Sugababes showdown

[Z]

Which line up of the Sugababes had the best debut single? I'm bored and I like music, go figure.

1.0 - Overload

lUmheG_VkIQ

2.0 - Freak Like Me

c336tadlkNk

3.0 - About You Now

DuMp_rZPZbw

4.0 - Freedom

lOf-IS9P9kw


N.B. I count "debut" as the first song off a fresh album project with each new line up, e.g. Amelle and Jade came into the band mid way through an album campaign so it wasn't "their" material. I don't count Easy or Walk This Way as being Amelle's debut because Easy was with the greatest hits and Walk This Way was a charity single.

[Marc]

2.0 > 1.0 > 3.0 > 4.0

['Conor]

OMFG TOUGHY

about you now > freak like me > freedom > overload

all amazing songs though

[2k9david2k10]

freak like me /freedom/overload/about you now / all good though :D !!

[Shaun]

ha2 at you suggesting Freedom is 'music'.

Freak Like Me, even if it's basically a mashup :tongue: Overload second.

[Tom4784]

Freak Like Me> Overload> Chlymidia> The rest.

[Doogle]

Overload > Freak Like Me > Freedom > About You Now (hate that song sf much)

But actual lineup overall:

2 > 3 > 1 > 4

['Conor]

Line up overall 2 > 4 > 3 > 1

[Zippy]

I love all those songs muchly(hell, I love all Sugababes songs, period) but Ive voted About you now.

It's such a great pop song and opened them up to a wider audience. Not so moody urban cool anymore.

['Conor]

4 weeks at No.1 :worship:

tbh we haven't even heard the full version of Freedom yet or video

[reece(:]

Freak Like Me :love: :love:

2>1>3>4

['Conor]

isn't about a girl also 4.0s 1st single?

[Lewis.]

2 :love:

[Joelle.]

Freak Like Me > Overload > Freedom > About You Now

Lineup overall
2 > 3 > 4 > 1

[Jordan.]

Just voted Freak Like Me and it came on the music channels :suspect:

[Marc]

How about you vote Cher next :suspect:

[Stu]

Freak like me has the most Gary Numan in it. So that.

I think I'm developing a crush on Heidi Range too. She's very hot in a very domestic way. Like someone plucked her straight from watching the soaps and said 'you're going to be a popstar, love!'.

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y237/kingofthering/Heidi_Range_heidi20range01.jpg

:amazed:

[Jordan.]

How about you vote Cher next :suspect:

Sky 362 right now :suspect:

[Z]

isn't about a girl also 4.0s 1st single?

As with Amelle joining mid way through an album campaign, I'm not counting Keisha's leftover material as 4.0's first single.

[Patrick]

WTF is with the hate for About You Now?

[Shaun]

it's so bland. If you reduce it to the melody it's just so dull. And there's nothing interesting in the rhythm or beat either - it's something that Atomic Kitten could've done, whereas 'Overload' was different.