Rank The US BB Winners

[SoBig]

I think we need a new thread since we have a new winner to add the rankings.

The ranking should solely be based on game play.

[Marc]

I'm excluding BB1, didn't watch and IDFGAS about it.

1. Dan
2. Will
3. Jun
4. Dick
5. Boogie
6. Hayden
7. Rachel
8. Drew
9. Lisa
10. Jordan
11. Maggie
12. Adam

[reece(:]

1. Dan
2. Jun
3. Dick
4. Will
5. Rachel
6. Hayden
7. Lisa
8. Jordan
9. Drew
10. Maggie
11. Adam
12. Boogie

[karl100589]

1) Will
2) Dan
3) Jun
4) Maggie
5) Hayden
6) Drew
7) Lisa
8) Boogie
9) Rachel
10) Adam
11) Evel Dick
12) Jordan

[BBfanUSA]

my top 5

1. will
2. dan
3. dick
4. Hayden
5. Drew

[swinearefine]

1. Jun
2. Dan
3. Maggie
4. Will
5. Hayden
6. Lisa
7. Drew
8. Boogie
9. Dick
10. Jordan
11. Rachel

I can't stomach watching all of BB1 or BB9 so I didn't rank them. I placed dick, jordan, and Rachel last because they were helped too much by unfair twists and rigging to be ranked with the others.

[Roy Mars III]

1. Will
2. Dan
3. Jun
4. Drew
5. Boogie
6. Hayden
7. Maggie
8. Dick
9. Lisa
10. Rachel
11. Jordan
12. Adam

[rk3388]

i think juns gameplay is overrated :$ she was kinda a floater

[swinearefine]

i think juns gameplay is overrated :$ she was kinda a floater

She's the ultimate floater - and that's why she's such a good player.

[Roy Mars III]

i think juns gameplay is overrated :$ she was kinda a floater

floating is a legitimate and good strategy. It's just the last two seasons when it's been looked down on.

[rk3388]

yeah but i mean i like seeing backdoors and big moves, not just being nice and not being good at competitions! although dan had a floater stragegy but i think it was better than juns cause he was doing it on purpose, im not sure if she was :p

[Roy Mars III]

Yeah, it is a somewhat boring strategy which is why a lot of people don't like players who do it. The ones who get away with it have a interesting personalty and make up for it by being fun to watch. People like Jun.

[swinearefine]

yeah but i mean i like seeing backdoors and big moves, not just being nice and not being good at competitions! although dan had a floater stragegy but i think it was better than juns cause he was doing it on purpose, im not sure if she was :p

Jun definitely wasn't 'just being nicer - she was a scheming bitch <3 and she definitely had her whole strategy planned out - be in the kitchen in the middle of all the action, see everything that happened, use the twist to her advantage instead of whine about it, and float to wherever she had to.

[Roy Mars III]

Jun definitely wasn't 'just being nicer - she was a scheming bitch <3 and she definitely had her whole strategy planned out - be in the kitchen in the middle of all the action, see everything that happened, use the twist to her advantage instead of whine about it, and float to wherever she had to.

yeah, she was great. :worship:

[lostalex]

I'm really surprised to see Hayden so high on many lists. It's nice to see Dr. Will isn't automatic number 1 anymore though. I've always felt Will was overrated.

[Macie Lightfoot]

Pretty great ranking of the winners I found on SurvivorSucks, by the poster Surfing Hippo in Trouble...

1. Dan - I can hear the Dan haters screaming now. "HIS FIRST WEEK WAS HORRIBLE!!!!!" I know. But the rest of his game was superb and there's no denying he's an incredible player and probably one of the best in BB history.
2. Hayden - Never EVER a target despite being one of the strongest social players in the game. No one went after him even after he nominated so many people.
3. Will - One of the best but similar to Dan his first few weeks were AWFUL. I don't understand how anyone can criticize Dan's early game when Will was 10000 times worse. Once Shannon left he stepped up his game like no other though and there's no question he's a legend.
4. Maggie - Played an excellent game. Had a constant target on her back, but she was lucky she was playing against a bunch of *******.
5. Mike - Played a pretty solid game. Not many mishaps. Definitely wouldn't have won if it weren't for Will.
6. Adam - He gets a lot of hate, but I think he was a pretty decent player. He played an AMAZING social game. And everybody loved Baller. Plus he never made any huge mistakes.
7. Jun - Played the floater game to perfection. The only thing that I fault her on is the fact that she would have lost to anybody else and she got really lucky that everything worked out for an Ali/Jun F2.
8. Drew - Another solid game. Diane kinda made all the big moves while he sat back and played a social game. But at the end of the day he was a pretty good winner.
9. Lisa - Not a strategic player at all. But she definitely stepped up her game once Eric left. She got lucky that she was playing in a pre-sequester season.
10. Rachel - Horrific social game. One of the few people who will ever win relying solely on a physical game and nothing else. I do admit she stepped up her social game once Brendon left the second time.
11. Dick - Obviously he wouldn't even be on this list if not for AP, but I do think he's a lot more game savvy then people give him credit for so who knows. But I highly HIGHLY doubt it. His name always has an asterisks next to it in my book along with...
12. Jordan - Awful winner. Zero strategic game. Bumble****ed her way to the end. Wanted to quit so Jeff could continue on. Just zero strategic brain on her original season (I saw a little more smarts this season, I'll admit)

http://survivorsucks.com/topic/86667/Rank-the-winners?page=2

[Marc]

I'm really surprised to see Hayden so high on many lists. It's nice to see Dr. Will isn't automatic number 1 anymore though. I've always felt Will was overrated.

He wouldn't survive in this current game. Golden power of vetos and twists. As shown in All Stars.

Hayden is high'ish on my list because he kept with his alliance and made sure he wasn't voted off even though he should have been

[MeMyselfAndI]

BB5-BB13


Terms of my favourites.
1. Jordan (In BB11, in BB13 she would be like 5th, but was loveable in BB11 & actually won the final HoH:D)
2. Dick (So entertaining & loved D&D, F2)
3. Dan (Amazing Gameplay, enjoyed watching him)
4. Drew (Likeable guy, but took Cowboy D:
5. Rachel (Annoying, Undeserved but entertaining)
6. Adam ( Slightly Dull & wasted the money)
7. Hayden (Dull & Annoying)
8. Maggie (Hated Nerd Herd, Disliked her)
9. Mike ( Hated him)

Terms of gameplay
1. Dan (Great gameplay, only won competitions when needed)
2. Drew (He was literally never targetted.)
3. Maggie (Controlled the whole nerd herd & Howies decisions)
4. Hayden (Literally never targetted & great Alliance)
5. Adam (Okay Winner, nearnly was evicted early though)
6. Jordan (Great social game but relied on Jeff alot)
7. Dick (loved him, but relied on twists & Danielles HOHs)
8. Mike (relied on Will SO much & won due to Janelles mistake.. Travesty)
9. Rachel (Relied on TWO twists & dreadful social game)

[Marc]

Jordan..?

:crazy:

[Roy Mars III]

I'm really surprised to see Hayden so high on many lists. It's nice to see Dr. Will isn't automatic number 1 anymore though. I've always felt Will was overrated.

Hayden is a good game player, just a boring one.

[Marc]

I agree with Roy. He was boring as hell and it was all predictable, but it doesn't take away the fact that he didn't get targetted as much as he should have and he stuck to his alliance and stayed strong till the end.

[MeMyselfAndI]

I loved Jordan in BB11