good you might think it is - clashes something horrid with the red text in your sig. Bad Romance is the titanium plated Judas from the year 2511. Not the other way around.

Judas is the in-the-club drivel. It's made for the club. The irony is just staggering.

Who wrote that anyway?

[Smithy]

Popjustice

[Harry!]

I don't nessacerily think she is trying to offend it, Harry. Just nicking their iconography. Islam isin't really sexy.

As much as I hate the song myself your just running on autopilot with your hate and it's a bit boring.

The Christian iconography for shock in music videos has been done before. Lady Gaga's songs dont have to be all about hard hitting lyrics and having strong messages through them. Sometimes the best songs of all time have had far simplier message and have not relied on shock factor to be 'good'. Lady Gaga's ''idols'' have done so. I would like to see what she would do with the Islamic faith.

[MusicMan]

Surprisingly the song grew on me by the end, but I really don't like the chorus.

[Harry!]

FYI, that is me showing my faith http://www.greendaycommunity.org/Forum/public/style_emoticons/Dark/hmph.png


From someone who listens to Aqua and tries to preach about their music, calling this a typical pop song doesn't mean much

Where did it say she was trying to offend them? http://gagadailyboards.com/images/smilies2/toofunny.gif

She is trying to offend the Christian faith or for them to 'take notice' of it which is nothing new. Aqua are underated.

[Smithy]

She is trying to offend the Christian faith or for them to 'take notice' of it which is nothing new. Aqua are underated.

K, but HOW is she trying to offened them?

The song is about embracing you're demons to bring yourself into the light, surely that's a positive message?

And there's a reason for that

[Stu]

Lady Gaga's songs dont have to be all about hard hitting lyrics and having strong messages through them.
They ... don't. That's the point. You may have missed it.

Why would you want her to do a song about Islam? That's just ****ing retarded. She's not going to be chanting to the west bouncing around on a Camel's dick hollering ga-ga-Gaddafi. It doesn't sell. It's not the type of pop music she is in the business of making.

Is it a deep song or a throwaway pop one? Do you want her to do the simpler stuff like you said or do an Islamic song? What are you actually talking about?

By the way she's not offending the Christian fate. Stop saying that. I reckon she has a hard on for the Jesus figure and it's more out of that than wanting to say 'yeah, down with Bishops!'.

Again she is just nicking their iconography. Christianity can be very, very sexy.

[Smithy]

Why would you want her to do a song about Islam?

I could see that working

Whoah-oh-oh-oh-oh-oh-oh

Whoah-oh-oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
I'm in love with All-a-ah, All-a-ah

All-Allah, All-Allah, All-Allah, Alla-Gaga
All-Allah, All-Allah, All-Allah, Alla-Gaga

[Stu]

My favourite 'deep' GaGa moment was the nauseous, select audience only meaning of Born This Way. Coz' God makes no mistakes and that's presumably why children are born with horrific defects.

Wishy washy ball cockness of the highest order, dawg.

[Barbie]

Really want to like Gaga's music again but this is nothing on her earlier stuff, where the quality of bad romance and telephone! This song is better than born this way, and i can see it being quite catchy but im not overly keen :( come on gaga! get back up there!

[Harry!]

K, but HOW is she trying to offened them?

The song is about embracing you're demons to bring yourself into the light, surely that's a positive message?

And there's a reason for that

Just wait for the video...

They ... don't. That's the point. You may have missed it.

Why would you want her to do a song about Islam? That's just ****ing retarded. She's not going to be chanting to the west bouncing around on a Camel's dick hollering ga-ga-Gaddafi. It doesn't sell. It's not the type of pop music she is in the business of making.

Is it a deep song or a throwaway pop one? Do you want her to do the simpler stuff like you said or do an Islamic song? What are you actually talking about?

By the way she's not offending the Christian fate. Stop saying that. I reckon she has a hard on for the Jesus figure and it's more out of that than wanting to say 'yeah, down with Bishops!'.

Again she is just nicking their iconography. Christianity can be very, very sexy.

Isnt the fact that a song with ideas of the Islam faith different to anything in popular music merit on its own. She could challenge the ideas the faith has about woman and how they are treated. That could be interesting and could try to enlighten people of how bad some people treat women in the faith. With a music video as well. It just is not different as many people have used the Christian faith in their music.

[Smithy]

Just wait for the video...



