LA Noire VS Red Dead Redemption?

[Patrick]

So LA Noire has been out a week now and I personally think it was waaaay over hyped.

It's amazing yes, but honestly - had Rockstar of made the game it would of been better.

The driving makes the game feel like Vice City or San Andreas, where as I preferred the GTA IV style of driving.

Anyway - I replayed San Andreas and GTA Ballad Of Gay Tony around the new year and then begun playing abit more of Red Dead Redemption at Easter - brining me up to LA Noire.

And I have to say, Red Dead Redemption is still the best game out of any 'Rockstar Game'.

[I know LA Noire wasn't made by Rockstar but they do publish it]

So what do you think?
Let's not even put GTA in the question as there is more than one and it wouldn't be fair.


Out of 2010's Red Dead Redemption and now LA Noire; which is the best?



http://metavideogame.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/02113092-photo-red-dead-redemption.jpg
http://genuinegamers.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/LA-Noire.jpg

[Jordan.]

Not played La Noire but Red Dead Redemption :love:

This reminded me the other day I was planning on going on it then remembered I lent it out months ago to a mate so I asked for it back and hes traded it in, prick. :bored:

[Patrick]

Not played La Noire but Red Dead Redemption :love:

This reminded me the other day I was planning on going on it then remembered I let it out months ago to a mate so I asked for it back and hes traded it in, prick. :bored:

:shocked: The Bastard.

[MeMyselfAndI]

my brother has RDR but i dont like the accents so i never played it

[Patrick]

my brother has RDR but i dont like the accents so i never played it

:joker:

[Doogle]

RDR. :love:

I doubt LA Noire can beat RDR to be honest, but I haven't played so I can't say that for definite yet.

[Rob]

I've so fallen in love with the trailers for La Noire, i'm going to have to get it!

[Patrick]

I've so fallen in love with the trailers for La Noire, i'm going to have to get it!

Don't base it on trailers - EA always make The Sims games look outstanding in the trailers, you buy them and they aren't that good.

Rockstar don't usually do that - but with LA Noire, the trailers make the game look better than it actually is.

Believe me though - it's VERY VERY addicting.

[Doogle]

Don't base it on trailers - EA always make The Sims games look outstanding in the trailers, you buy them and they aren't that good.

Rockstar don't usually do that - but with LA Noire, the trailers make the game look better than it actually is.

Believe me though - it's VERY VERY addicting.

As much as I love The Sims series I have to agree. If you've ever seen the Sims 2 trailer you'll know what I mean. 90% of the stuff in it you can't do.

[Ramsay]

LA Noire

[Jordan.]

http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z341/jordannn__/Cher%20Lloyd%20GIF/kf5qo1jpg.gif?t=1306680743

RDR is underrated.

[arista]

So LA Noire has been out a week now and I personally think it was waaaay over hyped.

It's amazing yes, but honestly - had Rockstar of made the game it would of been better.

The driving makes the game feel like Vice City or San Andreas, where as I preferred the GTA IV style of driving.

Anyway - I replayed San Andreas and GTA Ballad Of Gay Tony around the new year and then begun playing abit more of Red Dead Redemption at Easter - brining me up to LA Noire.

And I have to say, Red Dead Redemption is still the best game out of any 'Rockstar Game'.

[I know LA Noire wasn't made by Rockstar but they do publish it]

So what do you think?
Let's not even put GTA in the question as there is more than one and it wouldn't be fair.


Out of 2010's Red Dead Redemption and now LA Noire; which is the best?



http://metavideogame.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/02113092-photo-red-dead-redemption.jpg
http://genuinegamers.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/LA-Noire.jpg





No
Red Dead is only 720P


And La Noire is Full 1080P HiDef
and much more invested in it.


You can not compare a Western
to a Gangster Movie Play.

[Scarlett.]

