Save and Replace- keep it?

[Joe.]

I liked the way sometimes people were put up when they usually wouldn't but sometimes it annoyed me when people wormed out of being up because of it,

what do you think?

[DigitalSid]

Bin it.

[Omah]

It bin

[CharlieO]

Bin it.

[daniel-lewis-1985]

It bin

Fail.

[joeysteele]

Bin it for me, I thought it was pretty pointless in the end.

[Vicky.]

It was bloody useless :bored:

[Pyramid*]

It completely ruined the show as far as I'm concerned.

Nominations should be left as they are: without interferrence.

[T*]

Bin it with fire

[Vicky.]

Keep noms simple.

And IF theres going to be a twist(which I would prefer there wasnt, but there likely will be at some stage) then announce it BEFORE THEY NOMINATE. Not once you know who will be up.

[Jordan.]

No it needs to die forever.

Imagine how much better last years series could have been if it wasn't for people like Dave, Steve and Mario saving themselves :bored:

[Marc]

Get rid.

[Jords]

KEEP IT.

Best thing of BB11, opened a whole new concept.. need better tasks though.

[joeysteele]

It completely ruined the show as far as I'm concerned.

Nominations should be left as they are: without interferrence.

I totally agree, the worst messing about with nominations too was that daft bucket of gunge nomination process one week in the last series.

[Marcus.]

it was good so if they were up an if they win they can get the fanil say

[Jords]

They could try have all HMs compete in a task BEFORE nominations and the top 2 are immune from nominations instead?

[Marcus.]

They could try have all HMs compete in a task BEFORE nominations and the top 2 are immune from nominations instead?

that an good idea

[12bigbrother12]

Keep it. Makes the whole thing more interesting, and can cause backstabbing.

The only difference should be a six hour period being imposed between the S&R being won and the power being used.. to cause drama, Imagine Nasty Nick knowing someone had that power - he'd orgasm with the manipulation he could do :)

[Gillian-73]

I say bin it! i don't think there should be any messing about with nominations!

[tigranes]

I bet the MrT lookalike was a reserve for either Dave or Steve. If Dave had gone the first week,instead of staying until the end,the show might have been a lot better

[Colbert-Bump]

Keep it.

[Joelle.]

I would say bin it, but some weeks it worked better than others in terms of getting people who were generally disliked up for nomination, so it wouldnt be the end of the world if it stayed.

[Jase.]

Bin it.

[starry]

It must be kept, it gave us at least one exciting task every week which of course could be seen on the live stream as well (which also must be kept).

And it only affected one of those who were nominated, the rest who were up remained up.

[Joe.]

Yarr must admit I loved coming home from school on a tuesday and switching on live feed to watch a save and replace :)

[starry]

I bet the MrT lookalike was a reserve for either Dave or Steve. If Dave had gone the first week,instead of staying until the end,the show might have been a lot better

Except that Dave was one of the best characters in the series and so it was great that he won a task to save himself.

Save and Replace gives us an unpredictable element and adds excitement regularly to tasks which is desperately needed.

Of course sometimes it won't go your way, in which case vote to save your favourite in a public vote if you feel so inclined or campaign for them. But look at the long term view, it adds excitement.

[starry]

I liked the way sometimes people were put up when they usually wouldn't but sometimes it annoyed me when people wormed out of being up because of it,

what do you think?

They don't worm themselves out of it they have to win themselves out of it by winning the task.