In other words "Im making it up as I go along, just hating for the sake of hating"

[Smithy]

omg I just read the other part of the post omg, how can you expect her to write a song about a religion she knows nothing about

omg f/

[M X]

Just so y'all know, be prepared for some 10 minute long Religiously themed Video where she's Mary Magdaline http://www.spillitnow.com/images/smiles/juggle.gif
So excited! And it's her directorial debut! :dance:

[Marsh.]

I could see that working

Whoah-oh-oh-oh-oh-oh-oh

Whoah-oh-oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
I'm in love with All-a-ah, All-a-ah

All-Allah, All-Allah, All-Allah, Alla-Gaga
All-Allah, All-Allah, All-Allah, Alla-Gaga


Sounds more like Rihanna's thing.

[Stu]

Just wait for the video...



Isnt the fact that a song with ideas of the Islam faith different to anything in popular music merit on its own. She could challenge the ideas the faith has about woman and how they are treated. That could be interesting and could try to enlighten people of how bad some people treat women in the faith. With a music video as well. It just is not different as many people have used the Christian faith in their music.
But why? The argument is just silly. I hate the Black Eyed Peas but I don't think a measure of self improvement could be instigated by them doing a concept album around the theme of the Australian Aboriginals right to their homeland just for the heck of it. It's just such a stupid, juvenile demand. Especially as it contradicts your earlier one that she should leave out all the messages and just do simple pop for a change.

That is what she's doing, by the way. It is just simple albeit well produced and well performed pop and anyone is kidding themselves if they think there is some unfathomable mythology to it all.

Anyway, have it your way. Aqua are underrated etc.

[Harry!]

In other words "Im making it up as I go along, just hating for the sake of hating"

No I am not making it up as I go along.

omg I just read the other part of the post omg, how can you expect her to write a song about a religion she knows nothing about

omg f/

Research...

[Smithy]

No I am not making it up as I go along.

Research...

Yes you are.. f/

that's not how you write a song... you have to be inspired by something, researching kinda defeats the point o.0

[Stu]

Get on to her agent. She might flash a few Burkas in the next video to prove she's 4 realz.

Even if the song has nothing to do with the Islam subjugation of woman. Just fling it in the video. Even if you don't know that much about it. Because apparently that's your solution to make a song deep.

???

The mind boggles. I'm going to bed.

[Ninastar]

D:

[GypsyGoth]

Is Judas her boyfriend?

[Harry!]

Get on to her agent. She might flash a few Burkas in the next video to prove she's 4 realz.

Even if the song has nothing to do with the Islam subjugation of woman. Just fling it in the video. Even if you don't know that much about it. Because apparently that's your solution to make a song deep.

???

The mind boggles. I'm going to bed.

Her song American Life whislt challenging the American Dream the Uncensored music video was about the Afgan war and did show girls in burkas highlighting the destruction at the time.

[Shaun]

http://i51.tinypic.com/312uw54.png

[Marsh.]

Is Judas her boyfriend?

:laugh3:

[Smithy]

Yeah he is Claudia, kind of

(Well he tweeted the other day "I Am Judas" so I assume thats who she wrote it about)

[Shaun]

Is Judas her boyfriend?

haven't seen him post in a couple of days.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

http://i51.tinypic.com/312uw54.png

:joker::joker::joker::joker::joker:

[Smithy]

http://i51.tinypic.com/312uw54.png

:laugh2:

[MeMyselfAndI]

I like this:)
Papparazi>Telephone>Just Dance>Bad Romance>Judas>Poker Face> Alejandro > Born This Way

[Jords]

Poker Face > Bad Romance > Telephone > Alejandro > Love Game > Just Dance > Papparazi > Judas > Born This Way

[Harry!]

http://i51.tinypic.com/312uw54.png

Well Kylie Minogue's latest album though not critically liked (by some) her tour was amazing and used imagery to its best. Although people who might not of been to her tour wouldn't of known that. I only played Hey You as it was one song and I wanted to listen to a 1 song album on my music liabary. That was the song I chose.

[Doogle]

The most annoying thing is that people are comparing this song to Madonna as well.

[GypsyGoth]

Yeah he is Claudia, kind of

(Well he tweeted the other day "I Am Judas" so I assume thats who she wrote it about)

Is it the guy she was dating or with a few months ago, I think there were pictures of them messing around at a pool on holiday?

haven't seen him post in a couple of days.

He disappeared and this single gets released http://img696.imageshack.us/img696/4066/suspicious.png

[Smithy]

Is it the guy she was dating or with a few months ago, I think there were pictures of them messing around at a pool on holiday?