The PS3 LA Noire also looks best, as it was developed on the PS3 (Plus it's all one disc - Blu Ray utter bliss :p)

RDR and LA Noire are two different types of game, it's hard to choose, but I'll say RDR, it's quite unique

[Niall]

Ew Red Dead. :bored:

I just got L.A Noire today but I already love it and think its amaze. L.A Noire >>

[Patrick]

http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z341/jordannn__/Cher%20Lloyd%20GIF/kf5qo1jpg.gif?t=1306680743

RDR is underrated.

This.
Just like GTA

[Patrick]

Ew Red Dead. :bored:

I just got L.A Noire today but I already love it and think its amaze. L.A Noire >>

:shocked:



http://pixelatedgeek.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/red-dead-redemption-screenshot-big.jpg
http://cache.gawker.com/assets/images/kotaku/2009/05/red_dead_redemption_2.jpg
http://www.jimmyhasablog.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/Red-Dead-Redemption-Screens.jpg



That is not ew. :laugh:

[Niall]

:shocked:



http://pixelatedgeek.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/red-dead-redemption-screenshot-big.jpg
http://cache.gawker.com/assets/images/kotaku/2009/05/red_dead_redemption_2.jpg
http://www.jimmyhasablog.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/Red-Dead-Redemption-Screens.jpg



That is not ew. :laugh:

Idk why but I just don't like the game. Whenever I've played it I get bored? I can't figure out why. I think its the old fashioned setting with horses and shizz. :tongue:

Fallout ****s all over RDR anyway. :wink: :tongue:

[Patrick]

Would you believe LA Noire and Red Dead Redemption take place in the same time period?

My Mum told me this the other day and I'm not joking, I sat like this: :shocked: for about 20 minutes.

I couldn't get over it. LOL

[Scarlett.]

Isn't RDR like...the late 1800's....and LA Noire like...1940's lol

[Niall]

Would you believe LA Noire and Red Dead Redemption take place in the same time period?

My Mum told me this the other day and I'm not joking, I sat like this: :shocked: for about 20 minutes.

I couldn't get over it. LOL

http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lkjtpjqwgL1qbu0h5.gif

They can't. Thats not true lmao. The people in L.A Noire have cars. In RDR they did not. http://oi56.tinypic.com/23ubh3b.jpg

Isn't RDR like...the late 1800's....and LA Noire like...1940's lol

This.

[CharlieO]

GTA > everything other game imo.

[Patrick]

Isn't RDR like...the late 1800's....and LA Noire like...1940's lol

Is it? :shocked:

OMG Maybe - 'cus on the map of RDR I think it said 1894 or something like that.

Still not sure, but I'm not taking video game advice of a woman again.

[Scarlett.]

Lol it's strange how much the world changed in those 30 years, and crazy how much the world changed in 100

[Patrick]

GTA > everything other game imo.

Yeah, definitely.

But RDR >>>>>>>>>>>>> GTA IV.

GTA IV was depressing and miserable, BoGT was amazing though - honestly.
In GTA 5 they need to go back to the fun of GTA SA and Vice City.

I really can't wait to see if they announce GTA V at E3, they actually better or I'm going to go off the rails.

Lol it's strange how much the world changed in those 30 years, and crazy how much the world changed in 100

:laugh: Yeah, quite exciting to think how much the world will change in the next 10/20 years aswell.

[Ramsay]

This.
Just like GTA

are you seriously saying GTA is underated?:joker:
GTA is one of the most rated game of all time man..

[Patrick]

are you seriously saying GTA is underated?:joker:
GTA is one of the most rated game of all time man..

Yeah it is under rated, I get what you mean though - it's probably one of the biggest games ever, infact it is.

If you say Grand Theft Auto everyone knows it, but you never see it talked about anymore, merchandise being sold etc

Call of Duty ruined the gaming industry, it's the only game that's ever spoked about.

Rockstar release brilliant games, all of us buy them and they're all over the place for about a week - then next thing you know Call of Duty is back with another ******ing game and everyone goes crazy about that even though it won't be released until November :bored: