LA Noire - Win or Fail?

[Scarlett.]

The game has been out long enough now, what did you think of it?

After the first two desks I started getting very bored with it all, it all just began repeating and repeating, and there was nothing else to do in the game, I didn't expect GTA, but there should at least have been something else for you to do.

[GiRTh]

Spot on review. Its a good game but it has zero replay quality.

[Stu]

It's just boring as sin really. I wasn't expecting a GTA game and still found it a bore.

Didn't take me long to switch back to some decent games and trade it in.

[Ramsay]

I loved it

[Scarlett.]

I was expecting something along the lines of Heavy Rain, but centered around a policeman

[Ryan57]

I found it to be too repetitive.

The facial capture was a top idea, mind.

[Patrick]

Fail.
It was hyped up and I got bored of it after about 3 days - and haven't played it since May, I actually went back to good old RDR, the greatest game ever.

[Shaun]

finished it tonight (couldn't be arsed to play it before now)

hands down the worst game i have ever played

tedious story, tedious gameplay, terrible over-acting, stupid to tease us with that open world and then give us nothing to do in it and no opportunity to explore... repetitive beyond the extreme, and just...boring. No variety: all the side missions are either car chases or shoot-outs.

the only good thing I can say about it is that it looks nice.

Would give it a 2-3/10.

[Samuel.]

I liked it a lot from what I played, roughly 3-4 hours.

I can see it getting repetitive and boring (maybe a reason why I didn't go back to it...) but I liked what it was doing enough.

I'd go back to it if next gen wasn't almost here.

[Tom4784]

It reminds me a lot of the first Assassin's Creed, a lot of good ideas that were overshadowed by endlessly repetitive gameplay. It's a shame it will probably never get a sequel as it could have been fantastic.

[Novo]

It could have been better yeah but it was still great even if it was really repetitive but then again the only part of the game i really found seemed to drag on was the all the murders in a row involving lipstick and all the victims were women apart from that the story was interesting enough to keep me going and i loved Phelps and his background story, it was great when he cheated on his wife though considering how much of a Professional he is and then just speaking to everyone after it and people giving him abuse over it :joker:

good old Rusty as well, what a guy :worship:

[Shaun]

Rusty was the best character

[Scarlett.]

I hated the guy on the Vice Desk, lol

[Novo]

the guy with the Polish sounding surname? there was some other guy who looked to much like Rusty as well

[Shaun]

oh also every time I see the actor who played Earle I want to punch him in the face... such an annoying voice.