Yeah, that's him Luc Carl :bored:

[Doogle]

Luc Carl followed me today. I didn't even know who he was. :joker:

[Josy]

I asked Josy for help but she ignored me :''(

08marsh if you reply to him, I will kill you

I did not :nono: I was reading the thread :laugh:

I'm deleting all of the off topic posts, so can we keep on topic in here now.

[Marsh.]

KILL JOSY.

You should delete your own post. Nothing to do with the Gaga.

[\PJ/]

I miss the Andy Warhol days.

[Marsh.]

Is it the guy she was dating or with a few months ago, I think there were pictures of them messing around at a pool on holiday?



He disappeared and this single gets released http://img696.imageshack.us/img696/4066/suspicious.png


I thought his name was Jesus not Judas. Is that his brother?

[Smithy]

I did not :nono: I was reading the thread :laugh:

I'm deleting all of the off topic posts, so can we keep on topic in here now.

Oh, ok, I thought you'd gone offline

TY :love:

[Marsh.]

I miss the Andy Warhol days.


Delete, delete, delete!

[Smithy]

I just listened through headphones for the first time, and it sounds so much better :shocked:

[iRyan]

I LOVE IT. I think it surpasses Bad Romance as my favorite Gaga song...

It was just okay first listen, but now i'm on the 5th listen and i'm addicted.

[Tom4784]

It's grown on me a lot more, better then that lump of crap BTW but it's not on the same level as Bad Romance, Pokerface, Paparazzi, Telephone ETC.

[Z]

Don't like it on first listen and don't intend on listening again.

[Barbie]

Its growing on me, miles better than born this way, no bad romance or pokerface though!

[MusicMan]

I can't get this song out of my head, seriously it's been on non-stop loop all day in my head and I've listened to it like 3 times.

How does Gaga always do this??? It isn't even that good a song, at all. But at the same time it's genius.

[Shaun]

xWvEB14Qw8Q

[Zippy]

:joker::joker::joker:

now she's ripping off a 2009 Ukranian smash! LOL

http://poptrashaddicts.blogspot.com/2011/04/loli-lux-latest-victim-of-lady-gagas.html

[BB_Eye]

Not sure I'll forgive myself for saying this, but with all the crap on the radio at the minute being played over 9000 times a day, Lady Gaga's "Judas" doesn't seem so bad.

[Shaun]

-agrees-

[Patrick]

Smithy isn't there a Lady GaGa thread?

Because I know for a fact if anyone else where to make a thread and post a song in it, you would be redirecting us to other places to post it.

Honestly, see this is why people hate Lady GaGa now.

Her fans shove her down people's throats, and she's not doing herself any favours by making songs like this - She really needs to get her head out of her hole and realize she's nothing special.

[Stu]

It's not as if you could miss the thread updates with Michael's nauseous title changes.

[Patrick]

The whole stealing the Chuck Norris surreal greatness thing with the quotes doesn't really hide the fact that she's starting to sound like a David Guetta B-Side.

And I genuinly want to like it. But no. It's just ****ing garbage, really. It's amazing to think that this is the same artist who gave us Bad Romance and Paparazzi.

Hit the nail on the head.

[Smithy]

Smithy isn't there a Lady GaGa thread?

Because I know for a fact if anyone else where to make a thread and post a song in it, you would be redirecting us to other places to post it.

Honestly, see this is why people hate Lady GaGa now.

Her fans shove her down people's throats, and she's not doing herself any favours by making songs like this - She really needs to get her head out of her hole and realize she's nothing special.

Yes, but what's your point? Whenever a song by a big artist is released it's posted as a separate topic.

And this isn't why people hate her, it's why YOU hate her, you're so ignorant, you're opinion doesn't represent the majority, stop acting like it does :rolleyes:

And noone forced this down your throat, you chose to click it and comment, she's nothing special? :laugh3:

[Smithy]

It's been 5 years since this was released :o

[Firewire]

screaming at Patrick

[Pete.]

There are better songs from Born This Way

[Jordan.]

I miss 2011ga

[Ninastar]

hate this song, one of her worst

[Black Dagger]

**** off Patrick.

[Dominic]

There are better songs from Born This Way

Judas is one of the only few ones that are decent or good

[EspeonBB]

There are better songs from Born This Way

True
http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar16072_158.gif

[Jordan.]

the chorus & video slays

[Samm]

Still her best song

[Daniel.]

Her best single

[Ninastar]

i like the song 'judas this way' more but i cant find it on youtube now

[Gstar]

I want part two of Patrick v Smithy

(one of her best singles)

[Smithy]

:fan: